bushwacked Posted February 27, 2017 Report Posted February 27, 2017 So after he finally released his dust collection video, I started wondering if something like that is possible with a smaller dust collector. I am in about the same size 2 car garage too. I would not have near that many runs, as of now. I would have the TS drop and in my shop it would work for planer and jointer too. The Miter Saw run I would like to have and maybe one more , but that is about it 2-3 different runs. Link to his video: I have and older version of this one ... http://www.rockler.com/jet-dc-1200vx-bk1-dust-collector-2hp-1ph-230v-30-micron-bag-filter-kit Quote
Eric. Posted February 27, 2017 Report Posted February 27, 2017 1 hour ago, bushwacked said: So after he finally released his dust collection video, I started wondering if something like that is possible with a smaller dust collector I have a similar system to his with a 2HP collector, Super Dust Deputy cyclone, LV blast gates and a labyrinth of 4" pipe. I think I actually have quite a bit more ducting than he does, at least in linear feet (more machines, more drops). My canned answer about its efficiency is that it does a great job picking up the bulk of the mess but is lacking in the fine dust department, especially at the table saw and bandsaws. If your goal is safety, you need a 5HP unit or larger and modified machines. If your goal is cleaning up the mess, a smaller system can work. Quote
bushwacked Posted February 27, 2017 Author Report Posted February 27, 2017 Thanks for the great info Eric. As of right now, I am not trying to collect every single piece of dust. 80-90% will do. I figure once I get the system up and going to test it I can always come back and upgrade the DC if needed later on down the road without too much hassle. No at the moment dropping $2K on DC is not going to happen. It will be a few years before a DC that expensive comes back in the budget. Too many other tools on the list to justify buying something again that I already have. Quote
Chet Posted February 27, 2017 Report Posted February 27, 2017 I am a lot like Eric I have my drum sander, table saw, band saw, router table, planner and jointer all hooked up to the DC. Everything is 4 inch pipe and at the end of a good shop session I brush off all of the machines and sweep up the floor and all of that would probably fit in a coffee can. Then there is all the floaty stuff that settles on the machines after I am in the house. My DC is 1 3/4 HP. 1 Quote
Eric. Posted February 27, 2017 Report Posted February 27, 2017 I should add that if I were in a basement, I would prioritize the DC and would absolutely have a Pentz-approved system. But since I'm in the garage I don't really worry about it. I wear my respirator when I'm hand sanding or running the table saw or bandsaws, and I put on the backpack blower once every couple months and clear the whole shop. It's a system that works fine for me but it certainly would be insufficient if my shop were inside the house. 1 Quote
bushwacked Posted February 28, 2017 Author Report Posted February 28, 2017 ok well good this makes me feel better now. Going to keep looking at a full setup now since this is not too crazy of an idea Quote
Jfitz Posted February 28, 2017 Report Posted February 28, 2017 22 hours ago, bushwacked said: I started wondering if something like that is possible with a smaller dust collector. I would say sure. but with a few caveats... - that unit appears to come with a 30micron bag filter. At that point, I'd be less worried about the lack of collection of fines at the tool than I would about that bag just blowing fine dust all around the place. A better filter might be warranted (and there are some good ones that can also improve airflow). - Be careful with pipe routing, turns, etc. and make sure everything is sealed so you don't lose airflow. I don't know what the fan curve of that unit looks like - it claims 1200CFM @ 4" SP so it can move a lot of air....might even be worth looking at going to 6" pipe instead of 4", but I think that might be pushing it. A 6" pipe needs 800CFM to maintain 4000FPM (which is usually accepted as what is necessary to keep wood dust moving, especially in vertical runs). Upgrading to 6" might also be fruitless without appropriate modifications of the tools themselves. Like some of the others above, I have a 1.5HP unit (delta 50-760) piped with 4" pipe; I upgraded it with a Wynn filter (better airflow, and better filtration even though stock bag was pretty good). I also have a Super Dust Deputy (which is awesome, IMO). I use 4" pipe, and the runs are not very long. The longest is to my bandsaw (adding under-table collection is a must IMO), and the next longest is to my planer (dewalt 735 which also has a blower - win win). I think the collection is pretty good. Yes I'd love to upgrade to bigger unit with 6" piping...but for now, this works for me. So is it possible? yes. go for it and see if the results meet your expectations. Quote
Ronn W Posted February 28, 2017 Report Posted February 28, 2017 I also have a 1 3/4HP unit with all 4" ducting. I ran my ducting at about 2 to 3" above the floor and along the walls to keep my distances to a minimum. I use only on piece of equipment at a time and close the blast gates to all but the machine in use since that size machine can only handle one machine at a time. If I accidentally leave another gate open, I can tell right away. I also recommend an air filter in the shop. Quote
