Recommended Posts

Posted

I am looking to upgrade my table saw and I am looking at the Sawstop but I am debating on how much I actually need. 1.5HP, 1.75HP or 3HP ... I really think I can live with 1.5/1.75. 

However my main question comes with the models and how they will stand up over time and perform.

The Sawstop Jobsite, Contractor, or Professional.

The jobsite I was thinking if I get that, I would build it into my outfeed table (like a Ron Paulk type style) outfeed but with some more permanent solution. Like a shelf that it is bolted down to or something. I think if I bolt it down tight and maybe add some padding under it, it would help dampen the vibration to almost nothing since it would be attached to a big wooden heavy outfeed table.

The contractor would be a stand alone, but I worry about vibration from that being not heavy cast iron contruction. It would drive me crazy to hear it rattle or something like that due to not the professional heavy cast iron construction

The professional, would be the end all be all, everything is amazing with - If I go that route I would have a harder time deciding on motor HP.


Now as far as rip fence length, is it easier to spend the extra money on the 52" and be done with it, or is buying an aftermarket rip fence rail setup easy enough to add to any of the above models? Mainly this would be on the jobsite and contractor setups if I go with them to get the full 50-52" extension. The professional I would just suck up and pay for it since it would be the rolls royce purchase.

 

Thoughts? Am I missing something here?

Posted

I don't know about the Sawstop version, but 52" rails on most jobsite saws would be a total hack. Also consider that jobsite saws usually have smaller motors, and achieve the HP rating by running at a higher RPM. I suggest going with at least the contractor style saw, unless the portability of the jobsite saw is a deciding factor. Sawstop make quality stuff, or so I hear. I doubt vibration is going to be an issue.

  • Like 1
Posted

Don't get the job site unless you actually need the portability. 

With the fence systems, just don't get the 30" which I think is a lesser fence.  If you don't think you'll ever use an aftermarket fence system, maybe just go 52" if you want the capacity.  Otherwise try 36" and see how you like it...can always upgrade with aftermarket.  If you happen to be considering the Incra system in particular, you can get the 36" version and just slide the rails to the right and get 48" right-side rip capacity (but basically 0 on the left which is probably ok).  Saves some money on the longer Incra version. 

For 1.75 vs 3, it's hard.  Few that have 3 are ever going to say they wish they had less or have any awareness of when having less would have been a problem.  For the guy with 3 bogs down, it's his problem with the board or how he's doing the cut or whatever....if the guy with 1.75 bogs down, he's like "wish I had the 3".  Very subjective opinions.  Mike on the forum has 1.75 and has said he wished he had 3...can probably give examples of situations that highlighted that wish. 

Posted

I would stay away from a jobsite saw. If budget is the issue then the jobsite saw is a consideration. If you have the budget to get a stationary saw, definitely go that route. If budget is not an issue and you are doing installs on site and need something portable, get a cabinet saw for the shop and a jobsite saw for the jobsite.

Currently I have a sawstop pcs 3hp with 52" rails and a bosch jobsite saw. My last table saw was a general contractor saw, so I have some experience with the three types you are inquiring about. My contractor saw was 1.5 hp and had 52" rails. It served me very well but its obviously not in the same class as a cabinet saw. The cabinet saw has less vibration, is more accurate, and has way better dust collection. The 3hp motor is not a "need" but if you are getting a cabinet saw I don't see why you would opt for the smaller motor as the price difference is negligible. If you have the space get the 52" rails. Its much easier to cut them then to get longer rails if in the long run you decide you need them. I have them and don't really need them but the long table is nice for putting lumber and my radio lol. If you have a track saw to cut down sheet goods then the 52" rails become even more useless. 

My recommendation, Sawstop PCS 3hp with with the 36" or the 52" rails. Dont forget the overhead dust arm as an accessory. it is amazing. 

Posted

I'd echo what everyone else is saying with regard to jobsite saws - don't get one unless you absolutely need the portability.  

