Chestnut Posted August 15, 2018 Report Posted August 15, 2018 2 hours ago, Marmotjr said: What clunker is that? My turbo charged AWD car gets 31 mpg on premium, is 14 years old, will still do 140mph if I ask it to (I don't, but I have), has a 19 gallon tank so I rarely have to fill up even with my 46 mile commute, and I wouldn't be able to make that commute in the winter without the AWD. There's a big difference between AWD and 4WD. AWD is great for maintaining control and speed on roads in bad conditions. 4WD is great offroad, but just sucks extra fuel when you don't need it. WRX never was made for millage... And i love it My right foot doesn't help. Quote
drzaius Posted August 15, 2018 Report Posted August 15, 2018 22 hours ago, Chestnut said: What does the number of wheels that get power have to do with stability? I see a heck of a lot more suv and pickup roll overs then i ever see cars rolled. 4wd doesn't do much to stop or steer a vehicle but it does help you get going to higher speeds faster in sketchy conditions. We don't get tons of snow, but my daily commute includes about 25 Km of highway driving & the roads are frequently quite slick. A 2WD pickup just want's to head straight for the ditch in those conditions. A front wheel drive or 4WD is much more stable. Quote
Chestnut Posted August 15, 2018 Report Posted August 15, 2018 3 minutes ago, drzaius said: We don't get tons of snow, but my daily commute includes about 25 Km of highway driving & the roads are frequently quite slick. A 2WD pickup just want's to head straight for the ditch in those conditions. A front wheel drive or 4WD is much more stable. I've lived in an area that gets tons of snow and ice and have driven a manual 2wd pickup for 15 years my awd car is more prone to sliding and loss of steering and breaking control. Not driving the front wheels i never have to worry about how the engine is going to effect steering. If the front looses traction i have the ability in some conditions to break the back end free which plants the front end. Maybe i'm just that good at driving rwd but i doubt it. 1 Quote
drzaius Posted August 15, 2018 Report Posted August 15, 2018 1 minute ago, Chestnut said: I've lived in an area that gets tons of snow and ice and have driven a manual 2wd pickup for 15 years my awd car is more prone to sliding and loss of steering and breaking control. Not driving the front wheels i never have to worry about how the engine is going to effect steering. If the front looses traction i have the ability in some conditions to break the back end free which plants the front end. Maybe i'm just that good at driving rwd but i doubt it. The problem with RWD in something with a very light rear end (like a pickup) is that when, at highway speeds, the rear wheels start to spin even just a tiny bit, they want to go sideways. If traffic is light & you have room to counter steer that's OK, but it can sure get exciting. I've never had a problem with steering & front WD or 4WD. I grew up learning on RWD & have never gone in the ditch in winter, but after driving my first front WD car in winter, I was hooked. I think it just has a lot to do with personal preferences & driving techniques. On dry pavement though, there's no question that RWD can be way more fun Quote
legenddc Posted August 15, 2018 Report Posted August 15, 2018 Oddly enough, I think the need for 4wd is greater in the DC area because whenever we do actually get snow, they don't know how to take care of it. 2" is enough to close schools. Sometimes the threat of snow is enough to close schools. When we bought a SUV we tried to find a FWD one with the options we wanted but couldn't so we ended up with AWD. Quote
Chestnut Posted August 15, 2018 Report Posted August 15, 2018 14 minutes ago, drzaius said: The problem with RWD in something with a very light rear end (like a pickup) is that when, at highway speeds, the rear wheels start to spin even just a tiny bit, they want to go sideways. People have been telling me this is a problem for years and i have 15 years of evidence that it isn't a problem. Also if it was such a problem every pickup would have this issue because i know few people that drive in 4wd constantly through the winter. So despite it being something that you should be aware of the issue stands on icy roads for all vehicles with rwd presenting different reactions to the conditions to FWD. AWD reacts the worst of both you can either lose the back end or the front end or both. Also AWD reacts the poorest on braking because the front and rear wheels are tied the proportioning valve isn't able to fully do it's job so there is a higher likely hood to lock up all 4 wheels despite having abs. The only saving grave is AWD on acceleration generally takes more power to loose traction, on ice this power threshold is still very low. Quote
Tpt life Posted August 15, 2018 Report Posted August 15, 2018 Hmm, AWD performs poorest on braking... Please prove that, since ABS and AWD are independent systems. Tell me what makes them “lock up all four” as I have never experienced this. Quote
Chestnut Posted August 15, 2018 Report Posted August 15, 2018 42 minutes ago, Tpt life said: Hmm, AWD performs poorest on braking... Please prove that, since ABS and AWD are independent systems. Tell me what makes them “lock up all four” as I have never experienced this. I suppose it depends on the system from my experience with the viscus and electronic clutch center differentials if you are on snow and hit the brakes hard all 4 lock pretty easily. I do this for giggles all the time in the winter with my car. ABS is completely useless when all 4 tires are on a surface with the same friction level. If you get enough braking force to lock all 4 at the same time the system is unable to tell that the car is sliding and isn't able to compensate, for example on the highway and have to stop in a hurry and are on a snowy slippery surface. If you want to test this find a skating rink or frozen lake that isn't snow covered yet this winter. I've experienced it in FWD and RWD vehicles as well but it's less likely beings that the front and rear tires aren't connected. Saddly this doesn't typically show up unless your in a situation where you need the braking power and by the time most people figure this out it's too late. Quote
