Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Smoking brisket...is there an easy way?

Featured Replies

I got a smoker a couple years ago.  I've smoked turkey and brisket a few times each.  The brisket turned out really good once, the other items it had good flavor but wasn't as tender as it could have been.

I have a 10. 5 pound brisket to smoke on Sunday and would like to get it right this time. 

Anyone have a dummy proof method?

Steve is right it just takes time and it will stall out during the day were the internal temp doesn't change much but don't panic just let it go.  Start early it will take Aaaall day to get it done right.

What kind of smoker?

In my opinion, the how you get there isn't nearly as important as the point that you take it out. You can wrap it to speed up cooking, etc - that's all fine. But there is a magic temperature for brisket. It's between 200-205, it's going to be amazing. Besides my own smoking, my references are 

  • Amazing ribs - http://amazingribs.com/recipes/beef/texas_brisket.html
  • Barrry Sorkin from Smoque, Chicago - My all time favorite brisket. I hated BBQ until I went to his restaurant. I've heard he takes his brisket out at 195, but I don't know which part of the meat he tests for temp either. 
  • Aaron Franklin - Widely considered one of the top five places in the USA to get brisket. In Episode 1 of "BBQ with Franklin" on amazon prime he states when he likes to take it out and says it generally is around 203. That episode will teach you much about brisket. 

The best thing you can do is realize every piece of meat is different. Some may be ready to go at lower temps, others at higher temps. So you have to learn what "done" looks like to get consistent results, everything anyone can tell you should only be a guide to get you going. If you are going to change anything in your cooking style, only change one thing at a time and record what you did and what the results were so you can repeat them or change it later. 

As for cooking temp, I like 225. Aaron Franklin does his at 275. And I've heard of people doing 325 at competitions. 

Oh yeah and make sure you have a kickass thermometer. I use the Maverick ones, and waiting for Meater to go on sale - and holy crap they are now on sale. I'm now officially super excited. https://meater.com/

 

 

What I've done, and it works quite well. Is, put it in the oven the night before for all night at 200*, then in the morning of the sit down, get the smoker going, with some good cherry or apple chips that have been soaked in water for an hour or so, get the temp around 225* and turn the smoke loose.  It'll be fall apart brisket.  You can smoke it till an hour or so before eating to let the juices settle.  Before putting it in the oven, season however you like, but I'd add some Cajun spice to your mix.  It'll be good.

  • Author
1 hour ago, Chet said:

Steve is right it just takes time and it will stall out during the day were the internal temp doesn't change much but don't panic just let it go.  Start early it will take Aaaall day to get it done right.

What kind of smoker?

It's a propane smoker, which is probably the pocket hole version of smokers.

1 hour ago, Cliff said:

In my opinion, the how you get there isn't nearly as important as the point that you take it out. You can wrap it to speed up cooking, etc - that's all fine. But there is a magic temperature for brisket. It's between 200-205, it's going to be amazing. Besides my own smoking, my references are 

  • Amazing ribs - http://amazingribs.com/recipes/beef/texas_brisket.html
  • Barrry Sorkin from Smoque, Chicago - My all time favorite brisket. I hated BBQ until I went to his restaurant. I've heard he takes his brisket out at 195, but I don't know which part of the meat he tests for temp either. 
  • Aaron Franklin - Widely considered one of the top five places in the USA to get brisket. In Episode 1 of "BBQ with Franklin" on amazon prime he states when he likes to take it out and says it generally is around 203. That episode will teach you much about brisket. 

The best thing you can do is realize every piece of meat is different. Some may be ready to go at lower temps, others at higher temps. So you have to learn what "done" looks like to get consistent results, everything anyone can tell you should only be a guide to get you going. If you are going to change anything in your cooking style, only change one thing at a time and record what you did and what the results were so you can repeat them or change it later. 

As for cooking temp, I like 225. Aaron Franklin does his at 275. And I've heard of people doing 325 at competitions. 

