Beechwood Chip Posted January 28, 2013 Report Posted January 28, 2013 My cordless drill / driver just died, and I'm thinking of getting a corded tool as a replacement, since I usually have an outlet nearby. I like the lighter weight, smaller price-tag, and not having to worry about charging and replacing batteries. But all the corded drills I see don't have a clutch. I find the clutch to be very useful when driving screws. Can anyone recommend a good corded hand drill that can be used as a driver? Does anyone have en explanation for corded drills not having clutches? Thanks. Quote
Rick A McQuay Posted January 28, 2013 Report Posted January 28, 2013 I can't answer your specific questions but I can relate my experience with various drills. Makita cordless - this was the best performer but it ate batteries like crazy Porter Cable cordless - came in a kit of stuff from Lowes, inexpensive and the clutch is inconsistent but otherwise fine Skil 1/2" corded - too powerful for driving screws into wood Black & Decker 3/8" corded - my wife bought me this years ago so I've never upgraded. It's adequate. I do have a drywall screw driving attachment that stops bottoms out once the screw is just below the surface but I rarely use it except for drywall. Quote
Dave H Posted January 28, 2013 Report Posted January 28, 2013 did a quick search, and came up with this http://www.amazon.com/s?ie=UTF8&keywords=corded%2Bdrill&page=1&rh=n%3A552804%2Ck%3Acorded%2Bdrill%2Cp_n_feature_keywords_browse-bin%3A2798205011 there are several that have clutches. Quote
SignWave Posted January 28, 2013 Report Posted January 28, 2013 I don't know why corded drills don't have clutches, but I have given up on driving screws with a corded drill. I've also given up on just having one. I have a drill press, a corded 3/8", and two 12V cordless (one is a dril with a chuck, and the other is impact which works very well for driving screws.) I like the press for accuracy, and the corded one for the torque. I like the cordless for their small size portability. It might seem excessive, but I used each of them today for different jobs (some woodworking, some home repair). Quote
Dlhunter Posted January 28, 2013 Report Posted January 28, 2013 I have one old Bosch corded drill and I use it for exactly 1 thing. Drilling pocket screw holes. It spins at a higher rpm than any cordless which I like for drilling pocket screws. If you want a good lightweight cordless I've heard the compact festool one is great. And the price isn't too outrageous. Quote
pghmyn Posted January 28, 2013 Report Posted January 28, 2013 I have one old Bosch corded drill and I use it for exactly 1 thing. Drilling pocket screw holes. It spins at a higher rpm than any cordless which I like for drilling pocket screws. If you want a good lightweight cordless I've heard the compact festool one is great. And the price isn't too outrageous.same exact reason I have a corded drill. I love it for pocket hole screws. Quote
tim0625 Posted January 28, 2013 Report Posted January 28, 2013 I bought the combo pack from HD. Lithium Ion batteries last a while but only have a 30 minute charge time. Great torque, good rpms and 'clutched'. Oh....free lifetime replacement on the batteries. I've been really satisfied. You could buy the dewalt corded, clutched, but for about the same money have the option to walk around and use it without having to drag an extension cord. Quote
Beechwood Chip Posted January 28, 2013 Author Report Posted January 28, 2013 OK, I already have a corded drill (Makita hammer drill, which I love), so I guess I'll go for a cordless drill / impact driver combo pack. Here's what's available at Amazon: Dewalt 12V $178 Bosch 12V $174 Bosch 18V $199 Makita 12V $154 All come with two Li batteries and a charger. I don't think I'd ever use them all day long, so I'm leaning towards the Makita. But the Ridgid with free battery replacement sounds like a good deal, too. Any opinions on 12V vs 18V? Quote
TheFatBaron Posted January 28, 2013 Report Posted January 28, 2013 http://www.amazon.com/Makita-LCT200W-18-Volt-Lithium-Ion-Cordless/dp/B000V2DSE2/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1359386234&sr=8-1&keywords=makita+impact+driver Makita has an 18V kit available. I have the 18V impact driver (I wish I had realized this kit was around when I bought my driver) - It's a great piece of hardware. I've done small screws in hard woods (like jatoba) without a problem, and large screws in softer woods (oak, pine, fir) equally well. Quote
