Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Overhead Air Cleaner

Featured Replies

I have decided to buy an overhead type air cleaner.  The question I would like to run past you folks is whether two small units would be better, worse or the same as one larger unit. 

I am into wood turning now,.  I do have masks for use when working, but turning generates copious dust which migrates and settles on everything.   So I admit my first goal is keeping the place cleaner, but keeping my lungs cleaner is also important.  I also put a premium on quieter operation.

I had done some research including other posts here and a older Fine Wookworking article on the topic and had settled on the Jet AFS 100B.  I have been waiting for a 15% sale to pull the trigger.  At 15% off I figure it will be about $325.  Now Woodcraft has the little Rikon on sale this month, it's the model 62-400 for $150.  I could buy two of the Rikons and still save money over the Jet.

That got me thinking, would that actually be better?  They move about half the CFM as the larger units, but I still think they move a lot of air compared to the size of my shop. I could put them at opposite corners of the shop which I think would improve the efficiency.  The little Rikons also pull about 1 amp each as compared to 4.5 to 6 amps for the larger units (Rikon, Jet, Supermax).  Which means I have a lot of freedom as to where to plug them in.  

I suppose the corollary question is whether one small unit is enough.

Shop size is about 23 x 23 with 8 foot ceiling.  

I've got one of the small units in a single car garage (12x21). It does a decent job in there, but I would want a bigger unit in your space (or two smaller ones, maybe). I'm not sure which is the better plan.

I have a mid/large-sized overhead air cleaner (https://www.busybeetools.com/products/heavy-duty-air-filter-with-led-csa-cx408.html ) that I use regularly when I’m working in my shop (23x23 double car garage) - I actually most often turn it on when I leave the shop and let it run for a few hours.  When I return to the shop the air is noticeably cleaner/fresher.

However, I run my 3HP Oneida dust collector while I’m turning anything on my lathe -especially when I’m sanding. Most times I don’t even need to wear a respirator since I can get near 100% dust extraction.  I used an inexpensive dust hood from Amazon (https://www.amazon.com/PSI-Woodworking-DLHOODC2-Magnetic-Mounting/dp/B000KIEC6U/ref=sr_1_3?s=hi&ie=UTF8&qid=1508067050&sr=1-3&keywords=Lathe+dust) and rigged it up so it’s moveable - I can get it as close to the spot I’m working as is possible without being in my way.  When it’s close, it does a surprisingly good job and I don’t get dust settling on everything in the shop.

I have the general unit, and it runs 800 CFM. It's string enough to create breeze in the shop.

The issue is decent filters. See if you can get HEPA bag filters - they are a big improvement over the 1 micron filters.

  • Author

@ChrisG-CanadaThe hood is an interesting gizmo, especially as it is working for you.  What kind of lathe do you have it mounted on?

  • Author

I spoke to Rikon tech support about using two small units instead of one big unit.  They said it actually works fine.

I would go if one large unit over two small ones for two reasons. The first reason is that these units work best by creating a literal swirl of air in your shop. The air swirling around gathers up the fines and traps them in the filter. If you put 2 filters in that might disrupt the process. Plus you will have the added annoyance of turning on 2 machines every time you are in the shop vs one.

The second reason is that a large unit with only one filter that you have to replace is going to ultimately save you money over having to replace two smaller filters. So any cost savings is negated.

My shop is about the same size as yours and the Jet does a great job of clearing the air. I would go with the Jet for all the reasons minorhero said. 

Stumpy Nubs has a good video on improving intake filters and exhaust side filtering . Got me to improve my Jet and Grizzly's performance, and increased time between filter cleanings.

  • Author
39 minutes ago, blackoak said:

Stumpy Nubs has a good video on improving intake filters and exhaust side filtering . Got me to improve my Jet and Grizzly's performance, and increased time between filter cleanings.

I might have seen that one.  Is that the one where he fits Wynn filters to the exhaust end?

I have the Jet AFS-1000B down in my basement shop, which is only like 15x10...  It's a nice unit, and has helped quite a bit keeping the dust on my workshop side and away from the furnace and storage area.

If you can wait... Rockler usually has the Jet AFS-1000B as one of their black friday specials.   I bought mine 2-3 years ago and it was 25% off as I recall.   No guarantees they continue, but they've done it the last many years I can remember.

 

Yes Mark, thats the video. I built a "box" from furnace filters on the intake side, and a round pleated filter on the way out. Not exactly cheap upgrades, but it was worth it to me.

  • Author

Thanks for all your contributions on this.  It's really helped me think it through.  I am probably going to pull the trigger on a dust collector this weekend.  So I am inclined to wait until the Jet goes on sale while I see what improvement the DC makes.

I know this is a late response and you probably have already purchased whatever you feel you need but . . .

