Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

benches/tables/workbench ... discussing three

Featured Replies

I do believe even our fearless leader, after building that torsion box assembly table years ago then giving it away (or selling it, maybe), has since said they're not necessary.

My workbench is just TWO sheets of 3/4 ply, and I am absolutely positive it is not to blame for any of my squareness woes.  That bench is going to be upgraded within a year or two, but it's good enough that I think I need to build a decent outfeed table first.  I think.  Maybe.

Regardless I'm in on this and wouldn't mind seeing some other outfeed tables.

  • Replies 64
  • Views 15.5k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • Brendon_t
    Brendon_t

    This is going to come heavily to personal preference so take this fully as mine. I would not want my outfeed surface to also be my main work surface.  Main reason being, I may have parts of a pro

  • SawDustB
    SawDustB

    I know that usually the route people go with the roubo is to go all out, but it doesn't have to be that way. For my vises I'm at about 35% of the cost of having bought all bench crafted, and that's wi

  • I needed a dead flat assembly area that was not my bench.  I built a drawer unit (everything in my shop has storage in it) and added a top that can be adjusted or changed out completely.  It also acts

Posted Images

  • Author
14 hours ago, gee-dub said:

I'll chime back in that my primary assembly area is torsion beams on adjustable saw horses. 

592608caeb8e0_MediaCabinet(171).jpg.3c929207dee7db39719aa1b682fea1dc.jpg

5926093d4dcf9_GnGLowCoD(241).JPG.fa57306cebcc823a48c83501ccff7ba2.JPG

The outfeed/assembly table is "extra" space.  As mentioned, if it were the "only" place, you would quickly find one function getting in the way of the other.  I sort of got the idea from a guy who has a fairly traditional looking workbench as his outfeed including dog holes and a shoulder vise.  This is an "extra" bench and he has another dedicated bench for most work. It may be that the combination of a folddown outfeed and a collapsible assembly platform would meet your needs.  Google "knock down assembly table" and look under "images" and there are a lot of good ideas.

Absolutely beautiful pieces there!!! 

My question on the beams is ... wont they move or slide around if you try to adjust your piece? I would be afraid I would want to wiggle my project a little and then it would somehow fall off the beams or sawhorse haha

I like the idea of separate outfeed/assembly too.  My outfeed is a simple piece of leftover counter top hinged to the back of the saw.  It only adds about 30" to the back of the saw, but that is enough for 99% of the work I do.  A nice system that I seen by Jay Bates on his You Tube channel is the use of a Paulk type bench.  It is very handy for him and can be built to the custom size you need.  Worth checking out at least.

Another thought is to have a surface hinged to the wall where your wife occasionally has to park.  Either a torsion box or Paulk style that can be dropped down for parking room.  Although it could be inconvenient as you may have to unload it with weather coming in.  It could also be on castors instead so you could push it out of the way.  Lots of options to think about, so I thought I would just throw a couple out there as you will have to decide which option fits your work flow best.

  • Author

ok as far as a workbench goes ... I wont be building a roubo :) 

I have always like the looks of the sjobergs ... simple/functional and looks really basic to build. The one below is 57" long x 23" wide. Not sure on my dimensions I would need but, it would be close to that I think. Also without the need for massive amounts of wood, I can possibly sneak a few nice accent pieces on there and maybe spice it up a little.

41wX9cnd3GL._SL500_AC_SS350_.jpg

1 hour ago, bushwacked said:

ok as far as a workbench goes ... I wont be building a roubo :) 

I have always like the looks of the sjobergs ... simple/functional and looks really basic to build. The one below is 57" long x 23" wide. Not sure on my dimensions I would need but, it would be close to that I think. Also without the need for massive amounts of wood, I can possibly sneak a few nice accent pieces on there and maybe spice it up a little.

41wX9cnd3GL._SL500_AC_SS350_.jpg

I think I want that for my outfeed table, without the vices.  Hmmmmm.  

1 hour ago, bushwacked said:

41wX9cnd3GL._SL500_AC_SS350_.jpg

 

My main complaint would be I don't like how there's no good way to support a long board (think deadman).  And I think the bench is too short in general.  The Roubo is more than seven feet long and I still want for more length fairly often.  If you only plan to do small projects it should be okay.  I would find that bench...limiting...for my work.

