21meyer Posted December 28, 2016 Report Posted December 28, 2016 14 hours ago, The Region Rogue said: Hi, I "lurk" here a decent amount, but haven't posted very much or often. That changes today. A little background info first: I started flipping houses, and I'm doing some custom woodwork for them like sliding barn doors, etc.(in the future, I'll be building cabinets as well). Most of these houses are historic, and I have access to A LOT of reclaimed lumber that comes from 100+ year-old barns in the area at really, really good prices. Some of it is over 4 inches thick and 12+ feet long, but I digress. I know some posters really advise to steer clear of the reclaimed route, but it's a huge selling feature where I'm selling, so I'll have to deal with the added inconveniences that comes with it. Right now I have a Laguna 1412, and I'm coming to the realization that the kind of resawing that I need to do, as well as the volume and regularity, is a bit beyond what this can handle. Don't get me wrong, it would be great if I were doing occasional resawing, but right now I have three 7 1/2 foot by 3 foot barn doors to build from stock that is at a minimum 2.5 inches thick, and the feed rate to cut down a 7-12 foot board into three 3/4 boards takes so long that it's just going to be too slow when my volume and production needs inevitably increase. So, to get to my question. I'm considering either a Grizzly G0531B (21" 5hp - 2195) or a Grizzly G0514X (19" 3hp - 1475). My inclination is that the 5hp is going to meet my needs better, though it's decently more expensive. Honestly, just being able to move up to a thicker, more aggressive blade will likely make a big difference in itself. Has anyone here had any experience with needing to resaw lots of long, thick boards at a decent rate? Was 3hp enough, or did you wish you had more? I have had the Laguna 1412 for several years and have been happy with it. Once I started to do more resawing I scoured Craigslist for almost two years for a more powerful saw. I finally gave in about a year ago and purchased the Grizzly G0636X along with a 1" Resaw King. For me, the throat capacity wasn't as important as the motor size and resaw capacity. I know several members have had issues with Grizzly machines and have a sour taste but between this saw and my G0609X jointer I have had zero issues. The 1412 is now used strictly for cutting curves. You may need to add a power feeder and table extensions but in my workflow, I have not needed them yet. Quote
The Region Rogue Posted December 29, 2016 Author Report Posted December 29, 2016 On 12/28/2016 at 7:14 AM, The Region Rogue said: https://lansing.craigslist.org/tls/5880009085.html So, this looks like it's built specifically for what I need. It's a decent drive, and who knows the condition, but here's the modern version: Wondering what others would do here. At $1100 it seems like a good deal, but it needs a TON of work to get it back to shop-worthy condition. It's also 4-5 hours away from me. The guy says that it runs, but it's in a place where it can't be plugged in to verify. Would you buy it not being able to see it run? My thoughts are a new motor would be $300-$500 if it didn't work, but there could be so many other problems that don't present themselves when it's not on that it just doesn't seem worth for that price. Quote
Brendon_t Posted December 29, 2016 Report Posted December 29, 2016 Does that say 2" blade? Look like a decent project with high payoff if you get it up and running rather inexpensively 1 Quote
andrew-in-austin Posted December 29, 2016 Report Posted December 29, 2016 Looks like it only needs a switch and some rust removal? If so that seems like a very good deal. Quote
Chet Posted December 29, 2016 Report Posted December 29, 2016 Yea Brendon, it looks like there is close to a 2 inch blade on it, if you look at the picture showing the upper wheel. Quote
pkinneb Posted December 29, 2016 Report Posted December 29, 2016 Personally I would not buy a tool that I could not see run but...I have sold several where the buyer didn't seem to care. 2 Quote
The Region Rogue Posted December 29, 2016 Author Report Posted December 29, 2016 Yeah, it seems like a great deal, but after mulling it over, I just got kind of a bad vibe from the seller, so with it being so far away and not being able to really judge what kind of work I'd need to put into it, I just decided to pass. $1100 is an awesome price; maybe someone who lives closer can get a great deal. Quote
Brendon_t Posted December 29, 2016 Report Posted December 29, 2016 Don't let a weird person screw it up if you think that's a machine that fills your needs and the price is right. I've done a lot of cl deals with people who were strange 1 Quote
