Recommended Posts

Posted

One of the cabinet shops in the area bought about 1,500 lbs of "reject" deck screws and they are selling them in 23 lb boxes. The pic shows a 5 lb box I paid $30 for a year ago beside a box with 24.5 lbs in it I paid $40 for. He didn't have any 4" screws boxed up, so he grabbed an odd box beside him and when he slightly over filled it, he said "close enough".

Altogether I've bought 5 boxes of 4 different sizes. 2" - $30, 2.5" - $35, 3" & 4" - $40 I got 2 boxes of 3" since I use more of them.

101.jpg

  • Like 1
Posted

I'm with the OP - screws over nails, exery time. Especially doing 'lone wolf' framing, it is a lot easier to hold a rafter / joist in place and drive a screw, than to swing a hammer. And no, Shane, I don't own a framing nailer.

Posted

Just beware... screws are often not in the code because of the tendency to snap under shear load and shifting. This does not mean snapping is going to happen, only that it is more likely. 99% of the time (made up stat based on limited experience) using screws just takes more time. That little bit that is left is inappropriate usage. I am not saying don't do it, just beware of the downside. 

Posted

Just beware... screws are often not in the code because of the tendency to snap under shear load and shifting. This does not mean snapping is going to happen, only that it is more likely. 99% of the time (made up stat based on limited experience) using screws just takes more time. That little bit that is left is inappropriate usage. I am not saying don't do it, just beware of the downside. 

Exactly. Screws are not for framing. The only advantage of screws over nails for framing is pulling two pieces together but that's what ardox nails are for.

I'd be surprised if code allowed screws for framing in tornado and earthquake areas.

Sent from my SGH-I337M using Tapatalk

Posted

I didn't think that outhouses would be allowed in CA? Doesn't all solid waste have to be recycled and all liquid waste gets processed and pumped back into the drinking water system both getting fed right back to you?

Posted
40 minutes ago, Chestnut said:

I didn't think that outhouses would be allowed in CA? Doesn't all solid waste have to be recycled and all liquid waste gets processed and pumped back into the drinking water system both getting fed right back to you?

As opposed to what? Pooping in the woods, fertilizing a blackberry bush, and then eating those blackberries? Everything gets recycled/processed and re-consumed, just a matter of where and how quickly.

Posted
7 minutes ago, BonPacific said:

As opposed to what? Pooping in the woods, fertilizing a blackberry bush, and then eating those blackberries? Everything gets recycled/processed and re-consumed, just a matter of where and how quickly.

I was making a joke because what i said is what happens everywhere. Wastewater treatment plants separate out their bio solids and sell it to local farmers that use it as fertilizer. They then dump the treated water in a stream to the next city to be picked up by water treatment, treated and piped to your house.

The joke is that they need as much recycled water as possible because of the massive drought.

Posted
42 minutes ago, Chestnut said:

I was making a joke because what i said is what happens everywhere. Wastewater treatment plants separate out their bio solids and sell it to local farmers that use it as fertilizer. They then dump the treated water in a stream to the next city to be picked up by water treatment, treated and piped to your house.

The joke is that they need as much recycled water as possible because of the massive drought.

Miss-read your joke, overreacted a little, must be spending too much time hearing about the election.

  • Like 1
Posted

In other news, next years version of the building code (yeah its bigger and worse than last cycle) will allow the use of grey water for irrigation.  It was only allowed on a case by case basis as approved by the local building officials before. 

We're supposed to be net zero energy usage for residences by 2020.  What is this affordable housing I so often hear of?  We've also reduced the flow amount of faucets so much that they are starting to have problems with things like toothpaste building up in the "P" traps.  Then there is the exhaust fan that has to run all the time to keep the indoor air quality up because we have sealed the houses up so tight they don't breath and create unhealthy interior environments.  I hate this state for so many reasons, but it is so hard to leave.

 

I'm also curious as to what makes them rejects?  Left hand threads?  LOL  that would screw the new guy up. 

Posted

I don't have much use for codes. They are usually ridiculous rules that defy common sense. There are dozens of carpenter crews in this area. They have to follow the codes in whatever area they're building in, but I've heard for years screws hold better than nails.

Until a couple years ago, in this county, you didn't need a permit to build anything. Now, they want you to get one if you're putting up a big building.

  • Like 2
Posted

I'm in your state. I have yet to see a code that defies common sense. I also was careful as the nail vs screw can be a bit of a hot boast fest. Just know the limitations of the product. I have been out to fix decks with snapped screws. 

Posted
13 minutes ago, C Shaffer said:

I'm in your state. I have yet to see a code that defies common sense. I also was careful as the nail vs screw can be a bit of a hot boast fest. Just know the limitations of the product. I have been out to fix decks with snapped screws. 

I think some of the issue stems from the forming methods of both. Cheap screws are cast, but even cheap nails are still formed from extruded metal. Stupid people will try and frame their house with drywall screws because they're cheaper. The Code is there to reduce the chance of either idiots or con-men building your house. It's not perfect, but it helps.

Posted

I have had screws snap just trying to drive them in, so I know they are more brittle than nails. I switched from nails to screws several years ago because nails eventually loosen. I replaced a 16x32 deck with nail heads sticking out everywhere 2 years ago. Nothing coming apart yet.

As far as the reject description of the screws I bought, I haven't found anything wrong yet. Maybe the corrosion resistant coating wasn't right.

 

Posted
I have had screws snap just trying to drive them in, so I know they are more brittle than nails. I switched from nails to screws several years ago because nails eventually loosen. I replaced a 16x32 deck with nail heads sticking out everywhere 2 years ago. Nothing coming apart yet.

As far as the reject description of the screws I bought, I haven't found anything wrong yet. Maybe the corrosion resistant coating wasn't right.

 

Next framing project you have try a framing gun with nails with some hot dipped or brite coating on them. Never in a million years will those things loosen. The heads bend before the nail pulls out.

9601baf5e0d46f4eed3459f5895f2e21.jpg

Sent from my SM-N910W8 using Tapatalk

Posted

Local building codes in my area banned the use of nail guns for many operations (mostly roofing) because the single insertion impact apparently splits the wood fibers, rather than breaking through them, resulting in a weaker hold.

This ban happened after the first tornado to hit the area in several decades left a 15-mile swath of destruction.

I don't know if coated nails were common at the time.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   2 Members, 0 Anonymous, 44 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32k
    Total Topics
    437.5k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,009
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Bob44
    Newest Member
    Bob44
    Joined