Pwk5017 Posted January 4, 2018 Report Posted January 4, 2018 Decided to rotate my inserts for the first time in 1.5-2 years of use. For all the marketing material out there that says how much time you will save over conventional straight knife cutterheads, it is complete and total crap. You save zero time, instead you turn 8 sessions of 20 minutes into one session of 2-3 hours. Marking, removing, cleaning, and torquing that many inserts is idiot work. I will be interested to see what the performance gain is, and if i even needed to rotate them at the two year mark. My concern was the slow erosion of performance over 2 years going unnoticed. I still stand by the cost effective nature of these insert heads, but the rotating process was pretty awful. Anyone do their whole cutterhead yet? Quote
Jfitz Posted January 4, 2018 Report Posted January 4, 2018 I had to do it when I first installed it - removed all the cutters and cleaned it before installing (I bought it used from someone), and then reinstalled/retorqued them all. I recall it taking a long time but I also considered it an investment - I don't fight with dull knives, and I also don't need to worry at all about which direction I run my boards (and that in itself is a time saver). Glad you got it done - and hopefully it'll be another few years before you need to do it again. Quote
shaneymack Posted January 4, 2018 Report Posted January 4, 2018 I had this conversation via PM with @toddclippinger and from what I can recall, he was at around 5 years (maybe more) and had not rotated his inserts yet and he is a professional. I was pretty surprised. Based on that, I don't intend to rotate mine for at least another 3-4 years and mine are almost 3 years old. I notice no performance issues whatsoever and I've jointer and planed some really gnarly exotics on my machines. 1 Quote
Keggers Posted January 4, 2018 Report Posted January 4, 2018 Rotating those little boogers is a painstaking operation. I can't know for sure, but unless you use your machine everyday for long hours I doubt you really needed to rotate them. On my jointer I'm more likely to rotate the nearest three rows closest to the fence as they are the ones that see the most use. I've had my jointer for almost eight years and have only rotated mine twice. It certainly isn't a fun job. I just put on some good tunes and enjoy the fact that I'm in the shop. 1 Quote
wdwerker Posted January 4, 2018 Report Posted January 4, 2018 I've got a router bit with inserts. I've cleaned it but haven't had to rotate it with around 15,000 feet of laminate trimmed with it. Still got 3 pristine edges to use. All of a sudden a $150 Festool router bit doesn't seem that expensive . 1 Quote
Chestnut Posted January 4, 2018 Report Posted January 4, 2018 idk 20 min to change blades, disposable blades lasted probably 2 months for me maybe 3 so that's 80 min a year or 160 min every 2 years vs 120-180 min for the inserts. I think it evens out. I'd bet you could run your inserts a LOT longer though. Sounds like he was averaging blade sharpening on strait knives 5 times a month or 60 times a year. So 20 min x 60 is a heck of a lot more time than 2-3 hours. Linked his thread below. Quote
Llama Posted January 4, 2018 Report Posted January 4, 2018 Faster/slower... doesn't matter to me. What does matter to me is I can rotate one cutter if it gets damaged somehow. I'm not rotating my whole set until I can see a difference. Worst case scenario is I'll have to sand at 120 or 180 instead of the 220 I can now off the machine... Doesn't seem that bad to me. Quote
Pwk5017 Posted January 4, 2018 Author Report Posted January 4, 2018 My cutterhead came to me used and i put several thousand bdft through it, which is why i decided to rotate them. I just want to get a baseline for what brand new edges do, because so far the helical design hasnt overly impressed me. I can get over the mini-ridges, but it roughs up reversing grain like crotch figure. I am a fan of insert shaper/planer cutterheads because of how cost effective they are over 5, 10, 20 years, but i also wanted to start this thread to dispel a bit of the marketing bs. I knew this process would suck a little before i started, but brushing each and every little cutter was beyond annoying. I almost wish they were single sided and disposable. I change my jointer blades 2-3 times a year, which is $20 a pop to sharpen. That right there is the reason to own carbide inserts. I think Todd's case is a little extreme, because he is planing rocks, paint and whatever other garbage clings to the reclaimed wood he works with. I once had 6-7" of linear cutting through lead paint cook a freshly sharpened resaw king. As with most mishaps, the project wasnt mine or for me. I shy away from reclaimed or dirty material 99% of the time. Quote
