The Region Rogue Posted December 28, 2016 Report Posted December 28, 2016 Hi, I "lurk" here a decent amount, but haven't posted very much or often. That changes today. A little background info first: I started flipping houses, and I'm doing some custom woodwork for them like sliding barn doors, etc.(in the future, I'll be building cabinets as well). Most of these houses are historic, and I have access to A LOT of reclaimed lumber that comes from 100+ year-old barns in the area at really, really good prices. Some of it is over 4 inches thick and 12+ feet long, but I digress. I know some posters really advise to steer clear of the reclaimed route, but it's a huge selling feature where I'm selling, so I'll have to deal with the added inconveniences that comes with it. Right now I have a Laguna 1412, and I'm coming to the realization that the kind of resawing that I need to do, as well as the volume and regularity, is a bit beyond what this can handle. Don't get me wrong, it would be great if I were doing occasional resawing, but right now I have three 7 1/2 foot by 3 foot barn doors to build from stock that is at a minimum 2.5 inches thick, and the feed rate to cut down a 7-12 foot board into three 3/4 boards takes so long that it's just going to be too slow when my volume and production needs inevitably increase. So, to get to my question. I'm considering either a Grizzly G0531B (21" 5hp - 2195) or a Grizzly G0514X (19" 3hp - 1475). My inclination is that the 5hp is going to meet my needs better, though it's decently more expensive. Honestly, just being able to move up to a thicker, more aggressive blade will likely make a big difference in itself. Has anyone here had any experience with needing to resaw lots of long, thick boards at a decent rate? Was 3hp enough, or did you wish you had more? Quote
Woodenskye Posted December 28, 2016 Report Posted December 28, 2016 Personally I have no experience with the Grizzly's you mentioned. Yes more horsepower will be better. With that said I think you would be better looking at the European makers like Felder, Minimax, or the Italian Lagunas, I would also throw in Powermatic. You may need a power feeder to effectively resaw a 12' board. Quote
HuxleyWood Posted December 28, 2016 Report Posted December 28, 2016 That thickness of resawing is still within the wheelhouse of a table saw... Looking back the 2.5" may not be the "height" of the resaw, what exactly is the height and in what species? I primarily use a MM24 and a power feeder for resawing but that doesn't seem to be in your budget. Quote
Popular Post shaneymack Posted December 28, 2016 Popular Post Report Posted December 28, 2016 I have an 18" Italian Laguna and it has a 4.5hp baldor motor. That combined with a carbide resaw blade (i have the resaw king blade) is unstoppable. That will handle anything I throw at it and very quickly. I've tried my very best to bog it down and it just laughs at me. Sent from my SM-N910W8 using Tapatalk 4 Quote
Brendon_t Posted December 28, 2016 Report Posted December 28, 2016 If production style work is what you're ramping up for, I'd drop grizzly out of contention immediately. Production shop quality tools to me should be rock solid and need the less amount of fiddling and adjustment possible. Those are two attributes are not attributes I envision with grizzly tools, my own included. I would go old build American referb or euro. Quote
The Region Rogue Posted December 28, 2016 Author Report Posted December 28, 2016 This is awesome feedback. I agree that the European bandsaws would be better, but they're at minimum twice as much if not three times the price. If I can find an old American refurb, I'd jump on it, but I don't really have to time to wait around trying to find one, either. If it's meant to be, I'll find one at the right time. I'm glad to hear that it's hard to bog down a 4.5hp motor, because I can bog down the 1412 without trying very hard. I hear your point on the production shop quality, but budget also has to be balanced with needs. I'd love to have a Minimax, but I can't pay for one, either. Quote
Brendon_t Posted December 28, 2016 Report Posted December 28, 2016 Check out a clean up build @Tom Cancelleri did on a minimal. Bunch of evaporate and elbow grease bult him up a great machine. What area of the country are you in? Quote