  • Author
32 minutes ago, Eric. said:

 

My main complaint would be I don't like how there's no good way to support a long board (think deadman).  And I think the bench is too short in general.  The Roubo is more than seven feet long and I still want for more length fairly often.  If you only plan to do small projects it should be okay.  I would find that bench...limiting...for my work.

true... that is the main major drawback I see with this. I was already going to beef it up with 4x4 legs out of whatever material I use.

How thick should the tops be on these? 3-4"? or what ... 

I completely agree with Eric on the length but will give that the sjoberg benches at woodcraft look and feel very nice.

 

I'm confused. You would build a sjoberg but not a roubo?  I could see the "I just want a bench and don't feel like building it so I will buy a sjoberg" aka the @SplinteredDave, but if you're gonna build a bench why would you build a sjoberg over a roubo. 

Also I echo Eric's point about length. Mine is 90" and I often wish it were longer (teehee). 

2 minutes ago, bgreenb said:

I often wish it were longer (teehee). 

Anything less than 12' will have you wanting more. :) 

Why not consider a Nicholson style bench?  @Chet K built one I believe and then he and @TIODS added a BC leg vise.  I have been practicing sketch up by designing a bench and the one I like is called the RouboSon.

Here's where I get myself into trouble.  But I'm gonna take the gamble anyway.

Brian is right...If you're gonna build a bench, I see no reason to not build a Roubo.  I'm still waiting for someone to give me an example of how another (traditional bench) design is somehow more versatile than a Roubo.  The Roubo can do it all.

The only reason I can think of to not build a Roubo is Bandwagon Oppositional Disorder (BOD)...which I fully understand and embrace.  But sometimes you just gotta hold your nose and hop on the wagon.  It's the best bench out there for hand tool users, and unless you're super heavy on Festool...it's probably the best for more machine-focused woodworkers, too.  It just has so many work-holding options that it can't be beat.  Premium hardware is optional (but oh so nice).  You have to buy the lumber no matter what you build, so there's really no financial reason not to build one either.  It's also a very easy build, technically.  Food for thought.  Not sure what your aversion is.  It's like saying you don't want a Ferrari.

  • Author

My 2 aversions to building a roubo is:

 

1) it seems .. to me ... more in depth and skillful. Maybe I am wrong on this? As you say Eric it is technically easy so maybe I'm missing something?

 

2) price ... the wood alone is almost double what I have mocked up needing for the sjo. I have not looked into the hardware but marks site says he spent 809 just on hardware. Then another 800ish on wood. I just don't have 1600 to spend on a bench. I was also going to most likely only go for 1 vise as well to save on money.

 

The Nicholson I have looked into but it seems like it would waste a lot of space not being able to put a good amount of storage under the table top.

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

3 minutes ago, bushwacked said:

marks site says he spent 809 just on hardware

That's for the Benchcrafted hardware.  You don't have to use that.  Any old vises will work.

If you can make a mortise and tenon and a dovetail you can build the Roubo.  And if you can't...you need to learn it. :)

  • Popular Post

I know that usually the route people go with the roubo is to go all out, but it doesn't have to be that way. For my vises I'm at about 35% of the cost of having bought all bench crafted, and that's with having bought a criss cross. I used two vise screws for the rest. It does also scale down nicely. Mine is just over six feet because that's what fits my space. Now, I am still into it for about $1000 CAD ($740 USD) in wood, but that's because I went with hard maple since it was only about 20% more than the alternatives at the supplier I have here. I'm also pretty inexperienced, but none of it was super difficult if you take your time. My point is, make sure you're choosing not to do it for the right reasons. If you're putting 4 inch legs and a 3-4 inch top on the sjoberg, it's starting to sound a lot like a roubo in terms of the build.

8 minutes ago, SawDustB said:

 I went with hard maple since it was only about 20% more than the alternatives at the supplier I have here because I'm smart and make good decisions.

FTFY :)

 

FTFY [emoji4]

 

And I read Eric's rant about hard maple being the only acceptable bench wood one too many times...

  • Popular Post
22 minutes ago, Eric. said:

That's for the Benchcrafted hardware.  You don't have to use that.  Any old vises will work.

If you can make a mortise and tenon and a dovetail you can build the Roubo.  And if you can't...you need to learn it. :)

Yeah it's tough to characterize the difficulty of the Roubo.  It's a difficult build in the sense that it's a huge piece and all the parts of it are huge.  It takes a long time (unless you're @Tom Cancelleri).  

I guess what I would say is it's a simple build but not an easy build.  It doesn't require any advanced skills.  Can you mill lumber straight and square?  Can you glue it together?  Can you use a handheld router to cut a mortise?  Can you cut a tenon?  Then you can build the roubo.  It truly isn't complicated or complex at all.  

