If you could have only one Sander...... ?


Recommended Posts

Posted

Like the title says, if your goal was to make smaller projects (jigs, wooden toys, puzzles) and not so much in the way of larger projects (save for a rocking horse project) and you could have only one sander, which one would you choose and why? 

 

Thanks!

 

Posted

Do you mean one sander in total, or do you just mean handheld sanders? If I could only have a single sanding machine, it would probably be a stationary belt sander, or the Rigid oscillating sander. For handheld use, I'd probably choose a pneumatic Mirka ROS.

Posted

Handheld. I have a porter cable bench top belt/disc combo but my ryobi random orbit sander just crapped out and need to replace it

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Posted

Lol maybe I should have put a price limit on this game

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

I like the RO 90 since it has the detail attachment and would let me get into tighter spaces. Problem is that either of these would be a pretty tough sell to my wife. I can probably sell her on $200 but $300+ is a tough sell at this point in time. Any alternatives to the 150/3 or RO 90 under $200? (Even if it's not the greatest if it will do a decent job and last me 2-4 years until I can save up for the festool that would be great

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Posted

Well, if you don't like my options... :)    BTW: they are my go-to sanders and can recommend both... Coming off the planer, add a trace coat and process through the wide-belt... And the LN #4 is a great finish cordless sander...

 

The best sub-$200 that I can personally vouch for is the Porter Cable low-profile RoS... They are discontinued, but I suspect there is legacy stock -- the trick would be to locate it...

Another idea -- Some folks are eBaying low-hour ETS sanders to purchase the ETS/EC series... Now that the line is being discontinued, eBay could be your friend...

Posted
9 minutes ago, hhh said:

Another idea -- there are folks who drink waaaaaay too much green Kool-aid: they will eBay perfectly good ETS sanders to purchase the ETS/EC series... eBay could be your friend...

Um, anyone that has that Felder sander shouldn't be making fun of the kool-aid drinkers! Unless you're sanding Roubo tops 8 hours a day, that sander might be a little overkill...

Posted

==>Unless you're sanding Roubo tops 8 hours a day, that sander might be a little overkill

Fair point...

 

<edit>

Although some clarification may be needed: a WBS isn’t about sanding big things, although it can handle overlarge stock, that's not really it's core capability... It’s just another member of the panel sander family. The tool is more flexible, efficient and yields far superior results compared to any drum or dual-drum sander... Once a panel leaves the belt, it’s ready for finish... The only downside is weight, cost and being somewhat temperamental... Sure, it’s overkill for a hobby shop – so are a lot of tools. However, the efficiency and results are hard to argue against... It’s one of those tools that once you have one, you can’t image a workflow without it – and until you use one, it’s hard to image how to justify adding it to your shop...

Think of it like a 16” jointer: big, heavy, expensive and impossible to justify – until you have one... :)

  • Like 1
Posted

Trip nailed it - the 390K Porter Cable. I've seen it a couple places, but it certainly got rare real quick. 

I did give mine to my BIL when I upgraded to the ETS 150/3. 

 

If I could only have one sander, it would be a 5-6" RO. Why? I can do corners and edges by hand if need be. I'd kill myself if I had to do something like the Roubo with the RO 90. Great sander, its on my list for 2016.

Posted

The PC 390k is definitely hard to find. What about the ETS 125 EC? See a few of these on eBay for 190-250 range which is a stretch but doable. Any other suggestions for a companion to the bench belt/ disc sander?

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Posted

If you can score an EC for $190-$250, then go for it (MSRP is around $400 for the 125 and $500 for the 150)... But, check provenance carefully. FT usually sells for MSRP unless you do a large tool purchase, then it's discounted maybe 20%. So the best one would hope for would be just north of $300, and that would be on a $4K order... So unless it's a factory refurb, I would be suspicious of that price.

These days, some hobbyists are selling their non-EC sanders to buy an EC, so the price on the ETS line is dropping rapidly... You can certainly find an ETS for under $200... A hobby-shop tool is generally lightly-used, so if you get a hobby-shop ETS for under $200, that will give you years of reliable service... 

Posted

Ahhh, that makes more sense...

All things being equal, the FT is a smoother sander... If you use a sander for long periods of time, then get the FT... But, if you plan to add a panel sander to your shop, then the amount of time spent using an RoS drops dramatically, so it wouldn't make a difference --- then get the PC and use the difference to get a good selection of sandpaper... BTW: quality sandpaper costs -- so don't be shocked when your initial order of paper exceeds what you spent on the sander...

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   2 Members, 0 Anonymous, 41 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,008
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Bob44
    Newest Member
    Bob44
    Joined