Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Total shop overhaul. Submit opinions within!

Featured Replies

I have about a 500 sq/ft shop (whole garage). I've been working the wood for a couple of years now and I feel that I'm at a healthy enough point to where I would like to upgrade to tools that I won't ever have to replace.. probably will when the next latest and greatest comes out, but let's assume I'm not. We've been making cutting boards and piddly stuff to make money on the side, but I'd like to turn the hobby into a full time gig at some point. I've been making due with the economy tools I've acquired over the last couple of years, but I can never get consistent precision out of them for more than a couple of weeks (my porter cable jointer is more like 2 days). I've got my list put together, but I would really appreciate any and all opinions on what you guys would recommend, as far as brands and models go. What works well for you? Assume I have a hefty budget, and I'm out for blood in my local market. What I'm in the market for:

-Table Saw

-Jointer 

-Mortiser 

-Drill Press

-Drum Sander 

-Band Saw

-Dust Collector

Any and all input is greatly appreciated! Thanks a lot in advance. 

Kyle

 

Kyle, welcome to the forum.  What sort of things do you plan on making as your full time gig? That could change the list completely.

I would also recommend visiting the power tool City sub and read a bit. There are probably a hundred threads there with essentially the same question and lost of tools. You would probably get a better respond and more pointed answers if you narrow your search down to specific tools. Asking about a table saw recommendation will get crickets. Asking what people's experience with xxxxx saw or this model jointer will often get the info you are hoping for.

Regardless, knowing what and how you build will be needed for about all recommendations. Except the drum sander. Super max 19-38 seems to be the hands down crowd favorite

https://www.amazon.com/SawStop-PCS31230-TGP236-Professional-Assembly-Extension/dp/B009C7NGTE/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1500586887&sr=8-1&keywords=sawstop+pcs

 

71q3SWczSSL._SL1500_.jpg

 

https://www.amazon.com/Powermatic-1610082-PJ-882HH-Parallelogram-Cutterhead/dp/B001GOALW6/ref=sr_1_5?ie=UTF8&qid=1500586956&sr=8-5&keywords=powermatic+jointer

 

51OEKTlRN+L._SX425_.jpg

 

https://www.amazon.com/Powermatic-1791213-15HH-230-Volt-Cutterhead/dp/B001GOEPF0/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1500587009&sr=8-1&keywords=powermatic+planer

 

613Fyu6HDZL._SL1000_.jpg

 

https://www.amazon.com/Festool-574432-Domino-Joiner-500/dp/B004SETSXE/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1500587088&sr=8-1&keywords=domino+500

 

81d9gkTj-qL._SL1500_.jpg

 

https://www.amazon.com/Jet-JDP-17-Drill-Press/dp/B00NF6P8PI/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1500587166&sr=8-1&keywords=jet+drill+press

 

71Z2yO+v09L._SL1500_.jpg

 

https://www.amazon.com/Supermax-71938-D-SuperMax-19-38-Sander/dp/B006O0NIU4/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1500587224&sr=8-1&keywords=supermax+19-38

 

41IsTApD8SL.jpg

 

https://www.amazon.com/Powermatic-PM1500-1791500-BandSaw/dp/B00A86U254/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1500587289&sr=8-1&keywords=powermatic+1500

 

61tSveRpSZL._SL1200_.jpg

 

https://www.amazon.com/Laguna-Tools-MBAND1412-175-Bandsaw-Black/dp/B00J3PKHX8/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1500587339&sr=8-1&keywords=laguna+1412

 

713pRHO556L._SL1500_.jpg

 

 

http://www.clearvuecyclones.com/9-cv1800-series

cv1800-lh-single-phase-with-filters.jpg

 

 

NOTE:  All links except the ClearVue are to Amazon...but not necessarily the best price.  Only given for reference.

 

Also, you forgot this :) ...