I have the Sawstop PCS3HP like Shane, but I have the 36" fence. As Ross said, if you go with the PCS then definitely get the 36" or the 52", as the 30" is an inferior fence system.  

Have you seen the saw in person?  Even the 36" is huge, and unless you're regularly processing sheetgoods (and don't have a track saw), I think you'd rather have the extra shop space than the extra 16" that will probably end up just collecting clutter.  I personally went for the 36" because I don't work with sheetgoods much and I have a TS55 anyway.

If you're going to buy the "Rolls Royce", why skimp and go with 1.75HP?  Getting the 3HP seems like a no brainer at that point.  I've never felt like I needed more power, but I've definitely felt like I was glad I had the 3 instead of 1.75 (building the Roubo being one example).

If you're looking for someone to chime in and tell you to buy less saw, you've come to the wrong place :)

  • Like 1
Posted (edited)

I would buy as big and as heavy duty as you can afford and have the space for. I have a 3 hp PM66 that my Dad bought new almost 30 years ago. The only problem I have had with it was the capacitor start on the motor went out, and that was earlier this year. 

Edited by CT Proctor
Posted

I have the PCS 36" 1.75 hp with the dust collection and the top drawer mobile base. It's an amazing saw and to date have not needed or wanted the 3 hp but if I win the lottery I'll get one! Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Posted

Woodshops need cabinet saws IMO.  The PCS is awesome but if you can't afford it I'd rather buy a 3HP Grizzly than a contractor or jobsite SS.

<Insert catch phrase>

What's two grand over the course of a lifetime?

Posted

I just got a SS PCS with 36" rails. After living with a contractor saw with 52" rails for 15 years I decided I needed a better saw, but prefer the shorter rails. That's completely a personal preference. But as others have mentioned, the 30" fence is really inferior. I can't understand why they would even sell it, considering the quality of the rest of the saw.

Posted

Woodshops need cabinet saws IMO.  The PCS is awesome but if you can't afford it I'd rather buy a 3HP Grizzly than a contractor or jobsite SS.

<Insert catch phrase>

What's two grand over the course of a lifetime?

 didI just read eric say something  nice  (ish) about griz..

Posted

It's only an endorsement of practicality.  I would find it really tough to give up so much saw for just the safety feature.  As a side note, my Grizzly table saw is the one Grizzly I have no complaints about.  No major complaints.  That may change in the future.  Stay tuned.

Posted

I have the PCS with the 36 inch fence and the 1.75 HP.  I am very happy with the set up.  I had looked at the 3 HP and like Shane mentioned the price wasn't that much different but the price of getting 220 to the place where the saw was just wasn't in the budget at the time.  The 1.75 HP is serving me well I really haven't had any regrets about that so far.  At the time I would have liked the 52 inch fence but I didn't want to give up the space.  Now looking back it has been a good decision, I don't do that much with sheet goods and there are other ways to brake it down and the real big plus is I ended up having a nice place to put the Supermax 19-38 that wouldn't have happened with the 52 inch.

Posted

I don't own one yet, but I'm lusting, I mean looking.  

Lot of good opinions already aired, 

I'll throw in this point:  if you do choose the Professional model you're going to be spending a good bit of money.  What's the chances you'll feel good about doing that again later in life or are you going to be living with this saw  for a long time, i.e forever.  So for me in that situation, I'm going to spend a little more now and get that 3 hp motor, and probably the other accessories.  

Side note on the 220v comment from ChetK.  If you are getting a new 220v power tool to use on an existing or new circuit find out from the manufacturer which of the, and I kid you not, 14 different types of NEMA 220v plugs it uses.  

By the by the SawStop professional uses NEMA type 6-15.  

Posted

thanks everyone for the opinions I appreciate it! 

Sounds like jobsite is a no go completely ... 

The contractor is a mediocre option ...

The professional is where I need to be if I am getting a sawstop, otherwise go with a grizzly 3HP for like $1700 or maybe even a PM1000 for $2000 (I think if I go non sawstop I may end up with a PM1000 due to it being a PM) even though I am getting less HP

It also sounds like I need at minimum the 36" rip capacity due to the higher quality construction on it as well.

