JimReed Posted June 18, 2013 Report Posted June 18, 2013 I am going to bite the bullet and get a mortiser. The largest mortise I am likely to make is 3/4" (more often 1/4" and 1/2"). I often work in hardwoods (maple, cherry, oak). Having never had a mortiser before I don't have a clue whether I can get away with a smaller bench top mortiser or whether I would be better off getting a bigger floor model? Also, who makes the best mortiser chisels? I only like to buy power tools once so I want to make sure I buy a machine that is a keeper. All advice is greatly appreciated. Thanks, Jim Quote
dwacker Posted June 18, 2013 Report Posted June 18, 2013 I would not invest in a hollow chisel mortiser. Take a look at the Laguna slot mortisers even the cheaper one is more accurate, easier and produces cleaner mortices than any hollow chisel. I have a little jet HC and its a good door stop, holds up to the strongest of wind gust. Quote
rodger. Posted June 18, 2013 Report Posted June 18, 2013 I have a delta mortised 14-651 (1/2 hp) and it is pretty good. If I was to do it again, I would probably put the money towards a domino. My mortiser is a bench top model, and came with a decent chisel set. FWW gave it a very good review in their tools issue a few years ago. My main issue with it is that it doesn't have a moving table, which is a very nice feature to have. Also, I find the table top a bit small for anything but small to medium projects. The stop feature for depth is a bit crude, but gets the job done. The price was reasonable. I think I paid about 350 cdn for it. 1 Quote
wdwerker Posted June 18, 2013 Report Posted June 18, 2013 I have a delta mortised 14-651 (1/2 hp) and it is pretty good. If I was to do it again, I would probably put the money towards a domino. My mortiser is a bench top model, and came with a decent chisel set. FWW gave it a very good review in their tools issue a few years ago. My main issue with it is that it doesn't have a moving table, which is a very nice feature to have. Also, I find the table top a bit small for anything but small to medium projects. The stop feature for depth is a bit crude, but gets the job done. The price was reasonable. I think I paid about 350 cdn for it. +1 on the domino! Faster , easier and I think it is more versitale . Hollow chisel is too much work even when it is razor sharp. Quote
Trip Posted June 18, 2013 Report Posted June 18, 2013 ==> I am going to bite the bullet and get a mortiser. are you sure? a lot of guys buy a HCM and it just takes-up valuable shop space. Before plunking-down your hard earned $$, do a forum poll to see how many sit unused... if you really want a HCM, just post on the forum --- I bet some member will be happy to supply one if you offer to pick-it-up. As stated above, get a domino. Quote
G S Haydon Posted June 18, 2013 Report Posted June 18, 2013 Hello Jim Reed Let your work guide you. If you like traditional joinery and cabinet making a HCM, in my opinion, would be a great choice. If you do invest in a HCM a 3/4" mortice is heavy work even for our industrial morticers. We have two of these and a 3/4" mortice is hard going. We normally have a 1/2" bit in all the time, for cabinet work a smaller size would be good. Regarding auger & bit choice I only use the Japanese pattern. I have found they clear really quickly and cut much faster than what I would call an English Pattern On machine choice I would look out for an old industrial machine, if you can afford the space. They vary in size so you don't have to end up with a monster. In my experience older industrial machines are built so well they often last many lifetimes. I would have no idea on who would be a go to firm in the US but I follow these US based guys on Pinterest and also, in the UK at least there is a plethora of stuff on ebay. I can't give my opinion on the Domino and perhaps I'm missing a trick, I just don't think you should wright off a HCM just yet, especially if you like traditional projects. Let us know what you go for. Graham 1 Quote
CessnaPilotBarry Posted June 19, 2013 Report Posted June 19, 2013 I have a Powermatic 719T, which I bought long before the Domino was available. It's on wheels, so it doesn't take much space. If it broke, I'd buy it again, over a Domino, because: - I do a decent number of through mortises (working from both sides) - I really like the way it plays with grooves, as in mortised cope and stick doors - I'm getting more and more into period stuff, where a Domino may not be appropriate - It's super easy to roll into place, fire up, and use - I also use it to create square peg holes, both real and decorative - I've used it for mortises ranging from 1/4" to 1 3/4" wide (multiple passes, do the center last), with happy results - The TEFC motor on the 719 is quiet and pleasant to work around I'd buy a Domino instead, if: - I rarely did through mortises. - Speed was more important than traditional joinery - I was so tight for space, that three to five square feet of floor space would kill me - I did lots of angled mortises, and I didn't require traditional joinery. With my 719, I use Jet chisels. I polish the outside of new chisels with F and XF DMT plates, then an 8000 grit water stone, and sharpen the inside with a handheld cone thingie. I can't remember where I got the cone thingie. I usually set the bit gap with a nickel or a dime, depending on the species, square the edge to the rear clamp face, and I'm good to go with bit changes. Except in very rare production cases, I