Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Triton TDJ600 Duo Dowel Jointer

Featured Replies

37 minutes ago, Cliff said:

I don't think I care which is stronger. They both serve pretty different purposes. Anyone that can afford or justify a Domino wouldn't care at all about that Triton dowel thing. And those (like me) that can't justify the Domino - the Triton thing looks pretty sweet. 

That being said, I was just thinking earlier today that I got a side job coming up that would give me more than enough cash to get a Domino. Then I smacked myself in the head as there are like 800 things I need first. :( 

That's the only reason I wouldn't buy a Domino. I won't be using it that much so as to justify the expense and the space needed for storage. I already own an excellent doweling jig, and I like it. If at some point I need a better jointing system, I will get the Domino, but wouldn't even consider getting that Triton thing.

  • Replies 87
  • Views 30.7k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • You can't be saying this after yesterday...

  • I'm sensing sarcasm. No one is claiming that the Domino is the strongest joint in the world or that it's somehow better than traditional mortise and tenon o

  • I just went back and looked at the FWW test results. They compared a butt joint with three 3/8" dowels on 3/4" centers for a total edge to edge span of 1 7/8" to a single 10 x 50 Domino centered in th

Posted Images

4 hours ago, Daniel. said:

AFAIK Dowelmax is just a doweling jig...

I thought dowelmax was overlapping dowels, but when I looked it up you are right that its just a dowel system. They should make a $800 dowel tool like the Festool Domino cutter so people will think its cool

  • Popular Post
6 hours ago, Andy Wright said:

They should make a $800 dowel tool like the Festool Domino cutter so people will think its cool

I'm sensing sarcasm.

No one is claiming that the Domino is the strongest joint in the world or that it's somehow better than traditional mortise and tenon or that it's not an expensive tool.  But it's an incredibly fast and easy way to make a very strong and precise joint, and a person sounds silly making fun of others who own them.

Guys who woodwork for a living make more money because of the Domino, and hobbyists complete more projects in less time.  I'm not a Festool fanboy but it truly is a game-changing tool, as the cliche goes.  And until you've added one to your workflow for a little while, you really don't know what you're missing.  I guarantee if you won a Domino in a raffle and used it for a year, you'd no longer be making passive aggressive comments about it and implying that people who own them only own them because they "think it's cool" because it's expensive.  You're speaking without experience and to me you just sound bitter and uninformed.

45 minutes ago, Eric. said:

I'm sensing sarcasm.

No one is claiming that the Domino is the strongest joint in the world or that it's somehow better than traditional mortise and tenon or that it's not an expensive tool.  But it's an incredibly fast and easy way to make a very strong and precise joint, and a person sounds silly making fun of others who own them.

Guys who woodwork for a living make more money because of the Domino, and hobbyists complete more projects in less time.  I'm not a Festool fanboy but it truly is a game-changing tool, as the cliche goes.  And until you've added one to your workflow for a little while, you really don't know what you're missing.  I guarantee if you won a Domino in a raffle and used it for a year, you'd no longer be making passive aggressive comments about it and implying that people who own them only own them because they "think it's cool" because it's expensive.  You're speaking without experience and to me you just sound bitter and uninformed.

As far as I can tell Festool seems to have divided the marketplace up into three groups - those that think it's cool or expensive and therefore by everything, those that represent what you just said about game changers and time saved, and those that just outright hate it and look down on people for using them for one reason or another. 

His sarcasm did have a grain of truth in it. There are some folks that will go buy anything painted green. And that's cool with me too because why do I care how people spend their money? 

I feel like owning a Domino at this stage in my woodworking career would cheapen me as a woodworker. Because I haven't mastered doing it the manual way. I've never done a dowel joint, I've done 3-4 M&T joints, done one picture frame with miter joints. No dovetails, no box joints. So for me, it would be missing out on the very things I got into this hobby to learn if I bought that right now. So I'm looking at it as a 1-2 years down the road tool when I can say, "yeah I've done that stuff, but now I want to go faster." 