I agree the benchcrafted stuff is really expensive (although delicious...) but what Brian said is right - you can absolutely build a premium bench with cheaper hardware.  

I know it sounds like a huge build...but it's so so so goddamn rewarding.  It's hard to explain to someone who hasn't done it.  Kind of like having a kid - you don't get it until you get it :)

 

4 minutes ago, SawDustB said:

And I read Eric's rant about hard maple being the only acceptable bench wood one too many times... 

I believe I've had a similar rant or two.  I built mine from soft maple and regret and depression eat my insides every day.  

The wood for the Roubo was $800?  Isn't it less than 200 BF?  I'd think you could source a suitable wood for less than $4 a BF.

The biggest drawback to the Roubo I see is lack of storage...I don't have much usable wall space since my walls are concrete, so storage under the bench would be very helpful.

 

@Bushwacked , you say a shorter bench fits your space, but will you have access to both sides?

 

 

My current 'whitewood' bench is about 5' long. Works fine for boxes and picture frames, but gets tight when building real furniture. I have a design cooking on the back burner of my brain, that I plan to build, eventually.

 

 

It is a mashup of roubo & nicholson features, perhaps with some storage added, as well. I plan to use a split top, maybe with 2 splits, and a planing stop / filler strip. Two splits, if used, will align with the miter slots in my TS, and the bench will match the TS height.

 

 

The top will be laminated, 3" to 3.5" thick to work well with holdfasts. One end of the top will be flush with the legs, and allow for a vise if some sort. One side will be flush with the legs, and include a thick apron ( still flush) with hold fast holes. Provisions will be made for a leg vise on this side. Probably a row of round dog holes in the bottom stretcher on that side, also.

 

The opposite end and side will hang over the legs, so clamps can be used.

 

 

Any storage cabinet would be a separated unit than sits inside the frame, with clearance for hold fasts. I believe Jay Bates did something like this on his SYP roubo.

 

 

One advantage of split design is that you don't have to make both (or all three) sections as a giant laminated beam. One can be like that (where the vises are), the other can be a torsion box, or just plywood on aprons. My three-piece could even have the center section open like a tool tray, although that seems like just a place to catch shavings.

 

 

When it comes down to it, the bench has to meet your needs, and no one elses. Don't be scared to pimp it out any way you like. And don't think you have to use expensive hardware like all the cool kids. Sure, its great if you can, but much less expensive devices can still hold your work.

 

 

  • Author
The wood for the Roubo was $800?  Isn't it less than 200 BF?  I'd think you could source a suitable wood for less than $4 a BF.

The biggest drawback to the Roubo I see is lack of storage...I don't have much usable wall space since my walls are concrete, so storage under the bench would be very helpful.

 

8/4 hard maple is 4.05 BF at my local yard.

8/4 pecan is 3.80 BF

 

Those are the cheapest hard wood I can get.

 

Yep storage is a big thing for me in my 2 car shop.

 

 

 

@Bushwacked , you say a shorter bench fits your space, but will you have access to both sides?

 

 

 

 

 

 

Any storage cabinet would be a separated unit than sits inside the frame, with clearance for hold fasts. I believe Jay Bates did something like this on his SYP roubo.

 

 

 

 

 

 

And don't think you have to use expensive hardware like all the cool kids. Sure, its great if you can, but much less expensive devices can still hold your work.

 

 

 

 

I am not sure yet if I'll get access to both sides. I am thinking I will but not sure how much room I'll have on the "back" side.

 

Ya I like Jays bench too. Simple and cheap haha.

 

True. That's why I am thinking pecan even though it may be tough to build with it will be the hardest bench around here [emoji1][emoji1]

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

8 hours ago, bleedinblue said:

 Isn't it less than 200 BF?  I'd think you could source a suitable wood for less than $4 a bf

No way. At least not in my part of the country and not if you're getting it kiln dried from a quality dealer. The only hardwood you're getting for under $4/bf around here is poplar (or shorts of various species). 

I suppose you could save some cash by buying shorts, which are typically discounted, for the base parts where you don't need the length, but shorts are usually only available in a few species from time to time, and almost never in 8/4. 

  • Popular Post
8 hours ago, bleedinblue said:

The biggest drawback to the Roubo I see is lack of storage...I don't have much usable wall space since my walls are concrete, so storage under the bench would be very helpful.

 

:)

 

V.jpg

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,010 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Lolli4 Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.