Recommended Posts

Posted

I'm contemplating buying a Domino DF500.  I have some questions for those of you who are "in the know":

 

1.  Other than the speed of creating mortises, how much better is the Domino vs. cutting mortises with a router and/or router table and making my own loose tenons?

 

2.  I can't afford to buy the dust extractor at the same time.  Is this a deal breaker?  I do have a dust collector and a couple of shop vacs. Can I compromise until the purchase of a dust collector is possible?

 

3.  I've used Imperial scale my whole life.  Yeah, they said when I was in high school we were changing to the metric system, but that didn't happen so I'm metric-stupid.  How much of a hassle is the conversion?

 

4.  Does anyone use Dominos to align face frames?  Just curious.  

 

5.  Tell me all the reasons it will improve my woodworking and the reasons it will hamper.  

 

This is a LOT of money for me to spend, so I really value y'alls advice.

 

Thanks!

Posted

In a word, yes.

I hummed and hawed over it for a while, but bought one a while back. Totally worth it. But don't kid yourself, it's a pure luxury. There are many ways to make mortise and tenon joints, and they don't cost what a festool does.

I used a regular shop vac for a while until I eventually bought the ct26. The regular vac worked just fine, but needed an adaptor to fit the dust extraction point in the domino. It got in the way of my hand, but still worked fine.

I have used it for face frames, and will use again in the future. Pocket screws are still faster and easier, if you have a pocket hole jig and the frames reverse sie will be 100% hidden. Otherwise, dominos are a great choice.

Check out my refiew in the reviews section.

Posted

1) Speed is what the domino is really all about. Better no its a hole in wood both make clean mortises.

2) Shop vac is just fine.

3) Metric is no big deal you will get he hang of it.

4) Face frames no way to many clamps needed pocket holes are easier and faster.

5) It will make you lazy. :) But more seriously if you use the old school method of calculating M&T sizes and then find the closest      Domino or make your own domino it will do the same job. BUT that quite possibly means you need both the bigger and smaller machines. If you don't care about that sort of stuff then it doesn't matter. 

 

Personally I would just get a Jessem Paraline and a bench brush for the saw dust. If you decide down the road when you feel more comfortable spending the money then step up to the convenience of a Domino. If you prefer more traditional work then I'd do a slot mortiser. I have a trick to having a good slot mortiser for a less than the smaller domino.

Posted

==>Domino worth it?

There are sooooooooooooooooo many Domino threads, Domino -vs- XL threads, Better BBQ w/ Domino threads (just kidding)... There can't be any more to say on the matter... Just search the WTO forums...

 

In a nutshell, some find it transformative, some very useful, some useful, some take-it-or-leave-it and a few maintain that it’s a waste of money... You will get out of it what you expect... Find a project that lends itself to loose tenon joinery, spend the $3K for a Domino 500, Domino XL 700 and CT26 ---- try it all for 30 days, keep the stuff you like -- or not...

Posted

PB, The Jessem Paraline you refer to, can you provide a link please. I googled it and found feather boards and other things. Is it a doweling jig.

Thanks

  • Like 1
Posted

Santa brought me one for Christmas.  So, I would say yes.  I am still getting used to it, and I too was on the fence for a long while, but I am glad I went for it.  I think with any FESTOOL you will feel that way. 

 

miw

Posted

Brett build a pretty nice loose mortise jig  just make a simple jig for what ever project i'm need LM for some scrap and glue, pocket holes down and dirty straight bit and bushing your in business. 

Posted

I have one and will soon be adding the XL to the collection as well. I love it and never regretted the purchase.

With that said, it is a luxury. Unless you're doing it for a living and really need to increase speed, you can accomplish the same task in several other ways.

So, in the end, only you and your wallet can decide if it's a tool that should be in your shop.

Posted

Since we're on the topic, how about alternatives? Is a good mortising machine, which is much cheaper, a good alternative. Leigh's super fmt Jig? Others?

I wasn't clear about face frames. I was thinking about attaching face frame to cabinet. I love my Kreg jig

Posted

Since we're on the topic, how about alternatives? Is a good mortising machine, which is much cheaper, a good alternative. Leigh's super fmt Jig? Others?

I wasn't clear about face frames. I was thinking about attaching face frame to cabinet. I love my Kreg jig

You can make jigs, but the leigh fmt is more than the domino.
Posted

I love my Domino. I used it for several years with my shop vac. You can add bits as you go,depending on what size dominos you need for a project. I rarely use the FT accessory jigs. I use my aftermarket "Domiplate" on a daily basis.

I rarely use my biscuit machine since I got my domino .

A small metric ruler does help some with layout work, but it isn't nessacary .

Posted

I love my domino 500 and use it a ton. The metric part isn't too big a deal. Just convert when you need to and it'll be fine.

I rarely use the accessory that centers the machine on a narrow piece (like the ends of rails) and never use the one that extends out the stops. I bought the domino assortment of sizes and cutters and while that was expensive it was a nice deal and I'm quite glad I did. I have used almost all the sizes in one project or another and though I've used quite a few dominos I still have plenty left. Plus the organizer/systainer is quite nice.

Whether it's worth it or not is pretty much the same decision as any other tool that takes a task and makes it faster/easier. As others have said, there are plenty of ways to accomplish the same thing with tools/jigs that you already have or are substantially cheaper. But nothing I've seen matches the speed, convenience, and ease of setup/use of the domino. Whether that convenience/speed is worth the price to you is a personal decision.

