Recommended Posts

Posted

Asked a while back about sanders, but I was curious about pneumatic. Right now I just need a decent sander. $60 or less, preferably. All our cheapo sanders have died. So anybody got a suggestion for a sander that will be usable for 4-6 months in a production shop? I know that investing is good, and plan to later, but now I just need to get by.

Posted

The Dewalt is certainly adequate.  Just open it up and take out the rubber gasket they put over the power switch that keeps you from being able to actually turn the darn thing on.  Maybe it was just my 50 degree in the winter shop that didn't get along with the rubber, but that thing didn't last a day before I had it off of there.  I like that they built a dust collection adapter right into the sander so you don't have to buy anything else and can easily switch back to the bag if you need to go somewhere without the vac.

Posted

==>will be usable for 4-6 months in a production shop?

==>$60 or less, preferably.

 

That's a tough combo... PSA/H&L? Who's pattern? Assume you don't want to inventory some new pattern abrasive...

 

For that $$, I'm thinking Mirka or Dynabrade pneumatic if you've got sufficient shop air.

 

The PC-low profile is about the lowest electric I could recommend, but it's about $86. For production use, you've got to avoid the real crap -- 8hrs a day with a low-end sander and you'll get tendinitis for sure... The PC-low profile really is about as low as I'd go...

Posted

We don't actually have air compression. Sorry, I was a bit vague. My previous post was just trying to get an idea of whether we wanted to pursue that. I am looking for an electric sander. Preferably quartersheet, unless someone knows of a good price on hook and loop paper. The trouble with the quartersheet sanders we've had (admittedly pretty cheap) is that they stop holding the paper after a month (or barely hold 150-220 right out of the box). Which makes them remarkably obnoxious to work with.

Thanks for the replies. I checked out the dewalt, and I'll check out the other suggestions later.

We had someone give is 2 new ryobis once. The one had a short in the cord right out of the box. The other developed a short, and the clips that held the sandpaper on broke. Pretty sad that the cheapest of the cheap sanders at Harbor Freight lasted considerably longer.

Posted

==>Preferably quartersheet,

So you want an orbital-action sander?

What's your application?

I don't know what an orbital action sander is. The only sanders I've really used have been quarter sheet random orbit sanders. I've used a couple disc sanders with sticky paper, and a "Mouse" detail sander, and a rectangular black and decker (which worked surprisingly well).

We us the sanders for furniture. Right now, table tops. So depending on what the deal is, we go as low as 60, but usually 80-100-150, and sometimes 220, depending.

Our shop is a non-profit, and has been doing mostly custom word-of-mouth orders, but now we're doing 1.5" thick commercial tabletops (and still the custom stuff). It is also a training environment for unemployable people. So we're not exactly running sanders 8 hours, 6 days a week. But they do get used. We've been limping by on cheapos, and like I said, we will get some good ones. But we just started training two guys this week and all our sanders died (and the planer's down, so we're scrambling).

We just got some hook and loop paper for a Masterforce (Menard's brand) sander one of our guys had, but I'd like to try to find a decent quartersheet sander, unless that doesn't exist, in which case I have to convince our executive director to spend considerably more on sand paper.

Posted

Quarter sheet sanders are square (and fairly worthless).  Random orbit sanders are round.  You need a random orbit sander for furniture work.  Sanders fall firmly into the "get what you pay for" category.  If you intend to continue on with your work, invest in a good one.  Otherwise you end up paying the same amount or more constantly replacing cheap ones, and struggle with mediocre results all the way along.

  • Like 1
Posted (edited)

The PC-low profile is about the lowest electric I could recommend, but it's about $86. For production use, you've got to avoid the real crap -- 8hrs a day with a low-end sander and you'll get tendinitis for sure... The PC-low profile really is about as low as I'd go...

 

 

The Porter Cable 390K 5'' Low Profile Random Orbit Sander is discontinued, why I don't know, it's a great sander I have one, but you can still find some in stock at some stores.  
 
EDIT: can't 100% say it's Discontinued, but it's missing from the list of ROS on the Porter Cable and many web sites have it listed as Discontinued.
 
