Recommended Posts

Posted

I purchased 2 Norton combo stones and they are no where near flat. I tried flattening them with sandpaper on glass but after several sheets, they are still not flat on all 4 corners. Is this normal? I would think that they would come flat for the money paid for them. I would think that the stones would need to be as flat as possible to work. Am I over thinking this?

 

I guess my next question is, I am looking at the King stones at Lee Valley and was wondering if these come some what flat, or will they require a bunch of work as well? 

 

Thanks!

Posted

To work properly, the surface of the stone must be flat...  I'm not exactly sure what you mean by 'all 4 corners'...  I'm not familiar with Norton stones.  I use Natural Waterstones, which are far from 'perfect' -- missing corners, uneven edges, etc are all common.  As long at the honing surface is flat, you are golden...

 

Sandpaper on a thick plate of glass/slab of granite/etc is a common flattening method.  I use 240grit wet/dry.  If it's really bad, I use 150 or 180grit drywall sandpaper sheets.  

 

If it takes you more than a minute or two to flatten a stone, then something is wrong.

 

Some folks purchase lapping plates, diamond stones, etc for this purpose...  You can do that as well, but drywall sheets work just fine and are about the cheapest way to go and certainly flatten as fast as a specialty item...

Posted

Hi Sean

 

I have always had access to a tormek system that worked well for be but I was interested to try a waterstone. I purchased a King combo stone as an experiment. I must confess after trying it waterstones are not for me. I found this

using diamond plates (love the freehand sharpening). I purchased a set of these and one better quality superfine  and never looked back. 
Posted

I guess what I mean is the stones dipped towards the side of the stones. High in the middle, low on the sides.

 

To work properly, the surface of the stone must be flat...  I'm not exactly sure what you mean by 'all 4 corners'...  I'm not familiar with Norton stones.  I use Natural Waterstones, which are far from 'perfect' -- missing corners, uneven edges, etc are all common.  As long at the honing surface is flat, you are golden...

 

Sandpaper on a thick plate of glass/slab of granite/etc is a common flattening method.  I use 240grit wet/dry.  If it's really bad, I use 150 or 180grit drywall sandpaper sheets.  

 

If it takes you more than a minute or two to flatten a stone, then something is wrong.

 

Some folks purchase lapping plates, diamond stones, etc for this purpose...  You can do that as well, but drywall sheets work just fine and are about the cheapest way to go and certainly flatten as fast as a specialty item...

Posted

==>  guess what I mean is the stones dipped towards the side of the stones. High in the middle, low on the sides.

 

My stones have several chipped corners (so they are lower than the center)...  The majority of the face is flat and that is the portion that I use to hone...  I don't worry about the corners.  That's some of the appeal of natural stones -- they are far from 'perfect'.  the grits are not 'standard', there are chips, dings, missing corners, etc -- but they work and work exceedingly well...  I wouldn't get too hung-up on getting a perfectly flat, rectilinear stone...

Posted

Sean, I just got the cheap DMT stones, but they have worked fine for me. If I ever move away from production woodworking, toward a more "creative" style that requires more hand tool work, I might consider some nicer stuff, but right now I'm satisfied.

  • Like 1
Posted

Sean, I just got the cheap DMT stones, but they have worked fine for me. If I ever move away from production woodworking, toward a more "creative" style that requires more hand tool work, I might consider some nicer stuff, but right now I'm satisfied.

Which DMT stones did you get Troy? What size? I use the little ones and the paddle type to touch up router bits.

Posted

I use imanishi stones from lee valley. I use grits 1000, 4000, and 8000. The stones are awesome, but as stated above, they must be flat. Instead of sandpaper or a crazy expensive diaflat plate, I opted for a diamond sharpening stone for flattening. It's a DMT plate, and is 220 grit. Works super!

I draw pencil lines on the stones, and then run them underwater while rubbing the dmt on them. Flattens them in about 5 seconds. The lapping plate "sticks" to the stone, and then I check to see the pencil line progress. I flatten every time I sharpen.

As for cost, the plate was about 50, and each stone about 70 dollars.

