first attempt at sharpening, need stone recomondations


Recommended Posts

Posted

I just got my first hand plane in the mail today, a Stanley low angle block plane #220 if im not mistaken. It was used but in decent condition, except for the blade. I knew i would have to sharpen it when i got it. I also received my "fine glass plate sharpening kit" that i ordered on amazon.  Ive watched many videos online about sharpening with sand paper and figured this was the way to go. Im on a severe budget and couldn't pop for actual stones. however, after setting up this kit and getting to work i quickly realized that i was going through the provided sand paper really fast. seeing how i have some old crappy chisels to sharpen as well. I got the plane assembled and went to try it out. It worked, much better than before i sharpened, but not as well as i would have expected. I know this kit only goes up to 2000 grit, and i didn't put a micro bevel on it. at 8-10 bucks for a pack of self adhesive sand paper, i would quickly pass the price of the stones i think. So i guess my question is what are some good yet affordable stones. I cant pop 100 bucks per right now. Im also a fan of buying quality so want to stay away from the 10$ versions online. Any suggestions or tips would be greatly appreciated.

Thanks

Posted (edited)

Sharpening systems, no matter what you pick, are going to be an investment. The good news is that it should last you a long time. I started out with the "scary sharp" method originally and quickly came to the same realization as you did about replacement costs. 

I picked up two DMT DuoSharp diamond plates, they are double-sided and one was Extra Coarse / Coarse, and the other was Fine / Extra Fine. You could save some money and get one 8" DuoSharp with Coarse / Fine and that would get you to a workable edge. The advantage of diamond plates is that they remove material quicker and stay flat (don't dish) compared to traditional stones. Then you may want to consider getting a 8k stone and/or a strop and some compound to get to the finest edges.

http://www.amazon.com/DMT-WM8FC-WB-8-Inch-DuoSharp-Bench/dp/B000H6MLOK/ref=sr_1_2?s=hi&ie=UTF8&qid=1449099500&sr=1-2&keywords=duosharp

The Japanese marketed version of the same Shapton stone is about half as much as the American branded one:

http://www.amazon.com/Japanese-Whetstone-Sharpening-Shapton-Kuromaku/dp/B002LVZG0U/ref=sr_1_1?s=hi&ie=UTF8&qid=1449099571&sr=1-1&keywords=shapton+8000

There are numerous proprietary systems, such as the WorkSharp 3000 out there as well. Sharpening is a rabbet-hole by itself, and there are different methods and systems to get there, and each person has their own preference.

Edited by Al Capwn
Posted

I know it's exactly what you said you can't do right now, but I use the Shapton stones and have never regretted it. I have been through the gambit of sharpening systems, and surprisingly, the second most effective other than this was using my belt sander. I have belts up to 2000# which was more than enough, after a quick strop, to have it easily shave. The only limitation on this is that it is best for things that you do not need to have a perfectly flat edge (chisels and planes). Rather, it works best for knives and such, which is what I was primarily using it for. 

I'm hesitant to post this because I am relatively new to sharpening in general, and everyone here knows loads more than I do so take it for what it's worth, but here's a post I wrote for my blog a while back that goes over how I approach sharpening.

sharpening introduction

John

Posted

Another plus one for DMT, I bought a Duosharp recently and want to add more.  Finish with a leather strop and some polishing compound.  Leather strop can be a piece of leather contact cemented to a flat board.  I bought my leather at amazon.com.  I also opted for some diamond lapidary paste, also from amazon, for my strops.  I made 4 out of the leather I bought and had a little left over. 

Posted

Before I got my set of Shapton glass stones and DMT DiaFlat lapping plate I used a set of cheap combination stones that I picked up from Rockler.

http://www.rockler.com/combination-waterstones-waterstones

I went with the 800/4000 and the 1000/6000 and would generally hone 1000/4000/6000. They weren't the greatest set of stones in the world, especially compared to the Shapton stones, but they got the job done for a year or two until I was able to upgrade. This is one area where I don't think the 'buy your last tool first' mantra is as important. $40 stones will still get tools sharp in general, they probably just won't last as long as stay flat as readily. In my case I paid $80 for the two stones, used them for two years, then turned around and unloaded them on Craigslist for something like $35. Definitely got my money's worth out of them.

Posted

While agreeing with all the above, let me offer one more option for a 'severely limited' budget. Buy a set of diamond sharpening plates from Harbor freight, for about $10. For chisels and planes, I highly recommend a roller guide, even a cheap one is better than nothing. Also, self-adhesive sandpaper isn't necessary. Buy wet-dry automotive paper from your local WalMart or Pep Boys. Wet the paper and it will adhere itself flat to the glass. Tape or clamp the ends. Use the diamond plates to create the edge, and paper just to refine & polish. The plates are small, so large planes irons are awkward, but it works. The sandpaper can be used over and over if rinsed and allowed to dry. Once the bevel is established, you won't need the plates much, just re-hone with the paper. Having said all that, if you can scrape together the cash to buy a set of 3" x 8" stones or plates, your life will be much easier. And with either method, follow up with a strop! A highly-polished edge stays sharp longer, and a few strokes on the strop is often all you need to bring the edge to full efficiency.

