Recommended Posts

Posted

We have a 24 x 40 wood framed building that was here when we bought the place 38 years ago.  It was thrown up as cheaply as possible, and the sheet hardboard siding needs to be replaced.  On one long side, years ago, I built a 24' wide shed roof to store hay under, but we have since stopped storing hay, and it's mostly boat, and tractor implement storage.  I don't have to worry about the siding under the shed roof.

The inside of the building is mostly full of stuff, but I have a spot cleared out enough to work on trucks, or tractors.  It's not insulated, and has a high roof. I think the walls are 14 feet tall.  The walls are lined with full shelves that more than half the stuff could be thrown away, but I don't want to bother.

I'm to the point that I want to get a lift.  The concrete floor in there is the best part of the building, but it's only 4" thick, so I'm thinking it's not thick enough to install a two post lift.

Another factor is that I was left a complete metalworking shop, and have nowhere to put the stuff.  It includes a milling machine, a couple of nice lathes, a surface grinder, etc., and so forth.

I'm thinking about putting another shed roof on the opposite side of the building.  It wouldn't be a shed, but enclosed with a 6" slab floor.   I can build it, and insulate it, quicker than I could clear out the original part to insulate that.   It would be the 40' length of the main building.  That would also eliminate the need to fix the siding on that side.  I'd just cover the rotten part at the bottom with the slab.

My plan is for one end to take the metalworking tools, and all my welding stuff, and the lift in the other end.

My question for you is how wide should I make it.  I know bigger is normally better, but for heat, and air, I don't want to pay to cool unused volume.   For a minimum, I'm thinking 18 feet wide.  That would put an 8' wide vehicle in the middle, and leave 3 feet of walking space between toolboxes, and benches along the walls.  20' might be better, but I can't figure out if it would be worth it.  24 is easily doable too, but a lot more volume to heat, and cool.

There is 100 yards of open space on that side of the building, so nothing to matter about space taken.

I would appreciate your opinion, and anyone else's too.

Posted

Before I moved here we lived close to town and didn't have much land.   I built a 24x24 two story garage. wood shop upstairs and worked on cars down.   It was insulated well and didn't take much to heat.  I really wouldn't want anything smaller and 28ft  deep would be better.

Posted

Actually, heating and cooling is the main concern.  I've gotten to the point that I don't want to work when it's really hot, or really cold outside.  On days that I'm fine working outside, we have plenty of paying work to do.  If I have woodwork to do, I have a place to do that, but more than half the time, the paying work I have is outside.  This building would be for the days that are too hot, or cold to do the stuff that I do for a living.

edited to clarify:  The nice days, we'll be making money.  That takes all the days that I can work in the building like it is now.  I could do it on weekends, but that's not what I want to be doing on weekends.  That leaves the days that are too cold, too wet, or too hot that are just passing by now.

It will be 40 feet long in one direction.  The question is about the width for mechanic work.

  • Like 2
Posted

18' minimum. 8' car + 2 x 3' isles on each side and 2 x 2' bench or machine on each side.

on the machine end.  3' machine, 3' isle , 6' - (2 machines back to back in the center), 3' isle , 3' machine = 18' 

  • Like 1
Posted

That's exactly what I was thinking, but it's always hard to figure big enough.

Also, how high ceiling for the lift?  I'm not sure if 12' would be quite high enough.   14' would be available easily, but that may be a bit too high.  I do want a beam with trolley, and chain hoist.

One tractor is 10 feet tall, but it's not ever going on the lift.

Posted

A StepVan is around 109" tall plus maybe 76" room to work under it is almost 15' 6" so 16' isn't unreasonable. But if it's truly a shed roof that might be a more expensive route to go. 

Posted

I prefer wider to deeper in garages. It can be nice to do an oil change next to a car on the hoist when the rain is heavy. If you go deep rather than wide, put the hoist deep enough to have twenty feet behind the hoisted vehicle. My two cents from different shops I’ve worked in. 

Posted

I don't have a step van any more.  My truck is 79" high.

The walls to the building are 14', but I can go up the main part's roof slope any amount for the "shed" roof.  It will be standing seam metal, so the slope doesn't have to be over 2 in 12, which is what I think I built the one on the other side.  What I call a shed roof is just a single slope.  I used 2x12x24's for the rafters on the other side shed, and then scabbed on 2x6''s for the overhang.

Posted
1 hour ago, Tom King said:

Actually, heating and cooling is the main concern.  I've gotten to the point that I don't want to work when it's really hot, or really cold outside.  On days that I'm fine working outside, we have plenty of paying work to do.  If I have woodwork to do, I have a place to do that, but more than half the time, the paying work I have is outside.  This building would be for the days that are too hot, or cold to do the stuff that I do for a living.

edited to clarify:  The nice days, we'll be making money.  That takes all the days that I can work in the building like it is now.  I could do it on weekends, but that's not what I want to be doing on weekends.  That leaves the days that are too cold, too wet, or too hot that are just passing by now.

It will be 40 feet long in one direction.  The question is about the width for mechanic work.