Posted

Steve, I got the set of three, and they are about 2x6" each. They are just called fine, medium, and coarse. I couldn't tell you what grit they are. I'm waiting for them to wear out so I can get some better ones, but they keep right on doing what I need for them to do. I send all of my router bits out to have them sharpened, along with my saw blades. The only thing I sharpen myself are my chisels and plane irons.

  • Like 1
Posted

If you keep getting a high spot in the center, I would imagine that you are not putting even consistent pressure on the stone. You might be rocking the stone left and right. If you can feel it rocking when you set it on the sandpaper, instead of trying to balance it and work the center down, focus your pressure on one side. Make sure to keep the pressure on that side and work it until it is flat all the way across. The stone doesn't need to be square. 

 

My sharpening system consist of:

DMT 8"x3" extra course diamond stone for lapping my waterstone and heavy metal removal.

DMT 6"x2" fine/extra-fine diamond plate for working the primary bevel and flattening the backs of irons and chisels 

King 1000/6000 water stone (I only use the 6000 side) for final polish on backs and for secondary bevel

 

Eventually I would like to add the 16000 grit Shapton Glass Stone

Posted

I purchased 2 Norton combo stones and they are no where near flat. I tried flattening them with sandpaper on glass but after several sheets, they are still not flat on all 4 corners. Is this normal? I would think that they would come flat for the money paid for them. I would think that the stones would need to be as flat as possible to work. Am I over thinking this?

 

I guess my next question is, I am looking at the King stones at Lee Valley and was wondering if these come some what flat, or will they require a bunch of work as well? 

 

Thanks!

All waterstones need regular maintenance to be kept flat! The better waterstones go out of flat much slower than the lesser ones. Kings are rather at the bottom because of the natural binder. Yes, that's problematic; but, the rapid dishing is likewise what makes them work so well. Reflattening a King several times during an extended session is normal--not unusual. Some of us flatten our stones prior to each use. I do this before each use since I'm convinced that even drying out can introduce warping. I prefer my Atoma or my iWood for flattening over my DMT. The latter just lacks the muscle that either of the first two has. The iWood costs less than half of either. For me, this is far superior to sandpaper on mdf or granite though lots of satisfied folks use those, too. 

 

Yes, every waterstone carried by LV will require the maintenance of flattening. Their Imanishi stones are better than your Nortons--but your Nortons are good stones, especially the higher grits. I've invested in Sigma Power Ceramic stones. They dish far less often than my former Nortons, work faster, provide outstanding feedback, and leave a magnificent edge. Of course, so will Shaptons, Choseras, and a host of other costly stones. Waterstones, in general, will cut a better range of metals (buy better stones for this, though) at a faster rate and leave a sharper edge than oil stones. But oil stones will work O1 beautifully!!!!! Diamond plates work well, as does sandpaper. I never mastered getting my sandpaper to stay perfectly flat, so that I abandoned. I like the edge results of oil stones and waterstones better than the ones off diamond stones, but that's a personal thing. Truth be known: all these approaches will work. Pick one, stay with it, learn to free hand, and have fun. 

 

:)

Posted

I guess I should state that these waterstones were brand new in the box, and I have never used them. You can look at them from the side and the corners are at least 1/8 lower than the middle of the stones. I ended up emailing norton to see what we can do about them. It would take me a very long time to flatten these stones. I was able to sort of get the 4k/8k sort of flat, but again, the corners are still lower than the center. I went ahead and purchased a Fine/Extra Fine diamond stone (the 8 inch DMT stone) to go along with my 8 inch DMT diamond coarse stone. These three grits along with my strop should get me where I need to go. I guess i'm just screwed on the norton stones since I doubt Amazon would take them back after me trying to flatten them.

Posted

==> You can look at them from the side and the corners are at least 1/8 lower than the middle of the stones

 

As previously stated, I've no experience with Norton stones... I've used several brands of synthetic waterstones prior to my conversion to natural stones.  I still have some King kit for quick/dirty work and some diamond paste on MDF for 'really quick and dirty' work...  I suspect it wouldn't take more then a few minutes to true-up an 1/8 inch using the proper kit and methods offered in this thread.  But again, there is little sense in going crazy  -- having a perfect stone won't make your tools any more sharp...  Do you really need to remove the entire 1/8" inch or just half that amount for the majority of the face to be a decent honing surface?  Are both faces that far out?  Only one face needs to be flat...

