Lee Bussy Posted December 28, 2015 Report Posted December 28, 2015 The other thread about a 12" sander got me thinking. As I look around the Interwebz I see a lot of people doing some really squirrely things to try to make one. While they are not incredibly expensive, I still wonder if a person could not come up with a pretty good one as a shop-made. There's a few folks who sell plans for them on the typical websites. The weak links all appear to be the disk - specifically how to join it to an arbor. I thought I would throw a few ideas out there and have you'uns shoot holes in them. Option #1: Shopsmith parts and any motor with a 5/8 arbor: 555143 Shopsmith 12" Steel Sanding Disc ... ;$55.60 I've got a couple old grinders with ball-bearing motors. Slap this on there and make a quick table and a guy has a 12" sander all of a sudden. Option #2: "Calibration" Disc and a Table Saw CMT 299.112.00 10" Table Saw Balance Blade & Sanding Disc Set 5/8" Bore - $27.73 A Harbor Freight table saw for $99 and one of these discs. You're in about $128 but you have a pretty good table for a disc sander, a miter gauge, etc.. It's a 10" vs a 12" and you can't lift the blade up so the center is at table level, but it's a fairly sturdy setup. What do you guys think? 1 Quote
Immortan D Posted December 28, 2015 Report Posted December 28, 2015 I made my own 7" or so. Made all the parts. Powered by a drill. There's a thread about it but I don't think it applies to a 12"sander. Quote
treeslayer Posted December 29, 2015 Report Posted December 29, 2015 the grinder may be a viable option lee, if its variable speed, i would stay away from the ts idea, i think it would run too fast, i know from experience as i bought a disc for just that purpose on my ts many years ago, way too fast Quote
Gixxerjoe04 Posted December 29, 2015 Report Posted December 29, 2015 I kinda made one on my lathe, would need to build a base for it to do more with it, but wouldn't be too hard from scraps. Quote
Brendon_t Posted December 29, 2015 Report Posted December 29, 2015 I think the table saw option is pretty far reaching. You would only be able to access at max 3" of the disk. Quote
Tpt life Posted December 29, 2015 Report Posted December 29, 2015 This has come up a time or two. The key ingredient seems to be finding a device with bearings designed for side loading. This tends to be what gets table saw's poo-pooed. Quote
wtnhighlander Posted December 29, 2015 Report Posted December 29, 2015 +1 on the TS spinning to fast. This is especially true of benchtop, direct-drive saws, some of which exceed 5000 rpm. For wood, that speed is just going to scorch. Shaffer has a point about the bearings, but at a typical hobbyist frequency if use, you will probably be dead long before the 'incorect' bearings were. If you are considering a DIY job, I'd say just take a chance on the Harbor Freight units. If you get a good one, it will likely be good for a long time. If its crap when you get home, they have a pretty good exchange / refund policy. 1 Quote
treeslayer Posted December 29, 2015 Report Posted December 29, 2015 agree with highlander, i went with the harbor freight unit, its been running good for 3 years in my shop, not the best out there but it gets the job done Quote
Lee Bussy Posted December 29, 2015 Author Report Posted December 29, 2015 11 hours ago, Daniel. said: I made my own 7" or so. Made all the parts. Powered by a drill. There's a thread about it but I don't think it applies to a 12"sander. I purchased Izzy's plans just to see how he did it and to support his work. I figure I can pay once in a while if the content is interesting. Still, making that disk seems to be the long pole in the tent. 11 hours ago, treeslayer said: the grinder may be a viable option lee, if its variable speed, i would stay away from the ts idea, i think it would run too fast, i know from experience as i bought a disc for just that purpose on my ts many years ago, way too fast Why would I need/want variable speed? I've not seen any purpose-made disc sanders with that. 10 hours ago, Brendon_t said: I think the table saw option is pretty far reaching. You would only be able to access at max 3" of the disk. I figured it would be less, but I guess I didn't realize it would be that much less (although I could have gone out to the garage to measure. Okay we can scratch that one off the list. 10 hours ago, C Shaffer said: This has come up a time or two. The key ingredient seems to be finding a device with bearings designed for side loading. This tends to be what gets table saw's poo-pooed. Pretty sure a table saw is side loaded isn't it? I mean you are pushing the stock in. Since the TSC is off the table if you will excuse the pun, the grinder is definitely capable of side loading. That's how it works. 