 

http://www.incra.com/router_table_fences-ls_super_sys.html

 

p_lssuper_main.png

 

https://www.amazon.com/INCRA-Mast-R-Lift-II-Router-Lift/dp/B007JTYFKQ/ref=sr_1_2?s=hi&ie=UTF8&qid=1500587746&sr=1-2&keywords=incra+mast-r-lift-ii+router+lift

 

41yyhoth6yL.jpg

 

https://www.amazon.com/PORTER-CABLE-7518-Speedmatic-5-Speed-Router/dp/B0000222V3/ref=sr_1_1?s=hi&ie=UTF8&qid=1500587865&sr=1-1&keywords=porter+cable+7518

 

71qUlpXX-kL._SL1500_.jpg

  • Author
Quote

Not quite that hefty! LOL,

 

So here's the low down, we make cutting boards and small turned items as of right now. I also make furniture as best I can with the equipment I have. I would like to ramp that part of it up since that is what I enjoy building most. Probably going to do cabinets as well since that's what most people ask for.. So here is my list, and if you guys have any experience with any of these, let me know what you think of them. I'm not married to them, but I am drooling over them. 

Sawstop PCS31230 w/ the 52" fence 

Powermatic 60HH 8" Jointer w/ helical head 

Powermatic 2244 Drum Sander 

Powermatic 719T Mortiser

Laguna C|Flux dust collector

Grizzly 17" Band saw (the 30th anniversary model because it looks SWEET) 

Grizzly 12 speed 20" Drill press 

 

15 hours ago, Brendon_t said:

Kyle, welcome to the forum.  What sort of things do you plan on making as your full time gig?

Thanks, Brendon. Glad to be a part of the forum. Hope to be a helpful, contributing member.

Furniture is what I'm trying to focus pretty hard on, realistically it's going to be a lot of face frame cabinets.  

Wow, that's quite a list!  I'm assuming some of it is the 'want'/drool factor, not really a 'need' - for instance, do you really need a mortiser for FF cabinets? I'm going to side with Eric on his list, and suggest swapping that for a Festool Domino - Mortise and tenon construction is cool, but if you want to turn it into more of a full time gig, efficiency/speed will reign supreme and the Domino is aces in that department.

1 minute ago, Kyle Farmer said:

Sawstop PCS31230 w/ the 52" fence

How much room do you have & how much are you going to need the 52". I ask, because I lived with a 52" fence for about 15 years & rarely use the capacity. And cross cutting sheet goods with the fence way out there can get kinda dicey.

I've had a PCS with a 36" fence for a couple of years & have yet to need the longer rails

6 minutes ago, Kyle Farmer said:

Laguna C|Flux dust collector

Check out the Clear Vue & Oneida offerings. The stubbier cone, like on the Laguna do not separate the fines as well as the deeper cones. The Dust Gorilla & Clear Vue can be a problem if you only have an 8' ceiling, but the Oneida V series will fit there.

If you're doing primarily cabinets you might consider a sliding table saw or getting into the Festool world, specifically MFT and tracksaw.

The Supermax is a better bang/buck unit for a hobbyist, but if you're gonna be in production I would look at higher level units like the Woodmaster or a wide-belt like Ross said.  I just don't see the justification in buying the PM2244 over the Supermax.

Unless you're doing a ton of Craftsman style furniture, a Domino will be a much more versatile tool for you than a HCM.

The Clearvue is a better value than the Laguna DC.

I have a 17" Grizzly bandsaw.  It's junk.  Buy the PM1500 or a big Laguna or Minimax.  It's nice to have a second bandsaw set up for curves - Laguna 1412 is a no-brainer.  You won't need this for cabinets but for furniture work it's gold.

The Jet DP that I posted is kind of like the Supermax...hard to argue buying anything else at this time.  Best bang/buck.

25 minutes ago, Kyle Farmer said:

 

Powermatic 719T Mortiser

 

That looks like a pretty decent list. 

The HCM wouldn't fall to the bottom of my list, it would fall off completely and be replaced with a domino 700. 

Of the projects you stated, I can't think of an operation that isn't better served by the green weenie.

  • Author
8 minutes ago, drzaius said:

How much room do you have & how much are you going to need the 52". I ask, because I lived with a 52" fence for about 15 years & rarely use the capacity. And cross cutting sheet goods with the fence way out there can get kinda dicey.

I've had a PCS with a 36" fence for a couple of years & have yet to need the longer rails

Check out the Clear Vue & Oneida offerings. The stubbier cone, like on the Laguna do not separate the fines as well as the deeper cones. The Dust Gorilla & Clear Vue can be a problem if you only have an 8' ceiling, but the Oneida V series will fit there.

