Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Woodworking Forums & Project Advice | Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Cleaning up an old Hooker - how to refinish her top?

Featured Replies

Hi all and thanks in advance for your time reading and your thoughts! I finally found the 1950's Hooker Mainline floating desk of my dreams, but she needed some work on the desk top. I'm not sure of the top wood type? The drawers are oak sides and pine front. It didn't seem like the finish is poly, but I am a newby when it comes to assessing this stuff. My friend says it is too old for poly, that it was probably just stained and waxed? The damage was typical stuff for 60+ years old. Sun fade, pen marks, pock mocks, dings and dents, spilled paint, and just plain abuse. I tried a good soap and water cleaning, and that did wonders, but there was so much damage that I decided to sand her down.

I did 120, 220, orbital then hand sand with the grain. I didn't sand her down to far, but cleaned up all the imperfections for sure. She looked amazing after sanding and a good wipe down with mineral spirits. The color is RICH and amazing still, but looks a tad dry and thirsty compared to the draw fronts, sides, etc.  I still think it looks great! Pictures attached after sanding and cleaning.

Now I stand looking at the deep, rich top and wonder how you all would approach it?

I though about something like Howards Restore-a-finish followed by Howards feed and wax or Minwax paste wax, then a life of waxing, but since the underlying finish seem a bit dull would it always look dull? I certainly don't mind waxing!

I considered applying some fresh stain over the top, though it looks very even as is, it could help. 2-3 new coats of stain and then finish with some poly? That's the direction all my "friends" are telling me to go. They tell me I'll be much more happy with how it will hold it. I'm just not sure that will blend well with the other surfaces, but I know the top matters the most. This desk will be used for sure, its not a show piece by any means.

All thoughts appreciated! Thanks again for your time!

Mike

IMG_20170506_164744.jpg

IMG_20170506_164802.jpg

IMG_20170506_180601.jpg

Stop listening to your friends.  No offense, but they seems to be making stuff up :) 

the top looks like it is in pretty good shape and any of the suggestions you had will make it look worse. 

you can't put stain over an existing finish. Stain only goes on bare wood and you should never use more than one coat of stain. 

the top looks like walnut to me (either solid or more likely veneer) and if so that might be the natural wood color with just a clear coat - Probably lacquer because that is what 90% of furniture made in the 20th century was finished with. 

Just keep it clean and enjoy it.  Resist the temptation to feed and water it, it is wood, not a house plant and any oil or wax on a prefinished surface is only superficial.  

Pretty much no factory furniture is finished with "stain and wax" so tell that friend to stick to knitting or whatever :) 

Its a beautiful piece, enjoy. 

Also, take no offense from my little jabs.  all my advice was learned the hard way.... 

 

  • Author

That's exactly the kind of real advise I was looking for!!! You nailed the "friends"... that's why I came here. Though I think they are better drinkers than knitters!

The top is solid. No veneer on this beauty anywhere. I like the idea to keep it as is, and the lighting where it will be is low, and indirect (think cool 1950's lamps!).

I read about "Renaissance Wax", but felt the same way... it would be superficial.

Thanks Mike!

If you sanded off the dents , scratches etc. you probably removed most if not all the finish.

I bet a few coats of wiping varnish like General Finishes Arm-R-Seal would make that walnut top beautiful . You can sand lightly between coats. Just read the directions on the can.

By the title, I thought... well, I thought that someone was in a trunk. Or someone was on the way for a lift... Maybe some outpatient surgery?

Seems like the patient has been properly diagnosed, and has found a nice home. You know what they say... You can take the... er... can't make a... well, that's all I have.

 

I missed the part that said you sanded the top.  In that case, minwax wipe on poly or arm r seal might max sense.  

Or, if you are going to keep liquids away from it (no martinis or IPAs at the desk) you could just use wax and rewax periodically.   I suggest that because if you did not sand off all the old finish, then the poly won't go on evenly at all, and you will just give yourself a headache.  

Wax offers almost no protection (hence no beverages) but will give the sanded wood some life. 

  • Author

Thanks all. Very high likelihood of Martinis, Whisky, Scotch, and a sundry of other tasty beverages making its way to the desk. I think the ARS may be the way to go.

The top was a real mess, and sanding was my only hope. I'll follow up with the ARS results this weekend. I hope to have her done by then.

 

And yes Llama, I couldn't resist the topic :)

 

IMG_20170423_113447.jpg

I agree with the walnut but am still not sold that it's solid. Those book matches are so close on the bottom half I don't see how they cut  6 boards sequentially at around an inch with little to no variation.

