Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Woodworking Forums & Project Advice | Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Salvageable?

Featured Replies

I had posted a topic on some live edge Mesquite I got and was looking for some help on picking a few pieces and some other questions.  I have this piece and was curious if anyone knew what it is and if the piece is salvageable.  The wood has been treated with BoraCare and is the center piece for a live edge table.  The underside looks to be pretty rotted out.  I cleaned it up last night and ordered some Rotfix the other day (before actually seeing how bad it was).  Any thoughts on what it is and if it can be salvaged for the middle piece?

17078241_10105076810168688_714066657_n.jpg

17078079_10105076810083858_1028707361_n.jpg

17077808_10105076809834358_1147708328_n.jpg

17094271_10105076809909208_185211933_n.jpg

17078718_10105076809809408_280423377_n.jpg

17093946_10105076810038948_152309483_n.jpg

That should fit with the rustic aesthetic of many live edge pieces. 

  • Popular Post

You can fix a lot with Epoxy, hell you can turn a whole bowl out of epoxy... The real question isn't can you, but should you?

Structurally, you can probably make it sound, though it obviously depends on the design of your base. I'd personally say, unless you really love the look of this chunk of wood, grab another board, and cut out what small pieces of usable stock you can get from this one, then use the rest for firewood.

  • Author
1 hour ago, BonPacific said:

You can fix a lot with Epoxy, hell you can turn a whole bowl out of epoxy... The real question isn't can you, but should you?

Structurally, you can probably make it sound, though it obviously depends on the design of your base. I'd personally say, unless you really love the look of this chunk of wood, grab another board, and cut out what small pieces of usable stock you can get from this one, then use the rest for firewood.

The base will be a slab cut in half with a brace across the two (about half way down) and another across the top to support a frame for the top itself.  There are other pieces to the top that will need epoxy work.  However, this one just seemed like it was in rough shape and I wasn't sure if it is rot or something else.  I'll most likely grab another piece, it would take a ton of epoxy to fix this one up.  If it was left as is and lets say I did go the epoxy route, would the decay/rot continue after it's sealed?  There are a lot of nooks and crannies within the slab that I can't get to for cleaning purposes.  

  • Popular Post

As much as I like mesquite and live edges, I agree with BP, This board just has too much aggravation going on. If were a small knot or to, it would add character but the bottom of the board looks like a wet magazine. Besides, fajitas cooked over a mesquite fire are wonderful!

  • Popular Post

When you look at the cost to just use another board against the time and epoxy to save that board the question kinda answers itself. I don't even think there is enough decent wood in that piece to make the base legs or brace. 

Methinks it's destiny is coupled with some pork  !

  • Author
1 hour ago, RichardA said:

What was the cost of that piece of firewood?

I bought a whole trailer load, this was the worst piece of the bunch.  I think I paid $1300 for everything if I remember correctly 

IMG_1693.JPG

IMG_1654.JPG

Salvageable?

Looks like pen blanks to me :)

I looked at thread yesterday and was thinking maybe there was something that others would see in that Mesquite board that I did not. 

  • 2 weeks later...

I have to say I understand most people's opinion but I'm going to take the contrary. Not personally a live edge guy but I'd have to disagree. If you could make that happen, fill it with epoxy or whatever. That would look pretty cool. Plain old edge would tables tend to look pretty tacky to me.

If this were put together it would look more like something you would see at Crate and Barrel.

 

I've seen this sentiment before though. My uncle is a long time cabinet maker who's done all new high end finish stuff. Him and his long time friend/coworker can not wrap their heads around anything rustic or rough.

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

1 hour ago, Jer32383 said:

 Plain old edge would tables tend to look pretty tacky to me.

Auto-complete strikes again ! :P

Rustic and rough are lazy and useless.

 

Ah see I wouldn't even argue but when people make comments like these. Who died and you king? Your comment is a pretty hard statement. Unfortunately it's all about opinion so you can act like you're stating fact.

 

Your statement isn't even necessarily fundamentally correct. First some people enjoy and and think it makes their rooms look nice so it has a use, style. 2 if I buy a nice piece of wood or furniture and then distress it that's more wore then just rubbing a finish on it.