Probably won't need the 52" fence, but... does it hurt to have it? B) 

The new outfeed bench behind it will be the same length, which will be nice and spacious. Plus it's only like a $100 difference from the 36 to the 52.. so...

I will take a second look at dust collectors. I admit that I haven't done as much research on them. 

 

 

  • Author
7 minutes ago, Brendon_t said:

Of the projects you stated, I can't think of an operation that isn't better served by the green weenie.

:lol: :lol::lol:

I already plan on getting a domino to replace my biscuiter, I just didn't really classify that as "heavy equipment" so I didn't ask about those, but I am planning on doing higher end furniture and would like to have a stationary HCM. Obviously not a need, but a serious want. 

I'm planning on having a few more green things laying around the shop as well though. Their ROS makes me enjoy sanding. 

12 minutes ago, Kyle Farmer said:

Probably won't need the 52" fence, but... does it hurt to have it? B) 

 

 

It's a space issue. If your shop is huge then you r right it doesn't hurt. If your shop is a 1 or even 2 car garage then with all of these machines you want to add that is a lot of space being taken up by a table with small utility.

I second a domino over mortiser. I own a heavy duty mortiser and like it well enough but after doing a lot of mortises on a night stand project I am seriously considering a domino in my future.

  • Author
20 minutes ago, Eric. said:

The Supermax is a better bang/buck unit for a hobbyist, but if you're gonna be in production I would look at higher level units like the Woodmaster or a wide-belt like Ross said.  I just don't see the justification in buying the PM2244 over the Supermax.

I originally had the 25-50 spec'd, but saw the 2244 and assumed it was a little bit better quality. Do you have experience with the supermax that can sway me back in that direction? I'm definitely open to saving a few hundred bucks.. 

22 minutes ago, Eric. said:

I have a 17" Grizzly bandsaw.  It's junk.  Buy the PM1500 or a big Laguna or Minimax.  It's nice to have a second bandsaw set up for curves - Laguna 1412 is a no-brainer.  You won't need this for cabinets but for furniture work it's gold.

What are your major complaints about the Grizzly? Seems like a pretty good bargain saw and you're one of the first people to tell me they're junk.. 

  • Author
3 minutes ago, minorhero said:

It's a space issue. If your shop is huge then you r right it doesn't hurt. If your shop is a 1 or even 2 car garage then with all of these machines you want to add that is a lot of space being taken up by a table with small utility.

My shop is by no means "huge", but it will fit and won't impede on anything. 

There is a Powermatic 719 on the local CL that is marked all the way down to $675 the last I checked.  It would be cool to play with and I'd be lying if I said the thought didn't cross my mind, but it seems like HCM's are going the way of radial arm saws.

32 minutes ago, Kyle Farmer said:

 

What are your major complaints about the Grizzly? Seems like a pretty good bargain saw and you're one of the first people to tell me they're junk.. 

You said it, it's a bargain saw.  With most bargains, compromises were made.  With Grizzly it seems that compromise seems to be quality control.  You might luck out and get a gem, or you might get a lemon that slipped past QC. 

Sawstop PCS31230 w/ the 52" fence 

Powermatic 60HH 8" Jointer w/ helical head 

Powermatic 2244 Drum Sander 

Powermatic 719T Mortiser

Laguna C|Flux dust collector

Grizzly 17" Band saw (the 30th anniversary model because it looks SWEET) 

Grizzly 12 speed 20" Drill press 

 

First, i think a solid game plan is in order. You said you make small turned objects and cutting boards--tchotchkes of sorts. No offense meant with that term, i made the same for awhile to make money. Still, going from that production to something else requires a shift in mindset and especially tooling. You say you get a lot of demand for cabinets, but you want to make furniture. Unfortunately, if you want to eat, then it sounds like it will be a 90:10 split towards cabinets. Are you jumping in to this venture with both feet or a transition from office job to small business owner? If its a transition, then i would suggest doing it on the cheap with a used cabinet saw, 6" floor jointer, dw735, router table, table top drill press, kreg jig, middle of the road hvlp, and a solid ROS sander. You can buy all of this used for under $3000. See how your business grows. See if you can handle it. See if you even like it. I run a side operation, and i can tell you a full weekend of milling a few hundred board feet of lumber can make me excited to go in to the office on monday morning. That was very true on monday this week. I was whooped. 

