Random Orbit Sanders...Thinking about becoming a Fanboy


Recommended Posts

Posted

OK, I think I have reached my patience (and hand vibration) limit on my DeWALT 5" random orbit sander.  I was thin king about dipping my toes into Fe$tool Fanboy status, but not sure if it is worth it for a ROS.  I know I would have to at very least have to buy the sander and a non-antistatic hose to hook to my shop vac.  

 

I am not adverse to becoming a Fanboy, because I know the Domino is a life changer, the track saw is too...and I wouldn't kick a Kapex out of bed.  I am just putting my feelers out there to see if there are any other R/O sanders that y'all have experienced that can live up to Festool at a reasonable price.

Posted

Worth every penny IMO.  I really think you need the CT with them to get the best out of them tho.  There are some other great sanders out there as well.  They would also be similarly priced.

Posted

I've had the same personal debate. Right now I have a Rigid ROS that I'm perfectly happy with. I have the Domino and CT-36 dust extractor so I'd only need to buy the sander. However once I look at the cost of any of Festools, the Mirka sanders are in the same general price range and just looking at them I know I'd like their ergonomics better.

Posted

Yea, once you dip into the 6"+ size sanders you're looking to drop some cash.  But, they are also a different beast than the general use 5".  I don't have the Festool, but after my Fein dies it is certainly at the top of my list.  I think both units are at the top of their category.

 

It's times like this that remind me of a saying, "you can swear once writing the check, or you can swear everytime you need the tool you don't have <_<"..

 

It's an investment, but one that will get a lot of use.

Posted

I've had the same personal debate. Right now I have a Rigid ROS that I'm perfectly happy with. I have the Domino and CT-36 dust extractor so I'd only need to buy the sander. However once I look at the cost of any of Festools, the Mirka sanders are in the same general price range and just looking at them I know I'd like their ergonomics better.

 

I would not touch another Mirka. I had bad luck with them when they first came out. Took the advice of the forum and got the "new design" for my daughter in mid December its now mid Feb and its a rattling piece of junk. At the same time I got two FT sanders that have seen more use than the Mirka and they are both great. They have built a grand total of 7 kitchens and 22 baths Mirka is obviously still having issues when they wont outlast a cheap Porter Cable.

Posted

I have the same dewalt 5" and was tired of it as well. I get fantastic results with my CT and Festool ETS 150/3. I'm Probably going to add an ETS 150/5 to the mix. The CT is a must for using with a ROS, if you connect your shopvac directly to the tool you're going to get too much suction to the tool and pull it to the work piece and create pigtails in the piece. The CT allows you to adjust the suction, I keep mine at about 15% when finish sanding. It's a game changer for finishing, I didn't think electric sanding could be so nice until I upgraded. 

 

 

Edit: If you get a sander and a CT together you save a bit of cash.

Posted

==>mid Feb and its a rattling piece of junk

Maybe they just don't hold to production use... But that’d be kind of strange -- they certainly have a history with production sanders – so they know how to make them…

 

Have you contacted Mirka? I'd be really interested in their post mortem on the sander... Sounds like a bearing issue, but so soon? Maybe a fastener’s come loose in the mounting – that could happen… The issue with first units was fines getting sucked into the control mechanism, but that was over-heating, not vibration… And they recalled one of my units and simply shipped me a new one...

 

I had an issue with an early unit, and they simply replaced it no questions asked – maybe they’ll do the same for your daughter…

 

The 3M looks a little more robust, but haven't tried them...

 

 

Sorry, forgot the OP... The PC low-profile is about the best bang/buck... It's discontinued, but existing stock is still available... I'd get one while you can...

Posted

==>mid Feb and its a rattling piece of junk

Maybe they just don't hold to production use... But that’d be kind of strange -- they certainly have a history with production sanders – so they know how to make them…

 

Have you contacted Mirka? I'd be really interested in their post mortem on the sander... Sounds like a bearing issue, but so soon? Maybe a fastener’s come loose in the mounting – that could happen… The issue with first units was fines getting sucked into the control mechanism, but that was over-heating, not vibration… And they recalled one of my units and simply shipped me a new one...

 

I had an issue with an early unit, and they simply replaced it no questions asked – maybe they’ll do the same for your daughter…

 

The 3M looks a little more robust, but haven't tried them...

 

We use the 3M air sanders, they are fantastic, so far. I'm just going to take the Mirka back to Woodcraft and get another festool. I would not think of that little bit of work as production, its a box shop.

Posted

Buying the festool sander and vac together gets you a better price. Also, once or twice a year you can watch for the Festool reconditioned tool sale. I have gotten several tools that way, and have been very happy with them.

Posted

The only thing I don't like about my Fein is that is a very aggressive "rip and tear" kind of sander.   Lots of movement on the head which leaves pig tails on thin film finishes but does a number when you need to remove material!).  Does the Festool truly leave that fine of a finish pattern?

Posted

>>> The PC low-profile is about the best bang/buck... It's discontinued, but existing stock is still available... I'd get one while you can...

Any suggestions on where it's still available? I've looked and not had any luck...

Posted

The only thing I don't like about my Fein is that is a very aggressive "rip and tear" kind of sander. Lots of movement on the head which leaves pig tails on thin film finishes but does a number when you need to remove material!). Does the Festool truly leave that fine of a finish pattern?

BW, I'm going to say yes it does leave that fine of a scratch pattern. I used my 150/3 on hard maple, walnut, cherry, sycamore, and oak so far since I got it. For some end grain cutting boards it left the surface smooth as glass. Even at lower grits it leaves things smoother than other sanders I've used.
Posted

I'm not sure if I'm completely blind, or my sander is a step above, but my 150/5 going up to 220 grit hasn't left pig tails yet. I've sanded at least a little over 100 bf of table tops by now. All shapes and sizes.

Posted

>>> The PC low-profile is about the best bang/buck... It's discontinued, but existing stock is still available... I'd get one while you can...

Any suggestions on where it's still available? I've looked and not had any luck...

I got mine a couple weeks back off the grizzly website

Posted

I'm not sure if I'm completely blind, or my sander is a step above, but my 150/5 going up to 220 grit hasn't left pig tails yet. I've sanded at least a little over 100 bf of table tops by now. All shapes and sizes.

Same with my 150/5 going up to 220. I initially got pigtails but lowering the CT to 25% solved that problem. If the /3 leaves a better surface, my eyes wouldn't be able to tell. 

 

I took Bob Marino's advice and bought the /5 since I don't see the 6" Rotex in my future. He said proper technique is more important than /3 or /5. 

Posted

Wonder why PC is discontinuing this model?

 

You can thank Stanley Black and Decker they killed it on both the Dewalt and PC lines. As far as I know FT is the only player left in the game. I spoke to the manager at Woodcraft, Im apparently not the only one having issues with Mirka. 3M is the new kid on the block but they will probably never cater to the hobby market. I don't think it will be a bunch longer before everyone is selling something similar to the Mirka  or 3M and the bugs will be worked out along with the price coming down.

Posted

Thanks fellas.  I am either going to scoop up that PC Low Pro, or the Festool ETS125.  If I get the ETS125, I will get a CT at a later date.  For now, I'll deal with the suction issue.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 45 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,008
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Bob44
    Newest Member
    Bob44
    Joined