..Kev Posted January 4, 2018 Report Posted January 4, 2018 Just going to toss my 2 in here and I'm really not interested in debating blades vs helical. You won't change my opinion and I'm pretty sure I'm not going to change anyone elses' opinions. Helical heads are nice especially if dealing with lots of figured woods. They're also quieter than standard blades. Beyond that, they do not provide such an upgrade to warrant the pricing. Besides the pricing, they also can't take as big a bite as standard blades so, really doesn't make sense in a thickness planer. And, to top it all off, when you do need to rotate the cutters, it takes several hours which really negates the cost of just replacing straight blades. Now, with all that said, there have been times when I sure wish I had a helical head on my machines. But, in the big picture, I'm sure glad I didn't jump on that bandwagon! To me, it ranks right up there with paying a buttload more for 2 extra inches on a jointer! I'd rather save the money on both and invest in a nice drum sander. Rant over. My apologies to the OP for the rant! Quote
shaneymack Posted January 5, 2018 Report Posted January 5, 2018 1 hour ago, TIODS said: Beyond that, they do not provide such an upgrade to warrant the pricing. Says the guy that has 7k of duct work in his shop ! Hahahah Quote
..Kev Posted January 5, 2018 Report Posted January 5, 2018 1 minute ago, shaneymack said: Says the guy that has 7k of duct work in his shop ! Hahahah Spent it where it would do the most good! Quote
shaneymack Posted January 5, 2018 Report Posted January 5, 2018 1 minute ago, TIODS said: Spent it where it would do the most good! My couple hundred dollars of ductwork does the same job as your 7k. My planer and jointer with the Byrd head are a massive upgrade over my old straight knife machines. Also, one of the best upgrades I ever did was the 8" jointer. Couldn't imagine working with a 6". Next step 12" ! I guess all this stuff is perspective. Different strokes for different folks ! 1 Quote
Popular Post Llama Posted January 5, 2018 Popular Post Report Posted January 5, 2018 Just now, shaneymack said: Couldn't imagine working with a 6". Next step 16" ! FTFY 3 1 Quote
shaneymack Posted January 5, 2018 Report Posted January 5, 2018 Just now, Llama said: FTFY Even better! Hah !! Definitely upgrade my jointer before changing out my ductwork to have some fancy clamps on them! 1 Quote
..Kev Posted January 5, 2018 Report Posted January 5, 2018 1 minute ago, shaneymack said: My couple hundred dollars of ductwork does the same job as your 7k. My planer and jointer with the Byrd head are a massive upgrade over my old straight knife machines. Also, one of the best upgrades I ever did was the 8" jointer. Couldn't imagine working with a 6". Next step 12" ! I guess all this stuff is perspective. Different strokes for different folks ! How long did it take you to move that ductwork and put it all back up? I knew I was moving and will be moving it again so, well worth the cost. I happy for you that you like your machines! I'm sure that they're quite nice. However, the 8 wasn't enough and now you want 12. Wouldn't it have been better to stick with the 6 until you could get the 12? My point is that if you're buying your first machine, buy the biggest and best that you can afford. I'd rather have a drum sander than upgrade a good 6" jointer to an 8" jointer. The same goes for upgrading heads in current machines. Helical heads are nice but, they're not all that and a bag of chips. Quote
Popular Post shaneymack Posted January 5, 2018 Popular Post Report Posted January 5, 2018 6 minutes ago, TIODS said: How long did it take you to move that ductwork and put it all back up? I knew I was moving and will be moving it again so, well worth the cost. I happy for you that you like your machines! I'm sure that they're quite nice. However, the 8 wasn't enough and now you want 12. Wouldn't it have been better to stick with the 6 until you could get the 12? My point is that if you're buying your first machine, buy the biggest and best that you can afford. I'd rather have a drum sander than upgrade a good 6" jointer to an 8" jointer. The same goes for upgrading heads in current machines. Helical heads are nice but, they're not all that and a bag of chips. Lol I hear what your saying, just feeling a little frisky today. I gotta get back to work!!! Haha I am actually a little disillusioned when it comes to the duct work. I did not pay for the materials or the labour for ducts at the last house or this one. If I would have had to do it myself maybe that would have changed my opinion. 7k on ductwork is probably like 10x the price, still not sure I could justify that for something as unimportant as ducts. I was kidding about the jointer upgrade. I'm super happy with the 8", i was not with the 6". Only in my dreams do I own a 12" or 16" jointer. But a boy can dream right? This picture clearly proves your last comment wrong ! 1 2 Quote
