SawDustB Posted March 17, 2017 Report Posted March 17, 2017 I currently don't have a dust collector at all, and with building the Roubo I'm starting to hit my limit for having dust all over the garage. I originally wasn't sure I'd have room for a dust collector, but after looking at a few in person I'm realizing that they're smaller than I thought. I looked at some of the very basic options, but I'm pretty convinced that I want a two stage collector of some kind, and I want something with half decent filtration. I've been looking at the small cyclones at a local woodworking store (busy bee tools) and was wondering what opinions you guys would have, or if anyone has something similar. There seems to be the same collector from King, and almost the same from Grizzly. Would this work for a setup where I just take a hose from machine to machine? I only really see using it for the table saw and planer at this point, and I'm working in a 12x12 space for the most part anyway. I know the other option is to get a more basic collector and put a super dust deputy on it or something, although I'm less convinced that it's going to be as effective as a system designed with a cyclone. At the other end I could look at an Oneida mini dust gorilla or something. Space is at a premium for me, so I don't want to go all that big. Here are the specs: http://www.busybeetools.com/products/1-5-hp-cyclone-dust-collector-with-hepa.html Ultra high efficiency separation 1 micron canister with manual hand crank for cleaning 18 gallon steel drum with quick release levers and castor wheels for easy disposal 4 Wheel castors for portability Remote control for easy operation Motor: 1.5HP, 110V, Single Phase, 60Hz Amps: 14 Amps Motor Speed: 3450 RPM Collection Drum Size: 18 Gallon Suction Capacity: 1050 CFM Static Pressure: 7" H2O Noise Level at 36": 75 Db Impeller Size: 13" Switch: ON/OFF with Removable Key Inlet Size: 6" (with 4" Y Inlet) Assembled Dimensions: 45.5" x 20.5" x 64" Quote
collinb Posted March 17, 2017 Report Posted March 17, 2017 Quite similar for a chunk less: https://bislagunatools.com/mcyc1-5mobmc-110v-0145-laguna-tools-mobile-cyclone-1-5hp-manual-cleaner.html And the Grizzly for even less http://www.grizzly.com/products/1-1-2-HP-2-Stage-Cyclone-Dust-Collector/G0703?utm_campaign=zPage&utm_source=grizzly.com They all look good to me. Quote
rodger. Posted March 17, 2017 Report Posted March 17, 2017 I have been contemplating the Oneida mini gorilla for a while, but in Canada, it's hard to find for a decent price. I have a single stage delta (1.5 HP) and it does everything I ask if it. My only issue is that it only filters to 1.0 microns, and I would like HEPA. Be careful with discount brands like king - a lot of their stuff is pretty low end, and the price reflects that. Craftex is also not known for quality build, but I am sure they must have some gems in their collection. Do lots of research on your particular machine before dumping a lot of money on it. 1 Quote
SawDustB Posted March 17, 2017 Author Report Posted March 17, 2017 Quite similar for a chunk less: https://bislagunatools.com/mcyc1-5mobmc-110v-0145-laguna-tools-mobile-cyclone-1-5hp-manual-cleaner.html And the Grizzly for even less http://www.grizzly.com/products/1-1-2-HP-2-Stage-Cyclone-Dust-Collector/G0703?utm_campaign=zPage&utm_source=grizzly.com They all look good to me. Thanks Collin, but I'm in Canada, so they're actually more expensive. They can also be a big pain to get here, whereas the one I linked had a dealer 10 minutes from me. I suspect they're essentially the same unit. I have been contemplating the Oneida mini gorilla for a while, but in Canada, it's hard to find for a decent price. I have a single stage delta (1.5 HP) and it does everything I ask if it. My only issue is that it only filters to 1.0 microns, and I would like HEPA. Be careful with discount brands like king - a lot of their stuff is pretty low end, and the price reflects that. Craftex is also not known for quality build, but I am sure they must have some gems in their collection. Do lots of research on your particular machine before dumping a lot of money on it. I'm having the same dilemma. I think it was Elite tools that claimed they had the mini gorilla for $1500 or so, but it's never in stock. I can't find an Oneida dealer I can actually buy it from. The Craftex one is probably from the same factory as the King, and they're around the same price. The reviews suggest that they work reasonably well, although the separation isn't as good as clear vue or Oneida. I do like the idea of being able to actually buy it locally from a store. I think the risk is lower on something like a dust collector, since there isn't too much to go wrong. Sent from my SM-G930W8 using Tapatalk Quote