7 hours ago, Andy Wright said:

I thought dowelmax was overlapping dowels, but when I looked it up you are right that its just a dowel system. They should make a $800 dowel tool like the Festool Domino cutter so people will think its cool

When it comes to coolness, I consider my doweling jig to be far cooler than any power tool LOL. It isn't cheap either:

http://www.amazon.com/Joint-Genie-Dowelling-improvement-woodworking/dp/B005J4BBNW/ref=sr_1_81?s=hi&ie=UTF8&qid=1450534763&sr=1-81&keywords=dowel+jig

3 minutes ago, wtnhighlander said:

Dang, Eric! To me, it just sounded like Andy was poking fun at dowelmax by suggesting they need ride the coat tails of Festool popularity.

I think on this weekend everything is evenly divided between light and dark side of the force. No in betweens.

1 minute ago, Cliff said:

As far as I can tell Festool seems to have divided the marketplace up into three groups - those that think it's cool or expensive and therefore by everything, those that represent what you just said about game changers and time saved, and those that just outright hate it and look down on people for using them for one reason or another. 

Yep, I agree with that...there are definitely fanboys who aren't capable of being objective, and there are definitely haters who aren't capable of being objective.  But if you're in between, and you ARE objective, you see tools like the Domino for what they are...an expensive tool that significantly increases your efficiency.  That's what it is.  Yes it's expensive, but that doesn't mean it's not worth the cost.  No you don't need it to do top-shelf work, but that doesn't mean you shouldn't buy one...out of pure stubbornness.  If you have it in your budget and you value your time more than your money, then there's nothing wrong with buying the damn thing.  I get so tired of people on both sides taking extreme positions.  It's just like politics...the truth is almost always in the middle.

I also agree that a new woodworker should not buy a Domino for at least the first couple years.  Master the traditional M&T, then get a Domino later if you're so inclined.  I can tell you from experience it becomes very difficult to make yourself spend hours on M&T when you can knock out a batch of Dominoes in fifteen minutes.

Geez Eric.

1) I'm not "anti-Festool". I just dropped $800 on a Festool track saw two weeks ago to help speed up some cabinets I'm building where I needed to break down a lot of plywood

2) I'm not bitter. I can afford to buy whatever I want to buy, I just haven't felt the need to buy a Domino cutter. I prefer traditional mortise and tenon joinery (I guess its a bit silly but I enjoy the work that goes into those joints)

I was just poking some fun at people. It seems like using the domino is much "cooler" than dowels, and I think part of the reason is because the domino cutter is sexy but a drill is a tool everyone owns. Drilling a bunch of holes is not a very exciting way to build stuff so it gets poo-pooed  

13 minutes ago, Andy Wright said:

Geez Eric that post was pretty mean spirited.

1) I'm not "anti-Festool". I just dropped $800 on a Festool track saw two weeks ago to help speed up some cabinets I'm building where I needed to break down a lot of plywood

2) I'm not bitter. I can afford to buy whatever I want to buy, I just haven't felt the need to buy a Domino cutter. I prefer traditional mortise and tenon joinery (I guess its a bit silly but I enjoy the work that goes into those joints)

I was just poking some fun at people. It seems like using the domino is much "cooler" than dowels, and I think part of the reason is because the domino cutter is sexy but a drill is a tool everyone owns. Drilling a bunch of holes is not a very exciting way to build stuff so it gets poo-pooed  

Sorry if I took it the wrong way Andy.  What I interpreted from your post is, "People are duped into thinking they need the Domino simply because it's expensive."  If that's not what you meant then I misunderstood and please accept my apologies.

The Domino IS "cooler" than dowels IMO simply because it's so fast and easy to create super strong and precise joints.  At least that makes it cooler in my book.  Even the nicest doweling jigs out there are finicky and time consuming in comparison to the Domino.  But that doesn't necessarily mean the Domino is worth the money to everyone.  It was worth it to me, but just because it's not worth it to someone else doesn't mean that I was drunk on the green kool-aid and was incapable of making a rational and objective decision.

Two days in a row I find myself embroiled.  Perhaps I should take a break.  I'm stuck at the lumberyard for a stretch here and I'm a bit bored...arguments are entertaining. :)

2 minutes ago, Eric. said:

 

Two days in a row I find myself embroiled.  Perhaps I should take a break.  I'm stuck at the lumberyard for a stretch here and find myself a bit bored...arguments are entertaining. :)

Some days a person needs to just lash out. 

