Popular Post gee-dub Posted June 28, 2025 Popular Post Report Posted June 28, 2025 Hip, hip, hooray! 3 Quote
Von Posted June 29, 2025 Report Posted June 29, 2025 From my perspective, the change is continuing to work great - I don't think I've seen a spam post since! And I do think we had at least one newcomer post (the custom furniture question). From the mod's perspective, how is it working out? 1 Quote
Popular Post wtnhighlander Posted June 29, 2025 Popular Post Report Posted June 29, 2025 For me, it is working out great! Chip gets in a bit before I do each day, and cleans out whatever accumulated during the night... 4 Quote
Popular Post Beechwood Chip Posted June 29, 2025 Popular Post Report Posted June 29, 2025 On 6/29/2025 at 9:00 AM, wtnhighlander said: For me, it is working out great! Chip gets in a bit before I do each day, and cleans out whatever accumulated during the night... Unless I sleep in. I spend way too much time on the computer, and I got in the habit of checking WTO pretty often. I wanted to delete the spam before it bothered other people, and I kinda enjoyed playing Whack-A-Mole. But now, whenever I check, there's nothing there! I think I've banned only three spammers since the change went into effect. I'm going to have to find another hobby 3 1 2 Quote
Mark J Posted June 29, 2025 Author Report Posted June 29, 2025 25 minutes ago, Beechwood Chip said: But now, whenever I check, there's nothing there! That's interesting. I wonder if someone or something is learning? 1 Quote
Popular Post Beechwood Chip Posted June 29, 2025 Popular Post Report Posted June 29, 2025 On 6/29/2025 at 9:52 AM, Mark J said: That's interesting. I wonder if someone or something is learning? I know! I assumed that it was all automated, and would keep coming at the same rate no matter what we did. But more than half of the spam stopped as soon as we started moderating new accounts. I could speculate on what's going on, but it comes down to "I don't know". 3 Quote
Popular Post Mark J Posted June 29, 2025 Author Popular Post Report Posted June 29, 2025 Well I guess I'm thinkin' that, after awhile, if the invaders aren't back at the gates, we could stop moderating new accounts. All of us want to keep the work load for mods to a minimum. 3 Quote
Popular Post Beechwood Chip Posted June 29, 2025 Popular Post Report Posted June 29, 2025 We don't get that many new members. We're still seeing 3 or 4 spammers to every legit new account. I appreciate the concern, but I'm not worried about the effort of approving first posts. Also, with moderator approval turned on, we can allow new members to post photos, which is a big win. You really don't want to allow spammers to be able to post pictures. I don't care how jaded you are, there are things you don't want to see. When I make moderation decisions, I want this to be a place where you can let your 8 year old daughter browse around without worrying. 6 Quote
Popular Post Chet Posted June 29, 2025 Popular Post Report Posted June 29, 2025 On 6/29/2025 at 6:00 AM, wtnhighlander said: For me, it is working out great! Chip gets in a bit before I do each day, and cleans out whatever accumulated during the night... I am up and moving just a little after 6 AM every morning but being here on the left coast most everything is cleaned up by Ross and Chip before I get the coffee pot on. Anything I do seems to be mid day and early evening on the east coast. 3 2 Quote
Coop Posted June 30, 2025 Report Posted June 30, 2025 BUT, where will we get our coupons from? Just kidding, I promise. Great job guys! 2 Quote
Popular Post woodwhisperer Posted June 30, 2025 Popular Post Report Posted June 30, 2025 Just so you guys know what's going on, there's more than just moderation at play. I looked at some of registrations to determine the origin of the IP. If it's not one of our most common countries, I put it on a blacklist. So the worst offenders can't even register in the first place, which dramatically reduces the amount of crap the mods have to sift through in the morning. You can see in the attached image how much the registrations dropped since implementing the change a few days ago. Now of course, many of these bots come from a VPN and there's just not much that can be done about that. But the new user moderation rule manages anything that slips through and in the end, users should never see spam again, unless they get sneaky enough to fool a moderator. I will continue to monitor the registrations and blacklist any "non-essential" countries that pop up. Hopefully this finally resolves the issue. 5 5 Quote
difalkner Posted June 30, 2025 Report Posted June 30, 2025 Is it possible to create a rule that a new member must register without the use of a VPN? That way their true location will be registered even if they switch to a VPN afterward. Quote
Popular Post Beechwood Chip Posted June 30, 2025 Popular Post Report Posted June 30, 2025 On 6/30/2025 at 11:48 AM, difalkner said: Is it possible to create a rule that a new member must register without the use of a VPN? That way their true location will be registered even if they switch to a VPN afterward. I don't know of any easy or reliable way to detect the use of a VPN. It is a connection from the VPN location. This rate of spam is so low that I don't feel we have to fine tune any further. My only concern is that we mods will stop checking as often, and that will delay approvals of legit posts and discourage new members. But, really, this is a legacy platform. Most new members will be on Facebook or Instagram or whatever the millennials are using these days. 3 Quote
Von Posted June 30, 2025 Report Posted June 30, 2025 On 6/30/2025 at 11:55 AM, Beechwood Chip said: I don't know of any easy or reliable way to detect the use of a VPN. It is a connection from the VPN location. This rate of spam is so low that I don't feel we have to fine tune any further. My only concern is that we mods will stop checking as often, and that will delay approvals of legit posts and discourage new members. But, really, this is a legacy platform. Most new members will be on Facebook or Instagram or whatever the millennials are using these days. Last time I looking into this, there are lists of IP addresses for VPN exits nodes, but those nodes change regularly because it's an arms race of people trying to block VPNs and VPNs trying to avoid the blocks. +1 - at this point, unless some problem comes up, this seems solved to me. 1 Quote
Popular Post Beechwood Chip Posted July 1, 2025 Popular Post Report Posted July 1, 2025 I just want to give a shout out to @Von. He stepped up to get started on a robot moderator solution, and took the initiative to contact Marc for a real, permanent solution. Without him, we'd still be dealing with a flood of spam every day. 8 1 Quote
difalkner Posted July 1, 2025 Report Posted July 1, 2025 Speaking of bots and AI - https://www.instagram.com/reel/DK78QiTp_y6/ 1 Quote
Popular Post wtnhighlander Posted July 1, 2025 Popular Post Report Posted July 1, 2025 Maybe we need to start feeding the AI machine with enough garbage to drive it into paranoid schizophrenia. Maybe it will turn itself off as a defence mechanism. Someone needs to reference Asimov... 4 Quote
Beechwood Chip Posted July 2, 2025 Report Posted July 2, 2025 I like this YouTube channel on AI safety, if anyone wants to go into this more seriously. https://www.youtube.com/@RobertMilesAI 1 Quote
Popular Post Coop Posted July 2, 2025 Popular Post Report Posted July 2, 2025 I learned how to make a dado cut on this forum years ago but I’m not going to try to understand what you’re talking about now! Just to say, great job to those that do! 3 Quote
Popular Post Chestnut Posted July 8, 2025 Popular Post Report Posted July 8, 2025 On 6/29/2025 at 8:24 AM, Beechwood Chip said: I'm going to have to find another hobby Ya know there is always woodworking? 1 3 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.