The Region Rogue Posted December 29, 2016 Author Report Posted December 29, 2016 No, it's not really just that; it's just a contributing factor. Actually, most of my tools have been bought used through Craigslist, and I've sold a bunch, too. My first jointer was a Ridgid that had so much rust on it that it barely looked like it was made of steel/iron. After doing so many deals, actually, I've learned to identify pretty quickly the reasonable people from the unreasonable. There's always exceptions of course. The distance is a big factor for me right now, and coupled with the fact that the seller seems unaccommodating and disinterested in letting someone who genuinely wants to buy the bandsaw evaluate it, it's just not worth my time right now. If it was closer, I'd go check it out and deal with whoever was selling. I'm back and forth because it is a monster of a saw, but right now I'm content to wait and see what else pops up in the next few months. Once I sell this first house I'm flipping, I'll be going into building the cabinets for my houses in addition to doing custom woodworking elements, so a good bandsaw is just one piece of equipment in which I'll be investing. Sorry for being so wordy; I was an English teacher before this venture, so I can get a bit long-winded at times. 1 Quote
Pwk5017 Posted December 30, 2016 Report Posted December 30, 2016 I have never heard of a resale master before. What's the wheel diameter? Motor hp? 2" blade is serious business. I have an Italian laguna 20" saw with 4.8hp bald or motor and it can't tension a 2" blade. I think the max it takes is 1.25-1.5". I run a 1-1.25" resaw king on it for reassign, and it does a beautiful job. If you have the room, I would get a proper euro machine in the 20" range. Quote
Tpt life Posted December 30, 2016 Report Posted December 30, 2016 2 minutes ago, Pwk5017 said: I have never heard of a resale master before. What's the wheel diameter? Motor hp? 2" blade is serious business. I have an Italian laguna 20" saw with 4.8hp bald or motor and it can't tension a 2" blade. I think the max it takes is 1.25-1.5". I run a 1-1.25" resaw king on it for reassign, and it does a beautiful job. If you have the room, I would get a proper euro machine in the 20" range. Resaw Master is Laguna. Quote
HuxleyWood Posted December 30, 2016 Report Posted December 30, 2016 8 minutes ago, Pwk5017 said: I have never heard of a resale master before. What's the wheel diameter? Motor hp? 2" blade is serious business. I have an Italian laguna 20" saw with 4.8hp bald or motor and it can't tension a 2" blade. I think the max it takes is 1.25-1.5". I run a 1-1.25" resaw king on it for reassign, and it does a beautiful job. If you have the room, I would get a proper euro machine in the 20" range. The Laguna Resaw Master is made for them by ACM just like your LT20. The wheels are 18" and depending on how it is specced and the age the motor could be from 3.6 hp to 7.5 hp and either single or 3 phase. While it can't get a 2" blade to 30,000 psi it is capable of more tension than you LT20 more similar in tension ability to a Minimax MM20/24. Quote
Pwk5017 Posted December 30, 2016 Report Posted December 30, 2016 Yeah, I saw it's a laguna from the 90s, but that is the model "resaw master". Never saw or heard of one before. Just googled the model and that sucker sounds perfect for you. Not a practical general purpose bandsaw, but awesome for what you want to do. You need motor and resaw specifics. Laguna has upped the specs on their saws in the last 10-15 years. Actually, all the euro machines upped the ante in the last decade. The mm16 is a much different saw today than it was in 2002. If you don't want to drive, pay that dude with PayPal and have a shipping service pick it up and deliver it for you. If that machine turns on, buy it. 7 minutes ago, HuxleyWood said: The Laguna Resaw Master is made for them by ACM just like your LT20. The wheels are 18" and depending on how it is specced and the age the motor could be from 3.6 hp to 7.5 hp and either single or 3 phase. While it can't get a 2" blade to 30,000 psi it is capable of more tension than you LT20 more similar in tension ability to a Minimax MM20/24. Yeah, that is what I would watch out for. 3.6hp seems underpowered for resawing. Pfft the MM series is neck and neck with the laguna series, not above it. The MM20 is the same as my saw with a max 1.25" blade width. The MM24 does a 1.5" blade. For crying out loud, cremona's mill has a 2" blade on it! OP, I'd get that saw. Quote
Brendon_t Posted December 30, 2016 Report Posted December 30, 2016 17 minutes ago, Pwk5017 said: Yeah, that is what I would watch out for. 3.6hp seems underpowered for resawing. Is that sarcasm? 3.6 hp is still a crap load of ass for the thin blade load band saws have. You may not go 40 feet a minute but that'll do work.. Quote
HuxleyWood Posted December 30, 2016 Report Posted December 30, 2016 36 minutes ago, Pwk5017 said: Pfft the MM series is neck and neck with the laguna series, not above it. The MM20 is the same as my saw with a max 1.25" blade width. The MM24 does a 1.5" blade. For crying out loud, cremona's mill has a 2" blade on it! 1 Sorry, but that is objectively incorrect. The Centauro CO HD series which is made for SCM/MiniMax and the X20 series Felders have significantly more tension ability and less frame deflection than the ACM built Laguna and old Agazzani bandsaws. While there are plenty of niches on the internet that you can verify this I have owned variants of all these saws and have had strain gauges on all of them so I know their relative tensioning abilities. The blade width recommendations are about what fits in the guides not what tension is available, since one 1.25" blade can require 2-3 times the spring pressure to tension properly over another 1.25" blade depending on cross section and blade type. This isn't saying the Agazzani or Laguna aren't excellent saws, they are, they just don't have the tension capability that the Felder X20 and Minimax MM/SP series do. For hand feeding this isn't much of an issue, when I moved to power feeding is when I saw a more visible difference. This is only really an issue when one wants a dedicated resaw and doesn't have the room for a real old iron resaw. Quote