Tpt life Posted August 15, 2018 Report Posted August 15, 2018 Yeah, I could lock and spin a full size rear wheel ABS any time. I could not lock all four on an AWD Astro ever, even trying. But again, that’s ABS. I don’t buy AWD for braking. I buy it for driving. Quote
Chestnut Posted August 15, 2018 Report Posted August 15, 2018 2 minutes ago, Tpt life said: Yeah, I could lock and spin a full size rear wheel ABS any time. I could not lock all four on an AWD Astro ever, even trying. But again, that’s ABS. I don’t buy AWD for braking. I buy it for driving. Well the astro post 99 is a computer locked AWD system when there aren't tires spinning under acceleration it's operating in 2wd mode. So that vehicle while is AWD is not a full time AWD. Pre-99 it's a viscus center diff. The system in my parents CTS is more forgiving than my Subaru but i could still easily lock all 4. The power split is 25/75 on the CTS where my Subaru is 50/50. The Haldex system used in europe is akin to that of the post 99 astros with a faster acting computer and also keeps all 4 wheels connected though it's by an open differential that isn't going to transfer torque as well. If you get into systems that have 3 locking differentials you could essentially use the brakes on 1 wheel to stop all 4 wheels but these systems are very rare and the only car i know of off the top of my head that has it is the Subaru STI and you have to put it in that mode. The other are some 4wd pickups when in 4low. Most leave at least 1 differential open or in a limited slip configuration so you can turn a corner. Also sure you buy awd for what ever you buy it for but that doesn't change the fact that when you couple all 4 wheels it's going to change the driving dynamic. Again all this is dependent on the AWD system. Also again most of this doesn't matter until you slam on the brakes on an icy road. Quote
Marmotjr Posted August 15, 2018 Report Posted August 15, 2018 20 hours ago, Chestnut said: WRX never was made for millage... And i love it My right foot doesn't help. Aight... WRX might be the only car that gets a pass on mileage in this department. They're nice rides.... Quote
wtnhighlander Posted August 16, 2018 Report Posted August 16, 2018 Machine characteristics are not, generally the problem. The drivers are. Here, it rarely snows enough to be an issue, but freezing rain and sleet often make the roads slicker than snot. All the rednecks in their monster 4wd trucks are usually the first to hit the ditch. They like to put it in 4 wheel mode and drive all loosey-goosey. Then they hit a dry patch and drive themselves straight into the ditch. My #1 rule for driving in slippery conditions is "No abrubt changes of speed or direction". Slow down, leave yourself room, laugh at the monster pickups that blow past you just before they wrap a utility pole. For what it is worth, I have owned 2 4wd vehicles in four decades of driving. Never engaged the front wheels while on a public roadway, regardless of condition. As @Tom King said, the "unstuck" button is just for insurance. Regarding electronic vehicle enhancements, the traction control on my 2wd Avalanche is pretty good at spin control on ice & snow. ABS is worthless, as it quit working shortly after I bought the truck. Haven't needed ABS in 40 years, So I'm not worried. Quote
Pondhockey Posted August 16, 2018 Report Posted August 16, 2018 Well, living in a mountain town that gets snow measured in 100's of inches (or many feet) per year, 4WD is somewhere between helpful and essential, depending on the road and driveway to your house. It is also helpful on steep forest service roads and it smooths out the washboards on forest service roads that haven't been graded recently and have had too many 2WD vehicles on them. My old driveway was impassible with 2WD on many days until the plow guy came (and sometimes even after that.) AWD was often no help, as was traction control. Tires matter a lot too; different for snow than ice, unfortunately. I do agree that 4WD is best for getting unstuck, and you can just get stucker in 4WD. 2 Quote
Pondhockey Posted August 16, 2018 Report Posted August 16, 2018 On the original topic; yeah, that's a commuter vehicle. It probably sounds more obnoxious than it looks. Quote
krtwood Posted August 16, 2018 Report Posted August 16, 2018 On 8/14/2018 at 1:57 PM, Chestnut said: Challenge accepted. Where you live? NH. Bit of a drive for you. The trouble with it is there's a sharp nearly 90 degree turn at the bottom, because the end of the driveway has to be perpendicular to the road, and then it goes right into a steep incline. So there's just no way to hit the incline with any momentum. Usually the road and bottom of the driveway are clear enough that I can't turn into it in 4wd, so I have to come in in 2wd, get onto the straight incline and switch into 4wd, get up and then switch back to 2wd so I can turn into the garage. All the underground utility boxes are right at the edge of the driveway at the bottom of the incline, so if you slide backwards it's not going to be a good day. If you get sideways there's ledge on your left and boulders to keep you from going off the edge on the right. The stakes are real Quote
wtnhighlander Posted August 17, 2018 Report Posted August 17, 2018 @krtwood I recall seeing a lot of driveways like that when I lived in western NC! No fun in icy conditions, for sure. Quote
Chestnut Posted August 17, 2018 Report Posted August 17, 2018 3 hours ago, krtwood said: NH. Bit of a drive for you. The trouble with it is there's a sharp nearly 90 degree turn at the bottom, because the end of the driveway has to be perpendicular to the road, and then it goes right into a steep incline. So there's just no way to hit the incline with any momentum. Usually the road and bottom of the driveway are clear enough that I can't turn into it in 4wd, so I have to come in in 2wd, get onto the straight incline and switch into 4wd, get up and then switch back to 2wd so I can turn into the garage. All the underground utility boxes are right at the edge of the driveway at the bottom of the incline, so if you slide backwards it's not going to be a good day. If you get sideways there's ledge on your left and boulders to keep you from going off the edge on the right. The stakes are real Ok that one sounds right tricky. Had an alley that you had to turn into like that and it was a good and steap i avoided that one. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.