Nathanf912 Posted July 1, 2013 Report Posted July 1, 2013 I have an older craftsman 18v and the batteries aren't holding a charge any more. I think it's time to look at new rather than buying new batteries. With so many choices out there what we be the best way to go for a hobbyist wood worker? I do like the craftsman drills but I'm wondering if there's something that might be better for me. Quote
Tpt life Posted July 1, 2013 Report Posted July 1, 2013 There are several good options, the biggest factor for me would be lithium ion batteries. They are lighter and last longer. Quote
wdwerker Posted July 1, 2013 Report Posted July 1, 2013 I replaced several 12 volt Panasonic drills with the little Bosch 12volt lithium ion drills and drivers. We routinely drive screws up to 3 1/2 to 4" long in piloted holes with no problem. Building and installing custom cabinets I haven't needed anything bigger. LED Headlight helps inside cabinets and small size lets me carry 2 at a time, pilot drill and a driver bit. In softwood driving a 3" screw with no pilot is easy. There is a battery level meter on the drill to let you know how much charge is left. Quote
jab73180 Posted July 1, 2013 Report Posted July 1, 2013 Go to Lowes, home depot, sears and wherever else and see what fits well in the hand. -Jason Quote
dwacker Posted July 1, 2013 Report Posted July 1, 2013 Im with Wdwerker. The 12v drills and drivers are handy. I like the small size. I have a couple sets of the Dewalt 12v drills and drivers. For any real drilling I have a corded drill and drill press. 1 Quote
EdgewaterWW Posted July 1, 2013 Report Posted July 1, 2013 +1 12V drills, I love My Milwaukee 2401-80 12V Cordless M12 Lithium-Ion Sub-Compact Screwdriver it is a 1/4" Hex chuck. And 2 Dewalt's, 14.4V 3/8 chuck (18 years old) and 18V 1/2 chuck for the heavy duty work. Quote
Darren66 Posted July 1, 2013 Report Posted July 1, 2013 I've got a 14.4v makita, had it for 6 years on its second set of batteries. Now needs another set as its not holding charge again. Like you thinking a new drill might be better value than new batteries...just not sure i make enough use of it now! 14.4v seemed a good compromise and I've not regretted it. Quote
Nathanf912 Posted July 1, 2013 Author Report Posted July 1, 2013 Thanks. I think I'll look into the bosch I like the idea of a battery gauge on the drill. Quote
mikem Posted July 1, 2013 Report Posted July 1, 2013 I bought a bosch 12v last year. I also have two 18V drills. While the 12V is no where near as powerful as the 18V, that has become my go-to drill, just because it is light and quick to grab. I have noticed that the battery life isn't that great, but they charge in 15 minutes. With two batteries, this hasn't really been an issue. Quote
Tpt life Posted July 1, 2013 Report Posted July 1, 2013 I do enough rough work that I am a proponent of having both a drill and an impact driver. This has me looking for paired combos when I look. Quote
Tom King Posted July 1, 2013 Report Posted July 1, 2013 Home Depot has the white Makita drill and driver combo for $199. I've had that set for probably 4 years, used most days, and still kicking. I did also get the turquoise set with the larger batteries for use in running in larger lag screws a little over a year ago. Both sets are still going strong. Home Depot has the turquoise set, along with a circular saw for 299. If I didn't already have the Turquoise drill and driver, that's the set I would get. I've had them all but all my Makitas are still working while all the others have ended up in the trash. I still have a Makita 9.6 volt, that I bought in something like 1983 when they first came out with cordless drills. I've replaced the 9.6 battery a number of times, but they still make that battery. I changed the chuck on that one to a good keyed chuck, and it's only used for drilling out stainless rivets on sailboats with cobalt bits, but for a 30 year old drill, it's pretty amazing that it's still doing that. The original keyless chuck wouldn't hold a cobalt bit. Use an impact driver, like is in the sets, for driving screws, and you will never go back to using a drill. Use the drill for drilling holes, and the driver for driving, and they will last you a LONG time. I also highly recommend "star drive" (really a TORX) Deckmate screws from Home Depot. Use those and you'll never go back to Phillips or square drive. Quote
mikem Posted July 1, 2013 Report Posted July 1, 2013 Also, I think it is worth mentioning that if you have a Batteries Plus in your area, they can rebuild your batteries at a very affordable price. 1 Quote
G S Haydon Posted July 1, 2013 Report Posted July 1, 2013 Tom , loving the Makita 9.6, first drill driver I owned. Only reason I got shot of it was because replacement batteries were too expensive. Quote
wdwerker Posted July 2, 2013 Report Posted July 2, 2013 The Bosch comes as a drill/ driver with a keyless chuck, an impact driver, right angle drill or a hex shank driver. All work on the same batteries. There is a flex shaft camera that fits through a 3/8" hole so you can see inside walls that uses the same battery. That's on my wish list . I get mine refurbished from CPO Bosch website. They frequently have 2 batteries, charger, fabric case/bag and a drill for around $110. If someone buys a drill and returns it for any reason they run it through testing and quality control in the USA, fix anything and sell it cheaper with a full warranty. I have 6 different drills from them with no problems at all. One is over 4 years old and the batteries are still great after daily commercial use. I even have a LED flashlight that uses the 12volt batteries. 1 Quote
