Recommended Posts

Posted

Hello everyone. Long time since my last post, since I have had nothing interesting to speak of since school started and my life has been school, research, and work. But I come to you all as an unbiased source of information for my situation.

My wife (I'm finally married!) and I decided the next big upgrade is windows for the house. Big cost expenditure, and a really worth while one as well. My windows are single pane glass with almost all the glazing dried out and cracking off. I have three different window styles in my house, and they are all terrible. I can sit on my couch and with enough of a breeze outside it feels like someone is sitting behind me trying to get my attention by blowing in my ear and down my neck.

Let me give you the run down of windows:
10 double hung windows, typical size
1 bathroom slider
1 large picture window in my living room

I've gone to two companies and received quotes.

Company 1 (big name brand with lots of employees/overhead)
$11,000 - but if you order by the end of the month, $8,500! (ha...)
Their company makes the windows.

Company 2 (small local guy that does the quoting, ordering, installing...basically no overhead)
$4,000
(Windows are the brand "Mastic" by PlyGem)

Problem with the local guy is that he doesn't have reviews plastered all over the internet like the big name brands. It makes me nervous to hire a small time contractor with those shows on TV that twist me into thinking everyone is a crook. I liked and appreciated his honesty, to a point where I didn't actually feel pressured with him here. I felt better customer service from the small local guy than I did with the big name brand.

I mentioned that I wanted new doors, and immediately the big name company said their cheapest door is $3,000 minimum per door. The local guy said that he can order a door from his supplier and install it, but he can save me money if I pick out exactly what I want at home depot/menards/lowes/or wherever and he just charges me for installation. He measured and gave me all the dimensions that I need to look for if I chose this route.

I know that quotes are usually done in groups of three, but with the two that I have now, I am heavily leaning toward the local business. Is there something I can do to ensure I will not be (lack of a better term) screwed if he tries to swindle me?

Posted

Ask for references at the very least. I personally would go with the small guy if he sounds like he knows what he's talking about but you've gotta get references and follow up with them on how his work panned out.  

Posted

To each his own but...

We put steel siding on our house just last year. I got bids from five different places and four of them were within $2000.00 of each other and one was so cheap it scared the bejesus out of me! Two were "out of town'ers"  and three were "local".

There is something to be said about quality and cost and what you expect from the result.

We ended up going with the most expensive because they had done work for us before and we knew that they were pricy but, we've been very happy with the result. They are a local company so if we do have a problem, we know where to go to get it resolved

It took six weeks and $20,000.00 but, as I was here watching the workers all the time, IT WAS WORTH ALL OF IT!

Posted

I'd also agree to ask for references of his past work.  Call up a few of the people and ask them about how they felt the whole process went with him and if in the end they felt satisfied with his service.  Make sure to ask if they would use him again if there was a need.  Repeat customers generally mean they were pleased with the service/quality.

Its smart to be wary of getting screwed by everyone though, not just the little guys.  I know seeing the many home improvement shows on TV about hiring the wrong guy can make you think twice before saying yes to someone.

Posted (edited)

I replaced all the windows in my house with Millguard vinyl double pane, Double hung windows. Eight windows and the front door. Total cost of the windows was less than $2,000. I had the first four installed by  the company that supplied the windows, instalation was about $100 each but was so simple to do I installed the rest and the door myself! I've had them now for several years and couldn't be happier!

Edited by Strasberry
Posted

I had windows installed last year and I went with one of the big name brands (Marvin).   I have seen a lot of crappy installs.  My windows look original.  I did a full frame replacement (rather than an insert).   Personally I think you are better off going with the andersen/pella/marvins of the world.  They warranty the product AND the installation.  With the small guy who is providing the warranty on the installation?  If something fails, who steps up to the plate?  In all likelihood the installer will blame the manufacturer and vice versa.

 

 

 

Posted

You have two "far apart" quotes I think I would really search out at least one but probably two more quotes to see were you really are.  Mike is right you need to find out how all the warranty will be handled from the local guy and in writing, everything in writing.

Posted (edited)

Just got off the phone with the company that did the windows on my brother's house.

$5370 he said was the max that would be charged to me. There is wiggle room to go lower, but it will not go any higher. This was an over the phone consultation, and he will be coming out this weekend to give me a more in depth viewing.

All the companies that I went to do the work from the outside and do not touch the inside trim. I want to have the inside trim replaced since it is painted in some rooms, stained in others, some is very weathered from where previous owners let them get soaking wet. I will probably end up doing this trim myself, since I'm sure I can handle it.

I'm going to my brother's house today to look over his windows and see what he thinks about them.

Edited by pghmyn
Posted

I have been struggling with the same decision recently. With the super El Niño predicted, I think it's time to fix the leak in the garage roof and put up some gutters. I got three quotes, first guy showed up an hour and a half late, that's an automatic dq for me. The larger company with a big advertising presence came in about what I expected, and a smaller local company price was about 60% of the bigger company. 

What I like about the smaller guy is that he says " by your garage, I see you are handy, if you want to tear off the existing  material the day before we come out, I'll drop $500 from the price."   I yelped both and both have some quality reviews but the price difference does sort of scare me..