rodger. Posted March 1, 2017 Report Posted March 1, 2017 I use a 1.5 HP collector, and 5" pipe. Simply moving up from 4" to 5" makes a world of difference, even with the same collector. Quote
bushwacked Posted March 1, 2017 Author Report Posted March 1, 2017 13 hours ago, Pug said: I use a 1.5 HP collector, and 5" pipe. Simply moving up from 4" to 5" makes a world of difference, even with the same collector. Yes that is what I was hoping ... I am planning on using 6" for this, and 5" minimum. Then reduce them down to whatever size the machine needs. Need to do a little more research on the 5 and 6" but that is at least the plan. So in the future it is ready to go if I upgrade and only would need to swap out the DC unit and not my complete system. Quote
rodger. Posted March 1, 2017 Report Posted March 1, 2017 6 hours ago, bushwacked said: Yes that is what I was hoping ... I am planning on using 6" for this, and 5" minimum. Then reduce them down to whatever size the machine needs. Need to do a little more research on the 5 and 6" but that is at least the plan. So in the future it is ready to go if I upgrade and only would need to swap out the DC unit and not my complete system. the only reason i use 5" pipe over 6" is because the inlet is 5". I modified the port on my pointer and planer to receive a 5" pipe. I wonder if I could remove the flange on my DC and swap out for a 6"..I'll have to look at the housing when I get back out there. Quote
Eric. Posted March 1, 2017 Report Posted March 1, 2017 I won't argue with these guys who use 5" or 6" mains on their little 2HP or smaller collectors...but according to the physics, there isn't enough power to keep up the air speed in a big pipe like that, which is likely to cause buildup of chips and ultimately clogging. The bigger the pipe, the higher the allowable CFM but it kills velocity, which is why Pentz-approved systems are at least 5HP in order to maximize both CFM and velocity. Using a pipe the size of your inlet is a judgment call, but it is never advisable to use a main trunk a larger diameter than your inlet. That's just common sense. Quote
Tpt life Posted March 1, 2017 Report Posted March 1, 2017 Deleted dumb comment after confusing inlet and outlet... Quote
drzaius Posted March 1, 2017 Report Posted March 1, 2017 29 minutes ago, Eric. said: Using a pipe the size of your inlet is a judgment call, but it is never advisable to use a main trunk a larger diameter than your inlet. That's just common sense. But I've never been accused of having too much common sense. I've got a V-5000 with a 7" inlet, but I used 8" as my trunk because the cyclone is in my basement & the shop is the garage & there is more distance & elbows than is ideal. Seems to work fine though. I do find that after using one of the small 4" drops for a while, dust does build up in the main trunk. Periodically I'll open a 6" & an 8" gate & there is a great whoosh & banging of all the shavings, dust & the occasional fist sized chunk of wood that have accumulated heading down to the basement. Quote
Eric. Posted March 1, 2017 Report Posted March 1, 2017 40 minutes ago, drzaius said: But I've never been accused of having too much common sense. I've got a V-5000 with a 7" inlet, but I used 8" as my trunk because the cyclone is in my basement & the shop is the garage & there is more distance & elbows than is ideal. I would say that's even more reason to use a smaller diameter main. The bigger the diameter and the longer the runs and the more turns, the lower the velocity. On the other hand, a 5HP unit like yours is going to be much more forgiving in sub-optimally designed systems than a little 2HP or smaller unit...so that may be why you're getting away with it. This should be common knowledge, but let's recap anyway... An efficient DC needs enough velocity to pull the large chips through the ducting, and enough CFM to move the fine dust from the source. Larger ducting allows for more CFM but decreases velocity, smaller ducting allows for greater velocity but decreases CFM. Without both sufficient CFM and sufficient velocity, DC will be inefficient. Until you have at least a 5HP unit, the correct diameter of the pipe will be a delicate balance, and more often than not, the DC will ultimately be insufficient simply because of the lack of power, regardless of the diameter of ducting. My 2HP system does not sufficiently move the fines because I use 4" pipe throughout the entire system in order to keep velocity up...so my system is inefficient. I could increase the diameter of my ducting to increase CFM, but I would lose so much velocity that it wouldn't pull the chips through the drops. For those who say they use 6" pipe on < 2HP units with 5" inlets...all I can say is that I'm very surprised that system works. That goes against all conventional wisdom about collection systems...and physics in general. You should never choke down the diameter at the inlet...if reduction in duct size is necessary, the smallest diameter should be at the source. The largest diameter should be the inlet itself. 1 Quote
