Recommended Posts

Posted

My 2 HP router is on it's last legs. The motor is making loud noises. It's a piece of crap anyway - a very cheap one I bought years ago so I'm not going to repair it.

So I'm looking for suggestions:

  • 2HP or more powerful
  • 1/4" and 1/2" bit capacity
  • Router lift compatible. I've been looking at the JessEm ones from Lee Valley but I'm not set on them so if someone has a better suggestion?
  • MUST be available in Canada
Posted

Well, I currently have just a 1hp small router. I've been looking for a more serious router for a while, and here's the only one that has everything I wanted for well under $200:

http://www.sears.com/craftsman-14-amp-digital-router/p-00950429000P

Not sure you absolutely need the lift, it includes a hex key for over-the-table height adjustment, guides, both collets and the 2 bases. 14 amp is plenty of power imo (craftsman's biggest router). I think its main problem is having EXTRA features, I don't trust the digital adjustments for the long run.

 

If you don't trust craftsman at all (which i would find absolutely understandable), the equivalent in features and specs from Bosch is around $280 (MRC23EVSK). Their older 1617 is still around and I believe you wouldn't be missing much on the specs side and it should be around $190. 

 

From what I've seen, Bosch routers are fairly well trusted and even recommended, unless your budget allows for a festool.

Guest Randy
Posted

Over the years i've owned a Makita, PC, Dewalt, Ryobi, Triton, and Festool. I owned a Makita the longest (about 35 years) and feel they are really solid routers. My PC, Dewalt, Triton, and Festool routers are also great routers. Unfortunately I don't know much about compatibility with router lifts, since I have a dedicated Incra table/fence system/router lift in which I mount a PC 7518 motor. I do know that that motor is compatible with a number of lifts and is an excellent, powerful motor for router tables.

Posted

I've suggested a dedicated router table lift because the router I have has a mechanism to mount it in the table but it's very poorly designed. It is cheap so I'd be happy if it was just that. The design pulls the router off square as you raise it, so even if it's mounted correctly by the time it raised half way the mechanism binds to the point where you can't raise it any more.

I have a feeling this router will be permanently mounted in the router table. I have a couple of other 1HP routers which can do 1/4" bits easily and I don't have many 1/2" router bits - only a panel raising set which can only be used in a table.

Guest Randy
Posted

Given you want a dedicated router/router lift/router table combo, I agree that the PC7518 is a great choice. I also can't say enough good things about the Incra lift. It's accurate, precise, and it is already set up out of the box for the PC7518 router motor. It's a powerful motor which probably would do almost anything you want it to.

Posted

Probably because I chose to go that way but, I always feel compelled to point out the other favorite locomotive for the router table, the Milwaukee 5625.  I have a couple of them, one has been running since 2006 without any indication that any time has passed at all.  The motor diameter is a bit over 4-1/8" so most lift makers make a version for it (like my Woodpeckers) or pads to fit.  Plenty of happy owners of both over a fairly decent time span.

  • Like 1
Posted

I picked up the Milwaukee 5625 a couple of years ago & it's a very nice handling router. Far smoother & better balanced the my mid-sized PC router. I just did some bamboo countertops for my 5th wheel & I was doing 3/4" deep passes with a 1/2" bit & it had no problem at all.

  • Like 1
Posted

Always been my thinking that in a shop we need at least THREE routers. A Porter Cable 7518 motor dedicated to a router table, a trim router (such as a DeWalt 611, Festool OF 1010 or Bosch Colt)  for smaller edge profiles and other 1/4" bit jobs, and a mid size, all around router (such as the Bosch 1617 or Festool OF 1400) for everyday handheld use.

  • Like 2
Posted
33 minutes ago, ben_r_ said:

Always been my thinking that in a shop we need at least THREE routers. A Porter Cable 7518 motor dedicated to a router table, a trim router (such as a DeWalt 611, Festool OF 1010 or Bosch Colt)  for smaller edge profiles and other 1/4" bit jobs, and a mid size, all around router (such as the Bosch 1617 or Festool OF 1400) for everyday handheld use.

Agreed.  At least three.  I have an OF1400 as my everyday driver, PC7518 in my RT, Dewalt DWP611 plunge for miscellaneous small jobs, a pair of Bosch Colts, one with a chamfer, one with 1/8" roundover permanently chucked, and a pair of PC690s for the dovetail jig...and an ancient Ryobi from my previous life that never dies, although I basically never use it.  You can never have too many routers...especially when you're lazy.

Posted

My collection is probably excessive for a weekend hobbyist, but I would definitely have at least two: a 7518 or similar for the RT, and a high-quality, powerful plunge unit for everything else.  There's no way that I could handle the time-suck swapping in and out a router table unit for handheld use.

Then I'd add a trim router anyway because they're fairly cheap and I don't like doing small profiles like chamfers or small roundovers with a giant router.

  • Like 1

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   4 Members, 0 Anonymous, 54 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,008
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Bob44
    Newest Member
    Bob44
    Joined