If you plan to use it regularly, I would think a bit more protection than varnish. I have a small writing desk with 3 coats arm r seal and I get drag on the tip when writing with a pen.

  • Author

Brenden - I sure didn't think it was veneer, but that's what I get for thinking. Closer inspection sure looks that way. I'm off to find ARS now. Do they carry it at any of the big box stores. Thank you!

IMG_20170511_191948.jpg

i've never seen it at a bog box store Mike, Woodcraft, Rockler, Acme Tools is where i have found it at as well as many other places i'm sure.

18 minutes ago, MidMadModMike said:

Brenden - I sure didn't think it was veneer, but that's what I get for thinking. Closer inspection sure looks that way. I'm off to find ARS now. Do they carry it at any of the big box stores. Thank you!

IMG_20170511_191948.jpg

That COULD be just to cover the end grain but now I'm pretty sure it's veneer. Is that "band" on all sides?

Minwax Wipe On Poly is pretty much the same thing as ARm R Seal and the box stores carry it.   they are both diluted polyurethane varnish. 

  • Author
10 minutes ago, Brendon_t said:

That COULD be just to cover the end grain but now I'm pretty sure it's veneer. Is that "band" on all sides?

I think... see pics...

IMG_20170511_194750.jpg

IMG_20170511_194813.jpg

Mike you gotten a lot of good advise, so I'm not going to add.   Your title caught my attention and I just kept saying to myself, don't comment or you will be banned.

  • Popular Post

My sixty year old, although not a hooker, has a fine top and hand applied warm oils has continued to provide lasting beauty.

That is a beautiful desk & I'm jealous. You've gotten some good advice here & I'll add to the recommendation for a wiping varnish. It's really easy to get a great finish. Good luck with it

20 minutes ago, drzaius said:

That is a beautiful desk & I'm jealous. You've gotten some good advice here & I'll add to the recommendation for a wiping varnish. It's really easy to get a great finish. Good luck with it

I agree. Although not something I would fill my house with, I would certainly put it in my home office. Cool desk! Give us some pics of the final product when you're finished with it. 

If you do decide you want to change the color, a glaze (as opposed to staining the wood) can go on between coats of varnish.  Van Dyke Brown seems to be trendy, and is what I have recent experience with.  The glaze is a pigment; you aren't staining the wood, you're just adding a color layer between layers of finish.

[edit:  I'm not suggesting you need to change the color!!  I kind of like the look of the grain, and a pigment will occlude that grain a bit.]

  • 2 weeks later...
  • Author

Well, she is on her way to and old Hooker with a damn nice top!

The first coat of ARS scared me... she was DRY and took 3 days to really fully dry to the touch. I applied with a foam brush in long strokes. She really looked spotty and had a few "wet" streaks

Sanded lightly... then coat 2. Foam brush again. This time she took it much easier but left me with me with brush "marks". That 2 inch brush seemed to run out in the last 1/4 of the stroke. Took 2 days to dry... but looked much better.

Sanded again and cleaned with vac and mineral spirits. She looked really good.

This time got an old t-shirt and did what I suppose wiping varnish is meant to for. Wiped it on. It went on great! Very smooth and a nice finish! She dried in 24 hours. Now I'm going to very lightly buff her and clear her up and see if another coat is needed. I think it will take at least one more.

I will post pics when done. I couldn't be happier! Thanks for all the help!

Mike

  • Author

DONE! I think. She takes ARS like champ now, after the third coat it's a breeze and a little addicting. I stopped at 5, but I could see putting on ten coats. I buffer her out with some 0000 and wiped clean with some MS, and she just looks and feels awesome. I also bough some Renaissance Wax. I'm tempted to put on a layer, but it seems thoughts on that are mixed.  Again, thanks to all the guidance. I would definitely do this again!

 

IMG_20170526_174055.jpg

IMG_20170526_174114.jpg

IMG_20170526_174135.jpg

Wow, that's beautiful! The first time I used ARS I couldn't believe how good it was.

I'd skip the wax, doesn't need it at all.

  • Author
11 hours ago, drzaius said:

Wow, that's beautiful! The first time I used ARS I couldn't believe how good it was.

I'd skip the wax, doesn't need it at all.

Skipping the wax for sure. The top has a very nice open grain structure, and that worries me with the wax based on other forum topics! Thanks!

On 5/11/2017 at 9:22 PM, K Cooper said:

My sixty year old, although not a hooker, has a fine top and hand applied warm oils has continued to provide lasting beauty.

What a weird way to describe your mistress.....

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,011 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • bobtjanitor Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.