Recommended Posts

Posted

You're probably right, but wouldn't it be nice to use this as an opportunity to train up a whole generation of craftspeople?  I suspect there are many old buildings in France that could use some repair work, and this unfortunate incident could be the impetus to provide training.  It certainly looks like money won't be an issue.

  • Like 1
Posted

There is already a very active Guild there that keeps the old ways going.

http://www.historicalcarpentry.com/compagnonnage.html

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compagnons_du_Devoir

It just doesn't make a lot of sense to rebuild the roof structure out of wood, since it can't be seen at all.

If you needed an entry into a fire building contest, it would be hard to beat the design of the wooden spire.

Posted

I agree that it doesn't make "sense", but obviously it works structurally as it has for the last 700 years, and I believe there is something to be said for tradition.  That's not to say it shouldn't be upgraded with respect todays fire standards, but building a steel framework in that building just seems wrong.

Posted

I'm sure that debate will take a while.  None of the attic framing is ever seen unless someone goes up there.  This is close to what I do for a living, but it's rare that we work on any building, and not have to make some structural improvement.  I would argue to eliminate fire danger to start with, and not just with suppression.

If the timber framing would ever be seen, even by a small fraction of the public, I would be in favor of reproducing it.  I am in absolute favor of keeping the visible part looking exactly like it did, down to hand tool marks on any stonework that needs to be replaced.    Any addition should only be done to the original design that they never got around to, or figured out how to do.

Yes, it lasted centuries, until it burned.  Much more could have been lost.  I don't see putting the structure at risk again would be worth it.   We'll see what they end up doing.

I have no part in the say-so for what gets done.  This is just my opinion.

 

  • Like 2
Posted

I heard somewhere that they don't have big enough trees in France anymore to make it all with wood. I imagine they'll have to use other materials for areas that won't be seen.

Posted

I found this interesting... the Library of Congress has a book and photographs from when the cathedral was renovated in 1860.   If you can read French, they have the whole book posted online as a PDF and has tons of detail on the work done.

https://blogs.loc.gov/loc/2019/04/notre-dame-in-the-19th-century/

I suspect the Church will look at it as what can they do to reconstruct that'll last another several hundred years.   I also think it might not look quite the same as it did.   They may take a modern interpretation of old styling, much like Viollet-le-Duc's work in 1860.

A working fire suppression system may be high on their priority list.   Apparently the alarms went off and were ignored for 30 minutes as they thought it was another false alarm.

 

  • Sad 1
Posted

Shannon's Lumber Industry Update episode #2 is all about the lumber used in Notre Dame. I haven't finished the episode but did hear they used something like 13,000 trees for the attic which was 50ish acres of land they cleared. All 300 year old French Oak.

Posted

I saw some pieces on the timber list were 24"x24"x30'.  I don't know how many of the 13,000 pieces were that size, but that many of those didn't come off of 56 acres of land. 

One trouble with using timber again is that some stand of primary forest will have to be fallen for it, and I don't think Spanky has that many Oaks in his mountains that are that big.

I'm saying not to cut some primary forest to build a roof that won't be seen, and might burn again in another 700 years, on a building built to last millennia otherwise. 

  • Like 1
Posted

The podcast talks about those issues.  Apparently, large French oaks don't really exist anymore so the debate about whether to use them or not is really academic.  His take on it was that they will likely use modern materials (like laminated beams).  After listening, I have to agree with him reasoning, although the romantic idea of rebuilding to the original is appealing, I can see it isn't practical or even feasible.

Posted

I've looked high and low for interior framing pictures of the spire. From what I've read the spire was only about 150 years old. If I remember right a previous spire was removed in the 1700's due to rot and wind damage. The one that burned was bigger and more elaborate than its predecessor. 

A metal framed roof with lead or maybe titanium covering could last for maybe a 1000 years if done right. But a lot of the problems have been due to a pathetic maintenance budget. Spend a few million a year to take care of what you've got or spend billions to repair /replace seems like an easy choice.

