Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

benches/tables/workbench ... discussing three

Featured Replies

It is almost time for me to actually make something better than the hollow core door I have now as and outfeed table/assembly/workbench setup ... been ripping lots and lots of play and 1x for the house reno. Now that it will be over toward the end of summer, I am starting to think of what I would actually need in the shop and what would actually fit in the shop.

I know all 3 options would not fit...So here are my thoughts: Keep in mind this is a 2 car garage, I promised the wife as well when the softball size hail comes through I would let her park her new tahoe in the garage .. so mobility will have to somewhat play into this.

Option 1 - 

Build an outfeed table / workbench / assembly table all in one.

-overall size somewhere around 4x6 to give enough room for all activites

- Torsion box top

- miter slots from table saw routed into it

- some type of clamping system on opposite end .. not sure where or what, maybe just some T slots or dog holes or a mix of both

 

Option 2 -

- Build outfeed table

- overall size around 4 x 2 or 3' (not sure how deep yet)

- Other standard outfeed pieces (miter slots / cabinet storage .. etc)

- Then build another assembly table/workbench

- overall size (not sure exactly) but maybe around 4x4 or 3x5 .. something around that I think I could still work into the shop

- Torsion box top

- clamping system

 

Option 3:

Something amazing you all come up with? :)

 

Mainly trying to get ahead of this so I can start working on some sketches and figure out placement of the 1 or 2 new additions. Also start working on actual sizing that I could expect to have

  • Replies 64
  • Views 15.5k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • Brendon_t
    Brendon_t

    This is going to come heavily to personal preference so take this fully as mine. I would not want my outfeed surface to also be my main work surface.  Main reason being, I may have parts of a pro

  • SawDustB
    SawDustB

    I know that usually the route people go with the roubo is to go all out, but it doesn't have to be that way. For my vises I'm at about 35% of the cost of having bought all bench crafted, and that's wi

  • I needed a dead flat assembly area that was not my bench.  I built a drawer unit (everything in my shop has storage in it) and added a top that can be adjusted or changed out completely.  It also acts

Posted Images

  • Popular Post

This is going to come heavily to personal preference so take this fully as mine.

I would not want my outfeed surface to also be my main work surface.  Main reason being, I may have parts of a project laying on the work surface for days or a week as I am building subsequent parts.   It would suck to have to trim a board on the ts but have to move the project off of the work surface to do it.

Another reason is my main work surface has the habit of collecting stuff. If I had to move all of that to use the table saw, it would drive me crazy.

What Brendon said.  

Build a roubo, then come back here and we'll help you throw together an outfeed table :)

 

Brendon is probably correct, if you're one of those that doesn't put things away.  If you want a good reliable bench, you don't have to do a roubo. I built a bench that is poplar and pine, and after I built it I was told it's like a Nickolson bench [whoever he is, or his bench]  8/4 poplar for the top with dog holes and two vises. 4" x 6" pine for the base.  It was inexpensive and does what it's suppose to do for a tool.  My outfeed table is an old Harbor Freight workbench, that's mainly crap, but it works.  You can use your door for an outfeed and put it on castors, and you can get it out of the way whenever those hail stones make their yearly appearance.   My bench is against a wall with windows, it's out of the way of everything and the view keeps me there. 

If your shop is clean and squared away all the time then something like to outfeed table Kev recently built is something to consider.  It has good size, storage and heft, and it was on casters.  If on the other hand you tend to use any flat surface as a storage area, having a do all bench isn't going to work because it will always be buried.  

Another option would be to take that old door, put it up on tent poles and let the wife know you "built" her covered parking. : )

Again, personal preference but if I'm understanding your shop correctly I would build a hinged outfeed table that was attached to the saw. Then I would build a torsion box about 4 1/2" thick, 22" to 24" wide x however long you want out of MDF for the top and sides and quarter inch whatever you want on the bottom with supports every 12". Then I would build two sets of saw horses. One set that would put the torsion box at the height of my outfeed table in case you ever did want to use it for something larger you were cutting on the table saw. And another set of saw horses that would put the torsion box at about 22" off the floor. This is really a desirable height during cabinet/furniture assembly.

 

Sent from my SM-N920P using Tapatalk

 

 

I think a lot depends on the size of the shop.  If you have the room, I agree with separate bench and assembly table.  If a small shop, you may have no choice but to combine. 

  • Popular Post

I needed a dead flat assembly area that was not my bench.  I built a drawer unit (everything in my shop has storage in it) and added a top that can be adjusted or changed out completely.  It also acts as my outfeed.

57b0d68db52a5_TS-Outfeed(38).jpg.319662ad7bc8dd1e44b96858acaa34c6.jpg5702c0f8cdb83_TS-Outfeed(41).jpg.de9304f6e644d0e81cb98e72126c4e85.jpg

I have been using it now for 2 years and it has worked out fine.  I added a small metal vise to one corner that sets below the surface.  I clamp small items here or clamp a stop into it for planing.