I’m not an expert. Over the years, however, I’ve done a lot of research on dust collection and have worked at making sure as little dust as possible escapes into the air in my shop. I have an Oneida HEPA cyclone which I use for at-source collection, including my lathe. I also have a HEPA vac which I use when sanding and with smaller power tools.  I also have a JDS air cleaner which hangs from my ceiling to filter dust that escapes at the sources.  Finally I use a Trend Airshield Pro to keep any dust that escapes the other methods from getting into my lungs. I know the system isn’t perfect but very little dust collects on shelves and the floor, so I believe what I do to be as effective as possible.

I don’t believe that air cleaners, no matter which one you own, were meant to be the only method of dust collection. Instead, they are meant to be part of an overall system and designed to remove dust particles missed by at-source methods. Having said that, if it were me, and the only method I was using was an air cleaner, I’d buy the cleaner with the largest air flow I could afford. Given your stated shop size, approximately  23’ X 23’ X 8’, or approximately 4,200 cubic feet, a cleaner that moved 800 cfm  would circulate the total air in the shop about every 5 minutes or 12 times an hour. This is very good, except that, since you are using it as your only method, you may put as much or more dust into the air as the cleaner is taking out while you’re turning.

Based on past experience, it is possible that an air cleaner that size alone will do an effective job of collecting your dust, but it might not keep up with the dust produced while turning and I think you would be cleaning the filter every time you turn or more if the sessions are long. After you complete work for the day, the air will, of course, be cleaned quickly if the cleaner is left on for a period of time.

 I have been turning for less than a year. Before I turned my first bowl, I found a dust collection hood for my lathe which could be connected to my cyclone collector.  Of course, it doesn't collect most shavings and chips, but it does collect a very high percentage of the finer dust via my cyclone since it’s HEPA and pulls a lot of air away from the lathe.

While you can buy HEPA filters for air cleaners, to date it isn’t cost effective. They are single use and very expensive. When they fill up (which would be often in your case) they are not designed to be reused. Fortunately, as the filters included with your air cleaner load up with dust they become better filters. Because the pores fill up, the dust filtered becomes somewhat finer over time (until, of course, the filter must be cleaned again). Most air cleaners will filter 91% of the particles down to 1 micron. The first circulation of air will get 91% of the total dust in the air. The second circulation will get 91% of the remaining dust, etc. However, if you are putting more dust into the air than the cleaner takes out (which might be the case while you’re turning), then,  of course, the faster the air circulates the better; to keep up with your dust production.

So, regardless of price, if you plan on using only the air cleaner, I would suggest one rated at the highest cfm you can get. For example, I’ve seen air cleaners rated at 1200 cfm. In your case, that would mean the air would circulate about every 3 minutes or 20 times and hour. In that case, you might very well keep up with the dust produced during turning, but you would definitely need to keep an eye on the filters and keep them clean.

I doubt Jet or Rikon would provide much information concerning dust collection in general. It’s just not their area of expertise. Contacting JDS may give you a much better solution even if you don’t buy their products. They have always been very helpful regardless of whether the help resulted in a purchase of their product or not.

Good luck. It’s important to get as much dust out of the air and away from your lungs as possible.

  • Author

I am awaiting delivery of a 3 hp cyclone, but I still want to do an overhead air filter.

I decided to wait for a Jet sale and go with the AFS 1000B.  But, I just noticed that Grizzly has several models, as well and of course much cheaper.

Does anyone have any experience with these, particularly the "3-speed Heavy-Duty Hanging Air Filter"?

I was going to go with the Jet because it was repotedly quieter than some other units tested.  Otherwise the Grizzly and Jet specs seem similar.  

The Grizzly is on sale for $250, while the Jet would be $378 or $331 if there is a 15% sale.  

I know Grizzly has a reputation for occaisional manufacturing defect, but I'm thinking an air filter is too simple to mess up that badly.

I went with the jet unit after reading several reviews. They go on sale a lot so wait a bit if you can.

Unfortunately JDS no longer makes hobbyist air filter equipment. I originally wanted to buy one but a call to their company resulted in being told they are out of that business.

16 minutes ago, Mark J said:

I am awaiting delivery of a 3 hp cyclone, but I still want to do an overhead air filter.

I decided to wait for a Jet sale and go with the AFS 1000B.  But, I just noticed that Grizzly has several models, as well and of course much cheaper.

Does anyone have any experience with these, particularly the "3-speed Heavy-Duty Hanging Air Filter"?

I was going to go with the Jet because it was repotedly quieter than some other units tested.  Otherwise the Grizzly and Jet specs seem similar.  

The Grizzly is on sale for $250, while the Jet would be $378 or $331 if there is a 15% sale.  

I know Grizzly has a reputation for occaisional manufacturing defect, but I'm thinking an air filter is too simple to mess up that badly.

