Beechwood Chip Posted August 4, 2013 Report Posted August 4, 2013 I managed to snap off one of the "gib screws" on my Rigid 6" Jointer. These are the screws that go sideways into the dovetail way to lock the outfeed table into position. It snapped off flush with the cast iron. I tried cutting a slot into the screw so that I could use a screwdriver to back it out, but that isn't working. Plan B is to drill out the screw, and then tap the resulting hole and put in a larger gib screw. Maybe I'll make do with only one screw. But, when I drill out the screw I'll probably also put a divot into the outfeed table dovetail that slides in the way. Any advice would be appreciated. Can anyone recommend a screw removal kit? Plan C is to give up and either buy a new jointer, or join Philadelphia Woodworks. Quote
..Kev Posted August 4, 2013 Report Posted August 4, 2013 Drill a small pilot hole and use an "easy out". You can find easy outs at most big box stores and they're relatively cheap. Use vise grips to hold the easy out while tapping it into the pilot hole (hammer) and turning it. You should be able to get it out and save the threads. Quote
TerryMcK Posted August 4, 2013 Report Posted August 4, 2013 If you have a center punch try putting a punch mark into the broken screw towards the edge of the round part. Then you can angle the centre punch at a tangent to the screw and hit it with a hammer it until it starts to turn. Essentially you are using the center punch to turn the screw counterclockwise. You may have to hit it a few times but you will find the screw will unscrew and at the point where there is enough protruding to put pliers on you can remove it completely. Failing that a good extractor is this set from Amazon (you will still need a center punch to mark to drill the pilot hole even though it claims you don't need one) http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B001A4CWHO?ie=UTF8&tag=ia003-20&linkCode=as2&camp=1789&creative=9325&creativeASIN=B001A4CWHO Quote
tim0625 Posted August 4, 2013 Report Posted August 4, 2013 I had the same thing happen with my jointer. I drilled it and tried an easy out which is usually an easy fix but the screws were small and had a lot of friction and THEN snapped the easy out inside of the screw. It was a cluster; but I still think easy out is the best approach. I ended up finding another head on ebay. Quote
Tom King Posted August 4, 2013 Report Posted August 4, 2013 An Easy Out will work if a screw will come out easy. I have several broken off in a 3/4" Grade 8 bolt that holds the frontend loader on my tractor. It gets by with one less. Quote
Dave H Posted August 4, 2013 Report Posted August 4, 2013 If the easy out doesn't work you can drill out the hole to a larger size and tap out for helicoil insert they are sold as a kit I've never done one in your situation but have done this working on an old truck I use to have take out a screw that is similar to the striped screw go to an automotive store find the helicoil kit that corresponds to the sample screw. Here is a tutorial http://www.ehow.com/how_8071702_instructions-helicoil-installation.html good luck Quote
CessnaPilotBarry Posted August 4, 2013 Report Posted August 4, 2013 +1 on the Grabbit, as mentioned by Terry. They've saved my butt a few times. Quote
TRBaker Posted August 5, 2013 Report Posted August 5, 2013 Before you use an easy-out, spray the screw with some liquid wrench or something similar. That will work on any rust that may be keeping the screw from turning easily. 1 Quote
Pwalter5110 Posted August 5, 2013 Report Posted August 5, 2013 I didn't read all the comments so I am sorry if this was already brought up. I am a Toyota Tech, and part of the job is dealing with broken bolts. If I were you I would stay FAR away from easy outs. they are hardened, so WHEN they break, you won't be able to drill them out. If I were you, I would find a set of left handed drill bits. 50% of the time they have enough bite to unwind bolts. The other 50% of the time you have to drill them and tap them. Just be sure to grind the broken bolt flat and smooth, then use a center punch ensuring you are dead center. Quote
wdwerker Posted August 5, 2013 Report Posted August 5, 2013 I have used a drill press to drill a hole in a guide block, then clamp the guide block over the broken bolt, center punch through the guide block and finally drill. I would bet someone has a head they pulled out to replace it with a helical head. Might get one cheap. Quote
Beechwood Chip Posted August 5, 2013 Author Report Posted August 5, 2013 find a set of left handed drill bits. 50% of the time they have enough bite to unwind bolts. One of the kits I found on Amazon came with left handed drill bits and easy-out style grabbers. They said the same thing - half the time the left handed drill bit does the trick. By "drill them and tap them", do you mean drill and easy-out, or something else? Quote
Beechwood Chip Posted August 5, 2013 Author Report Posted August 5, 2013 I would bet someone has a head they pulled out to replace it with a helical head. Might get one cheap. The head is fine. The outfeed table is too low for my new blades, and I can't raise it because the gib screw is too tight, and I can't loosen the gib screw because it snapped off. Quote
Nick2cd Posted August 5, 2013 Report Posted August 5, 2013 Beech, Start with a penetrating oil just so u have things as loose as they can be. Ive heard that PB buster is good. Keep the updates coming Quote
Beechwood Chip Posted August 5, 2013 Author Report Posted August 5, 2013 Beech, Start with a penetrating oil just so u have things as loose as they can be. Ive heard that PB buster is good. Keep the updates coming I hit it with some PB blaster last night. I'm waiting for the left handed drill/extractor kit to arrive. Quote
Nick2cd Posted August 5, 2013 Report Posted August 5, 2013 You know, it's funny, I just had to tackle this exact same problem a few days ago......but it was in someone's mouth! Patient presented with a screw snapped off inside a titanium implant. The screw diameter was just under 1mm. To complicate matters, the gums had completely grown over everything. Talk about pucker factor. I didnt want to have to tell this patient i just mangled her $3k implant. But at the end of the day, I got it out with no damage. I think we were both surprised. Quote