 

Sharpening stones don't have to be 'perfect' -- the honing face should be flat -- and even that doesn't have to be flat end-to-end across all four corners.  None of my  stones is 'perfect' from corner to corner -- even on the honing face -- and they work just fine...  In fact, natural stones are typically only polished on one face and the rest of the stones five faces are left rough.

 

Now, I don't think I've ever had a stone 'a least 1/8th out of the box' (except the rough face opposite the honing face), but I've had to true-up each and every stone (except for a ceramic stone set I got on a whim -- and eBayed three months later).

 

I verify flatness prior to any 'sharpening session' with a couple of pencil lines and a pass over some sandpaper or sanding screen.  For synthetic waterstones, the honing face must constantly present new abrasive to provide 'quick cutting'.  As new abrasive is released by the binder, the stone hollows/furrows/etc.  It happens quite quickly.  The harder the stone, the slower it hollows (which is generally a good thing).  But it's a trade off -- a 'too hard' synthetic stone won't remove metal quickly.  A very hard synthetic stone is fine for final polish, but annoying for establishing a primary bevel or efficiently honing a secondary bevel.  With soft stones (king, et al), you have to flatten the honing surface after every tool or two, with harder stones, maybe every five or so...  Note:  Natural stones function quite differently than their synthetic cousins and are managed a bit diferently...

Posted

Maybe your flattening surface is the problem. Glass is flat, but it is also flexible, and if the surface under your glass is not flat, under the pressure of trying to flatten your stone it could be causing the glass to bow and not be flat...

 

I use a DMT diamond plate to flatten my stones, and my Norton combo stone has never been an issue. Never has taken more than 20/30 seconds to bring it back to dead flat at the worst of times...

Posted

==> I never mastered getting my sandpaper to stay perfectly flat, so that I abandoned.

 

One idea... you need to 'break the back' of sandpaper to get it to stay flat on glass/granite/etc.

Posted

Another idea.  If you are interested in honing chisels/plane irons/etc with waterstones (and get really good at it), get a copy of Dave Charlesworth's 4-disk chisel/sharpening/plane/misc Series DVDs.  You simply can't get better...  I know it's $90, but you get decades of experience delivered in about six hours of instruction.  You'll save yourself endless frustration (and perhaps lots of $$)...  In my shop, it's maybe the best $90 ever spent... That's not an exaggeration...   

 

http://www.lie-nielsen.com/catalog.php?grp=1320

  • 2 months later...
Posted

Norton also has a hard carborundum flattening stone for not too much $.  Much harder than my 4 water stones.  I have one and it works pretty well.  Use the corrugated side to clean off the wear marks, then a few passes with the non-corrugated side to get a good flat.

Posted

After watching the sharpening video with Paul Sellers, I actually enjoy sharpening now, I can get most of all my plane blades, chisels, scrapers and saws pretty good now but I still like using my Veritas MKII honing guide on chisels to really get a super sharp edge. I'm using Shapton stones and love them. The best thing s once you get the back truly flat and a micro bevel on the face, they last really well until you start working with material over 2000 on the Janka scale. Even then if you go back and touch up the edge more than normal it makes the edge last a lot longer.

  • 1 month later...
Posted

The first surface plate I ever bought raised by sharpening level from pretty good to the top.  You can flatten stones quickly with wet-or-dry paper.  I use 100 grit.  Just put water on the stone, lay the paper on it, and it doesn't take long at all.  My first one was a 9x12, which I still use for stones and block planes. Then I found a 12 x18 that let me flatten long plane soles diagonally, but bigger would be better. 

 

Now I'm looking for a big one that I can leave outside the shop near a water hose, because it does make a bit of a mess, and it would be great to blast all the mess off with a water hose, and not worry about it inside.  I'm planning to leave a big one on a stand under the lumber shed, with a hinging cover over it, near the freezeproof hydrant.  The small one is handy to just put in the sink in the shop, but it's not big enough to work on planes.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   2 Members, 0 Anonymous, 60 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,008
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Bob44
    Newest Member
    Bob44
    Joined