A good 1/4 sheet sander is the Porter-Cable Speed Bloc 1/4 Sheet Finishing Sander 330, I have 7 of this model, great long lasting sander, but the only place that you will find it only $60 is my craigslist ad.
Edited by Doug-EdgewaterWW
Posted

Quarter sheet sanders are square (and fairly worthless). Random orbit sanders are round. You need a random orbit sander for furniture work. Sanders fall firmly into the "get what you pay for" category. If you intend to continue on with your work, invest in a good one. Otherwise you end up paying the same amount or more constantly replacing cheap ones, and struggle with mediocre results all the way along.

Don't mean to bug you, but I am really quite ignorant. Why are quarter sheet sanders worthless, and why is a round random orbit sander better for furniture? And are there just hook and loop or peel and stick discs?
Posted

==>The only sanders I've really used have been quarter sheet random orbit sanders

==>we're doing 1.5" thick commercial tabletops

 

I need to channel Don for this one.... Hold on.... Here it comes....

 

Get a Shaper...   :)

 

Now that we've got that out of the way...

 

Using a 1/4 sheet orbital sander for tabletops is stupendously inefficient... (told you I was channeling Don)... And, unless the user is highly skilled, will most likely leave a terrible surface...

 

==>The Porter Cable 390K 5'' Low Profile Random Orbit Sander is discontinued, why I don't know, it's a great sander

That's really too bad. It was very high on the bang/buck scale... I've got one remaining, and I'd offer it to the OP, but not if these are discontinued...

 

Now on to helpful comments...

 

For tabletops, you want a sander with a large firm-pad for evenness (if that's a word) and Random Orbit Action (aka, dual action) for efficient stock removal*. As a first sander, I'd get a 6" Random Orbit sander. As stated above, you get what you pay for...

 

==>But they do get used

Depends on what you mean by this... in hrs/week... If you're talking about a sander being used 10hrs/week or more, then you can't get by with the inexpensive stuff... You'll just end-up spending more $$ because you'll just burn them out and have to keep buying more sanders...

 

==>Why are quarter sheet sanders worthless

Well, they're not worthless, but they're about the worst choice you could make for tabletops...

 

As for specific recommendations... It's going to come down to hrs/week and your budget. The obvious choices I could make would also be the most expensive (Festool, CEROS), but would need some more information before recommending that course of action...

 

Can you tell us hr/week and something about the tables -- how big, what material, how finished, commission expectations, etc.

 

 

 

*Note: There are many who mistakenly maintain dual action sanders leave a smaller swirl pattern, but these are misinformed rehashes of marketing literature... (still channeling Don)... :)

Posted

To save some money on sandpaper I would buy from www.woodworkingshop.com , sheet or disc sandpaper here is a lot cheaper then at Menard's or any big box store, Like you said you got so me H & L at Menard's, to compare $9.48 a 12pk of H&L 5" 8 hole disc at Menard's, at the above  http://www.woodworkingshop.com/product/vd60003/  is $15.95 a 50pk.

 

Maybe save some money on abrasives and spend a bit more on a sander that will last longer. 

Posted

You guys are wonderful. And my head is spinning.

The table tops are all reclaimed hardwoods (from pallets). Lots of oak, some maple (hard and soft) and ash, and also poplar and some assorted stuff. We do plane everything, but there are still some nailholes, and the wood generally has more "character", as it's not been chosen for any particular grade (we actually end up with some pretty cool stuff sometimes).

Hours per week? Well, assuming we actually get some orders in (besides the 5 custom things we have now), then likely more than 10 a week. However, since we've apparently been doing it wrong, that could decrease.

We plan to get a drum sander to send the tops through, and then finish sand from there. However, I don't know when those funds will be available.

The tables are being geared towards restaurants/cafes/etc. So 36x36, 30x48, in that area. The design we're going with has breadboard ends (although, if they just wanted butcherblock, we could certainly do that).

I did not know that discs last longer. I was seriously wondering how in the world shops were able to use them and still make any money off their work without charging a ton.