HuxleyWood Posted December 30, 2016 Report Posted December 30, 2016 32 minutes ago, Brendon_t said: Is that sarcasm? 3.6 hp is still a crap load of ass for the thin blade load band saws have. You may not go 40 feet a minute but that'll do work.. It all depends on how you look at it. An American bandsaw would have never been labeled as a resaw without at least 10hp but those are designed for power feeding only. My general rule of thumb for relatively slow power feeding is 1/4 hp per inch of resaw in domestic hardwoods using a moderate kerf carbide blade like the Woodmaster CT, you can get away with less using a thinner carbide blade (Resaw King) or a lot less using an impulse hardened spring steel blade (Woodslicer, Kerfmaster or Bladerunner) though the latter won't stay sharp long. 3.6hp (derived from running an Italian 50hz motor on US 60hz mains) is likely enough for 16" or so of resawing in domestic hardwood being handfed, it is hard to really slam a huge chunk of wood through a saw handfeeding it. The key really is how much resaw will you ever use, of my saws my max resaw capability is 24" and honestly can count with my fingers how many times I have needed to resaw over 15" in height and that is in near 30 years of woodworking and doing a lot of shop cut veneer. The RM in the ad looks like a good buy but will need some TLC but to be clear it is a one trick pony but really should be coupled with a power feeder to get the best out of it. Quote
The Region Rogue Posted December 30, 2016 Author Report Posted December 30, 2016 I'll just say this: there's a reason this thing has been listed for over a month. I just don't feel comfortable doing business with this particular seller; perhaps that sounds stupid, but in all honesty I was really psyched when I first saw it, and I usually like taking road trips. I just have a bad gut feeling about it I guess. Anyway, I don't think I'm ever going to need the production speed that a power feed lends, and if I do, I'll just get a horizontal resaw at that point and be done with it. From all the responses, it sounds like I'm looking for a saw that has 4+ hp and can tension a 1 1/4 inch blade. Anything else is gravy. I'm also not in a hurry. My 1412 is underpowered for resawing quickly, but it can still get the job done at a slower rate, which affords me the time over the next few months to see what kind of stuff shows up on the used market. If I find a good piece of old iron, I'll definitely make a thread on its restoration like Tom Cancellari did. I also wanted to say that everyone's been really helpful. I've learned a lot through this thread about some of the minutiae of good larger bandsaws and what to look for in them. Quote
Brendon_t Posted December 30, 2016 Report Posted December 30, 2016 21 minutes ago, HuxleyWood said: It all depends on how you look at it. An American bandsaw would have never been labeled as a resaw without at least 10hp but those are designed for power feeding only. My general rule of thumb for relatively slow power feeding is 1/4 hp per inch of resaw in domestic hardwoods using a moderate kerf carbide blade like the Woodmaster CT, you can get away with less using a thinner carbide blade (Resaw King) or a lot less using an impulse hardened spring steel blade (Woodslicer, Kerfmaster or Bladerunner) though the latter won't stay sharp long. 3.6hp (derived from running an Italian 50hz motor on US 60hz mains) is likely enough for 16" or so of resawing in domestic hardwood being handfed, it is hard to really slam a huge chunk of wood through a saw handfeeding it. The key really is how much resaw will you ever use, of my saws my max resaw capability is 24" and honestly can count with my fingers how many times I have needed to resaw over 15" in height and that is in near 30 years of woodworking and doing a lot of shop cut veneer. The RM in the ad looks like a good buy but will need some TLC but to be clear it is a one trick pony but really should be coupled with a power feeder to get the best out of it. Ok so with most of that that which I'll gladly say mostly went over my head, by your objective 1/4 hp per inch, so 17" is good and saying over 15" is hardly ever need to you off 20 years experience, that would go on the category of plenty of ass to me.. Quote