wdwerker Posted January 28, 2013 Report Posted January 28, 2013 I am amazed at the power we get from our tiny Bosch 12 volt drill drivers. We have 6 of them ,2 have drill chucks, 3 are hex bit chucks and the adjustable/right angle one has a hex bit chuck. We have drilled 3/8" holes in steel and driven 4" screws with them. Battery gauge on the drill let's you know how much charge is left .LED headlights are nice. I get them from CPO as refurbished tools. That means someone returned it, Bosch sends in through testing and quality control and I get a lower price and same warranty. On an install I will have a square drive bit in one, Phillips in another, and various pilot bits set up. Batteries charge pretty quick, they are about the size of a "D cell" Quote
Dlhunter Posted January 28, 2013 Report Posted January 28, 2013 I frequent the jlc forums and it seems the makita cordless is the favorite brand among those contractors. Just don't go with Milwaukee. I am more and more disgusted with mine every day and can't wait for them to totally crap out so I can justify their replacement. Quote
CessnaPilotBarry Posted January 29, 2013 Report Posted January 29, 2013 +1 on the small Bosch drivers. It's powerful enough to install self-drilling cabinet hanging screws right through BB plywood, yet the clutch can be gentle enough that I use it on the airplane without cross threading screws. On a side note, two weeks ago, I removed 500-600 screws as we opened the plane for annual inspection, then reinstalled all of them, ON A SINGLE BATTERY out, and another in. Quote
Beechwood Chip Posted January 29, 2013 Author Report Posted January 29, 2013 I'm leaning towards the Bosch or Makita 12V combo pack. If it was just price and power, I'd pay the $25 and get the 18V. But I'm thinking that the 12V will be powerful enough, and lighter. Having once spent an afternoon on my back putting screws into the underside of a loft bed, saving weight is attractive. Anyone want to tell me that I'm crazy not to go for 18V? Thanks, everyone, for chiming in. Quote
wdwerker Posted January 29, 2013 Report Posted January 29, 2013 I have a few older Panasonic 12 v full size drill / drivers that I keep around for the occasional job that runs the Bosch batteries down fast. I could use a corded drill for those if I wanted to. I have a Ridgid drill with the free lifetime batteries, waste of time, huge, heavy, and doesn't last. When the battery wouldn't hold a charge they gave me the run around and finally had to order the new ones( they didn't keep them in stock). Quote
SignWave Posted January 29, 2013 Report Posted January 29, 2013 FWIW, I recently picked up a 12v Bosch combo (Bosch CLPK22-120), and the prices vary widely. It was going for $139 over the holidays, then went up to $159. A couple of weeks ago, I saw it for under $100 (on amazon and ebay). Today, $200+. My point is that if you're patient, you can save quite a bit. As far as comparing 12v against 18v, I like the compact size of the 12v models more than the power of the 18v models, which are larger and less fun to haul around. I think there are some jobs that call for the extra torque and higher battery capacity, but I doubt most people really need that, aside from some trades. The 12v models are pretty powerful, and they recharge quickly. Quote
davestanton Posted January 29, 2013 Report Posted January 29, 2013 I have a few corded and cordless. I love the dewalt 18 volt, 12 volt hitachi impact and now the drill I always reach for is the festool CXS 10.8 volt. They all have their strengths. Corded drivers are a pain due to the fact that you are using a tool with a tether. Quote
sjeff70 Posted January 29, 2013 Report Posted January 29, 2013 I've read that Nicad batteries last longer than lithium (lithium about 3 years max). Those lithium batteries are expensive to replace, almost 2X the cost of NiCad. Expect to replace those batteries at least once or twice, the life of the drill. I got 8 years out of my Porter Cable before the clutch broke. I framed a basement with it and did several jobs around the house. The NiCad batteries still had some life in them. A corded drill will never cost you anything more but you do loose portability. You can expect a lot more power and dependability. Batteries weaken. I purchased a cordless Dewalt, 18V NiCad, to replace the Porter Cable. Quote
TRBaker Posted January 29, 2013 Report Posted January 29, 2013 I've got several corded drills for drilling holes (pocket screws, pilot holes, countersinks, etc.) and one cordless drill for running screws. I used to buy throw-away cordless drills (Ryobi) but now have a Hitachi 12v and absolutely love it. It is small enough to work comfortably inside of cabinets and other tight spaces and has enough torque to run any screws I normally use for the construction and install of cabinets. Quote