As far as expectations of the customer, those vary. We are very clear of the source of our wood, and what that could mean for the product. We generally tell people (or they already know) that part of our labor force is people in training. So I guess most people aren't looking for a flawless surface, regardless of the piece. Some have been. We've not gotten enough business in the tabletops to really judge the expectations of that market. We have had a decent amount of interest (plus 1 actual customer, and we will be making 10 for our cafe). I guess if we set the standard, and it's a good top, but just not a super polished surface, then we can always charge people more who want something else.

As always, my somewhat simple question is causing me to rethink the whole approach to the work.

Posted

Rock, meet hard place. Sorry you got stuck between them. Boy have I been in your situation. Cheap sanders die quickly in a production environment. 1/4 sheet vibrating sanders leave swirl marks. Cheap sandpaper wears out fast. It's all a balancing act, you have to pay for quality but expensive doesn't always equal quality. I used to buy Bosch random orbit sanders and replace them frequently then I bought a Festool 150 ETS it has lasted 3 times the life of the Bosch so far and is still going. Sorry I don't have a solution to your problem. Same thing applies to the sandpaper. The blue ceramic abrasives last longer and cut faster, but they cost more.

  • 3 years later...
Posted

Kind of new to the woodworking scene but from what I've been reading it seems like the sandpaper quality really affects the performance and final product with any sander. Might be a little off topic but other than by trial and error is there a pecking order for paper brands? I know there is quite the range of paper quality and paper price... 

 

Thanks in advance! 

  • Like 1
Posted

Cheap sanders and cheap abrasives aren't cheap.  You don't need top-of-the-line but buying cheap is a false economy. You will use far more abrasive materials  and have to use the sander longer if you go too low on the food chain  or use the inappropriate sander type. 

  • Like 1
Posted

I used to have a ridgid orbital sander, and I thought it was great, until I got a festool. I could never go back now. But, for the money, the ridgid was great.

  • Like 1
Posted
Kind of new to the woodworking scene but from what I've been reading it seems like the sandpaper quality really affects the performance and final product with any sander. Might be a little off topic but other than by trial and error is there a pecking order for paper brands? I know there is quite the range of paper quality and paper price... 

 

Thanks in advance! 

 

Personally I prefer to use 3M wet/dry sandpaper with a plastic backing for sheet. That way i can cut them to shape for hand sanding or use the whole sheet with some oil to flatten plane soles.

 

For hook and loop style like on a ROS I really prefer Klingspore abrasives. They are a German (I think) based abrasives company and they make sand paper for every thing from wood working to turning to auto body work. Because they are so big and produce so much they sell "bargain boxes" of offcuts and seconds for 20 bucks a box for like 10 or 20 pounds of paper. Sometimes you can get everything from 100 to 1000 grit but not always. It's basically just a big mix of stuff for cheap.

 

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk

 

 

  • 9 months later...
Posted

I'm the odd one out, but I was very disappointed in the Klingspor disks I purchased earlier this year. Maybe I just got a bad batch, but the Shopsmith disks found at my local blue box store performed much better.

Posted

Like other suppliers, Klingspor makes a wide variety of discs including inexpensive ones on light paper backings.  These 'bargain' discs are no better than most generic discs.  Their better abrasives do quite well for me.  Industrial Abrasives 'better' discs also do well for me.

  • Like 1
Posted

And it's important to choose the correct abrasive for woodwork. Klingspor sells discs for all kinds of materials & work & what's good for metal or plastic may not perform well on wood.

Posted

I used Klingspor for many years. Bought in quantity and they shipped it to me. There are different "weight " paper backing discs, I was getting "J weight " I was fairly happy using it with a Bosch ROS. I was wearing out a Bosch in 3-4 years. Then I got a deal on a  ETS 150 when a Festool salesman stopped by.  Festool discs were pricey but they did a better job and lasted longer. I did a comparison and decided the better results and longer life made the Festool abrasives worth the price. That ETS 150 sander is about 10 years old and still going strong !  

Klingspor sanding mop/flap wheels I still use. Klingspor makes the abrasive rolls for SuperMax drum sanders.

3M makes some great abrasives but the difficulty in finding a reliable source at a decent price is a barrier. They basically refuse to discount anything below a full case of one grit.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   3 Members, 0 Anonymous, 36 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,008
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Bob44
    Newest Member
    Bob44
    Joined