HuxleyWood Posted March 17, 2017 Report Posted March 17, 2017 I can't speak to the quality of the particular machine be aware it has a 1.0 micron filter. You might want to do some research about the value of (closer to) HEPA filtration levels. I do understand the idea of a budget but I would only buy a cyclone with HEPA level filtration if it all possible. Quote
wdwerker Posted March 17, 2017 Report Posted March 17, 2017 I had a 1 1/2hp dust collector and the motor died. I replaced it with a 2 hp machine and the difference was impressive. Collection at my drum sander and edge sander improved greatly. Router table went to around 95% or better. A big filter is coming soon. Quote
Derek_PNW Posted March 18, 2017 Report Posted March 18, 2017 Here is my 1HP Grizzly dust collector with a Super Dust Deputy. I have started to think about upgrading to a 2HP, however that would require 220V and I do not know if I should invest in the cost while I am renting. I believe All said and done this cost me about $600-700. So honestly not much less than a pre-built cyclone. But I guess it is an option. Quote
Ronn W Posted March 18, 2017 Report Posted March 18, 2017 That unit looks exactly like my Laguna with a different name on it. Quote
SawDustB Posted March 18, 2017 Author Report Posted March 18, 2017 That unit looks exactly like my Laguna with a different name on it. I'm pretty sure they're all the same except for the paint and labels. Most of the Craftex machines from busy bee look the same as the grizzly equivalent. How do you like it? Quote
Mark J Posted March 18, 2017 Report Posted March 18, 2017 Is 240 V an option for you? There are a lot of threads on dust collection here and I have only read some of them. But I've gotten the impression that 3 HP is a better target. If you like the Oneida offerings it might be reasonable to contact them and ask where to go to get their stuff, then pick their brains on what to get in their line. Quote
SawDustB Posted March 18, 2017 Author Report Posted March 18, 2017 Is 240 V an option for you? There are a lot of threads on dust collection here and I have only read some of them. But I've gotten the impression that 3 HP is a better target. If you like the Oneida offerings it might be reasonable to contact them and ask where to go to get their stuff, then pick their brains on what to get in their line. I'd have to run a new circuit, but I could go 240V if necessary (making the 2+ HP machines available). I have a 20A 120V circuit there now I can dedicate to it. The bigger issue is that all the 3 HP cyclones are just too big for my space. I'm just thinking one machine at a time, not a plumbed in system. I may still try to see where I could get the small Oneida, since that's realistic for my use. I really can't see going much bigger unless I move at some point down the road. Quote
rodger. Posted March 18, 2017 Report Posted March 18, 2017 2 hours ago, SawDustB said: I'd have to run a new circuit, but I could go 240V if necessary (making the 2+ HP machines available). I have a 20A 120V circuit there now I can dedicate to it. The bigger issue is that all the 3 HP cyclones are just too big for my space. I'm just thinking one machine at a time, not a plumbed in system. I may still try to see where I could get the small Oneida, since that's realistic for my use. I really can't see going much bigger unless I move at some point down the road. If you are in Ontario, Welbeck sawmill sells Oneida. Quote
SawDustB Posted March 18, 2017 Author Report Posted March 18, 2017 If you are in Ontario, Welbeck sawmill sells Oneida. Wish I was, I'd have more options. I'm just outside Halifax, so I've already found all the local options. I can get King, Craftex, or Laguna. Quote