  • Like 2
Posted

While agreeing with all the above, let me offer one more option for a 'severely limited' budget. Buy a set of diamond sharpening plates from Harbor freight, for about $10. For chisels and planes, I highly recommend a roller guide, even a cheap one is better than nothing. Also, self-adhesive sandpaper isn't necessary. Buy wet-dry automotive paper from your local WalMart or Pep Boys. Wet the paper and it will adhere itself flat to the glass. Tape or clamp the ends. Use the diamond plates to create the edge, and paper just to refine & polish. The plates are small, so large planes irons are awkward, but it works. The sandpaper can be used over and over if rinsed and allowed to dry. Once the bevel is established, you won't need the plates much, just re-hone with the paper. Having said all that, if you can scrape together the cash to buy a set of 3" x 8" stones or plates, your life will be much easier. And with either method, follow up with a strop! A highly-polished edge stays sharp longer, and a few strokes on the strop is often all you need to bring the edge to full efficiency.

Proof that not everything has to come from LV or green whatever it is! Great ideas!

Posted

+1 on diamond stones.  If you use water stones or oil stones, you're going to have to have a means to flatten the stones.  (which for many folks is a diamond plate)

For chisels and planes, I highly recommend a roller guide, even a cheap one is better than nothing. Also, self-adhesive sandpaper isn't necessary.

Honing guide is really helpful for starting out, for fixing/setting angles on new-to-you planes, for setting a particular angle, and for consistency in the long run.  

And with either method, follow up with a strop! A highly-polished edge stays sharp longer, and a few strokes on the strop is often all you need to bring the edge to full efficiency.

Another plus one for DMT, I bought a Duosharp recently and want to add more.  Finish with a leather strop and some polishing compound.  Leather strop can be a piece of leather contact cemented to a flat board.  I bought my leather at amazon.com.  I also opted for some diamond lapidary paste, also from amazon, for my strops.  I made 4 out of the leather I bought and had a little left over. 

Adding in a strop made a huge difference in my sharpening.  I think the leather I bought was like $15 at Amazon, and I got the Veritas honing compound for $13.  http://www.leevalley.com/US/wood/page.aspx?p=32984&cat=1,43072 

I'm sure you read it a million times, but whatever system you pick, stick with it long enough that you can get decent edges consistently.  It's really easy to waste a lot of money chasing gadgets that will help you improve your sharpening.

Posted

After reading the comments I'll throw in my two cents. Get a can of 3m super 77 spray adhesive find good quality sandpaper it will last longer and try the mylar backed paper from TFWW to get down to 10000 grit polish. I've never had a better, sharper edge. The mylar TFWW paper has lasted me years because I normally use my set of Norton combo waterstones. But even with the stones they dish, I round my edge a little, I use a strop and round it some more, whatever I do the uber fine paper on glass splits hairs and gives the finest edges. I bought a glass shelf at the big box store and mounted the paper to, dirt cheap.

 hope this helps

Posted

thank you all for the replies. Ive looked at the links you guys have provided. I have a honing guide, it came with the kit i got off of amazon.

After reading the comments I'll throw in my two cents. Get a can of 3m super 77 spray adhesive find good quality sandpaper it will last longer and try the mylar backed paper from TFWW to get down to 10000 grit polish. I've never had a better, sharper edge. The mylar TFWW paper has lasted me years because I normally use my set of Norton combo waterstones. But even with the stones they dish, I round my edge a little, I use a strop and round it some more, whatever I do the uber fine paper on glass splits hairs and gives the finest edges. I bought a glass shelf at the big box store and mounted the paper to, dirt cheap.

 hope this helps

just ordered a sample pack of this paper. Think i will eventually buy those dmt plates when its in the budget, but for now i think i will stick with the sand paper route. I figure my sharping technique and skill can grow with my tool skill, seeing as i dont know how to really use the plane yet anyways. Dont want to let the cart get in front of the horse so to speak.

Posted

I have all the sharpening systems out there, sandpaper motorized, DMT, water stones (norton, king, shaption glass), oil stones). It is quite an investment.  All systems work but I go back to the 1K 4K 8K norton stones, it is quick and produces a long lasting edge.

Posted

If you decide to stick with the sandpaper route for a while, consider getting one of the Klingspor bargain boxes.  Bought one a year ago and haven't needed to buy sandpaper since, and probably wont for a while.  For $20, you get a box of really high quality sandpaper in random grits.  The box I got ranged from 60 to 5000.  There's definite more of the lower grits than the higher grits, but there was enough of the higher grits in mine to make it a good deal even if you never used the lower ones.  I don't use sandpaper to sharpen anymore, but I wish I had known about these bargain boxes back when I was using sandpaper, because it would have saved me a lot of money.

Long term though, definitely worth investing in some good stones.  I have a set of waterstones, but I sort of wish I had gotten diamond stones instead.  The waterstones are great, but the diamond stones don't need to be flattened, which saves a little time.

  • 1 month later...
Posted

For the budget consious, and for that matter anyone, the honing plat from Veritas plus diamond paste is about $30 for each plate plus diamond grit.  These plates will last a longtime, the abrasive is dirt cheap, and unlike water stones, you can use oil if you want, plus they will not need to be maintained flat.

 

in my opinion, a slow speed grinder, a coarse diamond stone, and a couple of honing plates with diamond paste is a comprehensive set of sharpening equipment, if you add a honing guide, you can achieve the finest edges anywhere bcy any means, and much cheaper than even mosestly priced water stones, diamond plates.

 

roger

Posted

I am using King water stones 800 - 4000 and the Veritas MkII honing guide. Seems to work pretty well. I am thinking about getting a leather strop. As long as you don't let your stuff get too dull a quick touch up in the higher grits every so often does the trick for me. 

 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.