8 hours ago, treeslayer said: agree with highlander, i went with the harbor freight unit, its been running good for 3 years in my shop, not the best out there but it gets the job done Well here's why I brought it up. The TS was just an idea I had in my head after seeing those discs advertised for sanding. The grinder however ... I was driving home and there's a guy around the corner performing the pagan ritual known as "clean the garage." Apparently this particular ritual was mandated by the Priestess "SWMBO" because there was a LOT of stuff on the curb. I saw a grinder and stopped. He said "take it!" so I did. Next, I sold a phone on eBay and they had this deal where if it didn't sell for $X they would make up the difference in an eBay credit. I could not figure out what to buy so I bought this Shopsmith attachment for $6 out of pocket. I will have all the parts here, I was looking/asking to see if there was any huge safety caveat I'd not considered. You know, BEFORE I spun it up. The speed on a grinder motor is the same as the sanders I have seen so at least that part is the same. Now if I had to buy one of those Shopsmith things new AND I had to go buy a grinder, well, I'd be close to that price anyway. Since I'm going to be out $6 it seems an economical thing to try so long as it's safe (or no more dangerous than a Harbor Freight one.) Quote
Tpt life Posted December 29, 2015 Report Posted December 29, 2015 >Pretty sure a table saw is side loaded isn't it? I mean you are pushing the stock in. Since the TSC is off the table if you will excuse the pun, the grinder is definitely capable of side loading. That's how it works. TS forces are planned to be in plane with the bearing. If you get out to the edge of a disc with unbalanced force, you are putting asymmetric force on the bearing races. Some TS may fare well. Some may not. Availability of replacement arbor bearings may be a thought you want to encounter in the process. That is all. 1 Quote
Lee Bussy Posted December 29, 2015 Author Report Posted December 29, 2015 44 minutes ago, C Shaffer said: TS forces are planned to be in plane with the bearing. If you get out to the edge of a disc with unbalanced force, you are putting asymmetric force on the bearing races. Some TS may fare well. Some may not. Availability of replacement arbor bearings may be a thought you want to encounter in the process. That is all. Gotcha, thanks for explaining. Quote
Andy Wright Posted December 29, 2015 Report Posted December 29, 2015 I had one of these from Sears years ago, and used it on a Craftsman table saw. It worked OK, but was too fast to do detail work, and you only got the top of the disk exposed http://www.amazon.com/WoodRiver-Sanding-Disc-10/dp/B003F0E3B4 I later mounted the same 10" sanding plate to my Jet lathe and built a box out of plywood to act as the work table. That setup worked really well, and the vs lathe let me get the right rpms. Now I have a dedicated 12" floor model disk sander, so I no longer use the lathe setup Quote
Lee Bussy Posted December 29, 2015 Author Report Posted December 29, 2015 31 minutes ago, Andy Wright said: I had one of these from Sears years ago, and used it on a Craftsman table saw. It worked OK, but was too fast to do detail work, and you only got the top of the disk exposed I thought I read somewhere it could be leveraged as a pseudo-jointer? run it like a long rip against the "blade?" 31 minutes ago, Andy Wright said: Now I have a dedicated 12" floor model disk sander, so I no longer use the lathe setup I'll need to be careful with floor space here as I'm in the garage. I've been looking at those setups where people use like a sliding dovetail plate to hold each tool in the same bench space, sliding one out and the other in as needed. I think that may work for me if I can find a good place to store the ones not in use. Quote
Immortan D Posted December 29, 2015 Report Posted December 29, 2015 9 hours ago, Lee Bussy said: I purchased Izzy's plans just to see how he did it and to support his work. I figure I can pay once in a while if the content is interesting. Still, making that disk seems to be the long pole in the tent. I designed mine myself, here's the thread: http://www.woodtalkonline.com/topic/17820-drill-powered-disk-sander-jig/ Making the disk wasn't a problem. I used MDF and a router jig to cut the circle. Then threaded the center hole, inserted a 3/8" bolt with epoxy and laminated the exterior with melamine. 1 Quote
Lee Bussy Posted December 29, 2015 Author Report Posted December 29, 2015 4 minutes ago, Immortan D said: I designed mine myself, here's the thread: http://www.woodtalkonline.com/topic/17820-drill-powered-disk-sander-jig/ Making the disk wasn't a problem. I used MDF and a router jig to cut the circle. Then threaded the center hole, inserted a 3/8" bolt with epoxy and laminated the exterior with melamine. Nifty. That's not unlike Izzy's ... here's the video: Quote