Posted

Just got off the phone with the company that did the windows on my brother's house.

$5370 he said was the max that would be charged to me. There is wiggle room to go lower, but it will not go any higher. This was an over the phone consultation, and he will be coming out this weekend to give me a more in depth viewing.

All the companies that I went to do the work from the outside and do not touch the inside trim. I want to have the inside trim replaced since it is painted in some rooms, stained in others, some is very weathered from where previous owners let them get soaking wet. I will probably end up doing this trim myself, since I'm sure I can handle it.

I'm going to my brother's house today to look over his windows and see what he thinks about them.

You are paying for 3 things

1) windows

2) installation

3) warranty

You need to figure out how much you are paying for each of those on an apples to apples comparison. A single double hung window can be $100 or $1000 (or more), depending on the materials, quality, etc.  You really can't compare the overall quote without understanding the differences in materials.

In my case, the installer was a local (but big) company and factory certified installer for Pella, Andersen, Marvin and Simonton, among others 

They showed me windows at different price points, brands, and materials so i could compare the physical quality and build differences.   The cheapest window they showed me was half the cost of the window I bought.   

 

 

Posted

Another thing that is important, especially here in California, because there are so many fly by nights, is I want to see a license.  Not just a handy man certificate, If I am having a roof put on I want to see a roofing license.  To many things to worry about much less if you will ever be able to take proper steps against the company because there are no state records of the guy ever being in business.  95% are upstanding but all it takes is one and you could end up paying twice.  Its like Tom C. says when buying tools "Pay once cry once"

Posted

Company 1 sounds like Weathertight. Avoid them.

We went with Feldco, and love them. Had our whole house done, no issues. They even wrapped the garage door trim, and gutters on the garage for free.

 

Posted

Company 1 sounds like Weathertight. Avoid them.

We went with Feldco, and love them. Had our whole house done, no issues. They even wrapped the garage door trim, and gutters on the garage for free.

 

Company 1 was actually Feldco.

I'm sure that I've made my decision, and narrowed it down to warranty reasons - along with quality. The last company that I called is the one that did the windows for my brother. This company happens to be Window World. They gave me a ballpark estimate over the phone without seeing my house, because I was just curious. He said the price of $5370 is the max, and it can only go down depending on what he sees when he comes out here, and options that I want.

My brother paid $5500 for 14 windows, so I think that my price should go down just a little. Either way, I'm happy with the product that they installed at my brother's home. The inside and outside look clean. The windows perform well, and look aesthetically pleasing. I am choosing to go with this company because they are well known, have a market presence, and offer a lifetime warranty. Only thing that makes me shy away from the small guy is the fact that he does offer a warranty, but what if he is not around in 5 years if something goes wrong with the installation?

As much as I would like to support the local business, as I really liked this guy, I don't want to take a risk that my warranty will go up in smoke. Is there some way around that?

Posted

I have installed many of many brands. There are no absolutes. Each manufacturer excels at different things. If your brother is happy and you like what you see, don't fear that you are missing out. The vinyl weld introduction means that there are hundreds, if not thousands, of quality local shops that can custom build to your order economically. The fixtures, the sweeps, and the fit all depend on the mechanics of the window. Each window should come certified with federal numbers for air penetration. This is the critical number. 

Posted

Anyway... Back to being a llama...

I am a little surprised at the pricing for the windows from Feldco.

 

I didn't think it would be quite that high, although I was expecting them to be my highest quote. I just didn't like that the guy seemed incredibly pushy.

I have installed many of many brands. There are no absolutes. Each manufacturer excels at different things. If your brother is happy and you like what you see, don't fear that you are missing out. The vinyl weld introduction means that there are hundreds, if not thousands, of quality local shops that can custom build to your order economically. The fixtures, the sweeps, and the fit all depend on the mechanics of the window. Each window should come certified with federal numbers for air penetration. This is the critical number. 

I was happy with what I saw from the local guy, but if something on the installation end malfunctions and this guy is out of business, who is going to cover my warranty?

Posted

One word of advice, when you tear the trim off, pull all the old insulation out and use the door and window expanding foam. It is, IMHO, much better than insulation for that application. 

Posted

We bought Pella. They sent people out twice to measure and make sure they had the right dimensions. They had no problem with our local guy installing them and said the warranty stands no matter who installed them. They wanted around $400.00 a window to install, we got it done for $78.00 a window. Our heating bills went from six -seven hundred a month to three to four hundred. 

You might want to check with your local utility company. Some of them are offering to help pay for windows and insulation. We had our whole house insulated for around $400.00 and Ameren paid the rest.  Just a thought.

Posted

Check with the manufacturer about warranty service if your local installer should leave the business. Read the mfg install specifications and document that the installer has followed them. This should apply to any installer not just the small local guy.

Posted

If you've got mostly double-hung windows and the exterior of the jambs are in good shape you might want to get a quote for sash replacements from your local lumberyard. It'll be a lot cheaper than removing the old windows and installing new ones. Unless your old windows have  sash cords and lead weights...

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   2 Members, 0 Anonymous, 56 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,009
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Joseph b
    Newest Member
    Joseph b
    Joined