Tom King Posted December 30, 2018 Author Report Posted December 30, 2018 I like radiant floor heating, but it will be too slow for this. I don't want to have to plan a day ahead of when I use it. Quote
Brendon_t Posted December 30, 2018 Report Posted December 30, 2018 12 hours ago, K Cooper said: @Brendon_t?l if that’s the fellow you’re referring to? Heck, that boy buys and sells stock for a living! He has a driver take his Range Rover to the shop for an oil change ! Present!. @Tom King Yes ASE certified Tech, Yes FiNRA registered Financial Advisor . How can I help? 1 Quote
Tom King Posted December 30, 2018 Author Report Posted December 30, 2018 After walking around in different rooms, and where I've been working in that building, I've decided on a measurement. If I build it 21' wide on the outside, with a 6" wall, it will leave me about 20-1/2 feet wide on the inside. This will be a luxurious amount of space, compared to what I've made out with for so long. It will allow the rafters to be made from one board, including the overhang as well. I'll put flat metal up for the ceiling, lay the insulation in from the top, then cover it. That way, I won't have to do overhead insulation work. I can buy rolls of coated metal, just like they form the roofing panels out of, from the manufacturer I buy roofing metal directly from. I'll have to invent a system to get it up there easily, and pulled tight. Once that metal is up, the rest will go really quickly. I already have plenty of scaffolding to scaffold up the whole job. Electrical can go in conduit on the inside later. I'll be renting a mini-excavator for another job, sometime soon, so I'll go ahead, and dig the footings while I have the machine. I'll build the long wall, and put the roof up this Spring, and park the big tractor under it for a while. For an agricultural building, I won't even need a building permit, so it will be for parking that tractor under until I decide to do the rest of it, hopefully soon after, and then get a permit for the modification. Quote
Tom King Posted December 30, 2018 Author Report Posted December 30, 2018 Brendon, I was thinking you were a mechanic, and was asking about space for doing mechanic work. I had thought you were a BMW mechanic from a conversation a couple of years back. Any specifics that are favorable, or unfavorable for a lift? I'll be going with a 10k 2 post. Quote
Brendon_t Posted December 30, 2018 Report Posted December 30, 2018 2 minutes ago, Tom King said: Brendon, I was thinking you were a mechanic, and was asking about space for doing mechanic work. I had thought you were a BMW mechanic from a conversation a couple of years back. Any specifics that are favorable, or unfavorable for a lift? I'll be going with a 10k 2 post. Yessir that's me. I'm super jealous that you've got a spot for a 2 post. I'll have a 2 post and a trench when I build mine eventually. I was reading above about 8' spread+ 2' isles on each side. Personally, I'd want more. Anything from rotating and moving tires around the car to my rolling cart that goes with me around the he l vehicle, i want to be able to move with me. Do machines have to line the walls on both sides of the lift? If I had 2' isle on one side where my boxes are, and a wider say 4' working side on the other, I'd be more happy. Quote
Tom King Posted December 30, 2018 Author Report Posted December 30, 2018 No 2' aisles. The minimum width we were talking about, to start with, would have allowed 3' walkways, but newest plan gives a little over 4'. No machines near where the lift posts will be. The machine tools, for the most part, will be at the other end of the 40' length. There are some smaller tools, like a nice little precision lathe, a surface grinder, and grinders on posts that can go along the walls into the mechanic area, that won't stand off the walls much. Big things, like the big lathe, and milling machine will be in the other end, well away from the lift. Quote
Brendon_t Posted December 30, 2018 Report Posted December 30, 2018 11 minutes ago, Tom King said: No 2' aisles. The minimum width we were talking about, to start with, would have allowed 3' walkways, but newest plan gives a little over 4'. No machines near where the lift posts will be. The machine tools, for the most part, will be at the other end of the 40' length. There are some smaller tools, like a nice little precision lathe, a surface grinder, and grinders on posts that can go along the walls into the mechanic area, that won't stand off the walls much. Big things, like the big lathe, and milling machine will be in the other end, well away from the lift. Sorry, Stoli Raspberry much be clouding my vision still. Sounds like a great set up that will be a joy to work in. As far as the HVAC goes, I live in a climate with one and a half seasons. I'm severely unqualified to comment : ) Quote
Tom King Posted December 30, 2018 Author Report Posted December 30, 2018 So no complaints with 20' wide work area? It seems like plenty to me. What should I look for in a lift? I see them pop up on CL fairly often for 1500, or less, whereas new goes from 1500 for a cheap one, to a good one for 2500, or installed for around 3,000. I don't have any problem with installing one, with various sized hammer drills, and a front end loader. I'm thinking about making the floor a little thicker than 6" where the lift mounts to the floor. Quote