 

We are talking about live edge furniture. There is no point to live edge beyond style. Generally something like that the more effort it's going to require the more style your gonna get. Ordinary wood doesn't make successful live edge c5a5093ec0b583f1b87ee8f3ef49bb7e.jpg89bac65a837955d45413fecdc5d29c23.jpg

Good vs bad

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

  • Author
On 3/14/2017 at 2:30 PM, RichardA said:

Rustic and rough are lazy and useless.

I suppose it depends on what your idea of rustic and rough are.  I don't really see live edge as a rustic or rough look.  Sure, it might have the "old backwoods cabin" look at times when your using logs or trunks with bark on them, but a lot of the pieces now have more of a modern look.  When I see the terms "re-purposed" or "reclaimed" it makes me cringe.  Technically, wouldn't all wood be reclaimed? 

Pallet stuff is another cringe worthy word for me.  For example, someone making and marketing their stuff as "reclaimed pallet blah blah".  However, that's that individuals style, so I can respect that.  I might not like it (or in this case hate the wording) but to each their own and if they're selling it, more power to them.  On the flip side, for instance, it doesn't take much to pull some nails from a pallet and then use a nail gun to put together a wooden cooler.  I've started seeing saw mills advertise their wood/slabs as "re-purposed" because they found them after a flood.  I get the tearing down of an old barn and making something and calling it "re-purposed" or "reclaimed".  But I think the terms are thrown around pretty loosely these days.  Hell, I saw an add on craigslist for fence posts that had been torn down (you could see the new fence going up) and they were selling it under the term "reclaimed wood" for 10x what a picket would cost.

I guess my point is that there are things people use or make that we might not like, think is lazy, hate the wording, etc. but in the end we are all creating something (though others disagree or may not like it). But we, or that person, can call it their own and be proud of the fact that they've built something or found their niche.   

I try to make use out of what I have.  Out of that whole load, I'd say there were 3 slabs that were in rough shape.  The reason I posted this topic was because I wasn't sure if the rot was an issue and was worth trying to fix.  There are a few other slabs that have the same issue as the one I posted but they are not nearly as bad.  I ended up picking out 4 slabs and putting an edge on 2 sides of 2 of them to use as the middle and make up the width the customer asked for.  The two outer pieces match and have two holes where a branch were.  I wouldn't consider this table rustic or rough though.  Since "reclaimed" and "re-purposed" are already claimed, I'll coin a new term and say the table is "re-natured" 

Just Google "Nakashima "  then find some images and prices ! He called it "natural " among other terms. Some of the prices are astronomical.

  • Author
On 3/15/2017 at 2:04 PM, CandorLush said:

Check out Ron Sisco's work over at http://treestump.biz, he does a bunch of filled mesquite, I came across him at his booth at the American Craft Council.

He has some really great pieces.  I've done some filling on various pieces and thought about it for the board I posted above.  I just wasn't sure if the issue was a certain kind of rot or worth trying to fix.  I'm finishing a bar top for someone who wanted it to look "all natural" and have a glaze coat on it so they could use it outside in a covered area.  After talking to them and showing them some different ides, we went from all natural to epoxy with glow pigment powder.  I'll attach a before and after.  It's not all the way done but here is where it's at so far.  Side note: nothing says natural or nature more than a waterfall, right? lol

bartopslab.jpg

bartopslab2.jpg

  • Author
8 minutes ago, wdwerker said:

Just Google "Nakashima "  then find some images and prices ! He called it "natural " among other terms. Some of the prices are astronomical.

I've seen his work and really like it!  I've never looked at the pricing though, found a table for a mere $475,00!  When I see his pieces, the word "natural" definitely comes to mind.  I guess some may think of it as rustic or rough and/or not like the stlye, but beauty is in the eye of the beholder and everyone likes different things.  Back to that table...I'll split the cost with you if you want to go half in with me or I can cover the shipping haha  

  https://www.1stdibs.com/furniture/tables/dining-room-tables/george-nakashima-masterwork-single-board-solid-rosewood-table/id-f_4699923/

Ahhhhh! I can see it now, "Coop & Walnut" ;)

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,011 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • bobtjanitor Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.