..Kev Posted January 5, 2018 Report Posted January 5, 2018 7 minutes ago, shaneymack said: Lol I hear what your saying, just feeling a little frisky today. I gotta get back to work!!! Haha I am actually a little disillusioned when it comes to the duct work. I did not pay for the materials or the labour for ducts at the last house or this one. If I would have had to do it myself maybe that would have changed my opinion. 7k on ductwork is probably like 10x the price, still not sure I could justify that for something as unimportant as ducts. I was kidding about the jointer upgrade. I'm super happy with the 8", i was not with the 6". Only in my dreams do I own a 12" or 16" jointer. But a boy can dream right? This picture clearly proves your last comment wrong ! You're a good man Shaney! If the 8" is all you're ever going to want in your shop, then I say go for it! Buy the best one you can afford. As for the heads, I still don't think they're worth the cost on smaller machines. Maybe on the jointer but, never on a lunchbox planer. 1 Quote
Chestnut Posted January 5, 2018 Report Posted January 5, 2018 Shane should replace his koolaide avatar with a hulk one .... calm down man! lol jk Quote
Woodenskye Posted January 5, 2018 Report Posted January 5, 2018 If I was buying a new jointer, planer (not lunchbox) or combo I would invest in the helical head, but wouldn't invest the money to retrofit. Whether you have straight knives, a helical head or just a kinda fat guy like me those Doritos won't stand a chance. Quote
shaneymack Posted January 5, 2018 Report Posted January 5, 2018 31 minutes ago, TIODS said: Maybe on the jointer but, never on a lunchbox planer. I agree. I have a floor Standing 15". To me, it seemed silly to spend that kind of money and not get the helical. I definitely would not upgrade a lunch box planer though. 1 Quote
Chestnut Posted January 5, 2018 Report Posted January 5, 2018 3 minutes ago, shaneymack said: I definitely would not upgrade a lunch box planer though. I'm obviously biased because i upgraded my DW735 but i disagree. I can take a heavier cut and don't have to double bag hearing protection any more. Yes yes yes buy a 15" planer i can hear you thinking ... after the jointer fiasco i don't think I'll be trying to get any more large machinery down my stairs for a while. Quote
Unknown craftsman Posted January 5, 2018 Report Posted January 5, 2018 If you can go 7 years with rotating any inserts on a Bryd head that only proves it doesn't take a very sharp edge to cut wood if it's spinning fast enough. With the right rake angle. I did my inserts last years in my planer PM HH after a bunch of painted reclaimed wood. I could tell the machine was being pushed . Im not going to push straight knife jointers anymore now realize there's too many factors separating what makes a good jointer. Aj Quote
Cliff Posted January 5, 2018 Report Posted January 5, 2018 I say buy the drum sander then the billion inch jointer with helical head. I mean, why must it come down to "this or that" and not "this AND that!" As for inserts, I haven't had to rotate mine. I don't look forward to the process but I bet at my rate of use I don't have to do it for at least another 5 years and by that time I really do hope to upgrade to a 12" PM. Quote
gee-dub Posted January 5, 2018 Report Posted January 5, 2018 Like any activity one does for the first time, efficiency is lost due to inexperience. The first rotation of my jointer (40 inserts) took about as long as the last rotation of my planer (70-odd inserts). The key to efficiency is to setup just like you do before a glue up; all your tools and work area are positioned and at your fingertips. I have a rolling table with a t-shirt on it for a work surface, good targeted light, a can of compressed air, a small container for my mineral spirits and brush along with a small can of 3-in-1 for the threads. I am very diligent about cleaning the seats and the inserts prior to installation and the whole process was under 2 hours. I have spent a half an hour trying to get knives set in a knifed head. I do have smaller hands/fingers and I can certainly see how this would help. there are places at the ends where even my piano-fingers get jammed up. A small length of 1/4" dowel with an 1/8" rare earth magnet epoxied to it is a real helper. The main time-saving claims focus on the longer intervals between the maintenance activity. It will be easier and quicker next time. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.