bushwacked Posted November 2, 2017 Report Posted November 2, 2017 Same topic as most with just a little spin on it due to a cash back balance ... So my buddy was set on getting a PM 6" after using mine, however the last few milling sessions he seemed to have quite a bit just over 6" wide. He got a little annoyed having to do extra work getting the high edge out. So he starting thinking on it more and he talked his wife into using some of their cash back balance (some credit card thing they save) on new tools. Roughly about $1000 and he already had some saved away, I think it was just under $1K My question, after doing a little digging around here and reading a topic on here from like 2013-14? @Eric mentioned his Grizzly was a solid tool and for hobbyist it did its job well. Although, I think last year you got rid of it for a PM jointer ... His thoughts are: Spend a little more on the Grizzly 490X $1350? ish to get the 8" size and from most all reviews online an extremely capable machine ... basically paying $350ish out of pocket. Then spending the rest on other tools he is in the market for. Or Splurge on the $2K 8" PM jointer and blow his tool budget and then some for at least a year or so ... After looking around I was kind of steering him to the Grizzly since it seems to be one of their better jointers and he would have money to spend on other tools. The Eric and Kev and other voices in my head say you buy the best tool you can afford and then just be without the others for a longer period of time .. which would be the PM 8" On a side note ... if he went Griz, he could probably afford enough of the other tools to keep him out of my shop on a monthly basis lol ... selfish I know (hes a good friend though and its fun to BS .. just not helpful for productivity) Thoughts? Quote
RichardA Posted November 2, 2017 Report Posted November 2, 2017 The old saying applies here "Buy once, cry once". Get the best, then cry till you save enough to do it again. Rinse and repeat. 1 Quote
Chestnut Posted November 2, 2017 Report Posted November 2, 2017 I have the 8" PM and love it. I suggest getting Parallelogram beds. Segmented cutter head is really nice as well. In my opinion if your willing to put up with a little bit griz can save you money. If you don't want to worry about it go for the more expensive option. That's not saying that griz will be bad and the other will be good they will both work. Griz just doesn't have the quality control, which is why they cost less. 1 Quote
minorhero Posted November 2, 2017 Report Posted November 2, 2017 There are plenty of people using the green bear machines that like them. There are plenty of people using the yellow matic who like them. They both cut wood and they both have people who claim horror stories dealing with their machines. I have a 1960s 8" pm that I like quite a bit. I have spent considerable time using a modern pm 8" at a club shop I used to belong to, and frankly hated that machine. My first jointer was a 6" grizzly that was used when I bought it and a fine machine. I feel pretty comfortable in saying that which way your friend goes will be entirely determined by how he values the perceived difference between the two tools. I say perceived because there really is not much in the way of objective information here, just peoples opinions based upon just a few examples they have personally seen. What I can advise is whatever way he goes he should definitely get a spiral cutting head. The settings time savings is worth it all by itself. 1 Quote
Alan G Posted November 2, 2017 Report Posted November 2, 2017 I have a 18mo old Grizz G490W. That thing is a POS. I regret buying it everytime I use it. Nothing is flat, it wont hold an adjustment for any length of time. Im on my second fence which is better than the first but still is not flat. I think it is more luck than not to get a decent machine from Grizzly. I have had nothing but bad experiences with product and service. I will never recommend anyone get a grizz machine. Just not worth it. You get what you pay for. In the near future I am going to sell it and get the PJ882. I will put the segmented cutter in at a later date. Its a 900 up charge from powermatic when the head is just over 400. 1 Quote
bushwacked Posted November 2, 2017 Author Report Posted November 2, 2017 Ya I have heard Grizzlys sometimes are tough to keep aligned and get knocked out of wack easier than PM. I have also read almost every review out there, at least what was there when I was in the market and then it seemed to be a 70/30 shot if you got a good one vs a beat up model. However the 490X seemed to be a little better about it ... maybe 85/15 on good to bad ... Quote