Robby W Posted December 30, 2015 Report Posted December 30, 2015 I built a 12" disk sander years ago and it has been one of the most used tools in my shop. Back then, a disk sander was close to a grand in today's money, so building it was the only way I could afford one. It was a simple project and I had the welding skills and equipment needed to pull it off. I started with a good 1750 RPM 1/2 HP TEFC motor from Grainger. I took a 1" thick disk of aluminum about 3" in diameter and drilled a 5/8" hole in the center on a lathe. You can use a woodworking lathe for this if it has a 4 jaw chuck. Then I took the disk to a machine shop and had a keyway broached in it. I drilled and tapped three 1/4-28 holes to hold the disk. Next, I cut a disk of 7075 T 6 aluminum just over 12" in diameter, centered the hub on it and used transfer punches to copy the locations of the mounting bolts. After drilling the holes, I countersank them for Allen flathead screws and fastened the disk to the hub. I used steel from the local scrapyard to fabricate a stand and platen. After mounting the motor and disk, I turned it on and used the end of a file like a scraper to true the disk. Aluminum is easy to work. Just be careful. Add an 80 grit disk and you are off to the races. The one change I would make is to incorporate better dust collection. Quote
Lee Bussy Posted December 30, 2015 Author Report Posted December 30, 2015 4 hours ago, Robby W said: I built a 12" disk sander years ago and it has been one of the most used tools in my shop. Back then, a disk sander was close to a grand in today's money, so building it was the only way I could afford one. It was a simple project and I had the welding skills and equipment needed to pull it off. It's simple if you have the ability to do those things. I don't work metal nor even have a lathe. By the time you get to paying for "just a couple things" you are up to the price of a disk sander these days. I have a friend that does some metal working, I'll ask him to think about a price to do what you listed there just for informational purposes. I didn't think about the keyway - I'll have to see if there is one on this plate when it arrives. It might depend upon a flat on the shaft. Quote
Robby W Posted December 30, 2015 Report Posted December 30, 2015 3 hours ago, Lee Bussy said: I didn't think about the keyway - I'll have to see if there is one on this plate when it arrives. It might depend upon a flat on the shaft. Hi, Lee - If it does depend on a flat, you might want to pin it instead. It will hold better over time. Just put the disk on the motor shaft and drill a hole through the disk hub and the motor shaft, then press or drive a roll pin through the hole. Quote
Lee Bussy Posted January 1, 2016 Author Report Posted January 1, 2016 On 12/30/2015 at 9:15 AM, Robby W said: Hi, Lee - If it does depend on a flat, you might want to pin it instead. It will hold better over time. Just put the disk on the motor shaft and drill a hole through the disk hub and the motor shaft, then press or drive a roll pin through the hole. I'll see what I get. The plate was shipped so a few more days will tell. I need to finish prepping the table so I should not be getting side-tracked so much. Quote
Phil B Posted January 1, 2016 Report Posted January 1, 2016 I've had several disc sanders and basically hated them all. Spins too fast - too aggressive wood removal, too small contact area and it's easy to burn your wood. About 6 months ago I got the ridgid oscillating belt sander for about $200 and it works wonders. Much more gentle removal and no burning of the wood. I can't say the sander is a super high quality product but it's good enough. Lots of little issues and I had to make my own dust extraction set up. I expect it will last a couple of years and then I'll just buy a new one. Yeah, ridgid has a "life time guarantee" but you really have to jump through hoops so I discount it in my mind to 0. Quote
wtnhighlander Posted January 1, 2016 Report Posted January 1, 2016 I have the Rigid sander, but sometimes a disk is just the ticket, for exactly the same reasons Phil mentioned. It removes wood FAST. Quote
Lee Bussy Posted January 2, 2016 Author Report Posted January 2, 2016 I figure a guy needs a belt and a spindle ... the disk is gravy. I reserve the right to be wrong. Quote
socoj2 Posted January 4, 2016 Report Posted January 4, 2016 a harbor freight 12" disc sander is $128 why not just buy that? Quote
Lee Bussy Posted January 4, 2016 Author Report Posted January 4, 2016 16 minutes ago, socoj2 said: a harbor freight 12" disc sander is $128 why not just buy that? My motor was free and the arbor and plate were $6. Why spend more? (Not put it together yet, will report back.) Quote
socoj2 Posted January 4, 2016 Report Posted January 4, 2016 58 minutes ago, Lee Bussy said: My motor was free and the arbor and plate were $6. Why spend more? (Not put it together yet, will report back.) was comparing it to the options above. such as a table saw and Disc etc for $128. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.