Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Triton TDJ600 Duo Dowel Jointer

Featured Replies

First of all I don't trust those results because they were published by a company with a horse in the race.  Of course they're gonna come out on top...duh!

"Double Domino"...what's that mean?  how big of a Domino are they using and are they bigger or smaller than the dowels they used?

"Multiple dowels"...how many is "multiple?"

 

Also, it's all moot anyway, because if you think two Dominoes won't be strong enough to hold your Shaker end table together at 560 psi but half a dozen dowels will at 890 psi...then you're taking "overbuilding" to a whole new level.  The truth is, with the likely exception of biscuits, any of those methods will be plenty sufficient for the vast majority of joints any of us will ever be faced with making.  It boils down to speed and precision and how much those things are worth to you in dollars and cents.

  • Replies 87
  • Views 30.7k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • You can't be saying this after yesterday...

  • I'm sensing sarcasm. No one is claiming that the Domino is the strongest joint in the world or that it's somehow better than traditional mortise and tenon o

  • I just went back and looked at the FWW test results. They compared a butt joint with three 3/8" dowels on 3/4" centers for a total edge to edge span of 1 7/8" to a single 10 x 50 Domino centered in th

Posted Images

If you're curious, check their site, there are videos of the tests. I didn't watch them because it's a waste of time.

9 minutes ago, Eric. said:

First of all I don't trust those results because they were published by a company with a horse in the race.  Of course they're gonna come out on top...duh!

"Double Domino"...what's that mean?  how big of a Domino are they using and are they bigger or smaller than the dowels they used?

"Multiple dowels"...how many is "multiple?"

 

Also, it's all moot anyway, because if you think two Dominoes won't be strong enough to hold your Shaker end table together at 560 psi but half a dozen dowels will at 890 psi...then you're taking "overbuilding" to a whole new level.  The truth is, with the likely exception of biscuits, any of those methods will be plenty sufficient for the vast majority of joints any of us will ever be faced with making.  It boils down to speed and precision and how much those things are worth to you in dollars and cents.

I store my collection of World War II tanks on my shaker tables. Strength matters.

Wait I've been doing it all wrong. I buy mine buy the 1,000's  i know it might be overkill but who knows.

toothpicks.jpg

It looks like an almost carbon copy of the mafell unit.  If they have that track system to locate the dowels like Mafell,  it could be worth a look.

 

 

As a guy who doesn't own a single piece of fesgreen, I believe I am qualified as being unbiased.

Biscuit joiners were once all the rage but have since gone by the way side. It's not that they aren't good as alignment tools,they are just not precise and Bisquits aren't very strong for actual joinery. 

In comes the domino. The tool is very precise, uses a tennon with long  grain glue joints and costs an arm and leg.

With the only gripe being cost,  it's no surprise others are jumping on the band wagon. I'm sure festool has a crap ton of patents so others have to go back to the drawing board.   One dowel is strong, two must be better right? 

It comes down to. ... dum du du duuuuummmmm.. Who cares. . If you want to use dowels,  use dowels,  if you want dominos, use dominos. 

Strength seems to be limited by your wood anyways. 

14 minutes ago, Daniel. said:

Brendon, thank you for bringing clarity to this thread. My life has a meaning now.

You're very welcome. In case you need more meaning,  feel free to check out this same thread being beaten to death twice a month for who knows how long.  Plenty of great "facts" from all sides and more pontificating than one could shake a stick at.

Ok. Will check back from time to time to make sure dowels are still the strongest joinery method in this universe and all the other universes.

I'm still the new guy and it's easy enough for me to tell who has a vested interest (bought Festool) in a discussion.

Don;t get me wrong - if I win the lottery it's going to look like I'm Irish .. just saying.

Just an FYI, i almost never make marks when using the domino. I use the reference pins and the extension for longer runs of dominos. I agree, making marks slows everything down.

Sent from my SGH-I337M using Tapatalk

Yeah that thirty seconds really kills ya! [emoji3]

You HAVE been following Shanes rocker build, haven't you ????

On 12/18/2015 at 9:55 AM, Llama said:

Still not accurate... The mortise for the domino is formed with a high quality tool, not a drill. Most dowel jigs on the market rely on the user to properly clamp the jig to the piece in a repeatable manner. Much more unreliable than the Domino. Not saying it's not possible, or that all dowel joints are bad, because that wouldn't be true... There is much less user error when using the Domino over any dowel jig on the market.

Not to get too technical, but I work in a lab that tests mechanical and wear properties of various products. I cringe every time I see a "lab test" in any magazine. Their methods are laughable. 

The domino tool actually has a function that allows the user to add side slop to some of the mortices.  In a long joint on a piece of case work, presumably the user makes the first joint tight for location and then the rest of the joints side loose to allow for the inaccuracy of the tool and cut lengths of the parts.  The domino tool is not clamped to the work piece which is a liability from a joint precision stand point.

Single surface and hole referencing dowel jigs such as the Jessem Paralign both demand and provide precision.  You have to get the hole spacing dead on or a dowel joint won't go together; there is no side slop creation function.  I have not yet had a joint that wouldn't assemble as the tool provides the precision necessary.   The clamping of the jig and the length of the bushings is an accuracy provider.  Once the clamp holding the work piece slipped and I side loaded the 3/8 drill and broke it.  The jig remained tight on the work piece.  Once I removed the jig, the dowel hole drilled when I broke the drill was surprisingly perfect.