don't normally use the work stops. I'll mark out the mortises as I would with any other method, set the front to rear table stop to reference an edge, and use the left / right crank to cut the mortise, cutting the ends first, and finishing in the middle. I'll only fully mark out the first part, marking only the start and stop points of the ends of the slots on the others, as the fence will reference my chosen face. If you do this, all parts cut with the same setup will end up exactly referenced to the same surface, for example, the front faces of legs. I've also used the big Canadian-made General that's similar, and it's also a good machine if you got the HCT route. There are lots of places a Domino might be better. Nobody knows your work patterns and needs better than you. What's kind of funny, is that when I bought my machine, the non-HCT competition was the Multi-Router. I would definitely buy a Domino (or both Dominoes) over a Multi-Router today... 2 Quote
pghmyn Posted June 19, 2013 Report Posted June 19, 2013 Well that's a kick in the shin. I was thinking about buying one in the future. I don't plan on getting a domino in the near future. Something that really just does not bind well with my budget. If time really doesn't matter for a project, since I do it for fun, is a HCM a decent investment? Quote
PeteJr Posted June 19, 2013 Report Posted June 19, 2013 +1 on the Powermatic 719T and JET chisels Quote
Boatworks Today Posted June 19, 2013 Report Posted June 19, 2013 I also have the 719 with the powermatic chisels and really like it. For the types of designs I am interested in I feel it's a better fit for me (for many of the same reasons Cessna mentioned). That being said, if that isn't the kind of building that interests you then maybe the Domino would be a better fit. Really depends what you like to do ... Quote
krtwood Posted June 19, 2013 Report Posted June 19, 2013 You could build you own slot mortiser, http://woodgears.ca/slot_mortiser/index.html I had a Delta bench top mortiser and sold it pretty quickly. The pin in the handle broke the second time I used it. Someone decided it would be a good idea to put a shear pin in there to keep you from being able to actually apply any leverage with that long handle. Genius. I had to stick a nail through it to do anything with it. There was nothing to index the chisel square to the fence. If I ever find that doing it at the router table isn't cutting it for me anymore then I will probably build a slot mortiser. You can get square punches from Lee Valley to do the square peg thing if that's you're style. Quote
Tom King Posted June 19, 2013 Report Posted June 19, 2013 Old iron foot operated. 719. or largest Woodtek benchtop. I've had all three, and currently use the Woodtek because I need it on site sometimes. For clean edge square mortises, don't quite cut to the line with the drill in the chisel. Finish by taking the drill out. In matching some old work, often the edge of the mortise is right in a corner, so any overage from the drill bit will show. I use hand chisels for one offs rather than setting up a machine. Quote
JimReed Posted June 19, 2013 Author Report Posted June 19, 2013 Thanks for all the VERY helpful responses. I already have a Domino (and love it!) but as noted by CessnaPilotBarry, an HCT is great for through mortises and period furniture where I just feel it would be a travesty to use a Domino (no one else would know but I would know ). It sounds like the consensus is the Powermatic 719T with Jet chisels, so if anyone has one that is gathering dust but is in great shape, please let me know and I would be happy to take it off your hands! . Love this forum and appreciate all the advice. Jim Quote
Trip Posted June 19, 2013 Report Posted June 19, 2013 ==> so if anyone has one that is gathering dust but is in great shape, please let me know and I would be happy to take it off your hands! . I'd post in the 'MarketPlace' section. I suspect you can pick-up one cheap if you offer to pick it up... Quote
rodger. Posted June 19, 2013 Report Posted June 19, 2013 Well that's a kick in the shin. I was thinking about buying one in the future. I don't plan on getting a domino in the near future. Something that really just does not bind well with my budget. If time really doesn't matter for a project, since I do it for fun, is a HCM a decent investment? I have cut mortise and tenon joints by hand with a nice saw, a drill, some chisels, a shoulder plane, and a router plane. If time is not a major concern, that would be my preferred method. Very relaxing and quiet. My usual method does include the mortiser, however. I normally cut the tenons flat on then TS, and cut the mortises on the HCM. Clean up the tenons with a shoulder plane and block plane. The mortises usually are good to go off of the machine, but occasionally I clean them up a bit with a chisel. Quote
pghmyn Posted June 20, 2013 Report Posted June 20, 2013 I have cut mortise and tenon joints by hand with a nice saw, a drill, some chisels, a shoulder plane, and a router plane. If time is not a major concern, that would be my preferred method. Very relaxing and quiet. My usual method does include the mortiser, however. I normally cut the tenons flat on then TS, and cut the mortises on the HCM. Clean up the tenons with a shoulder plane and block plane. The mortises usually are good to go off of the machine, but occasionally I clean them up a bit with a chisel.I'm not much of a hand tool person. Although I do want to invest in some quality chisels. Quote