ClassAct Posted December 30, 2016 Report Posted December 30, 2016 The advice I usually see from woodworkers, including those running a business, are don't buy it until you have the money for it. As much as you'd like to step up to a bandsaw that makes the job quicker and easier, you don't have the cash flow to support that. Your choices are to limp along on what you have until you have either the savings to buy a new saw or the ability to draw down on some credit cards, a bridge loan, or home equity loan. The alternative is to get creative on how you do resawing. Barter some trade time with someone who can do the job. Pay for a month's time with a woodworking collective. Lastly, give a call to an accountant. If you are going to buy a saw anyway, you may want to do it this tax year so you can use depreciation immediately rather than waiting for the next tax year. 1 Quote
Pwk5017 Posted December 30, 2016 Report Posted December 30, 2016 Sorta. I get your advice if a business is buying a new $25,000-100,000 machine, but we are talking $1000 here. If $1000 sinks his business, then he should find a new way to spend his time. Example, I went out on a bit of a limb with the pm209hh last spring during the sale. Cost me like $3500ish, which is by far the most I've ever spent on a tool. Part of the reason I bought it was it was on sale and my local dealer gave me 12 months 0% financing. I can't tell you how much time that planer has saved me over sticking with the dw735. I mill a lot, which it does twice as fast as the dw735, but it also allowed me to plane 20" subsections and decrease the amount of abrasive planing I did at my drum sander. Taking 1/16" off each side of a 24-36" wide panel that's 4-10' long is PAINFULLY slow. In short, if you know your workflow and the bottlenecks, I think cap ex investments make a ton of sense. Now, this also comes with a grain of salt to not be stupid and buy a 50k shop on a line of credit that is going to sit for two years. Know your business and how it's growing. Huxley breaking out the 50 years of resawing experience on everyone! Point taken on the tensioning. I read that more as saying the MM line takes a much larger blade than the ACM line, which is what I argued. I've never used a minimax 20 or 24. I looked at a couple 16s prior to buying my LT20. Im very glad I waited. One, I bought the laguna for what the 16s were asking, and it's easily 1.5-2x the saw that the mm16 is. I don't have a ton of resawing experience, but I do have several years of working with entry level hobbyist kit versus light commercial stuff, and the latter is soooooooo much better and faster. If I resawed a decent amount for money, I honestly wouldn't consider my saw to be overkill. Actually, I would probably consider it the bare minimum and look to upgrade. If you are making money off what you are doing, you really owe it to yourself to research and invest in the tooling to fit your needs. Quote
HuxleyWood Posted December 30, 2016 Report Posted December 30, 2016 1 hour ago, ClassAct said: Lastly, give a call to an accountant. If you are going to buy a saw anyway, you may want to do it this tax year so you can use depreciation immediately rather than waiting for the next tax year. Section 179 might make a quick purchase financially wise but technically the equipment needs to be installed prior to Jan 1 so while many deduct based on purchase it really runs afoul of the IRS. RE resaw height. In most cases huge resaw heights are mainly a urination contest, admittedly one I have bought into at some level. Torben Helshoj is really responsible for pushing resaw capacity. Traditionally, outside of a special order, US bandsaws of 27" or less usually had only roughly 12" under the guides and one had to jump to the 36" saws to get massive resaw heights. Euro saws generally maxed out at about 17". In my mind the important bit about larger Euro saws is the ability to properly tension wider carbide blades vs more resaw height. If you notice when Euro saws go above 24"/600mm they revert back to more traditional heights under the guides which I feel is due to hobbyists like most of us being unwilling to go more than 24" and commercial buyers aren't dazzled by 24"+ resaw heights since they know how rarely it would be used. In the end I think if the OP has the room (height and a door to get it in the shop) looking for an old iron 32-36" bandsaw makes the most sense however they are a pain to move and deal with but once in place they are a pleasure to use. "We" also get suckered into using too wide of a blade. The benefit of a wider blade for resawing is not the width itself but the beam strength it adds when tensioned correctly. Don't expect a 20" or smaller saw to tension a 1.25" blade correctly (except the thin gauge Resaw King), stick with 1" blades, The MM24 and Felder 610 (was tired and typed X20 last night but it is the X10 series that is heavy) are about the smallest saws that can fully tension a .035" thick 1.25" wide blade. Once you have something like a 1" Woodmaster CT or Trimaster tensioned to 30,000 psi it has more than enough beam strength for handfeeding or slow power feeding and if the saw is maxed out on tension with the 1" blade a 1.25" blade won't be better, in fact it will be worse. Quote
