Recommended Posts

Posted

I am flattening a small block (or at least attempting to) with a small router sled that I have made for the purpose.  But I am not getting the results I expected.  I am thinking it is the bit as I am using one I had on hand.  

What are the best bits for slab flattening?  I have come across one from Infinty and two from Woodworker's Supply:  

Infinity Mega Dado & Planner Bit:  https://www.infinitytools.com/routing/router-bits/carbide/groove-making-router-bits/dado-planer-router-bits

Woodtek Dado and Planner Bit:  https://woodworker.com/dado-planer-bit-1-12-diam-12-shank-mssu-172-886.asp?search=172997&searchmode=2

Any thoughts or experience with these?  Something else?

Posted

I have had good success with a tray bit that has rounded corners like the Woodtek bit. A sharp corner can slightly dig in and leave a harder to remove line, but the radiused corner leaves a slight bump at worst which is much easier to clean up. 

Posted

I am using a 1 1/4" tray bit with 1/4" round over.   http://www.rockler.com/1-1-4-dish-carving-router-bit    Right off I think a wider bit with a smaller round over would be better.  But the bit is supposed to be, and appears to be, flat in the center 3/4".

Here's what I am doing:  

20180701_0904121.thumb.jpg.e921a2cc831e609693f66bafe9c62cfa.jpg

The sticks on the left form a fence.  Each is 5/8" thick so I can remove them one at a time and insure each pass overlaps.  1/2" passes would be better, but 5/8" is what was laying around.

So here's what I'm getting:

20180701_0904391.thumb.jpg.176c5237ab7828f85793eb665618e658.jpg

I am expecting the surface to be kitchen counter flat, but instead I have a very subtle washboard.  Are my expectations unreasonable?  

Posted

That's about the same bit I have used. Smaller overlap will reduce the washboard affect. 1/2" should give better results. Looks like the Woodtek bit has better internal clearance for the chips too. There is always going to be plenty of planing/sanding after sled flattening. You are just establishing a flat plane to reference from , then flatten the other side, flip and dress the surface you routed.  Sometimes I just shoot for 60-70% of the underside of a slab to be flat on bar and tabletops. As long as the perimeter is flat no one will notice so why waste the thickness ?

As a second pass to remove your ripples just use the same spacers and offset the cuts to roughly center on the ridges left.

  • Thanks 1
Posted

If the bit is giving you a wavy surface (magnified it would look like a bunch of Z's side by side) then the problem is not the bit but the perpendicularity of the router to the surface. You may need to shim under the front or back of your insert plate to level it out.

It's not necessary to have the center of the tool be flat all the way across, as long as it's not higher than the edges. The edges do the cutting since you're not plunging in this operation.

Posted
1 hour ago, Mick S said:

If the bit is giving you a wavy surface (magnified it would look like a bunch of Z's side by side) then the problem is not the bit but the perpendicularity of the router to the surface. You may need to shim under the front or back of your insert plate to level it out.

It's not necessary to have the center of the tool be flat all the way across, as long as it's not higher than the edges. The edges do the cutting since you're not plunging in this operation.

I took a look at my setup and as near as I can measure (which is not very precisely) the bit is parellel with the table top (and flat across the top).  The insert is as coplaner as I think it can be made to be, but nothing is perfect.  I know the table top has a low spot in back of about 4 thousandths.  Maybe that's all it takes.

Posted
32 minutes ago, Mark J said:

I took a look at my setup and as near as I can measure (which is not very precisely) the bit is parellel with the table top (and flat across the top).  The insert is as coplaner as I think it can be made to be, but nothing is perfect.  I know the table top has a low spot in back of about 4 thousandths.  Maybe that's all it takes.

That could be all it takes. 

Does it look / feel like the cut is sloped?

Posted
59 minutes ago, Mick S said:

That could be all it takes. 

Does it look / feel like the cut is sloped?

It is very hard to tell with the rounded bit and the very shallow passes.