Tom King Posted December 30, 2018 Author Report Posted December 30, 2018 Here are pictures of the ugly building. We didn't pay anything for it, on top of the land cost, so no complaints. It's been great to have, but well past needing a facelift anyway. Florence blew off that lower corner of tin. I need to replace the whole roof, and completely rebuild the front of the building anyway. Structurally, it's in great shape. Later, I'm also planning to build another shed roof off the back to park the big mower under (pictured). The outside is hardboard siding that if I don't cover with roofs on those sides, I'll have to replace it all like I will on the front anyway. I'm planning to change those huge hinged doors to sliding doors. This is on top of a hill, with lake surrounding in on three sides, so any breeze gets accelerated across the top of this hill, and it's too dangerous to open those doors when the wind is blowing. You can see the lake through the trees over that mower deck. That tractor is like the building. It's needs some cosmetic help too, but I don't want to bother until I have a roof to keep it under. The air conditioning quit working a couple of years ago, but no motivation to work on it when it's hot, or cold, so one of the many reasons to build the air conditioned shop. There is another tractor in the building that I've been needing to work on too. The list of mechanic work to do grows, while also does the paying work list, and that's not even taking into account the normal maintenance stuff. We've built our dream place, but it's like us, getting long in the tooth. I just want it to stop getting ahead of me. Quote
Chestnut Posted December 30, 2018 Report Posted December 30, 2018 Might want to look into needing reinforcement around where the lift sits. Not sure if it's necessary or not. Quote
Tom King Posted December 30, 2018 Author Report Posted December 30, 2018 They just bolt to the floor with long expansion bolts. That's what I was talking about making the concrete thicker there, so I could use even longer bolts, all with plenty of rebar in it too. Quote
Brendon_t Posted December 30, 2018 Report Posted December 30, 2018 Tom I think going thicker for the "pad" where they bolt is a great idea and wouldn't be hard to do. Personally I never liked the lifts that are connected in the center with the bump kill switch. You work on a lot of different stuff. May want the ability to lift high. My garage is 18'6 wide and before it was a shop, or laundry room, I worked on all the cars that I kept for years as maintenance as side money. With KRL boxes lining one wall, it was totally fine. Not sure about with 2 post legs though. Could you blue tape your thoughts into the floor and see how it feels? 1 Quote
Tom King Posted December 30, 2018 Author Report Posted December 30, 2018 I don't even have any measurements for the footprint of a lift. I know absolutely nothing about lifts, so what you said about the bump switch is not understood. I mean I know Absolutely nothing about them. Only that I want one. Your advice is greatly appreciated!! Quote
Brendon_t Posted December 30, 2018 Report Posted December 30, 2018 19 minutes ago, Tom King said: I don't even have any measurements for the footprint of a lift. I know absolutely nothing about lifts, so what you said about the bump switch is not understood. I mean I know Absolutely nothing about them. Only that I want one. Your advice is greatly appreciated!! Quick Google search of 2 post lift, images. You should see about half of them are simply two posts, not connected, the other half are connected at the top of the posts by a crossbar. That cross bar limits the height you can lift a vehicle to by having a kill switch on that bar that engages when it's touched. You're such a does everything, will find a way to do anything kind of guy, having that lift will very likely come in handy for a range of problems that haven't been identified yet. I wouldn't want the restriction. Quote
Tom King Posted December 30, 2018 Author Report Posted December 30, 2018 Great tip!!! Much appreciated! Crossbars, or any such things are off the list. edited to add: After looking at the pictures, I also don't want a bar across the floor. I may get the lift first, modify it, and run a conduit from one side to the other in the slab. I could go all the way up with the connectors, across the ceiling, and back down. It's rare that I don't modify anything I get. edited to add: These look like they take all that into consideration: https://mohawklifts.com/automotive-lifts/2-post-lifts/lmf-12-tp-16/ I'm liking this one a lot. I hate to go find a price though. https://mohawklifts.com/library/rough_specs/lmf-12-specs.pdf Specs call for minimum of 6-1/2" of 4,000 psi concrete, which is no problem, but would go up on thickness there. edited to add again: Found the list price: $12,547. That's probably out, but I'll have to think about it. edited again to add this one, which will more than meet my needs: https://mohawklifts.com/automotive-lifts/2-post-lifts/system1/ list for that one is $7,500, and it seems like those come up used more often. Quote
Woodenskye Posted December 30, 2018 Report Posted December 30, 2018 Tom, if you have 6" of concrete where the lift will meet the concrete, that should be more than enough. I would head over to garage journal forum and confirm or to get lift recommendations. Quote
