Recommended Posts

Posted

So, I was using my old Porter-Cable 690 plunge router with a new 1-1/8" diameter 1/2" shank bowl template bit.  I had done some work with it that seemed to go fine.  After a short break, I turned it on and started to lower the router when the bit blasted through the clear plastic guard and shot across the room.  The bit was above the work when it flew out.  No one was hurt, but I have some nice gouges in my cabinet doors.

I'd like to know what went wrong before going back to finish the project.

The usual suspects are:

  1. didn't tighten the collet enough (I used two wrenches, I didn't think I needed to really crank down)
  2. collet or shank dirty or oily (the bit was new out of the box.  It looked clean when I picked it up off the floor)
  3. shank undersized (It had two rings of scratches which might indicate it was only gripping at two points.  But, no diagonal scratches as it slipped out)

Any suggestions on how I can figure out what happened or how I can work more safely?

If nothing else, I'll probably switch to my Triton beast with a different 1/2" collet.

IMG_1236.JPG

IMG_1238.JPG

  • Confused 4
Posted

Follow up question: I've been using the same collets on my PC 690, my Triton, and whatever's under my router table.  The collets that came with them all looked the same and I lost track of which collets came with which motors.  But when I went to order some new ones, there are lots of different types listed as being compatible with different routers.  

Could that be the problem?  I guess I'll track down collets for the 690 and the Triton and see if they say they are also compatible with the other.

Posted

Here's what I've come up with:

  1. The PC 690 has no speed control and my bit was over 1" in diameter.  I was probably running it too fast.
  2. No one has the Triton collet except Triton's affiliated parts vendor in England.
  3. A genuine Triton 1/2" collet will cost me $43 + tax.
  4. I have a picture of the Triton collet, so I can probably find the one that came with the router.

I'm going to assume that the speed was the problem and use the PC router only for smaller bits, and use the Triton for anything over 1" diameter. 

I originally bought the Triton to use in a table, but decided against it because you have to flip the power switch to change the bit, which negates the convenience of above table height adjustment, which is why I got the Triton for my table.  I've rarely used it hand held because the thing weighs a ton.  

Posted
On 7/20/2025 at 12:30 AM, Beechwood Chip said:

use the PC router only for smaller bits, and use the Triton for anything over 1" diameter. 

Probably a good idea anyway, even if it wasn't the cause of the current issue.

  • Like 1
Posted

Glad there were no injuries. No answers, just a few thoughts...

As I understand things, you had been using the router, took a break, and then fired it back up but hadn't engaged with the work yet. That has me leaning towards the collet working its way loose somehow. Maybe some crud on the shank or in the collet?

The scratches on the shank are interesting. Perhaps crud inside the collet? Have you inspected the inside of the collet?

Router speed might have played a small role, but at 1 1/8", you weren't pushing things very much based on my recent reading.

I have the same issue with collets and router brands. I think I have them sorted right but really am not sure. Seems like if the collet physically goes on the router, it should work, but maybe somehow it's prone to loosening?

[Edited to add: I keep mixing up "shank" and "collet." I think I've fixed all my goofs, but if I'm not making sense, trying swapping those two words.]

 

  • Like 2
Posted

Hmm, I just had an awful thought (because it means it was my fault and I was stupid).  I store my router bits on a board that I drilled a bunch of 1/2" and 1/4" holes in.  I store my collets with them, by putting short dowels into the holes and then pushing the collets onto the dowels.  So it's possible that that damaged the inside of the collet slightly, or left tiny bits of wood behind.

I'm going to start treating my collets as precision devices, and store them accordingly.

Come to think of it, this is the 2nd, maybe 3rd time I've had a new router bit slip.  I'm going to start cleaning my new bits with de-greaser before using. 

I've had three cases of bit slippage, on three different routers (PC, Triton, and Bora).

Come to think of it, I mostly use my cordless trim router, and I've never had a bit slip in it.  But it only takes 1/4" bits so I've never changed the collet.

  • Like 1
Posted

Good luck finding the cause, but no way would I run a bit that large in a 690.  I have worn out a number of those Porter Cable collets.  I don't know exactly what happens to them but they get to a point that they won't hold a bit without it creeping.  I'm glad no flesh damage was done!!