I just dismounted the block from the flattening sled and placed it flat side down on the cast iron top.  Tapped all four corners and zero woble, but rotate the block 90 degrees and whoa is there woble.  One corner visibly lifted; feeler guage says .012.  

So I pulled out the refference granite stone and checked.  One corner of the block is elevated about .005.  I think I'm OK with that, but I am looking for any reasonable and rational improvements.

I did notice that the steel throat plate had burrs along the edges which were interfering with the jig's skids so I knocked them down with some fine sandpaper. 

When I try this next I am going to change the jig direction 90 degrees and go perpendicular  to the miter slot rather than parallel.  That will put me on a different section of the table.

Posted

Yup.  I've already gone on with the project.  Just trying to understand where the error... ahh, I mean variation is coming from.  

Used the flattened bottom for reference and flattened and trued the 4 sides on the SCM.  Now I've set up to flatten the top (6th surface), but that's for tomorrow.  We'll see if changing direction changes the outcome.

Posted

Honestly, I'm not sure there is a problem. I was in the industrial CNC router business for a long time before I retired. This was something we ran into frequently because for vacuum hold down systems the tables needed to be really flat. The process for making the router spindle perpendicular to the table is called tramming. We could tram a spindle so that it was flat to .001" over an 18" swing with a tramming gauge. We still got the ripples you're seeing. 

  • Thanks 1
Posted

I agree I think your expectations are too high for the operation you are performing short of an awful wide jointer/planer or maybe a drum sander you are going to have clean up to do.

  • Like 1
  • Thanks 1
Posted
1 hour ago, pkinneb said:

I agree I thing your expectations are too high for the operation you are performing short of an awful wide jointer/planer or maybe a drum sander you are going to have clean up to do.

+1

Posted
16 hours ago, Mick S said:

We still got the ripples you're seeing. 

So @Mick S what you're saying is that if I did have a CNC machine my ripples would be way more precise and uniform.  And who doesn't need uniform ripples.  (Back me up here guys 'cause that's how I'm trying to sell it to Mrs. J.):D.

Thanks all for the help and reality check.  I ordered the 2" Woodtek bit just for the future.  The block is all cleaned up and purdy now with six flat and square surfaces.

20180702_112449_Burst011.thumb.jpg.d4c6b3e72f7efe9e19cdf4f29e0d7dfa.jpg

  • Like 1
Posted

Even with a perfectly trammed router you'll get what look like ripples due to the direction changes of the cut. One side of the bit is climb cutting and the other is conventional. The surface may be very flat. If your router has any (and I'm talking thousandths of an inch) play in the arbor bearings it can cause the cutter to be pulled one way or another depending on direction of cut. Flex in the shaft of the bit may also contribute.

There are cutters that minimize the effect. Like Steve said earlier, having a cutter with slightly rounded corners helps. But what works really well on one species may do a lousy job on another; wood density, grain, figure, open or closed, etc all come into play.

So my advice is convince her that a CNC will eliminate the problem, and if it doesn't, blame me!

  • Haha 2
  • 6 years later...
Posted

That question is likely to get a lot of different answers. Also different answers for the two different applications.

Slab flattening will be more efficient when using a large bit in a large router, but a smaller machine is often better (more maneuveable) for many joinery tasks.

  • Haha 1
Posted

I just took a look and @Mick S checked in on the forum recently.  His contributions and conversations are certainly missed.  

I just read through this old post, blast from the past.  I'm still using the workpiece sled along with that 2" Woodtek bit for my flattening operations.  Alas, no CNC.

As to @BoltAndBeam 's question, I agree with wtnhighlander.   I'd put a big router in a router table, and prefer a smaller, lighter router for hand work.  The implication here is that more than one router is a good thing.  

  • Like 1
Posted
On 2/10/2025 at 9:01 AM, Mark J said:

...The implication here is that more than one router is a good thing.  

Well coming from a self identified router addict I would say of course it is :)

At last count I have 9 and counting :ph34r:

 

  • Haha 2

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   3 Members, 0 Anonymous, 46 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,009
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Bob44
    Newest Member
    Bob44
    Joined