EdgewaterWW Posted July 2, 2013 Report Posted July 2, 2013 Dito what Steve just said up one post. But I buy Milwaukee refurbished from CPO. Over 50 Tools use the same M12 Batteries, Flashlight and even a Heated Hoodie (I got on order) and Jacket. I got 10 M12 tools, 6 batteries and 2 chargers. You can buy the tools "bare tool" just the tool. I guess I really like the Milwaukee RED color. Quote
TRBaker Posted July 2, 2013 Report Posted July 2, 2013 Ditto what PB said. I use my 12v Hitachi for just about everything, and have corded drills and a drill press for the heavy stuff. I've used my cordless every day for the last three years and it's still going strong. Quote
tim0625 Posted July 2, 2013 Report Posted July 2, 2013 I bought this set from Home Depot on sale for $179. Only $199 regularly priced. They feel and hold well, the key less chuck is flawless, both have lots of power, and the LI batteries last a long time. I have no complaints...and when the batteries finally fail for good, they have a lifetime free replacement warranty as long as you register it on line. Quote
rodger. Posted July 2, 2013 Report Posted July 2, 2013 I bought this set from Home Depot on sale for $179. Only $199 regularly priced. They feel and hold well, the key less chuck is flawless, both have lots of power, and the LI batteries last a long time. I have no complaints...and when the batteries finally fail for good, they have a lifetime free replacement warranty as long as you register it on line.Be careful with that so called Life Time Service Agreement. I properly registered thousands of dollars in tools, and was told my receipts and paperwork were "lost" when I needed service. I will not buy a ridgid tool again, and I was a big supporter of theirs for years. Eventually when my ridgid tools die for good, I will replace them with different brands. Check out ridgidforum.com for similar complaints and comments. Here is a thread I started over there when I was burnt. I have been a member of that forum for years, and put a note in it for the moderator.https://www.ridgidforum.com/forum/t42208/ Quote
Nathanf912 Posted July 2, 2013 Author Report Posted July 2, 2013 Thanks everyone I'm gonna go with a 12v drill/driver just not sure which one yet. The bosch and the Hitachi look good and Craftsman has one too so now I just have to compare and decide. Quote
Chris H Posted July 2, 2013 Report Posted July 2, 2013 Ridgid at Home Depot may be worth the consideration. The LSA is pretty nice. Personally I have all DeWalt drill/drivers (and love them btw), but my old man has a set of the newer Ridgid lithium ions, and they can go toe to toe with my DeWalts. Just a thought. Good Luck! Quote
wdwerker Posted July 3, 2013 Report Posted July 3, 2013 Craftsman is no better than Ridgid in my opinion. CPO has the Bosch drill and impact driver combo set for 179 this week. Quote
Spencer_J Posted July 3, 2013 Report Posted July 3, 2013 IMO, i recommend the 12v bosch for the OP. for any one else in the pro-ish world I can highly recommend the makita 18v li-ion impact driver. I bought the white one (white impact driver, two batteries with charger & case) 6 years ago and it's still kicking ass. I still have one of the original batteries which holds about half what it's supposed to. I have dropped the impact driver off of roofs, fallen off the truck at high speeds... rained on over night... tossed and not caught... kicked off the workbench and hit onto the concrete floor about 2 times a week for 4 years.... used to tap things into place... used to hammer nails in the wall... the chuck is a little bit bent but still makes pilot holes and countersinks great! my makita impact driver is my daily driver Quote
jHop Posted July 3, 2013 Report Posted July 3, 2013 I've been kicking around a couple of options... my current battery (14.4) won't even drive one screw into a pre-drilled hole. I've been using the tailed drill or the drill press for my drill needs, and been thinking about a brace (but my hand drill technique really sux...) So thanks for all the input, guys. Do all you keep more than one battery? And do you charge them at the same time or swap one out for the other when it dies? (and do you use a timer for the battery charger?) Used to work for a guy who set up all of his drills to operate on the same battery, so all the drills were the same brand. Imagine 15 drills, and each having 3 batteries... with none of them marked which battery goes to which drill. Mornings when guys were collecting their gear were horrendous at the shelves where the batteries were supposedly being charged if someone forgot to leave the light switch on... (wall outlet was powered by the switch.) Quote
..Kev Posted July 3, 2013 Report Posted July 3, 2013 I use the Dewalt 20v's and love them. I bought 2 of them so that I had 2 chargers and 4 batteries. They're a little more expensive but, I've had great luck with them. I love having the option of one set up with a pilot/countersink and one set up with a screw apex. Just makes things go faster. I've never run into so much work that I can't always have a fresh battery. For me, having 2 drills with 2 chargers and 4 batteries means that I'm never at a work stoppage waiting for a battery to charge or breaking out a corded drill. The down side is that it's more money up front. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.