Chestnut Posted November 2, 2017 Report Posted November 2, 2017 1 hour ago, Alan G said: In the near future I am going to sell it and get the PJ882. I will put the segmented cutter in at a later date. Its a 900 up charge from powermatic when the head is just over 400. I thought long and hard about that up charge and it came to this. It was aligned from the factory and i Don't have as much free time as i once did. 15 minutes ago, bushwacked said: Ya I have heard Grizzlys sometimes are tough to keep aligned and get knocked out of wack easier than PM. I have also read almost every review out there, at least what was there when I was in the market and then it seemed to be a 70/30 shot if you got a good one vs a beat up model. However the 490X seemed to be a little better about it ... maybe 85/15 on good to bad ... 490X seems like a decent bet. Though he'll find that right after you get a 8" jointer you'll find all those beautiful 9" boards. 2 Quote
Dknapp34 Posted November 2, 2017 Report Posted November 2, 2017 I have a 490 that I put a byrd cutter head into. I love it. Got it used, so I have no idea what kind of abuse it was subject to before me, but I have had no issues with alignment. If it were me, I would get the Griz and use the left over money to but more tools. A joint is one of the simpler machines in the shop. There isn't much that can go wrong, and if something does it usually is easy to fix. 1 Quote
bushwacked Posted November 2, 2017 Author Report Posted November 2, 2017 3 minutes ago, Chestnut said: 490X seems like a decent bet. Though he'll find that right after you get a 8" jointer you'll find all those beautiful 9" boards. HAH! I told him the same thing ... it always happens that way. although if he gets mad and goes and gets a 12" maybe I will get a sweet deal on an 8" lol Quote
Chestnut Posted November 2, 2017 Report Posted November 2, 2017 Is it jay bates that does the planer sled or nubs or who ever. I just did that flatten leave the edge and then run it through the planer for the other side. Flip back grab the lip and done. Quote
bushwacked Posted November 2, 2017 Author Report Posted November 2, 2017 Just now, Chestnut said: Is it jay bates that does the planer sled or nubs or who ever. I just did that flatten leave the edge and then run it through the planer for the other side. Flip back grab the lip and done. ummm may be both, but I have watched JB's video on several times ... also the Spags has one on how to do it as well I believe Quote
Chestnut Posted November 2, 2017 Report Posted November 2, 2017 Just now, bushwacked said: ummm may be both, but I have watched JB's video on several times ... also the Spags has one on how to do it as well I believe Yeah but spags is all crazy with a hand plane and ain't nobody got time for that. Except for me last night bah i be a hypocrite. Quote
Pwk5017 Posted November 2, 2017 Report Posted November 2, 2017 I dont find setting knives in a jointer to be that difficult. 10 mins and i can set 3 knives within 2 thous of one another. I do think carbide inserts are the better choice in the long run--not for knife setting time, for money saved on sharpening. To sharpen three 12" knives for my machine is $20-25 locally. I have two sets that i rotate through every 6 months. Thats $80 for a spare set and then $40-50 annually. I plan on rotating my byrd inserts at the two year mark in my PM planer. I might not even need to rotate them, but i want to do it and see if i notice a sharp performance difference. Doing the math, you will save a few hundred over the course of 5+ years. Im not including any time savings factor, because cleaning byrd head and rotating 150-200 inserts with a torque wrench isnt a walk in the park. Given the choice, i would always rather have the bigger and higher quality straight knife machine over a smaller or inferior quality insert cutterhead. If the $400+ initial investment for the insert head is pushing your friend towards a 6" machine, then i would advise him to go straight knife 8". IMO, you get a better surface finish from straight knives, and im very interested in trying out the Tersa system one day. Quote