The Region Rogue Posted December 28, 2016 Author Report Posted December 28, 2016 The Indianapolis area. The thing with a used bandsaw is that it would have to be in working order. I don't really have the time to restore something that has seen years of abuse and neglect. I wish I did, but I just don't. As I've done some more research, it looks like the Laguna LT18 3000 (non-Italian) would be pretty solid, too. Not a fan of the guide blocks, though (blasphemy, I know, but I just don't like 'em). The fit and finish on the 1412 is really good, and I'd expect that would be the case as you move higher up the line. Quote
HuxleyWood Posted December 28, 2016 Report Posted December 28, 2016 Again, the height of the resaw and in what species. Solid guide blokes are all around better than "skate board" bearings they put on many Asian saws, quality Euro guides are better than cheap bearings but solid blocks from ceramic are hard to beat. That said with the right blade and tension resawing takes the least advantage of the guides, you can resaw without any guides and get good results. Quote
Brendon_t Posted December 28, 2016 Report Posted December 28, 2016 8 minutes ago, The Region Rogue said: As I've done some more research, it looks like the Laguna LT18 3000 (non-Italian) would be pretty solid, too. No direct experience but I have heard those two are totally different beasts. The price reflects it for sure. Quote
The Region Rogue Posted December 28, 2016 Author Report Posted December 28, 2016 The height of the resaw is typically 8 inches. Species: mostly oak, but it varies depending on what the barn was built with. Poplar and old growth pine are typical. Maple, too. Really just a variety. The guide blocks aren't a deal-breaker or anything, I just don't like them. If I had my choice regardless of price and space, I'd get a horizontal resaw. That would be awesome, but it's way too big for my space right now. Quote
pkinneb Posted December 28, 2016 Report Posted December 28, 2016 I have a Laguna 1412 for cutting curves and a Laguna 16HD with a 5hp Baldor motor for resawing it has always worked well for me. I mention the 1412 for one reason, before I bought it earlier this year I purchased a Rikon to cut curves but after using the Laguna for 12 years the Rikon just did not meet my expectations so I bought the 1412 and have been very happy. I would try to find someone that has a saw like you are considering purchasing and try it out before dropping money on one. Quote
hawkeyestoob Posted December 28, 2016 Report Posted December 28, 2016 Another consideration that you may want/need to keep in mind is if your shop is set up for three phase power. If so the larger three phase saws go for considerably less on the secondary market than the comparable single phase units will. 1 Quote
HuxleyWood Posted December 28, 2016 Report Posted December 28, 2016 11 minutes ago, hawkeyestoob said: Another consideration that you may want/need to keep in mind is if your shop is set up for three phase power. If so the larger three phase saws go for considerably less on the secondary market than the comparable single phase units will. If he finds a 3ph saw all he needs is a (relatively) inexpensive VFD. Quote
The Region Rogue Posted December 28, 2016 Author Report Posted December 28, 2016 I don't have three phase. I have a 30 amp and 20 amp 220v circuit fed from a 100 amp subpanel, so 5hp single phase is pretty much my upper limit, as anything over is typically three phase, and converting is too expensive right now. Right now I'm in the startup phase of the business after having transitioned from being a high school teacher, so the budget is tight. Not to mention, most of my capital is in the house. In fact, I'm probably going to power through on this first house with the 1412. Honestly, I'm not really all that worried about fit, finish, and finery. I just need a workhorse with power to give me a rough cut to rough thickness that I can finish up on the planer (or not, people like a rough finish with reclaimed wood). 1 minute ago, HuxleyWood said: If he finds a 3ph saw all he needs is a (relatively) inexpensive VFD. Yeah, I guess finding one at a cheaper price would make up for the converter. That would be a good option. Again, it's just timing. Hopefully a window of about a month would find someone selling something. Quote
Woodenskye Posted December 28, 2016 Report Posted December 28, 2016 This may work for you. http://www.woodcraft.com/product/418916/rikon-i18-18-professional-bandsaw-with-4hp-motor-model-10346.aspx Quote