  • Like 1
Posted
On 7/19/2025 at 5:14 PM, Beechwood Chip said:

I didn't think I needed to really crank down

You should tighten your router bits pretty well.  I have never had one come out but have had one creep up.  Since then I crank on it Pretty good.  I am also mindful of the speed setting for the bit in use.

  • Like 1
Posted
On 7/21/2025 at 1:02 PM, Chet said:

You should tighten your router bits pretty well.

I've also gotten warnings not to over-tighten?  What I do is to hand tighten the collet, and then put the two wrenches one face apart (60 degrees) then squeeze the handles together.  Like this.

But you made me wonder, and I found other videos and advice that say to use two squeezes (120 degrees) or more.  Opinions, please?

Posted

I use two full sized 1-1/8" combination wrenches, but have a good feel for how tight.  I think the reason they include the little wrenches with routers is so people have less chance of overtightening them.  The only wrenches that came with a router that I use are with a Milwaukee router that's still in the case it came in that I use when I need to change the bit in one.  Most of my routers have been dedicated to one job for years and even decades.  I'm sure I have at least double the wheelbarrow full that Norm had.

I have six 7518's just dedicated to building reproduction sash.  I can't even count how many 690's I have.  One of the 690's has the Rockwell name on it bought new in the early 1970's.  Two are with the Leigh jig.  I think four just for hanging house doors, etc., etc.,etc.

I think I threw away the stack of stock Porter Cable wrenches that laid in a window sill for over 20 years.  They were never used.

  • Like 1
Posted

Glad no one got hurt.  I am a big fan of the two wrench method.

twowrenchtechnique.JPG.df4478e9e03b5d34dac83eec18d106ee.JPG

The recent exception is the addition of the Muscle Chuck to the router table.  Father time and his accompanying arthritis made me try one of these since I swap bits at the router table so often.  Works great.  For the hand held world, the two wrench is my preferred.  Push button collet locks are for the birds IMHO.

  • Like 2
Posted
On 7/21/2025 at 1:44 PM, Beechwood Chip said:

I've also gotten warnings not to over-tighten?  What I do is to hand tighten the collet, and then put the two wrenches one face apart (60 degrees) then squeeze the handles together.  Like this.

But you made me wonder, and I found other videos and advice that say to use two squeezes (120 degrees) or more.  Opinions, please?

I would say I tighten moderately, no cranking down, and I have never had a problem with a bit coming loose.

FWIW, here is what my Dewalt 621 manual says:

Insert the round shank of the desired router bit into the loosened
collet as far as it will go and then pull it out about 1/16”. Hold the
spindle shaft by depressing the spindle lock button, while firmly
tightening the collet nut with the wrench provided to prevent the
bit from slipping.

 

  • Like 2
Posted
On 7/21/2025 at 6:14 PM, Von said:

I would say I tighten moderately, no cranking down, and I have never had a problem with a bit coming loose.

I saw a video that said, "on a scale of 1 to 10, where 1 is hand tight and 10 is as tight as you can possibly get it, go for 5."

On 7/21/2025 at 3:48 PM, Tom King said:

I think the reason they include the little wrenches with routers is so people have less chance of overtightening them.

All of my full sized routers came with 8" wrenches.  Are those "little"?

If I can get an actual number instead of "tight, but not too tight" I'd use a torque wrench to actually measure it.  Not every time, just to get a sense of how tight it should be.  It's crazy, but I've got a torque wrench, so why not?

  • Like 1
Posted
On 7/21/2025 at 7:01 PM, Beechwood Chip said:

I saw a video that said, "on a scale of 1 to 10, where 1 is hand tight and 10 is as tight as you can possibly get it, go for 5."

That describes what I do well.

  • Like 1
Posted
On 7/22/2025 at 8:37 AM, Mark J said:

Just a curiosity, but I'm not seeing how one would apply a torque wrench to a router collet with a bit mounted.  My torque wrench uses sockets. 

I was wondering the same. I guess a small bit, a deep well socket and the motor pulled out of the base?

  • Like 1

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   2 Members, 0 Anonymous, 62 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,009
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Joseph b
    Newest Member
    Joseph b
    Joined