Pwalter5110 Posted August 6, 2013 Report Posted August 6, 2013 (edited) Beechwood. When I say drill and tap I mean start with a small pilot hole dead center. Take it slow. Go up to the next bit size then the next. There are charts online that tell you what hole size needs drilled for the corresponding bolt/tap size. Sorry if this is hard to follow. I am having trouble coming up with the words to explain it. Here is a chart that should help you out. IF the bolt doesn't come out, start small and stop at the corresponding drill bit size to match the bolt size that goes into the hole. I know you said you bought a set of easy outs. I have seen them work a few times, But man do they scare the crap out of me when working on cars. If, and when they break, which is regularly, you make the situation a heck of a lot worse. Edited August 6, 2013 by Pat Walter 1 Quote
Beechwood Chip Posted August 6, 2013 Author Report Posted August 6, 2013 Pat, that's a good idea. The problem is that I don't know exactly how deep the hole should be, and if I go too deep I will drill into the sliding dovetail attached to the outfeed table. But, that may be OK, as long as I get the screw out. I'd rather back the screw out without needing to drill all the way through. On the other hand, I've successfully drilled and tapped holes several times, and I've never successfully extracted a screw. Maybe the left handed drill bit will be sufficient. If it isn't, then I'll look at the situation and decide whether to try the extractor, or drill out the screw and tap the resulting hole. Thank you, everyone, for your advice. Quote
Pwalter5110 Posted August 6, 2013 Report Posted August 6, 2013 In general, bolts usually don't go the full depth of the hole. A bolt tightens by stretching out. With that being said, you should feel when you get through the bolt, and start going into the sliding dovetail. Im not exactly sure where this bolt is located. I am having a hard time picturing it in my head. But just about everytime you can safely do it, heating the surrounding area around the broken bolt will expand the bolt hole and loosen the broken off bolt. Quote
Beechwood Chip Posted August 6, 2013 Author Report Posted August 6, 2013 This isn't a bolt - it's a gib screw. It works by going the full depth of the hole and then pressing against the sliding dovetail. It locks the sliding dovetail in place. Heating it is an idea - I may try that with the left handed drill bit. Quote
Trip Posted August 6, 2013 Report Posted August 6, 2013 ==> Heating it is an idea - I may try that with the left handed drill bit. +1 Helped my brother-in-law with a broken gib bolt --- used penetrating oil, then a torch and left-hand extraction drill bit... At work, we have liquid nitrogen, so we cool stuck bolts... Quote
Nick2cd Posted August 7, 2013 Report Posted August 7, 2013 Beech, if u take out one of the other gib screws u should be able to measure the depth of the hole, no? Quote
Beechwood Chip Posted August 7, 2013 Author Report Posted August 7, 2013 Beech, if u take out one of the other gib screws u should be able to measure the depth of the hole, no? yup, but I'm not convinced that trying to precisely drill out the entire screw without damaging the sliding dovetail is better than trying to extract the screw. The risk with extraction is that the extractor will break off, and I won't be able to drill through the hardened steel of the extractor. Quote
tim0625 Posted August 7, 2013 Report Posted August 7, 2013 You know, it's funny, I just had to tackle this exact same problem a few days ago......but it was in someone's mouth! Patient presented with a screw snapped off inside a titanium implant. The screw diameter was just under 1mm. To complicate matters, the gums had completely grown over everything. Talk about pucker factor. I didnt want to have to tell this patient i just mangled her $3k implant. But at the end of the day, I got it out with no damage. I think we were both surprised. Ok Nick? My hiney tightened. Quote
Beechwood Chip Posted August 8, 2013 Author Report Posted August 8, 2013 I attacked it with the Alden Pro Grabit Broken Bolt and Damaged Screw Extractor and didn't get very far. The left-handed drill "burnisher" didn't seem to make any progress I double checked that it was supposed to be used in "reverse", because it felt like trying to drill a hole with the bit turning the wrong way - spin, spin, spin and no bite. After a while I tried the extractor, and I could feel it begin to bite for a split second, then nothing. I tried the next larger size up, and this time I could feel the drill scraping, but again there didn't seem to be any progress. I then tried the extractor and again there was a split second of grab, then it just spun. Maybe I just need to find a comfortable position and sit there with the drill for a long time, and eventually it will make a deep enough hole. Should I expect it to take a minute, five minutes, 15 minutes, more? I'm going to get some real left handed drill bits (not the "burnisher" that comes with the Grabit kit) and see if that works. If I can't extract, maybe I can drill it out. I'm using 3-in-1 oil when I drill, because I've always been told to use a lubricant when drilling metal. From what I've read, heat works well to free a frozen bolt. My screw isn't frozen - it's just snapped off flush with the hole. I've got some other things going on, so I won't be able to work on this for a couple of days. Thanks for your help and advice, everyone. Quote
Pwalter5110 Posted August 8, 2013 Report Posted August 8, 2013 Hey Beechwood. Heat does more than "freeing" up frozen bolts. It makes the hole larger, which makes the bolt a little more loose. But I would stay away from heat until your last resort. Heat will temper the broken bolt, and make it just as hard as an extractor to drill out. I would get a "real" set of left handed drill bits. Brand new drill bits won't take very long. I am thinking less than 5 minutes for a pilot hole. Then 30 seconds for each size larger you go. The key is getting the pilot hole center so take it nice and slow. If you do decide to use heat, just make sure there is already a hole there. Once you apply the heat, you will just burn up drill bits trying to drill a larger size hole. Once there is a hole there, you could probably apply heat and use an extractor and it would probably come out. BTW. Here is a link to an extractor that is probably better suited for your needs. Drill a hole, tape the extractor in, and spin out using a wrench on the hex sleeve. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.