Pwk5017 Posted September 29, 2015 Report Posted September 29, 2015 I think it is time to stop delaying a fence modification for my unisaw. After a month or two of use, I am yet to get this saw to perform to my liking. The blade is 1 thou out from the miter slot. The shark guard splitter is properly aligned. The biese fence sucks. I wanted to blame that dumb fence from the start, and now it is the last possible scape goat.Here is my issue: I receive bowed cuts straight off the machine. I started the shaker table build last night, and I currently have four 1 1/8" square legs that have a 1/16-1/8" arc in each of them. Odd how consistent that arc is. Yes, the stock was properly face/edge jointed before approaching the saw. Those sticks were dead nuts flat before hitting the WWII blade.What I suspect: I don't know a ton about diagnosing table saw problems, but my dial indicator jumping up to 10-15 thous where the fence and start of the blade begin has to be my issue. I know everyone says not to get too OCD/anal about setting up woodworking tools, but the results I am receiving are crap, complete crap. Why is it acceptable for a biese fence to vary 10-15 thous across its face, but not acceptable for blade alignment to miter slot? These are the results I would expect if my saw blade was that much out of alignment. I should have never given up my unifence...dumb, dumb, dumb. I can take photos to illustrate my issue, but I have CC in hand and ready to buy from Alan. I know eric has the fence, but does anyone else? I think Marc still uses his, so he must like it beyond his review. I find it odd that not one other woodworker has provided a review for the fence though. Makes me lean towards it sucking. I don't want it to suck; I want it to rock, but the lack of glowing reviews on the forums has me a nervous Nellie. Is this thing the WWing world's best kept secret? Quote
Lee Bussy Posted September 29, 2015 Report Posted September 29, 2015 How would a variance in the fence create a curve? I'm not arguing, I'm just having a tough time understanding how that would play in there. You'd think it would be just like a jointer where the fence is the wood and the wood is the jointer ... sorta ... The length should/would even out irregularities. Quote
Brendon_t Posted September 29, 2015 Report Posted September 29, 2015 Are you wanting to be talked out of the vsct fence? Quote
Pwk5017 Posted September 29, 2015 Author Report Posted September 29, 2015 How would a variance in the fence create a curve? I'm not arguing, I'm just having a tough time understanding how that would play in there. You'd think it would be just like a jointer where the fence is the wood and the wood is the jointer ... sorta ... The length should/would even out irregularities.Good question. Im not entirely sure, but I would say it is like a jointer. Im pushing the material into the cut with the reference point being the start of the fence. "0" on my dial indicator. This is like pushing stock in on the infeed table. Ok, say I complete half the cut and I don't want to lose a few fingers cutting a 1 1/8" wide leg? I would then switch to a push stick/shoe and apply pressure to the fence and forward using that. At this point it would be like switching to the outfeed table on your jointer. If the tables aren't coplanar, then you get an arced piece of stock. I assume the same happens on a table saw if you fence is like this ( If you reference that non-straight surface, then the table saw will spit out an exaggerated copy of it. Once again, just assuming here. This could be something that I am doing wrong, but I don't know how I went from dead straight cuts on my delta contractor saw with unifence to archery blanks on my unisaw with biese fence. Actually, I think the length exacerbates the issue. 8' long rips display much greater bowing than the 27" legs from last night. Furthermore, I feel like I am fighting the saw a little bit when I am feeding material through it. This saw should be going kobayashi on 1.25-1.5" wood with a forrest blade. Are you wanting to be talked out of the vsct fence?quite the opposite. Tell me it rocks, and it will make all my cuts perfect. Tell me it will go beyond that and sell all the wood in my garage by Saturday. That is mostly what I am hoping to hear. Seriously though, I just want a fence that is straight and flat that can be easily aligned to a miter slot. VSC letting me move the fence forward parallel to the blade is a bonus. Essentially, I want to have a unifence on my saw, but those went out of production before I graduated HS, so that isn't going to happen. VSC looks like a strong fence with most of the benefits of the unifence with some cons/pros to it. Quote