Posted

yes, I am needing to decide if I really have room for the 52" or just deal with the 36" I think that would be a good reason to by a nice tracksaw to break down sheet goods and stick with the smaller 36"

Posted

Depends on you.  If your work requires you to crosscut full sheets of ply on your table saw and rip 12/4 hard maple all day, that saw would make sense.  For me it would be a waste of power and space.  I only have about a 27" rip capacity on my table saw...I crosscut long or wide parts with my Kapex or TS55.

5HP sounds like fun but 3 is always adequate in my hobby shop.

Posted (edited)

Yes, overkill.    get the 3hp sawstop or powermatic.    3hp is enough for a hobby shop.  The quality (PM/sawstop) and safety feature (sawstop) are worth the extra dough.  

Yeah if you're at 2100 with the Grizz, why not just buy the PM2000 on black friday for 15% off at 2550?  That would be my suggestion.  If you're willing to pay over 2k, then just buy the PM2000 on black friday.  If you're willing to pay over 3k, then buy the sawstop (if you care about the safety feature....if not then just buy the PM2K).

Edit:  Keep in mind too that Grizzly prices don't include freight.  So unless you're picking it up yourself, the PM2k on black friday and the grizz you mentioned above for 2100 are probably pretty close in price.

Edited by bgreenb
Posted

"Contractor" is not a mediocre option.  A quality contractor can do a fine job.  I'm happy with mine as are many others. 

Nobody mentioned the hybrids.  They give you the form factor and adjustability of the cabinet saw with the more modest weight of the contractor saw.  There are some nice ones under $1,000.  Right now I'm looking toward Spring and a chance to upgrade.  There are several out there for evaluation:

http://www.searsoutlet.com/1-3-4-HP-Premium-Hybrid-10-Table-Saw-22116-/d/product_details.jsp%3Fmd%3Dct_md%26cid%3D1224%26pn%3D1%26ps%3D25%26pid%3D32628&mode=buyUsedOnly&itemSelectionType=all

http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B006SJIEG4/ref=as_li_tl?ie=UTF8&camp=1789&creative=390957&creativeASIN=B006SJIEG4&linkCode=as2&tag=tablesawchoice-20&linkId=WPZ7GGKZWHEOVLJM

and others ...

Unless you're committed to SawStop ...

Posted

"Contractor" is not a mediocre option.  A quality contractor can do a fine job.  I'm happy with mine as are many others. 

It's all a matter of perspective.  A contractor saw would be great if you were upgrading from a jobsite saw.  Compared to most cabinet saws, most contractor saws would be a mediocre option.  Cabinet saws are where it's at for serious hobbyist shops.  Full stop.

And the obligatory qualifier so people don't get upset:

That's not to say you can't do fine work with a lesser saw.  We all know this.  I could cut my grass with an electric lawnmower.  But I wouldn't want to.

Posted

I said it before, but the fatal flaw with a contractor saw is the table adjustment.  Aligning the blade to the miter slot on a true cabinet saw is somewhat trivial.  On a contractor saw it is brain surgery.    My contractor sawstop is as good as they get when it comes to contractors saw.   It is heavy, vibration free and powerful. 

Yup, and especially on a sawstop cabinet saw - rather than a dead blow mechanism, it's an adjustment screw, so you can make infinitesimal adjustments in a very controlled fashion.  My miter slot was out a few thou when I got the saw and I got it dead nuts in about 10 minutes tops.

Posted

I have the 52" SawStop PCS and it's more than just the safety feature. Everything with the saw is quality and it has other nice features over other saws. The instructions and manual are great and the integrated base and overarm dust collection are nice (although a little pricey). All adjustments on the saw came dead on from the factory but I did have to shim one cast iron wing as it was a hair low. 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   1 Member, 0 Anonymous, 56 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,008
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Bob44
    Newest Member
    Bob44
    Joined