dtrust Posted February 2, 2013 Report Posted February 2, 2013 I have that exact same 18V combo pack that Thefatbaron mentioned. The batteries last a very long time, even being the compact size. Plenty of power, and very light. Something about the shape and layout of the drills just feels very comfortable to hold for extended times. The other advantage of that combo pack is the impact driver. That is the first one of those I ever used, and it is a revelation using an impact driver with long, difficult to put in screws. If you've never used one, it's hard to believe how much easier it is to drive in a screw. Makes it simply effortless. My vote would be for the Makita. When I got it, I thought it might be a little overkill. I mean, why should one need TWO different drills? Isn't that being a bit greedy? I'm a believer now, and wouldn't have it any other way. Quote
Dave F Posted February 2, 2013 Report Posted February 2, 2013 But the Ridgid with free battery replacement sounds like a good deal, too.I have the Ridgid combo pack with the Drill/Driver and the Impact driver... I absoutely love them. Great tools, reasonable price and unbeatbale warranty.. My 2 cents. Quote
Beechwood Chip Posted February 3, 2013 Author Report Posted February 3, 2013 The drill that I had (that broke) was an 18V NiCad. I liked it, and it did a good job for me for many years (I can't remember how many years ago I bought it). So, I'm leaning towards 18V NiCad again. I don't want to have to replace batteries every two or three years, and I hear that that's the case with Li batteries. I'll probably head to Home Depot tomorrow to see what they have. Quote
Chris H Posted February 5, 2013 Report Posted February 5, 2013 I have only had experience with Black and Decker and DeWalt cordless, mostly because once I used the DW, I don't think I will ever buy another brand. I can't imagine ever intentionally buying a corded drill/driver unless I need long term, raw power (think mixing thinset or dilling though thick concrete, neither really "woodworking" jobs). That said, it's just a personal preference. It doesn't seem to matter how long the cord is on corded tools, it's always just a bit short, or wrapped around something. For those I have experience with, I say got DeWalt. I have the 18v lithiums and they last forever! I literally go a week or two before swapping out the battery on my DeWalt's (hour or two a day intermediate use). I have 3, and really only use 2, but I found a 2xbattery pack combo set in a home depot clearance center for less than they were selling a single replacement battery for....something like $48 for a drill and x2 ion batteries. So keep your eyes peeled for a deal. I am guessing someone made an oops when pricing the clearance center set, but you just never know when you will stumble upon those. The B&D are pure crap, don't waste your money, no matter how "on sale" they may be. B&D has a long track record of garbage batteries. As for Nicad, be careful. My understanding is that NiCad's lose life the longer they sit on the charger. I assume that is a problem they have fixed in the last few years, but just do some research on the brand. My Lithiums have lasted much longer (both on the drill, and actual life span) than the NiCads. Quote
calmari Posted February 5, 2013 Report Posted February 5, 2013 I've had the DeWalt 18V XRP set of tools for about 6 years, had the first battery die on me this year. I noticed a decrease in charge life over the last couple of years, so I knew it was coming. I also have a B&D 3/8" chuck corded *somewhere* in my shop that never gets used, as well as a Ryobi 1/2" chuck corded hammer drill that i use fairly often...oddly enough I use it when i do pocket screws. It's heavy and bulky, but it drills the pocket holes better than the cordless ones, IMO. We just bought a set of the Makita 12V lithium compact drill/driver/impact driver combo at Christmas. Happy with it so far, especially the size, but don't have enough use under my belt to give a good review of it. Quote
Chris H Posted February 5, 2013 Report Posted February 5, 2013 Lol, Don, I have the same Ryobi 1/2", and I have it set for my pocket jig too! I don't use it for any other regular task. I bought it for when I am laying tile, and need to mix thinset or grout, but it spends most of its life sitting at the Kreg jig for pocket screws! Quote
Beechwood Chip Posted February 5, 2013 Author Report Posted February 5, 2013 Anyone know if the DeWalt 18V NiCad XRP is the same as the Craftsman 18 V NiCad EX? I'm hoping to get my Craftsman drill fixed, and having two chargers, four batteries, two drills and an impact driver with interchangeable batteries would be sweet. I guess I could go to Sears are try to buy compatible Craftsman tools, but that's less convenient. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.