Brendon_t Posted September 29, 2015 Report Posted September 29, 2015 Use the search. There are A LOT of positive reviews on the fence. I started one myself. I personally didn't go with it because I don't want to screw around with building a set of rails from scratch for it. Quote
Pwk5017 Posted September 29, 2015 Author Report Posted September 29, 2015 Use the search. There are A LOT of positive reviews on the fence. I started one myself. I personally didn't go with it because I don't want to screw around with building a set of rails from scratch for it. Damn, I did search! What did you search, VSCT? I spelled it out... Well, the nice thing with having a biese currently is the VSCT fence should be pretty much plug and play. Now, there are a few NIB unifences floating around on CL that I might be able to get people to ship to me. Maybe. CL and shipping is always a problem. Quote
mat60 Posted September 29, 2015 Report Posted September 29, 2015 Very super cool ..I wouldn't expect great things myself..Some things are not worth the trouble to try and save a little..Just my opion...All I have is a biesmeyer and I am happy with it...Always something better .. Quote
Vyrolan Posted September 29, 2015 Report Posted September 29, 2015 (edited) Here's Brendon's thread: http://www.woodtalkonline.com/topic/17803-aftermarket-fence-recommendations/It includes various posts/links from @Eric. who has a VSCT fence and likes it. Edited September 29, 2015 by Vyrolan Quote
Eric. Posted September 29, 2015 Report Posted September 29, 2015 It doesn't suck, it rocks. And it's not a secret, it's just that people are always suckered into buying Biese and Vega fences because they're the old standards. Emphasis on old.The Biese clone that came with my Grizzly did exactly what your fence is doing...telegraphing a curve into cuts because it had a nasty dip in the middle of it. I got the VSCT fence, and after a little installation hiccup, it's been smooth sailing ever since. Dead straight cuts...my table saw is perfect now and has been since the upgrade.You can't dismiss a product just because a ton of people don't have it. Maybe Allan isn't the greatest marketer...doesn't mean it's not a quality product. It's better than a Biese, that much I'm sure of. The Biese is one of the most overrated products in all of woodworking, IMO.Marc still uses his...he has access to any tool out there. Trip has one (or had one)...I think he has expressed some frustrations with his...can't remember what they were exactly and I'm not sure if he's still using it. You might PM him for another opinion.I'm happy with mine...and I'm picky. That's the best info I can give you. Quote
Lee Bussy Posted September 29, 2015 Report Posted September 29, 2015 I'm picky.I'm new here but I;ve not seen you to be picky ... Quote
mat60 Posted September 29, 2015 Report Posted September 29, 2015 (edited) I'm new here but I have not seen you to be picky ... No ..I think Eric is picky .. Edited September 29, 2015 by mat60 Quote
Popular Post Brendon_t Posted September 29, 2015 Popular Post Report Posted September 29, 2015 Eric is not picky as long as he gets everything he wants the way he wants in a timely fashion 3 Quote
mat60 Posted September 29, 2015 Report Posted September 29, 2015 Who are you looking to band Daniel.? Quote
Immortan D Posted September 29, 2015 Report Posted September 29, 2015 Are you serious now? Because I'm not... Quote
Pwk5017 Posted September 29, 2015 Author Report Posted September 29, 2015 It doesn't suck, it rocks. And it's not a secret, it's just that people are always suckered into buying Biese and Vega fences because they're the old standards. Emphasis on old.The Biese clone that came with my Grizzly did exactly what your fence is doing...telegraphing a curve into cuts because it had a nasty dip in the middle of it. I got the VSCT fence, and after a little installation hiccup, it's been smooth sailing ever since. Dead straight cuts...my table saw is perfect now and has been since the upgrade.You can't dismiss a product just because a ton of people don't have it. Maybe Allan isn't the greatest marketer...doesn't mean it's not a quality product. It's better than a Biese, that much I'm sure of. The Biese is one of the most overrated products in all of woodworking, IMO.Marc still uses his...he has access to any tool out there. Trip has one (or had one)...I think he has expressed some frustrations with his...can't remember what they were exactly and I'm not sure if he's still using it. You might PM him for another opinion.I'm happy with mine...and I'm picky. That's the best info I can give you.sold! just bought it. Pricey, but I hope it's worth it. A table saw is semi worthless if it doesnt cut a perfectly straight line so there you go. I was going to be at $300 to buy the NIB unifence