mikem Posted June 21, 2013 Report Posted June 21, 2013 I'm not much of a hand tool person. Although I do want to invest in some quality chisels. Famous last words. I said that a couple years ago. Now I just finished build a hand tool cabinet half full with hand tools, planning to fill it completely. Quote
wilburpan Posted June 21, 2013 Report Posted June 21, 2013 I am going to bite the bullet and get a mortiser. The largest mortise I am likely to make is 3/4" (more often 1/4" and 1/2"). I often work in hardwoods (maple, cherry, oak). Hello Jim Reed Let your work guide you. If you like traditional joinery and cabinet making a HCM, in my opinion, would be a great choice. If you do invest in a HCM a 3/4" mortice is heavy work even for our industrial morticers. We have two of these and a 3/4" mortice is hard going. We normally have a 1/2" bit in all the time, for cabinet work a smaller size would be good. To Jim: what is it that you envision the need for a 3/4" wide mortise? Mortises in that range tend to be for projects involving large beams, like timberframing. Furniture scale projects rarely require a mortise much larger than 1/4", and if you really needed a mortise that was 3/4" wide, there's an argument to be made that making twin 1/4" mortise and tenons would be a better way to go. At the very least, you could make a 3/4" mortise with a hollow chisel mortiser by running a 1/4" mortise up and down both sides of the mortise, and wasting out the middle with a Forstner bit. That would be easier overall than trying to plunge a 3/4" mortise chisel all at once. Quote
Tpt life Posted June 21, 2013 Report Posted June 21, 2013 Wilbur, I have never seen so narrow a tenon as 3/4" in timber framing. I rarely see less than 1.5". I see plenty 3/4" tenon in door and window joinery as well as trestle table tenons up to 1.5". 1 Quote
pghmyn Posted June 21, 2013 Report Posted June 21, 2013 Famous last words. I said that a couple years ago. Now I just finished build a hand tool cabinet half full with hand tools, planning to fill it completely. Not that I do not like hand tools, but they are not in my immediate future. I would like to eventually assemble an arsenal of top notch hand tools like a smoothing plane, jack plane, block plane, and a shoulder plane. A dovetail saw and fret saw would be up there, too. I would like everything in my shop, but hand tools are not my priority at the moment. But that will change Quote
G S Haydon Posted June 21, 2013 Report Posted June 21, 2013 Wilbur, I have never seen so narrow a tenon as 3/4" in timber framing. I rarely see less than 1.5". I see plenty 3/4" tenon in door and window joinery as well as trestle table tenons up to 1.5". +1 on that C, on western style joinery and framing at least. 3/4 is a joinery scale mortice. But Wilbur's recommendation is sound. He makes a very good point about using a narrower chisel and taking two passes. Often quicker than changing tooling and suffering arm pump on larger size chisels. Quote
Tom King Posted June 22, 2013 Report Posted June 22, 2013 Here's a picture of me cutting mortises with a chisel. This is about as low tech as you get. A couple of helpers hand holding the board in place on sawhorses. This was a heart pine board to replace a rotted out top wainscoting rail. Windows had been missing from this house for 50 years, and this was one small result. The rail it's replacing is on the saw horses beside it. There were only 4 mortises, and they were all spaced differently from the face of the board so no contest between chisel or machine. The mill marks you see on the board in the picture shows how we received the board from the supplier. It was hand planed before being put in place. If we are making a bunch of mortises, we'll use a machine. For just a few, it's quicker on site to bring out the chisels. http://www.historic-house-restoration.com/images/ElamsHouse_Oct._2012_045.JPG The next picture shows that section of wainscoting, with the rail replaced, as well as the baseboard, and middle panel, and you might be able to see the new floor board repairs too. Still some more small molding pieces to make in that picture, but we usually do all the big stuff, and then any little pieces that go on top. All mortises and tenons were cut to match the old ones. http://www.historic-house-restoration.com/images/ElamsHouse_Oct._2012_052.JPG Quote
ModernistWoodworker Posted February 8, 2014 Report Posted February 8, 2014 Wow, not a lot of love for the HCM here I see I wasn't sold on them either until I took a Joinery class at the William Ng School last month. Aside from his famous sharpening pond (which probably still contains a lot of my drool...but that's another blog post), my favorite tool we used in his shop was the General 75-075 HCM. William being William, he had us cutting VERY precise mortise and tenon joints (measured to the 5 thousands of a inch with his Mitutoyo calipers). And given what we were making, it needed to be that precise. Check out these three way miter joints for example. No clue how you could cut these by hand and make them fit, or even go the drill+Mortise chisel route. So since I've gotten back, have been patiently waiting on Craigslist for a floor standing model with an adjustable bed to come up for sale for <$1k Quote
Rick LoDico Posted February 9, 2014 Report Posted February 9, 2014 For chisels, look at the Austrian-made Delta or Clico. Plan on around 50.00 per. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.