2 minutes ago, Eric. said:

 Even the nicest doweling jigs out there are finicky and time consuming in comparison to the Domino

hmmm have you ever used a doweling jig? The Domino requires you to place marks on both pieces while doweling jigs don't need that. And when you have a 12" doweling jig like I do, only little indexing is required making things even faster.

Yes I have Daniel.  Granted, not the Dowelmax, but I tried two others early on and found them both terribly frustrating and slow to use.

Have you ever used a Domino?  There's really no argument to have here...the Domino is faster and more precise, hands down, unless we're talking about one of the fifty thousand dollar industrial units IKEA uses to make their holes.

Again, let me be clear...I'm not saying the Domino is even close to a necessity.  If Andy likes taking the time to make traditional M&T, more power to him.  I enjoy it sometimes too, on the right pieces.  But other times I just wanna slam through a project as quickly as possible, and I know of no other tool available to the hobbyist that puts two pieces of wood together faster while still being strong, precise, and aesthetically acceptable.

I don't think anyone is going to convince Domino owners that a doweling system is better no matter how cool or cheap it is. I own a Domino and Leigh FMT and neither one of them is ever leaving my shop. 

7 minutes ago, Eric. said:

Yes I have Daniel.  Granted, not the Dowelmax, but I tried two others early on and found them both terribly frustrating and slow to use.

Have you ever used a Domino?  There's really no argument to have here...the Domino is faster and more precise, hands down, unless we're talking about one of the fifty thousand dollar industrial units IKEA uses to make their holes.

Again, let me be clear...I'm not saying the Domino is even close to a necessity.  If Andy likes taking the time to make traditional M&T, more power to him.  I enjoy it sometimes too, on the right pieces.  But other times I just wanna slam through a project as quickly as possible, and I know of no other tool available to the hobbyist that puts two pieces of wood together faster while still being strong, precise, and aesthetically acceptable.

Perhaps your jig sucked big time or you didn't take the time to learn how to use it properly.

I know the Domino is a better jointing system, I've already said so. But you were talking about how slow and finicky doweling systems are, you always seem to bash the tools that are not part of your workflow.

5 minutes ago, Daniel. said:

But you were talking about how slow and finicky doweling systems are, you always seem to bash the tools that are not part of your workflow.

I said slow and finicky "in comparison to the Domino."  I'm not bashing anything.  I defended dowels as a technique early on in this thread...I even defended BISCUITS a few days ago, LOL.  I'm just putting things on a scale of better and worse...and trying to be objective about it regardless of which tools I own.

I'll concede, both of the dowel jigs I tried in the past were junk.  It wasn't because I was using them improperly, it was because their designs presented limitations in precision and ease of use.  I'm sure there are better dowel systems out there...but if there were any that were as fast and easy as the Domino, they'd be a whole lot more popular.

 Even the nicest doweling jigs out there are finicky and time consuming in comparison to the Domino

hmmm have you ever used a doweling jig? The Domino requires you to place marks on both pieces while doweling jigs don't need that. And when you have a 12" doweling jig like I do, only little indexing is required making things even faster.

Just an FYI, i almost never make marks when using the domino. I use the reference pins and the extension for longer runs of dominos. I agree, making marks slows everything down.

Sent from my SGH-I337M using Tapatalk

11 minutes ago, shaneymack said:

Just an FYI, i almost never make marks when using the domino. I use the reference pins and the extension for longer runs of dominos. I agree, making marks slows everything down.

Sent from my SGH-I337M using Tapatalk

Yeah that thirty seconds really kills ya! :D

Just an FYI, i almost never make marks when using the domino. I use the reference pins and the extension for longer runs of dominos. I agree, making marks slows everything down.

Sent from my SGH-I337M using Tapatalk

Yeah that thirty seconds really kills ya! [emoji3]

Im all about efficiency. 30 seconds here, 30 seconds there, it all adds up. I always think of the most efficient way to do something without sacrificing quality. Like I've told you before, comes from years of production carpentry.