in florida and ship it up to PA. This fence seems like it has a few benefits over the unifence. Looks a heck of a lot stronger, that is for sure. Also, I was talking to Allan this morning and he told me they mill the extrusions now with a CNC. They truly should be dead flat now. Its not about marketing or everyone owning one; I did a few simple searches and turned up nada. Marc is legit the only guy to do any form of a review. Typically if a product is good, people talk about it. If a product is bad, people definitely talk about it. This doesn't seem to inspire much dialogue. Marc still using it was about 35% of the decision to go with it. I know he has used every single version of a table saw fence out there, and he chooses to rock this one. It says a lot. Time to behold the power of the t-nuts. Anybody need a less than ideal biesemeyer t square fence without rails? What, nobody? Quote
Eric. Posted September 29, 2015 Report Posted September 29, 2015 Marc still using it was about 35% of the decision to go with it.Cool...if you end up not liking it be sure to give him 100% of the blame. It's a simple mechanism...definitely a function over form type of deal. But it achieves the goal...straight cuts. At least it did for me. It's cool that they're doing CNC now.I agree...there's very little chatter about these fences in the ether. Perhaps it's simply because they haven't achieved critical mass...perhaps they never will. I don't know.LOL about the old fence. Mine is still consuming space in my shed. It's one of those things...can't sell it because it's garbage, yet I can't bring myself to throw it away. Quote
Guest Posted September 29, 2015 Report Posted September 29, 2015 Cool...if you end up not liking it be sure to give him 100% of the blame. It's a simple mechanism...definitely a function over form type of deal. But it achieves the goal...straight cuts. At least it did for me. It's cool that they're doing CNC now.I agree...there's very little chatter about these fences in the ether. Perhaps it's simply because they haven't achieved critical mass...perhaps they never will. I don't know.LOL about the old fence. Mine is still consuming space in my shed. It's one of those things...can't sell it because it's garbage, yet I can't bring myself to throw it away.I think it is bad marketing. I was looking into that fence and found their website very confusing. Everything was sold in components rather than a turn key kit. at least that was my impression. I really did not know what I needed to buy so I did not buy anything. I am a total impulse buyer. I am not the type that wants to do research and think about my purchase. Quote
Brendon_t Posted September 29, 2015 Report Posted September 29, 2015 I think it is bad marketing. I was looking into that fence and found their website very confusing. Everything was sold in components rather than a turn key kit. at least that was my impression. I really did not know what I needed to buy so I did not buy anything. I am a total impulse buyer. I am not the type that wants to do research and think about my purchase. Im im at the other end of the spectrum. I want to do lots of research and that made the website even more confusing. Quote
Tom King Posted September 29, 2015 Report Posted September 29, 2015 Their hole saw plug poppers are absolutely worth the money. Quote
Guest Posted September 29, 2015 Report Posted September 29, 2015 Ground zero for their problem. Does this menu make any sense? At least 4 of these menu options might be for a table saw fence. i guess the problem is I call it a fence and he calls it an extrusion. Quote
Tpt life Posted September 29, 2015 Report Posted September 29, 2015 (edited) You can purchase the extrusion without the fence kit. Edit: It has been awhile since I browsed. You buy the fence kit and then match with the desired extrusion. It is a custom build of sorts. Edited September 29, 2015 by C Shaffer Quote
Trip Posted September 30, 2015 Report Posted September 30, 2015 I've got one...It's probably the best fence available for older American or Asian-sourced iron... Why? The 80:20 extrusion is dead-nuts on, the T-square is well made and the system's extensible... I've made several custom extensions for the extrusion -- that's why I wanted it. I've kept it because it's well made... Quote
Vyrolan Posted September 30, 2015 Report Posted September 30, 2015 I've made several custom extensions for the extrusion -- that's why I wanted it.Examples? I always see that as an argument and I can certainly imagine a wide variety of things you COULD do, but I've never really seen many actual "this thing helped me do X". Eric always says along the lines of "never have but I might one day". Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.