HuxleyWood Posted December 28, 2016 Report Posted December 28, 2016 My rule of thumb with a good carbide blade is 1/4 hp per inch of resaw, you can get away with less using a carbon or hardened spring steel blade since they are initially sharper than carbide. Honestly, with only 8" of resaw to deal with the stability of the saw running those long heavy timbers through it is more an issue than HP or resaw height. The new Rikon 18" Pro is another saw to consider, a couple of hundred less than the Laguna 18/3000 and has decent Euro guides. I see I was beat by a couple of minutes on the Rikon, the WC price is high, Circle Saw in Houston has the best Rikon BS prices. Quote
The Region Rogue Posted December 28, 2016 Author Report Posted December 28, 2016 I haven't used a carbide blade admittedly. I've been using either the Laguna 5/8 shearforce or 1/2 Timberwolf 3pc, but even with the 1.75hp of the 1412, I have to feed pretty slowly to keep it from bogging down. I haven't really had much of an issue with stability. I use rollers on the infeed and outfeed side. Granted, it's not easy feeding 8 ft of resaw through, though. Trying to maintain that slower feed rate is harder with the longer boards. I try to avoid feeding a whole 12-14 ft board through, too, and haven't had to, yet. Quote
wnaziri Posted December 28, 2016 Report Posted December 28, 2016 Ok, I will be the contrarian. I would not rule out the idea of refurbishing old iron, if you have longterm plans. If you restore an old workhorse, you could solve your problem for many years. If you can continue to use your Laguna, you would buy yourself some time. I personally restored a Northfield. These machines are quite simple. The one great aspect of Northfield Woodworking products is that you can get factory parts and support to this day. The saw I have is 5 HP (3 Phase) and I CAN NOT bog it down. Plus, it can run all day, non-stop. As an aside, question for the experts here: It seems that I get resin build up on the bandsaw blade after a while. Does anyone else see this? Quote
The Region Rogue Posted December 28, 2016 Author Report Posted December 28, 2016 You guys have been a great help and have given me many things to consider. Hopefully, in the next few months the correct option for me will become more clear (and maybe someone with an old Northfield will decide they don't want it at just the right time). Quote
andrew-in-austin Posted December 28, 2016 Report Posted December 28, 2016 You never know what might come your way. I picked up a Northfield 36" for $1100. Not that I am a resaw expert, but from what I have read from professionals that do this, a carbide blade and a saw that can tension it properly are the keys. Most all of the vintage US cast iron large saws have no problem with that. The modern MiniMax bandsaws have no problem with that. The Grizzly "ultimate" bandsaws (and not the extreme or any other moniker) can also tension those blades without issue. Actually, if $2500 was in your budget, I would get the Grizzly 17 G0636X and be done with it. Only other improvements I can think of would be much higher feet per minute (and higher HP) and power feeder. But unless you are doing hundreds of feet per day, that's probably not necessary. Quote
Unknown craftsman Posted December 28, 2016 Report Posted December 28, 2016 I Resaw with 20 inch bandsaw and Woodmaster Ct.A good Resaw blade is what makes a great Resaw machine. The Woodmaster ct 1.3 tpi lasts an very long time.Well worth it. But you need to have a saw frame that will tension it.I wouldn't go below a 20 inch wheel.Longer the blade the longer it will last. Aj Quote
Tom Cancelleri Posted December 28, 2016 Report Posted December 28, 2016 Here's my restoration thread of an MM20. If you can score some higher end kit that's been rusted. Evaporust is king dick when it comes to cleaning up tools. Quote
The Region Rogue Posted December 28, 2016 Author Report Posted December 28, 2016 https://lansing.craigslist.org/tls/5880009085.html So, this looks like it's built specifically for what I need. It's a decent drive, and who knows the condition, but here's the modern version: http://www.lagunatools.com/bandsaws/bandsaw-resawmaster# I'm guessing minimum 5hp on it, but likely 3 phase. 2" blade capacity, though. It was posted a while ago, so who knows if it's sold already. For anyone in the Montana region: https://bozeman.craigslist.org/tls/5907121101.html Looks like a good deal on a Minimax, way too far away from me, though. Quote
Keggers Posted December 28, 2016 Report Posted December 28, 2016 You might also consider finding someone who has a band sawmill that would be willing to break down your thick lumber for a reasonable fee. You would, of course, have to make sure all the metal was removed from your barn wood before sawing. You'd have to do that anyway if sawing it yourself. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.