 

If this venture blossoms and becomes something or you know in your heart of hearts this is what you want to do, then i suggest throwing out your current hobbyist paradigm. It wont work. Have you been in a pro shop before? Spoke to these guys? You need to, seriously. No offense given, but all suggestions are very hobbyist centric choices. Nobody mentioned a shaper, which is probably #2 on the list of most important tools required for cabinet making. #1 is a panel saw/slider. Quickly going through your list, it is great for a guy starting a general purpose woodworking hobby shop. It misses the mark for someone trying to make money efficiently. I mentioned the need for a slider over a cabinet saw already. Most shops have cabinet saws setup with power feeds for ripping rails and stiles. You dont need a $3500 sawstop to save your power feeder's fingers. Your jointer is an ok pick, but it is worth it to step up to the PJ model with the parallelogram beds. The drum sander would require two passes for your typical assembled face frame(24"). I had a 719 for a hot minute. Own the domino and you wont touch a HCM again. For the visible joinery that you do 2% of the time, you can other means. Personally, i dont think a HCM is suitable for the cleanest through-mortises, but thats just my experience. I dont know about the DC, but it's a well traveled road that oneida and clearview put out very good products. I have a grizzly cyclone and it does well in reviews. Honestly, i dont think you need a bandsaw for cabinet making. Put off the purchase until you can get a MM16 or something if the furniture gig takes off. You want a line boring machine and not really a supped up drill press. I would be on the hunt for a used blum machine. You can also look into the LR32 system from festool. Your boring comes down to hinges and shelf pins. A cheap POS benchtop drill press can handle the cup recesses just fine for euro hinges. Finally, you need a spray system for sure. 

 

Hopefully that came across as helpful and not poo-pooing your plan. I meant it to be helpful atleast...Im not a cabinet pro and i dont intend to be one, but i personally know a handful, and i know a bit about professional setups. It is worth your time to talk to some and understand how they work. The one guy i know has such a simple setup. 10' slider, pm66 in the outfeed with a feeder, widebelt, edgebander, 7.5hp euro shaper, line boring machine, big compressor with spray setup and spray booth. Boom, that is it. Buys his solid wood surfaced, straight lines it on the slider and hes off to the races. 

1 hour ago, Kyle Farmer said:

I originally had the 25-50 spec'd, but saw the 2244 and assumed it was a little bit better quality. Do you have experience with the supermax that can sway me back in that direction? I'm definitely open to saving a few hundred bucks.. 

What are your major complaints about the Grizzly? Seems like a pretty good bargain saw and you're one of the first people to tell me they're junk.. 

I own the SM19-38, as does another million hobbyists, many on this forum.  They are basically universally accepted as the best bang for your buck for hobbyist drum sanders.  But like I said earlier, if you're planning on going into production, you might consider a larger, more powerful unit that's better suited to heavy use.  They will cost you significantly more money but they are built for production rather than casual hobbyist usage.

If you've boiled the choices down between the Supermax and the Powermatic, I just don't see the justification for the significantly higher price tag on the PM for one feature that isn't really necessary.  I'm sure they're great machines, but it's hard to justify when the Supermax is available and cheaper and is loved by basically everyone.

The Grizzly bandsaw is...a Grizzly.  They are budget machines and budget quality.  I've spent countless hours tuning that saw and upgrading its parts, including urethane tires, Carter guides and a hundred blades of varying configurations from a number of makers.  It cuts wood.  It works.  But it's always left a rougher cut than I desire, and for resaw I have not been able to achieve the results that I would expect from a better saw.  It gets the job done...but nothing more.