Chestnut Posted November 2, 2017 Report Posted November 2, 2017 42 minutes ago, Pwk5017 said: I dont find setting knives in a jointer to be that difficult. 10 mins and i can set 3 knives within 2 thous of one another. I do think carbide inserts are the better choice in the long run--not for knife setting time, for money saved on sharpening. To sharpen three 12" knives for my machine is $20-25 locally. I have two sets that i rotate through every 6 months. Thats $80 for a spare set and then $40-50 annually. I plan on rotating my byrd inserts at the two year mark in my PM planer. I might not even need to rotate them, but i want to do it and see if i notice a sharp performance difference. Doing the math, you will save a few hundred over the course of 5+ years. Im not including any time savings factor, because cleaning byrd head and rotating 150-200 inserts with a torque wrench isnt a walk in the park. Given the choice, i would always rather have the bigger and higher quality straight knife machine over a smaller or inferior quality insert cutterhead. If the $400+ initial investment for the insert head is pushing your friend towards a 6" machine, then i would advise him to go straight knife 8". IMO, you get a better surface finish from straight knives, and im very interested in trying out the Tersa system one day. Depends on the strait knives and the segmented head. My Byrd heads in my 735 and pj882hh give a way better finish than the strait knives in the 735 ever gave me. Comparing the cut quality of the pj882 to a craftsman 6" with strait knives seems foolish but it's far superior. Quote
Pwk5017 Posted November 2, 2017 Report Posted November 2, 2017 I actually think the DW735 with OEM blades gave me a better surface finish compared to my powermatic 20" with byrd head. I know that sounds absurd given the cost difference between the two. Now, the PM kills the dewalt in speed, volume, reliability, longevity, work piece consistency, and general operation. With new/semi-new knives in my jointer, the surface is considerably better than the planer with byrd. As i mentioned, the insert heads are incredible for their ability to process a lot of material with little to no maintenance. I also appreciate the chip compaction in my cyclone bin from the byrd. My empirical findings from my PM with byrd head and a friend with 735 with byrd head is they arent the best finish cutterblocks in the world. Both leave very faint tracks in the surface, and mine is starting to rough up gnarly grain a little. Oddly enough, ive noticed the byrd will give me a tearout free cut on difficult grain if i run it against the grain, but tearout if i run with the grain. The same board fed correctly through my jointer wont result in tearout. Anyways, didnt want to beat on the insert cutterheads. I think they have a lot of pros going for them, but i do not think they are a panacea. A jointer isnt a finish tool, so i think you can easily argue why an insert head is a good choice, but i would rather have the larger or better made machine. Food for thought, 95% of large industrial jointers are straight knife. Probably the most expensive/best machine you can buy new right now is the Martin T54. A long distance friend purchased one 2-3 years ago, and i remember it being around $23-25,000 delivered. Byrd or equivalent cutterhead isnt even an option for the machine, and it's not to hit a certain price point. Quote
Chet Posted November 2, 2017 Report Posted November 2, 2017 One thing to consider that doesn't seen to be mentioned here and if it was I apologize for the repeat. But for some reason Grizzly can't seem to keep the better jointer models in stock so Drew, if your friend goes that route he may end up waiting. I am in the market for a replacement jointer right now and every time I would click on a 8 inch model that I was interested in, it was out of stock. So I have scratched grizzly off the list. I am going with a 6 inch model, probably PM. My thinking is that 95 % or more that is enough and the few times it isn't I'll go wit the other techniques to finish and the $$$ savings will go to the next tool on the list. Quote
bushwacked Posted November 2, 2017 Author Report Posted November 2, 2017 now that you mention it Chet ... they do seem to be out of stock quit often. Not sure if thats a good thing because they are selling so many or if they dont know how supply chain works or they just have to fix everything on every one and run low on parts ... according some reviews lol Quote
KenMasco Posted November 2, 2017 Report Posted November 2, 2017 I have an older 8" delta I am very happy with my buddy bought a Grizzly 490X and I have used it several times, I think it is an excellent tool Quote