Oh yeah and make sure you have a kickass thermometer. I use the Maverick ones, and waiting for Meater to go on sale - and holy crap they are now on sale. I'm now officially super excited. https://meater.com/

 

 

I think you outlined why smoking brisket is such a mystery to novices like myself.  One article says to cook it to an internal of 185, others 195, 205 and on up.   Same goes for the cooking temperature, everyone has a different method.  I've used 225 every time in the past.  I think my tenderness issue comes from cooking too long or too short, I'm not sure which.  I suppose taking notes is a good idea.

I should get a remote meat thermometer for the future too, but I won't have time to before tomorrow.  That's bound to be better than opening the door constantly to check temp.

20 minutes ago, RichardA said:

What I've done, and it works quite well. Is, put it in the oven the night before for all night at 200*, then in the morning of the sit down, get the smoker going, with some good cherry or apple chips that have been soaked in water for an hour or so, get the temp around 225* and turn the smoke loose.  It'll be fall apart brisket.  You can smoke it till an hour or so before eating to let the juices settle.  Before putting it in the oven, season however you like, but I'd add some Cajun spice to your mix.  It'll be good.

I've wondered about pre-baking the meat in the oven.  We told everyone we'd eat between 5-6 PM tomorrow, so if I were to have the meat on the smoker for 12+ hours you can do the math at what time I'd be getting up.  Screw that.  I'll look into this more.

1 hour ago, bleedinblue said:

.  We told everyone we'd eat between 5-6 PM tomorrow

We we have plans like this I usually do the cook the day before then the next day slice it and do a slow re-heat in the oven about 200.  I know this no longer helps you but something to stick in your back pocket for next time.

I use a Thremoworks thermometer and one of the things I pay attention to as far as doneness is when I check the temp, how easy does the probe go into the brisket.

1 hour ago, bleedinblue said:

I should get a remote meat thermometer for the future too, but I won't have time to before tomorrow.  That's bound to be better than opening the door constantly to check temp.

I literally don't think I could make a quality smoked meat without the remote temperature probe. Once I put the meat on, I do not remove the top again. I remove the door (Weber Smokey Mountain) to throw in more coals or wood. Hopefully a 1-2 min process. I did once take the top off and when I put it back on the temperature shot up 150 degrees because of all the air that got in. 

I've never cooked meat then smoked it. My understanding (and may be wrong) is that meat absorbs the smoke flavor during the first 4-5 hours of the cook then not really much after. I do sometimes finish in the oven though. Cause I can set the oven to 225 instead of wasting another pile of charcoal if I only have 5-10 degrees left.

Another thing to think of is the quality of the meat matters on the overall tenderness. I know brisket is the toughest part of the cow, but man.. if you get meat from an old cow - the quality just isn't there. My parents butcher cows when they can no longer get pregnant, and we just turn it all into hamburger because it's really good for nothing else. But yay for having 600lbs of hamburger in my freezers!

 

4 hours ago, Chet said:

We we have plans like this I usually do the cook the day before then the next day slice it and do a slow re-heat in the oven about 200.  I know this no longer helps you but something to stick in your back pocket for next time.

I use a Thremoworks thermometer and one of the things I pay attention to as far as doneness is when I check the temp, how easy does the probe go into the brisket.

I have started doing the same thing...it beats getting up at 4 in the morning to get things fired up. I use a lot of Jeff Phillips tips and recipes check him out at

http://www.smoking-meat.com 

I find he keeps it simple...side note his boneless chicken thighs wrapped in bacon are amazing

 

  • Popular Post

"boneless dark meat chicken breasts wrapped in bacon". ????????

That sounds like " jumbo shrimp "  and lots of other mutually exclusive terms.  Dark meat ain't chicken breasts !

1 hour ago, Cliff said:

I literally don't think I could make a quality smoked meat without the remote temperature probe.

 

3 hours ago, bleedinblue said:

That's bound to be better than opening the door constantly to check temp.

This is what make this "sport" kind of interesting, there are so many approaches to it. You sort of need to mess with it until you find your technique.   I don't open my door all the time but I do open it a few times.  I have a real nice stick burner (good to have if you are a woodworker:D) and i like to move and rotate the meat to keep it from getting to done on one side before the other.  I also don't open it until its close to done to check it with my thermometer.  