I'd wait until the black Friday sale time. i always remember seeing the air cleaners on sale then. I'd get the griz The two companies probably use the same overseas motor in the. Both motors are probably going to outlast the warranty and the griz might be cheaper to get replacement parts for? Looking at the parts break down i can't tell a difference. I'm in the market sometime soon as well.

 

What DC did you end up getting?

  • Author
2 hours ago, Chestnut said:

What DC did you end up getting?

I went with the Laguna 3 HP PFlux model that was on sale at Woodcraft last month.

I did not want to commit to a specific location in my workshop or for that matter commit to this particular workshop.  So mobility was a must.  

The current workshop is also "vertically chalenged" so total height was an issue, so Clearvue and Oneida didn't work out.

There seems to be consensus on this forum that 3 and 5 HP units are significantly "better".

The Laguna cyclone is significantly taller than the Jet.  It's not 11 degrees, but better.

Finally I went with the PFlux over the CFlux because it's quieter and that is also important to me.

40 minutes ago, Mark J said:

I went with the Laguna 3 HP PFlux model that was on sale at Woodcraft last month.

I did not want to commit to a specific location in my workshop or for that matter commit to this particular workshop.  So mobility was a must.  

The current workshop is also "vertically chalenged" so total height was an issue, so Clearvue and Oneida didn't work out.

There seems to be consensus on this forum that 3 and 5 HP units are significantly "better".

The Laguna cyclone is significantly taller than the Jet.  It's not 11 degrees, but better.

Finally I went with the PFlux over the CFlux because it's quieter and that is also important to me.

Well I'm interested to hear how it works out for you. I'm leaning towards the Oneida pro model. I've spoken with a sales guy extensively and he is confidant that a 2hp model will work well for me. My longest run will only be about 15 feet. I still fear I'd be making a big mistake if i went with the 2hp model. When is your pflux getting delievered?

  • Author

Maybe a week more?  I'll share my experience, but I won't have anything to compare it to.

I don't believe there are any clearly correct or incorrect answers to this.  My thought is to do a reasonable amount of research, make a decision that seems reasonable, then stop thinking about it.  

Next challenge for me will be getting it home and putting it together.  I can post on that, too.

47 minutes ago, Chestnut said:

Well I'm interested to hear how it works out for you. I'm leaning towards the Oneida pro model. I've spoken with a sales guy extensively and he is confidant that a 2hp model will work well for me. My longest run will only be about 15 feet. I still fear I'd be making a big mistake if i went with the 2hp model. When is your pflux getting delievered?

Make sure you get the "crossbar".  It was added later in the design to help with the effectiveness of dust separation by this unit. (they may be including it now). There is a Youtube video that discusses it.  I will try to locate and update here.  I bought that same unit but had a slight problem when I dropped it :)  Long story... I have a thread here somewhere where I confess my stupidity.  In the end I went with a ClearVue as I needed the higher power for my CNC.

PS you may want to check out the posts over on Lumberjocks regarding this unit as there is a lengthy thread with a lot of participation :)

Link to video regarding crossbar

2 hours ago, SplinteredDave said:

Make sure you get the "crossbar".  It was added later in the design to help with the effectiveness of dust separation by this unit. (they may be including it now). There is a Youtube video that discusses it.  I will try to locate and update here.  I bought that same unit but had a slight problem when I dropped it :)  Long story... I have a thread here somewhere where I confess my stupidity.  In the end I went with a ClearVue as I needed the higher power for my CNC.

PS you may want to check out the posts over on Lumberjocks regarding this unit as there is a lengthy thread with a lot of participation :)

Link to video regarding crossbar

I read your confession thread earlier today. I was talking about the Oneida Dust Gorilla pro 2hp unit though. I also don't and will never have any interest in CNC. No debate it's just not my thing. I talked with the rep from Oneida and if i wasn't going down the CNC route ever the high power isn't as necessary i guess.

2 minutes ago, Chestnut said:

I read your confession thread earlier today. I was talking about the Oneida Dust Gorilla pro 2hp unit though. I also don't and will never have any interest in CNC. No debate it's just not my thing. I talked with the rep from Oneida and if i wasn't going down the CNC route ever the high power isn't as necessary i guess.

No worries Chestnut... Sorry I was referring to Mark buying the Laguna 3hp unit and quoted the wrong post.  I love the whole CNC debate since I like popcorn :)

9 minutes ago, SplinteredDave said:

No worries Chestnut... Sorry I was referring to Mark buying the Laguna 3hp unit and quoted the wrong post.  I love the whole CNC debate since I like popcorn :)

I'd prefer to debate something more meaningful. Like asphalt vs concrete or blondes vs brunettes .

Just now, Chestnut said:

I'd prefer to debate something more meaningful. Like asphalt vs concrete or blondes vs brunettes .

I agree...

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,009 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Joseph b Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.