Chestnut Posted November 2, 2017 Report Posted November 2, 2017 1 hour ago, Pwk5017 said: Food for thought, 95% of large industrial jointers are straight knife. Probably the most expensive/best machine you can buy new right now is the Martin T54. A long distance friend purchased one 2-3 years ago, and i remember it being around $23-25,000 delivered. Byrd or equivalent cutterhead isnt even an option for the machine, and it's not to hit a certain price point. Oh i agree that good strait knives give a better surface but the 735 knives lasted about 10 BF before they'd get a ridge and the jointer i had with strait knives was junk. For me the quality on thick cuts is crap if i run a 1/64th cut for a finish pass the quality is far far better than a thick cut. Noise was a HUGE issue with me, strait blade be noisy. Quote
bushwacked Posted November 2, 2017 Author Report Posted November 2, 2017 hmmm my 735 blades have been pretty solid so far ... about 40BF of hickory/pecan and another 20-30bf of softer woods and still no signs of issue. Maybe just a bad set? I would prefer my jointer have a fancier blade than my planer. 1 Quote
Just Bob Posted November 2, 2017 Report Posted November 2, 2017 34 minutes ago, bushwacked said: now that you mention it Chet ... they do seem to be out of stock quit often. Not sure if thats a good thing because they are selling so many or if they dont know how supply chain works or they just have to fix everything on every one and run low on parts ... according some reviews lol I just bought the 490 (straight knife model) because Grizzly was out of stock on the X. But they had the Byrd Shelix head in stock. So I just swapped heads while I was putting it together. I really like the jointer, there were no fit and finish problems, and since it is a parallelogram very easy to set up. I bought the jointer a month ago, and it was on sale, with the purchase of the spiral head it came to a couple of bucks less than the G0490x model. I did a bunch of research before I bought, I was leaning very heavily towards a PM. I just could not justify the extra grand+ for a name. During my research I found that the machines are made in the same factory, http://www.geetech.com.tw/index.php/en/strategic-partenrship-e and while I am sure there differences in QC/machine specs, between companies, I just don't think that justifies the higher price. I have always been happy with Grizzly, and I am very comfortable buying their products. I have had a shelix head in my 735 for 18 months, and I am thrilled with the cut quality. 1 Quote
Chestnut Posted November 2, 2017 Report Posted November 2, 2017 34 minutes ago, bushwacked said: hmmm my 735 blades have been pretty solid so far ... about 40BF of hickory/pecan and another 20-30bf of softer woods and still no signs of issue. Maybe just a bad set? I would prefer my jointer have a fancier blade than my planer. I ran through 4-5 sets 2 sides each. They lasted a heck of a long time with ridges i just can't give a ridge surface from a strait knife a better quality rating than the very very impreciptably wavy finish of a segmented head. Quote
gee-dub Posted November 2, 2017 Report Posted November 2, 2017 I guess I'm another one of the lucky ones. My G0490X was so well aligned of the pallet that I kept rechecking to see what I had missed. My fence was out of spec and the new one arrived in a box with a label to send the old one back. From phone call to return ship was about 4 days. I have never had to re-align the beds which is a sort of reverse-Murphy's-law thing since I had p-beds at the top of my list after owning a couple of DT-way machines. I never wanted to try to align a dovetail bed machine again and p-beds are pretty easy. Just to annoy me the thing has stayed perfect since 2008 and I use it on every project. This must just be make-up for all those Vegas visit ;-) 1 Quote
Unknown craftsman Posted November 2, 2017 Report Posted November 2, 2017 I'm fan of straight knives in the jointer and Bryd head in the planer. I've had it both reversed and found the carbide inserts unacceptable for facing lumber by hand. Now if I were into building shabby seek furniture with reclaimed lumber I could see the need. One point not talked about with straight knives is sharpness angles and using good Hss. T1 and M2 as very good. There are lower quality steels but why waste your time. Theres other simple habits that can make a straight knive machine perform well and satisfy even the perfectionist woodworker. Plus it keep the hobby interesting learning some of the old ways. Aj Quote
Chestnut Posted November 2, 2017 Report Posted November 2, 2017 39 minutes ago, Unknown craftsman said: I've had it both reversed and found the carbide inserts unacceptable for facing lumber by hand. I'm interested in what you mean by this. I've never had a finish off my HH joitner that i couldn't do something with using hand tools hand sanding or otherwise. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.