Gee-dub do you do a torsion box style construction or build an assembly that can be leveled independently?

 

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk

 

 

  • Author
1 hour ago, gee-dub said:

I needed a dead flat assembly area that was not my bench.  I built a drawer unit (everything in my shop has storage in it) and added a top that can be adjusted or changed out completely.  It also acts as my outfeed.

57b0d68db52a5_TS-Outfeed(38).jpg.319662ad7bc8dd1e44b96858acaa34c6.jpg5702c0f8cdb83_TS-Outfeed(41).jpg.de9304f6e644d0e81cb98e72126c4e85.jpg

I have been using it now for 2 years and it has worked out fine.  I added a small metal vise to one corner that sets below the surface.  I clamp small items here or clamp a stop into it for planing.

hear comes a dumb question ...

 

I thought torsion boxes were the one way to make something flat. How does your way guarantee perfectly flat?

  • Author

great ideas guys, thanks for them so far! Also the folding outfeed table sounds like it could be a solid soluiton, then that would give me the option possibly have a bigger assembly table if needed.

  Torsion boxes are great but , this top is two pieces of laminated three-quarter inch Baltic Birch plywood topped with an 1/8 inch tempered hardboard lamination.  This was built up on top of my workbench as a reference surface. The lamination of the multiple sheets create rigidity.

Although not to machine shop standards this is more than flat enough for setting the legs on a chair. The entire assembly can be adjusted at the four connecting points to the drawer carcass. These are 3/8" through knobs on carriage bolts and The intention was to use shims for leveling.

I lucked out and the floor position at the rear of the tablesaw sets level on the casters as it is. I do shim the casters when I have the table out in the middle of the shop floor or at an angle. My shop is a garage so of course I've got that slope.

30 minutes ago, bushwacked said:

hear comes a dumb question ...

 

I thought torsion boxes were the one way to make something flat. How does your way guarantee perfectly flat?

Also remember, torsion boxes are not to hard to build out of flat unless you have a perfect reference surface and they don't stay flat long without the proper support underneath. If you go torsion, build the base study and able to level independently so you can put it anywhere and keep it flat.

  • Author
54 minutes ago, Brendon_t said:

Also remember, torsion boxes are not to hard to build out of flat unless you have a perfect reference surface and they don't stay flat long without the proper support underneath. If you go torsion, build the base study and able to level independently so you can put it anywhere and keep it flat.

hmmm did not think about that. It would need to be on wheels so I could move it as well. Not sure what I would do as far as leveling it with wheels. Do they make 4" casters that you can level with?

Also, is a torsion box out of flat worse then and MDF sheet as my top?

EDIT: Just rememberd, I could get adjustable feet so it would always be level on the ground and then put some workbench casters on it for when I need to move it.

f3v8P.jpg

 

As far as an outfeed table design ... I was thinking something like this

51eckJdcFIL._AC_SL230_.jpg

I really like the quick access to clamps I would use most and the sled storage to get it off the floor

I know you changed to thinking Workbench casters, but at work we've used these heavy duty casters for some very large equipment.

WoodRiver Machine Leveling Caster Plate Mounted 4 Pack

10 minutes ago, BonPacific said:

I know you changed to thinking Workbench casters, but at work we've used these heavy duty casters for some very large equipment.

WoodRiver Machine Leveling Caster Plate Mounted 4 Pack

These are great. I used them for a mobile base for my PM1500 

What Brendon said is worth repeating, because it can't be overstated what a PITA it is when your assembly table is your outfeed table...or your workbench.  This is my life (the former scenario), and it's the biggest complaint I have about my shop.  I yearn for a huge, dedicated assembly table...something I will never have in this shop.  I can do some assembly on my bench if I'm working at the table saw...but then it's a PITA when I need to use the bench.

In a perfect world, you would have all three.

Second best is the situation I have, where you have a dedicated workbench (#1 priority), and an outfeed table that doubles as an assembly table.

The worst option is a single table that acts as all three.  I would urge you to do whatever is in your power to make the space for at least a dedicated bench and a separate surface for everything else.

If you absolutely have to do a 3-in-1 kind of deal, I'd look hard at Shane's bench because it's so versatile (especially if you Festool).  If it's on casters you could just kind of roll it away from the table saw if you needed to make a cut on a shorter piece and the bench had a bunch of crap on it.