  • Author
10 minutes ago, Pwk5017 said:

First, i think a solid game plan is in order. You said you make small turned objects and cutting boards--tchotchkes of sorts. No offense meant with that term, i made the same for awhile to make money. Still, going from that production to something else requires a shift in mindset and especially tooling. You say you get a lot of demand for cabinets, but you want to make furniture. Unfortunately, if you want to eat, then it sounds like it will be a 90:10 split towards cabinets. Are you jumping in to this venture with both feet or a transition from office job to small business owner? If its a transition, then i would suggest doing it on the cheap with a used cabinet saw, 6" floor jointer, dw735, router table, table top drill press, kreg jig, middle of the road hvlp, and a solid ROS sander. You can buy all of this used for under $3000. See how your business grows. See if you can handle it. See if you even like it. I run a side operation, and i can tell you a full weekend of milling a few hundred board feet of lumber can make me excited to go in to the office on monday morning. That was very true on monday this week. I was whooped. 

Hey, I greatly appreciate all of your time and advice in writing this. However, my business plan is pretty well thought out, in my opinion. I'm not starting from square one either, just kind of overhauling. I'm not necessarily in the market for "commercial" equipment, just nice equipment that should last me a long while. And because I'm me, I wan't shiny new toys. 

I worked in a relatively successful cabinet shop in Omaha, NE for a while and understand workflow on that level, but I'm not planning on running a cabinet shop.

I'm planning on doing commission whatever, with the focus being on residential furniture and fixtures because that's what I feel that I do best. I will pump cabinets out though, as a vehicle to get where I would like to be, only because people pay more for cabinets than cutting boards. My goal is to have a well equipped, single man furniture shop, and in having all of the necessary tooling to do one-off furniture pieces, I feel I will be well equipped to do cabinets when need be.

I didn't take offense to anything you said, I totally get what you're saying, but I'm just trying to let you know where my head is. I'm not shooting for massive scale cabinet shop. Or massive scale furniture for that matter, just some respectable income on the side. Cutting boards aren't cutting it B). I have, what I would say is a good day job, but my heart is in the shop. Always has been. Just need some nicer stuff to do what I want to do... 

2 minutes ago, Kyle Farmer said:

My goal is to have a well equipped, single man furniture shop, and in having all of the necessary tooling to do one-off furniture pieces, I feel I will be well equipped to do cabinets when need be.

See post #3 in this thread. :)

  • Author
2 minutes ago, Eric. said:

I own the SM19-38, as does another million hobbyists, many on this forum.  They are basically universally accepted as the best bang for your buck for hobbyist drum sanders.  But like I said earlier, if you're planning on going into production, you might consider a larger, more powerful unit that's better suited to heavy use.  They will cost you significantly more money but they are built for production rather than casual hobbyist usage.

If you've boiled the choices down between the Supermax and the Powermatic, I just don't see the justification for the significantly higher price tag on the PM for one feature that isn't really necessary.  I'm sure they're great machines, but it's hard to justify when the Supermax is available and cheaper and is loved by basically everyone.

The Grizzly bandsaw is...a Grizzly.  They are budget machines and budget quality.  I've spent countless hours tuning that saw and upgrading its parts, including urethane tires, Carter guides and a hundred blades of varying configurations from a number of makers.  It cuts wood.  It works.  But it's always left a rougher cut than I desire, and for resaw I have not been able to achieve the results that I would expect from a better saw.  It gets the job done...but nothing more.

I greatly appreciate the feedback Eric. I will go back to the drawing board on the band saw and dive a little deeper into it. 

I don't see building cabinets for income in a 500 sq. ft. shop with all that equipment in it.  

I built new houses for 33 years.  I'd build the garage first, and move all the tools in it (so I've had 33 garage woodshops). I built all the cabinets for the house, as well as many other parts, such as door jambs, staircases, etc, etc.  All the cabinet assembly was done in the house, and pieces were put in place as soon as the carcasses were built, so no room was needed to store the assembled cabinets before installation.   It takes a lot of room just for assembly, and to put the assembled pieces somewhere before they leave, before even thinking about where the finishing is going to be done.

9 hours ago, Kyle Farmer said:

My shop is by no means "huge", but it will fit and won't impede on anything. 

I somehow missed that the shop is only 500 square feet. You should really re-consider the 52" fence. My shop is only 30 square feet smaller then yours and I have the 36 inch rails on the 3hp sawstop and I am very very glad I don't have a larger table. I have all the same equipment as you want to buy except I don't have a drum sander and I do not know where exactly I could put one without constantly tripping over it.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Who's Online (See full list)

  • There are no registered users currently online

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,010 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Lolli4 Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.