2 hours ago, wdwerker said:

"boneless dark meat chicken breasts wrapped in bacon". ????????

That sounds like " jumbo shrimp "  and lots of other mutually exclusive terms.  Dark meat ain't chicken breasts !

LOL you are correct i have corrected it :) 

2 hours ago, wdwerker said:

Dark meat is moist & tasty ! Chicken breast is dry aand tasteless !

True dat. You gotta add flavor to the breast. Nothing better than chicken thighs though.

  • Author

Haha.  I got up at 430, got the smoker to 225 and had the meat in at 5.  I stayed awake to make sure it maintained temp and went back to bed.  I got up at 9 and checked it, the temp had spiked to 325. 

Whoops.  Out of water, I guess that allowed the temp to climb. 

The meat was the prettiest of any smoke I've done yet, with more of the dark bark that I've never been able to achieve.  Heres to hoping the meat didn't dry out too much...but if it did, that's what BBQ sauce is for. 

 

  • Author
  • Popular Post
2 hours ago, Chet said:

Hotdogs to the rescue???

:D God I hope not, if nothing else because this big chunk of meat wasn't cheap! 

It might taste like leather, but this is the first time my smoked brisket has looked like briskets on the internet.  It's purty. 

9 hours in, I'm getting temp readings everywhere from 170-188.  I think when that top number hits 195 I'll pull it, wrap it and drop it in a cooler for a couple hours.  Making it up as I go along! 

20171022_142847.jpg

1 hour ago, bleedinblue said:

Making it up as I go along! 

Thats the spirit. :)  Then when company tells you how great it is you, tell them "it's taken a few years to develop a recipe I like but I am getting close".

The thing about mastering your smoked meats, you can change people's lives. Around me bbq is awful. I had some friends over and the pulled pork turned out subpar. Everyone said it was great. I said, "Well no, it's garbage." They think I'm being modest. Few weeks later I called emergency pork eating session and brought everyone in. They tried that and finally realized what I had meant calling the other stuff garbage. Now - they can't eat at local bbq joints. And honestly, that's what happened to me when I was first turned on to it. It changed my life completely. 

  • Author

The thing is though, I have no desire to make this another hobby, god knows I  don't need another.  I just want to be able to offer something different for family functions and such

This brisket turned out really OK.  Probably the most tender I've made so far, definitely the best bark.  I think it took a step back in smoke flavor, but that's probably because I used peach wood chips instead of the hickory I used every other smoke. 

The bottom piece in the picture seemed to have all the fat and was much more tender.  I had to cut it in half like that to fit the smoker.  I'm not sure of a way around that. 

All in all, I consider this progress.

 

23 hours ago, bleedinblue said:

The thing is though, I have no desire to make this another hobby, god knows I  don't need another.  I just want to be able to offer something different for family functions and such

This brisket turned out really OK.  Probably the most tender I've made so far, definitely the best bark.  I think it took a step back in smoke flavor, but that's probably because I used peach wood chips instead of the hickory I used every other smoke. 

The bottom piece in the picture seemed to have all the fat and was much more tender.  I had to cut it in half like that to fit the smoker.  I'm not sure of a way around that. 

All in all, I consider this progress.

 

Yeah hickory is mostly king of brisket. I bet adding some peach in might be good, or it might get swallowed by the hickory flavor anyway. Glad you had a better smoke.

23 hours ago, wtnhighlander said:

Smoking a brisket seems to be pretty simple.

Rolling one, on the other hand .....

:lol:

Now that’s funny! 

Glad it turned out good Blue!

On 10/22/2017 at 11:10 PM, wtnhighlander said:

Smoking a brisket seems to be pretty simple.

Rolling one, on the other hand .....

:lol:

I was wondering who would say it first ;)  I remember buying a Cheech and Chong album and the inside sleeve was a giant rolling paper.  Still, I think it would be hard to keep it lit.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Who's Online (See full list)

  • There are no registered users currently online

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,010 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Lolli4 Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.