Posted

Im so glad this topic was made. I am also contemplating purchasing the DF500. The one for $850. My question is, will I need to buy anything more than what it comes with?

 

I bought the set that's 925, and the assortment of tenons with the cutters.

 

I like the trim stop for centering on end grain, set it up once for a project like rails and stiles for a face frame and it's really fast, I was mortising faster than I could change the piece in the clamp. I haven't used the cross stop yet, however I can see it being useful for evenly spacing without having to do layout lines once you have a registration mortise.

Posted

I bought the set that's 925, and the assortment of tenons with the cutters.

 

I like the trim stop for centering on end grain, set it up once for a project like rails and stiles for a face frame and it's really fast, I was mortising faster than I could change the piece in the clamp. I haven't used the cross stop yet, however I can see it being useful for evenly spacing without having to do layout lines once you have a registration mortise.

 

I bought the tenon assortment and cutters as well - totally forgot about that!

Posted

I'm contemplating buying a Domino DF500.  I have some questions for those of you who are "in the know":

 

1.  Other than the speed of creating mortises, how much better is the Domino vs. cutting mortises with a router and/or router table and making my own loose tenons?

 

2.  I can't afford to buy the dust extractor at the same time.  Is this a deal breaker?  I do have a dust collector and a couple of shop vacs. Can I compromise until the purchase of a dust collector is possible?

 

3.  I've used Imperial scale my whole life.  Yeah, they said when I was in high school we were changing to the metric system, but that didn't happen so I'm metric-stupid.  How much of a hassle is the conversion?

 

4.  Does anyone use Dominos to align face frames?  Just curious.  

 

5.  Tell me all the reasons it will improve my woodworking and the reasons it will hamper.  

 

This is a LOT of money for me to spend, so I really value y'alls advice.

 

Thanks!

 

1.  I'm a 2 year old WWer, so I'm pretty new to the adventure.  Got a domino a few months ago.  Up to that point I'd done about 2 dozen M&T with a router and dado set.  Each one would take me nearly an hour to get an acceptable fit.  With the domino, the first one I cut was as good as any 'traditional' ones I had done before and it took me about 10 minutes (about 7 of that was figuring out how to clamp the piece down).  So speed is #1 for me.  

 

It also allows tolerance in the process.  Example:  for a door frame, I dont worry about getting the mortise exactly centered on the thickness of the wood or on the left/right position.  I eyeball the height so I'm close to center, line up the two pieces and mark a line across both, then cut.  Its much more forgiving than spending a lot of time making sure you have equal shoulder width around the tenon and that the mortise is Goldie Locks right in the middle of too wide or too narrow.

 

2.  No.  I bought the Bosch hose on Amazon for something like $30-40.  It fits the dust port on the DF, and the other end fit directly to my old crappy shop vac.  When I use it, I get virtually no dust/debris left over from cutting the mortises.

 

3.  No.  See the second part of #1.  I dont worry too much about exact measurements.  as long as you mark the two pieces accurately, and line up the center mark on the DF with your mark; you are good to go.  I'm sure that there are uses where figuring out exact measurements are necessary, but I haven't run across them yet.

 

4.  You could, but I wouldn't unless I had a spot where I couldn't hide pocket holes and didn't want to use pin nails.

 

5.  Improve - it's less complex to mark out your pieces to make a mortise, so there is less room for error there.  I find that its easier to get near perfect fitting joints, so my projects look better.  And its far less time for me, like a quarter of the time it would take me with a router and dado stack.

 

Hinder - some see it as cheating or a shortcut.  I dont, but some do.  There is probably less sense of accomplishment for making that perfect joint with hand.   tools.   You could become too reliant on this easy way to do it, and if you run into a situation where you can't use the domino and need to do something by hand, you haven't developed the skills to do so.  I'm really reaching there.

Posted

==>how about alternatives?

On the used market, a horizontal mortiser...

Go to grizzly buy the $500 horizontal boring machine. Don't install the motor. Go to any hobby Cnc supplier they are all over the web. Buy a router mount for $90. Install the mount in place of the induction motor. Any router like a pc690 or similar is fine. Now you have a slot mortised and it will cut shoulders on tenon along with other misc cuts.

If you feel the need for big hp then use a big router. If you feel the need to have serious power buy a spindle for the same price as a big router. If you have a spare router investment is about $600 if not pc motors are inexpensive. Cut mortises up to 1/2 thick wth a small router as deep as your cutter will go and any width.

Posted

If you use it it's worth the money. Good tools are almost never a mistake to purchase and the Domino is a good tool. Don't forget, you can easily make longer mortises and use your own tenons. With a little work you can even make wider mortises by plunging from both sides of a board then cleaning up the "heart shaped" ends with a chisel.

Posted

Thanks to everyone for the advice! There's no better place to get help than on this forum. I'm going to put off the purchase of a Domino for a while. I've decided there are other tools that can have a greater impact in my woodworking growth and enjoyment. Besides, Wdwerker's shop's not that far away and I'll just go borrow his if I need one - LOLOLOL.

You guys are great. Thanks for your help!!!

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 45 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,008
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Bob44
    Newest Member
    Bob44
    Joined