rodger. Posted March 1, 2017 Report Posted March 1, 2017 Yes, my reading on the topic agrees with Eric's responses. The inlet on my DC is 5", so I run a short length of 5" flex hose to which ever machine I am using. Most small dust collectors were not designed to be fully ducted. I was considering, if my impeller is large enough (it's 12" I think), replacing the 5" in with a 6" inlet, not reducing it, but replacing it. 1 Quote
drzaius Posted March 1, 2017 Report Posted March 1, 2017 37 minutes ago, Eric. said: An efficient DC needs enough velocity to pull the large chips through the ducting, and enough CFM to move the fine dust from the source. Larger ducting allows for more CFM but decreases velocity, smaller ducting allows for greater velocity but decreases CFM. Without both sufficient CFM and sufficient velocity, DC will be inefficient. By using larger duct, the velocity is lower, but the static pressure loss is less, for both the duct & the fittings. So the trick is to use the largest duct possible while not letting the velocity get low enough to let the duct clog. For my system, when I open the big gate, there is enough velocity to move some pretty good chunks of hard maple. But yes, for a lower power blower & smaller duct, maintaining air velocity is more critical. Quote
sjm1580 Posted March 1, 2017 Report Posted March 1, 2017 Actually the larger main causes a reduction in the head loss (pressure) in the system. This is not static head losses, but head loss due to friction in the system. Static pressure losses are losses due to elevation for example. You are right that Pipe losses higher velocities will result in lower pressures due to head losses, so use as a main pipe within reason. Had to reach back to my fluid dynamics class memories for that one. Quote
drzaius Posted March 1, 2017 Report Posted March 1, 2017 2 minutes ago, sjm1580 said: Actually the larger main causes a reduction in the head loss (pressure) in the system. This is not static head losses, but head loss due to friction in the system. Static pressure losses are losses due to elevation for example. Had to reach back to my fluid dynamics class memories for that one. Now your talking all expert on me, but what you say makes sense when I think it through. But that's what they call it in all the reading I've done (& that was a lot) researching my own system. Quote
krtwood Posted March 1, 2017 Report Posted March 1, 2017 I ran a 1.5 hp DC with a 6" inlet with 6" piping for a while as an intermediate step between my original 4" flex hose cheap setup to moving to a 5 hp cyclone. I didn't see any point in putting any money into any 4" pipe knowing that I would be changing it all later. It generally worked okay. The only large chip generator hooked up to it was my 12" planer which had problems clogging the 4" flex hose and also would clog the 6" main. It would only do it with certain woods though, like soft maple. I could run 8" walnut through the planer all day without a problem (other than going broke) but run a 6" wide soft maple board through there and the main would be hopelessly clogged by the third pass. So it wasn't really any worse than what I had before with the planer and was better with everything else. The main advantage was that I was able to spread out the cost of going to the cyclone by getting the majority of the pipe I needed in advance. Quote
sjm1580 Posted March 2, 2017 Report Posted March 2, 2017 3 hours ago, drzaius said: Now your talking all expert on me, but what you say makes sense when I think it through. But that's what they call it in all the reading I've done (& that was a lot) researching my own system. At the end of the day static pressure losses and dynamic losses all result in the same thing. You need more pressure to overcome the losses either no matter what causes them. I am an engineer and had a hard tiime picking out the right DC and probably still got it wrong. Go figure. Quote
bushwacked Posted March 2, 2017 Author Report Posted March 2, 2017 man all these new terms I have to google haha ... this is really good info though, even if it takes me 3-4 times as long to read with all the googling I have to do to figure things out Also, I see a lot of mention of 5HP units ... is this the king of DC? I am curious because oneida has some cheaper 2-3-4HP units ... I was wondering if those would be any better at this than my Jet .. or would I really only see a worthwhile investment in a 5HP upgrading from mine now? I guess my question is are these cyclones and oneida setups more efficient or is a 4HP or 5HP motor going to work the same in all setups and the biggest difference is how the dust/chips are collected? Quote
jplemons Posted March 2, 2017 Report Posted March 2, 2017 Dust collection makes my head hurt -- from fittings, to pipe size, to HP, CFM and velocity. All of it is a huge PITA. Quote
wtnhighlander Posted March 2, 2017 Report Posted March 2, 2017 Also, I see a lot of mention of 5HP units ... is this the king of DC? Out of woodworking context, but no. At work, we have a 4000 hp "dust collector", and it just uses filter bags. Quote
bushwacked Posted March 2, 2017 Author Report Posted March 2, 2017 haha ... well I know there are more powerful out there. I was meaning more for the small shop/weekend warrior type setups. and pics of this 4000HP beast would be cool Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.