Guest Randy Posted March 18, 2017 Report Posted March 18, 2017 My recommendation is to find a collector with a HEPA filter. I haven't looked through the entire post and responses, but some appeared not to be HEPA. The cost will be higher, in general, for comparable cyclone collectors, but I feel the results are worth it; keeping the smallest particles possible out of the air. Oneida has a variety of smaller cyclones, but they are expensive. In my experience, their efficiency and results are superior. Laguna also came out recently with several HEPA mobile collectors, which appear also to be good based on reviews I've seen on other sites. So, whatever you decide on, I would recommend HEPA filtering. Quote
Ronn W Posted March 19, 2017 Report Posted March 19, 2017 15 hours ago, SawDustB said: I'm pretty sure they're all the same except for the paint and labels. Most of the Craftex machines from busy bee look the same as the grizzly equivalent. How do you like it? I like it. My longest run is about 16" plus a couple feet of flex. I have it hooked up to six machines but only use one at a time. Quote
Tom King Posted March 19, 2017 Report Posted March 19, 2017 I have a simple,general rule for dust collectors. I like for the motor in the DC system to be the largest motor in the setup running. I have a 2 hp dedicated to a 24 " re saw bandsaw, and it's not close to being enough to make me happy. That saw is in a different building than my other tools Quote
mat60 Posted March 19, 2017 Report Posted March 19, 2017 By the time people do all the mods to a dust collectors are they saving any money over getting a better unit to begin with. 1 Quote
SawDustB Posted March 19, 2017 Author Report Posted March 19, 2017 By the time people do all the mods to a dust collectors are they saving any money over getting a better unit to begin with. Well, that's kind of why I was asking about it to begin with. I'd like to just get what's going to work, not buy something and then want to upgrade it. At the same time, I can buy a little cheap dust collector for $200 that would be far superior to not having one at all, which is my current situation. This one struck me as being a reasonable compromise. I'm not about to go and spend $2-3k or more right now, which is where it seems very easy to end up in a discussion about dust collection. Anything more than a 2 HP just isn't going to fit, either. 1 Quote
wdwerker Posted March 19, 2017 Report Posted March 19, 2017 If you have a price limit and the cost of a 240v circuit eats into that then get the best 120v rig you can afford. Be forewarned it will need to be the only thing running on that circuit . And a 15 amp circuit won't cut it either . 1 Quote
SawDustB Posted March 19, 2017 Author Report Posted March 19, 2017 If you have a price limit and the cost of a 240v circuit eats into that then get the best 120v rig you can afford. Be forewarned it will need to be the only thing running on that circuit . And a 15 amp circuit won't cut it either . The 240V circuit would really only set me back the $100 or so for the breaker and wire I'd need. I'd do the wiring myself, and the panel is in my garage with the tools. The 120V is tempting because I already have 2 20A circuits dedicated for my tools, so the DC could easily have one to itself. Quote
Pondhockey Posted March 20, 2017 Report Posted March 20, 2017 9 hours ago, wdwerker said: If you have a price limit and the cost of a 240v circuit eats into that then get the best 120v rig you can afford. Be forewarned it will need to be the only thing running on that circuit . And a 15 amp circuit won't cut it either . Cosign this. After preparing for a 2 or 3 hp DC by installing it's own 240V circuit, I wound up with a 1.5 hp Laguna with 120V power supply. The circuit I use is 20A and I can't run anything else on the same circuit. Quote
wdwerker Posted March 20, 2017 Report Posted March 20, 2017 The 50 year old building I moved into had several 20 amp circuits , one kept blowing just from the start surge on my 1 1/2 hp edge sander. I checked the wires were the right size and ended up replacing a worn old breaker. I just hope the 1 3/4 hp Supermax doesn't blow the breaker. Quote
jplemons Posted March 20, 2017 Report Posted March 20, 2017 I just bought the 1.5 Pflux from Laguna. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.