Tom King Posted December 30, 2018 Author Report Posted December 30, 2018 Brendon, Mohawk has some cool toy accessories. Check this out: Quote
pkinneb Posted December 30, 2018 Report Posted December 30, 2018 14 hours ago, Pondhockey said: Not sure this would work for you; especially if you want fast changes in temp, but since you are building the slab you can also install coils in the slab for heating and cooling. You get a few efficiency gains since the heating and cooling are close to the bottom, where you and your work are (less so for the top of the 14 feet.) Couple this with ground source heating and the operating cost would be very low. Since you do so much of that kind of work yourself, you might make that pay off in a reasonable time frame. To complete the picture you could put solar panels on the roof to power the heat/cooling pumps ;-) But maybe shade trees would be better. I thought of doing that in my shop becuase we have it in our basement and attached garage but the problem for me was it takes to long to bring it up to temp. When I'm not in the shop I leave the temp at 50 then turn it up to about 65 when i'm working out there. With forced air I can bring it up to temp in just a few minutes much quicker than radiant heat in the house. The attached garage isn't an issue becuase it stays at 52 all winter. Quote
wtnhighlander Posted December 31, 2018 Report Posted December 31, 2018 Brendon, or others with lift experience: How do those things lock into position when elevated? Surely they don't rely on hydraulics to keep the user safe while under tge load??? Quote
Chestnut Posted December 31, 2018 Report Posted December 31, 2018 1 hour ago, wtnhighlander said: Brendon, or others with lift experience: How do those things lock into position when elevated? Surely they don't rely on hydraulics to keep the user safe while under tge load??? They have safty teeth that operate like a wratchet or toothed crank that allows the lift to go up but now down unless released. The 4 post lifts have a release by the controls and 2 posts have releases on each post that needs to be released. My expereience is limited so this is probably lift specific. Also standard operation was to raise the vehicle till they clanged and then lower it to rest on these instead of relying on the hydraulics. 2 Quote
Tpt life Posted December 31, 2018 Report Posted December 31, 2018 They have gravity locks usually that are hinged every six inches or so. A mag switch locks them in the up position for lowering the vehicle. Otherwise, as you pass each level they flop down and you lower the vehicle on to them once it is close to where you want it. You never leave the hydraulic loaded. 1 Quote
Tom King Posted December 31, 2018 Author Report Posted December 31, 2018 There is an automatic, mechanical lock every few inches. You have to release them to lower it. After seeing how the Mohawks are made, I don't think I would ever be comfortable standing under a vehicle on one of the Chinese lifts. Here's a video of the safety operating: 1 Quote
Brendon_t Posted December 31, 2018 Report Posted December 31, 2018 25 minutes ago, Chestnut said: They have safty teeth that operate like a wratchet or toothed crank that allows the lift to go up but now down unless released. The 4 post lifts have a release by the controls and 2 posts have releases on each post that needs to be released. My expereience is limited so this is probably lift specific. Also standard operation was to raise the vehicle till they clanged and then lower it to rest on these instead of relying on the hydraulics. Yeah, that. Quote
Pondhockey Posted December 31, 2018 Report Posted December 31, 2018 It's been fun to follow this thread, Tom. Sounds like your plan is coming together. I didn't mean to ignore you guys, I've been traveling for two weeks and had intermittent access to the site. I agree that radiant floor heating is slow; I keep my shop at 55F and warm it to 60 when I know in advance that I'll use it. 55 is actually a very comfortable working temp (at least for me.) Cooling is theoretical - it was offered to me, and condensation (in this area at least) was not a concern. In the SE I can imagine that condensation is always an issue, though I don't understand specifically (water on the floor?) Payback for heating coils in the floor is reasonably fast, especially if you do it yourself; for ground source heat pumps, not so much. In any case the response time is much slower than HVAC (but less air movement!) Insulation makes a lot of solutions work well. Quote
Tom King Posted January 1, 2019 Author Report Posted January 1, 2019 Looks like the heating system is decided on before anything else gets done. I was given a 3-1/2 ton heat pump today. All I have to do is go get it when the HVAC guy calls me. It's 8 years old, and working fine. I've sent that HVAC outfit a lot of work, and helped them move units with my loader. The buyer for the lake house is buying it for a rental, and is putting in new units to hopefully avoid getting repair calls when they have renters in the house. These houses rent for thousands of dollars a week. A heat pump wasn't my first choice, but for free, it'll work. 2 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.