The speed of the domino over single surface referenced dowel jigs is perhaps due to the fact that it does not make, nor does it need to make the hole spacing as accurately as required for a successful dowel joint.

I think dowel joints can be incredibly strong for several reasons.

1.  Dowels and dowel holes are round.  Round rods and round holes are easy to make to great precision.  Machine made holes made are likely to be very consistent in various woods, plywoods, mdf, particle board, etc.

2.  Dowels and dowel holes are round.  It is easy to assemble round things even if the fit between the hole and dowel are tight interference fits.  This lesson is best learned in the machine shop with metal parts.  Provided you have accurate round holes and shafts and a reasonable interference along with a precise lead-in chamfer, round shafts can be pressed into round holes with interference relatively easily.  On the other hand, square are rectangular parts with a tight clearance fit can be much harder to assemble since they do not self align the way round parts do.  I believe it is possible to provide a much tighter mechanical joint with dowels than loose tenons due to this feature.

3.  Dowels and dowel holes are round.  When you drill a hole in something, you make it weaker.  When you make a mortise in something you also make it weaker.  There is an optimum thickness of dowel/domino to the thinness of the remaining wall in the mortised part.  Obviously, a larger diameter dowel is stronger than a smaller diameter dowel but at some point too large of a dowel means the remaining wall may be too weak.  With a dowel joint, the thinnest part of the wall occurs at only one point whereas loose tenons thin the wall along the entire length of tenon.

I believe that dominos provide a fast way to make joints in comparison to single reference dowel jigs. There is likely to be a lot of variability in joints made by dowel jigs and dominoes as well as the actual dowels and dominoes themselves and the materials being joined.

Which method is strongest?  That depends on all the factors mentioned and perhaps a few others such as the way the load is applied to the joint.  But I don't think it is unbelievable that either method could be tested to outperform the other in a given situation.

This is an easy one... And for some reason it is not being talked about as loudly as it should.

Both methods are strong enough for making furniture joints. All methods of joinery have the ability to introduce user error. There is no perfect method of joining wood.

I use a domino, and anyone else can use what they want to join and align wood. I have used dowels, and even GASP pocket screws. Guess what, they all have their place! 

The constant bickering about how to join wood, how to sharpen a blade, how to charge for things, how to blah blah blah really drives me nuts! 

Bonus: Tell me which method I used on this end table.

1379496_10202129099577162_684745272_n.jp

2 minutes ago, Llama said:

This is an easy one... And for some reason it is not being talked about as loudly as it should.

Both methods are strong enough for making furniture joints. All methods of joinery have the ability to introduce user error. There is no perfect method of joining wood.

I use a domino, and anyone else can use what they want to join and align wood. I have used dowels, and even GASP pocket screws. Guess what, they all have their place! 

The constant bickering about how to join wood, how to sharpen a blade, how to charge for things, how to blah blah blah really drives me nuts! 

Bonus: Tell me which method I used on this end table.

1379496_10202129099577162_684745272_n.jp

Wasn't this during your hot glue days mel?

3 minutes ago, Brendon_t said:

Wasn't this during your hot glue days mel?

Nah, tapered sliding dovetails using some darn BCTW contraption. 

Way before my days of BCTW awesomeness. That's a good idea though Carus :) 

Interlaced dowels? That would probably my choice because I woudln't feel safe with a tongue and groove method (based on my inexperience).

Mel used a credit card to buy the tools he needed to do the joinery method he wanted! :D

3 minutes ago, Woodenskye said:

Mel used a credit card to buy the tools he needed to do the joinery method he wanted! :D

Then he used his credit card again to clean the glue from the butt joints LOL

At the rate my cards get stolen, I might as well use them to scrape glue! Just had a card I've never used get stolen. 

46 minutes ago, Llama said:

This is an easy one... And for some reason it is not being talked about as loudly as it should.

Both methods are strong enough for making furniture joints. All methods of joinery have the ability to introduce user error. There is no perfect method of joining wood.

I use a domino, and anyone else can use what they want to join and align wood. I have used dowels, and even GASP pocket screws. Guess what, they all have their place! 

The constant bickering about how to join wood, how to sharpen a blade, how to charge for things, how to blah blah blah really drives me nuts! 

Bonus: Tell me which method I used on this end table.

1379496_10202129099577162_684745272_n.jp

Trick question, It's IKEA.

18 minutes ago, Woodenskye said:

Mel used a credit card to buy the tools he needed to do the joinery method he wanted! :D

I did buy the majority of my LN planes in one order. :) 

1 hour ago, Llama said:

This is an easy one... And for some reason it is not being talked about as loudly as it should.

Both methods are strong enough for making furniture joints. All methods of joinery have the ability to introduce user error. There is no perfect method of joining wood.

I use a domino, and anyone else can use what they want to join and align wood. I have used dowels, and even GASP pocket screws. Guess what, they all have their place! 

The constant bickering about how to join wood, how to sharpen a blade, how to charge for things, how to blah blah blah really drives me nuts! 

Bonus: Tell me which method I used on this end table.

1379496_10202129099577162_684745272_n.jp

I am guessing you drilled holes with a brace and bite, mounted dominos on the lathe and turned them into dowels.  Yes...No?

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,010 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Lolli4 Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.