Also, I'll just add...IMO torsion boxes are overrated.  It's one of those things that kind of reached legendary status in the woodworking ether - undeservedly.  Yes it's nice to have a dead flat surface, and if I were ever to build a dedicated assembly table that's probably how I'd build it...but it's not necessary.  If your joinery is square, your furniture will be square, regardless of the surface it's glued-up on.  If you need to level chair legs or something similar, your table saw top is flat enough to act as a reference for that.  My assembly table is just three sheets of 3/4" ply laminated together and banded with hardwood.  It's not dead flat - but it's flat enough.  I've glued up many a project on that table and they all stand on four legs without wobble...and any wobble they do have is due to my hardwood floor, not poor assembly.

I'll chime back in that my primary assembly area is torsion beams on adjustable saw horses. 

592608caeb8e0_MediaCabinet(171).jpg.3c929207dee7db39719aa1b682fea1dc.jpg

5926093d4dcf9_GnGLowCoD(241).JPG.fa57306cebcc823a48c83501ccff7ba2.JPG

The outfeed/assembly table is "extra" space.  As mentioned, if it were the "only" place, you would quickly find one function getting in the way of the other.  I sort of got the idea from a guy who has a fairly traditional looking workbench as his outfeed including dog holes and a shoulder vise.  This is an "extra" bench and he has another dedicated bench for most work. It may be that the combination of a folddown outfeed and a collapsible assembly platform would meet your needs.  Google "knock down assembly table" and look under "images" and there are a lot of good ideas.

  • Author

 

I know you changed to thinking Workbench casters, but at work we've used these heavy duty casters for some very large equipment.

 

410012xvshL.jpg

 

 

 

 

Oh those look good. Do the wheels swivel or are they straight roll only?

 

 

To move the table once it is set would I need to get my wrench and undo my level setting to lower the feet enough for rollers to move it? If so how long does that normally take... just curious

 

 

 

 

What Brendon said is worth repeating, because it can't be overstated what a PITA it is when your assembly table is your outfeed table...or your workbench.  This is my life (the former scenario), and it's the biggest complaint I have about my shop.  I yearn for a huge, dedicated assembly table...something I will never have in this shop.  I can do some assembly on my bench if I'm working at the table saw...but then it's a PITA when I need to use the bench.

 

In a perfect world, you would have all three.

 

Second best is the situation I have, where you have a dedicated workbench (#1 priority), and an outfeed table that doubles as an assembly table.

 

The worst option is a single table that acts as all three.  I would urge you to do whatever is in your power to make the space for at least a dedicated bench and a separate surface for everything else.

 

If you absolutely have to do a 3-in-1 kind of deal, I'd look hard at Shane's bench because it's so versatile (especially if you Festool).  If it's on casters you could just kind of roll it away from the table saw if you needed to make a cut on a shorter piece and the bench had a bunch of crap on it.

 

Also, I'll just add...IMO torsion boxes are overrated.  It's one of those things that kind of reached legendary status in the woodworking ether - undeservedly.  Yes it's nice to have a dead flat surface, and if I were ever to build a dedicated assembly table that's probably how I'd build it...but it's not necessary.  If your joinery is square, your furniture will be square, regardless of the surface it's glued-up on.  If you need to level chair legs or something similar, your table saw top is flat enough to act as a reference for that.  My assembly table is just three sheets of 3/4" ply laminated together and banded with hardwood.  It's not dead flat - but it's flat enough.  I've glued up many a project on that table and they all stand on four legs without wobble...and any wobble they do have is due to my hardwood floor, not poor assembly.

 

 

 

 

 

Yep in a perfect world I'd have all 3.

 

 

However with this thread I have talked myself out of the 3 in 1 combo. Even though I keep my shop clean and tools up I can see that getting quite annoying if I have a big project going and have to take it all down to make 1 cut.

 

 

Now as far as workbench vs assembly table ... I really don't do much at all with hand tools at the moment. I'm sure later on maybe, but for now I don't. Would a workbench still be top over an assembly table in that case? Or what if I made an assembly table stout kinda like @tiods outfeed table and modify it a little with some workbench features?

 

 

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

The wheels swivel, and roll very nicely. You do have to re-level after moving, but the adjustment can be made without a wrench (provided you don't have thousands of pounds on your bench).

28 minutes ago, bushwacked said:

Now as far as workbench vs assembly table ... I really don't do much at all with hand tools at the moment. I'm sure later on maybe, but for now I don't. Would a workbench still be top over an assembly table in that case?

I say yes, definitely.  Regardless of the tools you use, you still have to "work."  You need dedicated space for that and work-holding options.  That's a workbench.  A table is just...a table.

  • Popular Post
9 minutes ago, Brendon_t said:

How did you glue up the 3pieces of MDF? Vaccume bag?

It was ply, but no...don't have a vacuum bag...yet.  I drove a bunch of screws in from the bottom.  Used leveled saw horses to keep everything as flat as possible.  Ended up "good enough."

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,010 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Lolli4 Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.