The Region Rogue Posted December 30, 2016 Author Report Posted December 30, 2016 Yeah, $1000 won't break me, but it's not a drop in the bucket, either. I'm on my first house, so I don't have large capital reserves yet, but I'll be getting some machinery after we sell this first one. Not really where I expected this conversation to go, but it's an interesting discussion. I'll probably be carrying over a huge loss because I'm carrying the house through the tax year, so I'm not really worried about cashing in the depreciation in the next few days. Besides, I'll likely Section 179 write off the equipment for one year rather than dragging it out over several if it's an option for the next tax year. I'm actually meeting with an accountant next week. I should have done it sooner, but I just let it slide while taking care of working on the house. I'll actually be purchasing at least a shaper, power feeder, and hardier table saw next year (I have the Steel City hybrid right now) as well as I move into cabinetry. I might just skip ahead to the entry level Grizzly slider (sorry Felder just ain't in my wheelhouse right now). I'm just in a two car garage right now, so space is an issue, but hopefully as I ramp up the business in the coming years, I'll be able to ramp up shop space, too. Now, if I may impart some of my own wisdom gathered over the past year for anyone looking to get into the house rehabbing business. 1) Don't try to do it all yourself. It takes way too long, and there's just too many little things to do for you to focus on while also trying to keep up with the bigger picture. I've learned this the hard way. 2) Find a good, young up-and-coming contractor to work with. They work hard, do good work, and are reasonable in price. The bonus is that you both can grow together in the business. I've found that the more experienced and established contractors tend to work more on remodeling kitchens and bathrooms in high-end houses as their margins are likely higher on such projects. 3) Don't be afraid of hard money/private investors. When I started, I swore that I was going to avoid these at all costs, but I think I'll use hard money on my next project. It costs a decent amount in interest, but the ability to have multiple projects going at once means you'll make more in the end. That being said, you have to have an exit strategy when doing that, too, like turning a house into a regularly mortgaged rental if you can't sell it within the loan term. 4) Finally, it's all about buying the house at the right price. Construction costs are more or less going to be constant from house to house (per square foot), so the best way to make a good profit is to buy it at the right price. It's an obvious one, but it's the most important part of the business. 5) Use "who" in the subjective case and "whom" in the objective case. An easier way to think of this is that who should be used when a verb is the next word in the sentence (ex. "he who smelt it dealt it") and whom should be used when preceded by a preposition or when a noun is the next word in the sentence (ex. "for whom the bell tolls"). Well, that last one was from one of my professions anyway... Quote
Brendon_t Posted December 30, 2016 Report Posted December 30, 2016 Since when is the, a noun? And I totally disagree on hard money lending but that's just from my profession. If it works for you, great. Quote
Unknown craftsman Posted December 30, 2016 Report Posted December 30, 2016 I'm so glad I'm done with renovation and restoration work.There were very few jobs I enjoyed.Its very glamorized on tv now. It makes me sleepy thinking about it. Good luck to your business. Aj Quote
The Region Rogue Posted December 30, 2016 Author Report Posted December 30, 2016 I suppose I should have been more specific. In terms of the structure of the sentence, "bell" is the next word of any significance. "The" is serving as an adjective/article. If you were to diagram the sentence, "bell" would indeed be the next word. It doesn't really matter; it was just a tongue-in-cheek comment. In terms of the hard money and where I'm coming from: This first house is going to take me nearly a year to finish from close to close, if not a little longer. That's with trying to do most of the work myself. On the next one, I'll be hiring a contractor to oversee all the work while I focus on the business and design side as well as custom woodwork elements and maybe cabinets. Right now, I've got ALL of my capital tied up in one house. Hard money will cost somewhere around 15k, but I won't have to commit nearly as much of my capital, the project will get done close-close in 6 months or less, and I'll be able to start a second at the same time. Using it will allow me to hopefully get at least 3 houses started/done next, and more than double that the next year. At that point, I wouldn't have to rely on it as much anymore. Sure, there's a risk involved, and you're paying A LOT in interest, but until I have mega bucks in my business it's kind of a necessary evil to survive in this business. For what it's worth, I'll also be buying and holding rental properties in college towns as I grow the business. It's really not a woodworking business, but it will allow me to pursue what I really love to do, and the best part is that I really have no customers, per se, to answer to; I just have to follow trends. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.