Sent from my SGH-I337M using Tapatalk

I hear ya.  If I was doing a million Dominoes I'd do it that way too.  But for four aprons and four legs I can manage taking the few seconds it takes to make lines.  I don't see how making the lines is even an issue worth mentioning.  It's like complaining about the time it takes to plug it in and hook up the hose.

  • Popular Post

There's a universal human element to defending what you know and dismissing what you don't. Applies to any hobby, profession, way of life. There are some things that Festool does that are top of the heap, others that don't seem to provide much benefit over any other brand. I try not to disparage anyone's choice of tool, because you never really know what the circumstances are. Lack of funds. Tool of a loved one. Something you lucked into, or something that is your dream tool. I think one of the worst things one can do is try to keep up with the Joneses with woodworking tools. Find what works for you in your situation, and don't worry about what someone else has in their shop.

As for the Triton, I told Marc I'd love to see a video on it, and perhaps a comparison. I'd love to see a legit alternative to the Domino in the marketplace in terms of ease, convenience and speed. If it can do it at a third of the price, even better. Competition is only a good thing. I use the Domino all the time to make shop storage, and haven't seen any strength demerits over something like a dado joint to this point. I'm sure there are, but they haven't applied in my applications. I'll pick the Domino over setting up the dado stack every single day and twice on Sunday if the application allows for it. 

The Triton doesn't hold much appeal for me simply because I own a Domino. If I need to do an odd dowel, I'd get something much cheaper. As I said, however, it would be nice to see an alternative to the Domino used in some projects. Those who have the Domino would obviously know how to substitute, but those without may be exposed to an easier or quicker way to move onto techniques or projects that might matter more. If that's important to them.

 

 

  • Popular Post

I just went back and looked at the FWW test results. They compared a butt joint with three 3/8" dowels on 3/4" centers for a total edge to edge span of 1 7/8" to a single 10 x 50 Domino centered in the joint. Lousy comparison. It showed the dowels failing at 759 lbs vs 597 for a single domino. The result that convinced me that their tests were flawed was the comparison to a biscuit joint. The Domino was barely any improvement over a biscuit in their tests -  597 lbs to 545 for biscuits. I think anyone who has used both would argue that result until the sun goes down for good.

==>if they say dowels were stronger than Dominoes

If I remember correctly, they used rebar...  [emoji4]

 

 

==>There was a strength test conducted by FWW

As an FYI: FWW does a lot of things well... But one thing they don't do well is comparative testing... They tend to use a small sample sizes and their methodology is usually flawed... I strongly suspect they've never heard of a T test...

 

 

I pity those fools!

6d4d8ecd554d2bae7c2c5cb543e2f06e.jpg

P.S. I teach Educational Research and do know what a t-Test is. [emoji10]

Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

Gents - I think you are missing something in the FWW tests. It wasn't the Domino or the dowels that failed - it was the wood. Neither the Domino nor the dowels penetrate far into the rail and the rail failed at the end of the Domino or dowel. Both joints are fine for what they are and the Domino is probably the fastest. Both the Domino and the multidowel joint have about the same long grain glue surface, but the glue isn't the weak point - the wood is.

1 hour ago, micks said:

I just went back and looked at the FWW test results. They compared a butt joint with three 3/8" dowels on 3/4" centers for a total edge to edge span of 1 7/8" to a single 10 x 50 Domino centered in the joint. Lousy comparison. It showed the dowels failing at 759 lbs vs 597 for a single domino. The result that convinced me that their tests were flawed was the comparison to a biscuit joint. The Domino was barely any improvement over a biscuit in their tests -  597 lbs to 545 for biscuits. I think anyone who has used both would argue that result until the sun goes down for good.

The results from the Dowelmax site look more realistic: http://www.dowelmax.com/jointstrength.html. Of course they maybe partial and useless, for obvious reasons, but most important because Domino was not the winner (again).

 

#20 BISCUIT

285 lbs. per square inch

POCKET HOLE (5 SCREWS)

420 lbs. per square inch

DOUBLE DOMINO

560 lbs. per square inch

ROUTED MORTISE & TENON

640 lbs. per square inch

MULTIPLE DOWEL

890 lbs. per square inch

 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Who's Online (See full list)

  • There are no registered users currently online

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,010 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Lolli4 Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.