Please don't misunderstand, I'm not saying that heating/cooling isn't important.  I'm saying that it's more important to get the size and configuration that you ultimately want and then figure out your climate issues.

24 x 40 is a great size for working on vehicles and such!

  • Like 1
Posted
2 minutes ago, Tpt life said:

I prefer wider to deeper in garages. It can be nice to do an oil change next to a car on the hoist when the rain is heavy. If you go deep rather than wide, put the hoist deep enough to have twenty feet behind the hoisted vehicle. My two cents from different shops I’ve worked in. 

I'll only be working on one thing at the time.  Any oil change, other than a tractor, will be done on the lift.  If anything gets left in there, everything else can wait for it to come out.

  I only want to go the 40 feet long, and not half of that can be taken by the machine tools.

Posted
10 minutes ago, ..Kev said:

Please don't misunderstand, I'm not saying that heating/cooling isn't important.  I'm saying that it's more important to get the size and configuration that you ultimately want and then figure out your climate issues.

24 x 40 is a great size for working on vehicles and such!

Thanks.   24 feet is 20% more volume to heat than 20 feet.  24 would be nice, and really won't take any more time, to amount to anything, than building it 18 or 20.  Therein lies the dilemma. 

 Odd sizes don't bother me either with a concrete floor.  I can let the roof overhang be whatever.  The roofing metal can be ordered up to 40 feet long at any measurement. Siding will be board on board vertical White Oak, like all the other buildings here, so odd measurements don't matter, and not to worry about wasting part of a few pieces of plywood, or board parts as in building a house.

Posted

If heating and cooling costs  are the big concern,  I would have a heat loss calculation comparison done on the 2 possible.  40 by 18 is 720 ft2   with 116 feet of wall.  40  by 24 is 960 ft2 with 128 feet of wall.  Floor space has gone up by 33% and wall surface area 10%.  The extra square footage construction   and heating  cost may very cost effective.

Posted

Dmatt, Thanks a lot!  That's very useful. 

 It will neither be heated, nor cooled very often, but I will want to size any unit to bring it up, or down pretty quickly in extremes of conditions.   Back when I had a boat business, which this will be used for some fiberglass work too, I had a shop with an oversized system that could quickly cool it down to mid '60's, which is very useful for working with fiberglass resins, and then letting it go back up to 70's to cure.

Posted
28 minutes ago, wtnhighlander said:

Is there any reason you have to heat & cool the whole 40' length at the same time? I'd consider going 24' wide, and partition between the mechanic bay and the machine room, with seperate HVAC.

It will not ever be used enough to pay back the cost of installing two systems.  Also, it's not really long enough to be able to completely separate the machine tools, and a long vehicle.  The truck is close to 22 feet long. Some of the machines will have to be along the walls into the area used for mechanic work, and I have some long trailers that will be in there once in a while.

  • Like 1
Posted
43 minutes ago, Tom King said:

I made a big mistake then.  I was thinking he was the BMW mechanic.  Who is/was that?   I edited the topic heading.  Thanks,

Brendon was a BMW mechanic but now is a stock broker. 

Posted

I intend to insulate the hell out of it, except for the wall it shares with the original part.  There is so much stuff piled against that wall, inside the building, that I think it's probably insulated pretty good.  I can just use the siding on that wall for the inside finish wall on the new part for that 40 foot stretch.  It helps a lot to already have a wall to add on to.  It only took us two days to build the 24x40 foot shed roof on the other side.

I was also thinking that there is no reason for the whole ceiling to be high enough for max height needed over the lift.  I can put a big coffer in the ceiling where it's needed over the lift.

Insulation is really the main reason to build it.  It's just too much trouble to empty the main building enough to insulate that, or even to put a ceiling in it.  It has scissor trusses with just a tin roof on purlins, so no way any heat will stay in it right now.  I can run a 350,000 btu construction heater in there, and it only makes noise.

Posted

Not sure this would work for you; especially if you want fast changes in temp, but since you are building the slab you can also install coils in the slab for heating and cooling.  You get a few efficiency gains since the heating and cooling are close to the bottom, where you and your work are (less so for the top of the 14 feet.)  Couple this with ground source heating and the operating cost would be very low.  Since you do so much of that kind of work yourself, you might make that pay off in a reasonable time frame. To complete the picture you could put solar panels on the roof to power the heat/cooling pumps ;-)  But maybe shade trees would be better.

Posted

That all sounds good, but it's not going to be used enough to be worth any premium cost of a high efficiency system.  Most likely it will just be a gas pack, and maybe even a used one that has been replaced by a high efficiency unit somewhere.  It's on the North side of that building, and the only tree for over a hundred yards on that side is a Dogwood beside the building, that will have to come down. 

The HVAC will be left off unless the building is to be used.  Everything that's going in there has been living in unconditioned space for over 25 years, and is fine.  

Posted
8 hours ago, Pondhockey said:

install coils in the slab for heating and cooling.

I've seen radiant floor heating, but never cooling.  Is that a thing?  What happens with condensation?  

  • Like 1

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   2 Members, 0 Anonymous, 57 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,009
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Joseph b
    Newest Member
    Joseph b
    Joined