Posted

Seems like an easy choice, but one that rarely gets made.  I deal with this all the time.  It's much easier to come up with large sums of money when something is pressing, rather than a little all along to maintain what's there.  Usually, if it can be put off, or even a decision delayed until another day, that's what happens.

If you needed an entry into a fire building contest, it would be hard to improve on the design of that 19th Century spire.  I'm surprised a lightning strike hasn't taken it out before now.  The ceiling would probably be fine now, if not for that wooden spire being up there.

Posted

I think its funny how we 'muricans admire the 'ancient' 800 year-old construction. 

There used to be a newscaster here, who grew up in Sweden. Upon hearing remarks about 'old', historical buildings here in the States, she would casually mention that the 'new' church in her home town was constructed in 1089.

Posted

Sorry Ross, that’s kind of an obtuse statement. I don’t care to find the oldest building. Old is not what draws me. This is one of the better examples of avant- grade architecture of the time. It bears some gothic elements, but uses the flying buttress design happened upon in the so called Baroque Era to race toward a high stone arch roof...that had thin enough walls to let light in readily. St James in Rothenburg is beautiful. (I’ve been.) So are many castles and ruins around that area that are older structures. They are, however, a completely different style of build. I guess it just bothers me to boil things down that far as if it is just an “old” thing. If that were the case, I might never get past the pyramids. 

Posted

We have buildings and houses that are about 150 years old. I was associate pastor of a church in KY. Visited a family who visited our church which was about 8-10 years old. Their church in Germany was built in the 1600s.

As for the ND cathedral, it would be nice to rebuild with materials and techniques used at the time when the cathedral was built. I marvel at how things were done, using only hand tools and common sense.

Posted
6 hours ago, Tpt life said:

Sorry Ross, that’s kind of an obtuse statement. I don’t care to find the oldest building. Old is not what draws me. This is one of the better examples of avant- grade architecture of the time. It bears some gothic elements, but uses the flying buttress design happened upon in the so called Baroque Era to race toward a high stone arch roof...that had thin enough walls to let light in readily. St James in Rothenburg is beautiful. (I’ve been.) So are many castles and ruins around that area that are older structures. They are, however, a completely different style of build. I guess it just bothers me to boil things down that far as if it is just an “old” thing. If that were the case, I might never get past the pyramids. 

Your history is a little off.  The flying buttress evolved during the gothic period of building (typically about 12th to 14th centuries - what most of think of as medieval).  The Baroque period is generally acknowledged to be a later period.  You're correct in the reason for the flying buttresses, namely that they allowed high vertical walls with minimal structure, but they are certainly became widespread during the medieval period.

Posted
50 minutes ago, Art said:

Your history is a little off.  The flying buttress evolved during the gothic period of building (typically about 12th to 14th centuries - what most of think of as medieval).  The Baroque period is generally acknowledged to be a later period.  You're correct in the reason for the flying buttresses, namely that they allowed high vertical walls with minimal structure, but they are certainly became widespread during the medieval period.

Thank you, thank you, thank you. I greatly misspoke while editing on a phone. I had edited out another paragraph because I found myself chasing rabbits. That post came out all wrong. The fact is that St James is newer, but lacks some of the uplifting grace in my opinion. Again, thanks for catching that. 

Posted
7 hours ago, Tpt life said:

Thank you, thank you, thank you. I greatly misspoke while editing on a phone. I had edited out another paragraph because I found myself chasing rabbits. That post came out all wrong. The fact is that St James is newer, but lacks some of the uplifting grace in my opinion. Again, thanks for catching that. 

No problem :D.  I've always been very interested in European history, and in particular the art and architecture of that particular period, so this whole episode is very fascinating for me.

Posted
11 hours ago, Tom King said:

I have heard it said, more than a few times from Europeans, that Americans "don't know what old is".    I never bother to comment back.

I bet Europeans hear the same thing from folks around the Red Sea area.

 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 44 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
  • Forum Statistics

    32k
    Total Topics
    437.5k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,007
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    FurniCore
    Newest Member
    FurniCore
    Joined