mattbu Posted March 3, 2017 Report Posted March 3, 2017 I've reached the point where I'd really like to add a jointer to my shop. I currently do not have 240v outlets, so if I went with an 8" that would be an additional expense. Originally, I had been looking at the Grizzly jointers, but they've been out of stock for a while and I've read a couple of nightmare stories about people ordering a new one and having a lot of problems with them being faulty right away. Lately, I've been looking at the 6" Jet and Powermatic with straight knives. I had been leaning towards the Powermatic, because the price difference was pretty minimal, but now Jet is running their 10% off sale with free shipping for the weekend and the difference is more substantial. Also, I just came across this Jet 718200K 2HP 8" Jointer that I hadn't seen before. With the sale the price would be in the very upper end of what I was wanting to spend, and on top of that I'd still have to get a 240v outlet or more than likely a new subpanel for just the garage. Has anyone had any experience with this or any other additional advice? Ideally, I would like to try and keep it around $1,000 but there is some wiggle room. Options: 6" Jet:for $830 and free shipping http://www.rockler.com/jet-6-deluxe-jointer-w-quick-set-knives-model-jj-6csdx 6" Powermatic: $1,100 with shipping included http://www.rockler.com/powermatic-6-jointer-w-quick-set-knives 8" Jet: $1,300 with free shipping, cost of 240 outlet, and rental or purchase of hoist to lift the bed http://www.rockler.com/jet-718200k-2hp-8-jointer-with-closed-stand ZOOM Jet 718200K 2HP 8'' Jointer with Closed Stand Quote
Eric. Posted March 3, 2017 Report Posted March 3, 2017 That Jet has dovetail ways which would scare me off. Plenty of guys use them without issue but I personally wouldn't wanna deal with the nightmare of calibrating it when it gets knocked out of whack. The jointer is the most finicky tool in the shop to get working perfectly, and it's also the most critical that it actually does work perfectly...without square stock, your whole project is gonna suck. My first jointer was an 8" Grizzly with straight knives. And while I used it for years and completed many projects with it, it was always - from day one - a huge pain in my ass. Later I bought a Powermatic and it's been pure joy. My advice is always to spend big money on a really good jointer, and cut corners somewhere else. I'd rather have a great jointer than a great table saw. Quote
LazarusDB Posted March 3, 2017 Report Posted March 3, 2017 Depending on what you like to build you may find you quickly outgrow the 6" jointer. My next purchase is also a jointer so have been researching and 99% sure I'll be ordering this Grizzly G0490X. Maybe it will be back in stock at the same time my tax refund arrives. Aaron Quote
Keggers Posted March 3, 2017 Report Posted March 3, 2017 I can only speak about Grizzly jointers since that's all I've ever owned. I've owned the Grizzly 8" jointer with spiral cutter heads and currently own the Grizzly 12" model - also with spiral cutter heads - both were Extreme Series models. Unlike Eric, who had a bad experience with his Grizzly, I only have good things to say about the ones I've owned. I agree with Eric that it's not a good idea to cut corners on purchasing a good jointer. You might consider waiting until you have more cash available so you can purchase a jointer that you feel really comfortable with owning. Quote
mat60 Posted March 3, 2017 Report Posted March 3, 2017 I now have a Shop Fox /Grizzly 8" Jointer and it has been a pita. I wish I had spent more for something nice. Quote
Dknapp34 Posted March 3, 2017 Report Posted March 3, 2017 I have the grizzly G0490 and I've had no problems with it. Picked it up used on Craigslist. I think you will quickly regret it if you only get a 6" jointer. Even with an 8" I often find that I wish I had additional capacity. Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro Quote
mat60 Posted March 3, 2017 Report Posted March 3, 2017 1 hour ago, Eric. said: That Jet has dovetail ways which would scare me off. Plenty of guys use them without issue but I personally wouldn't wanna deal with the nightmare of calibrating it when it gets knocked out of whack. The jointer is the most finicky tool in the shop to get working perfectly, and it's also the most critical that it actually does work perfectly...without square stock, your whole project is gonna suck. My first jointer was an 8" Grizzly with straight knives. And while I used it for years and completed many projects with it, it was always - from day one - a huge pain in my ass. Later I bought a Powermatic and it's been pure joy. My advice is always to spend big money on a really good jointer, and cut corners somewhere else. I'd rather have a great jointer than a great table saw. What model Powermatic do you have Eric? Quote
Eric. Posted March 3, 2017 Report Posted March 3, 2017 https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B001GOALW6/ref=oh_aui_search_detailpage?ie=UTF8&psc=1 1 Quote
Just Bob Posted March 3, 2017 Report Posted March 3, 2017 @mattbu I am glad you asked this question. I have been looking for a new jointer to replace my current piece of crap. One thing I would strongly recommend is a spiral cutter. Its not totally necessary but after replacing the straight cutters on my planer with a Shelix, I will never buy anything with knives again. The difference in cut quality and noise reduction is amazing. Because of shop size I am limited to a 6" jointer and I think I will order this in the next few days: https://www.amazon.com/Powermatic-1791317K-54HH-Jointer-cutterhead/dp/B001AZV2OM/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1488562610&sr=8-1&keywords=powermatic+jointer I live 21 miles from Grizzly's showroom in WA, and I own quite a few of their machines. But having looked at their jointer offerings, am not comfortable buying one. Quote
gee-dub Posted March 3, 2017 Report Posted March 3, 2017 There are just enough Grizzly, Jet, Powermatic, etc. stories to keep one a little apprehensive about any brand. Contrary to Eric's experience my G0490X arrived so well setup I kept rechecking thinking that I must have missed something. It has done nothing but work since 2008. The extra cost of the index cutterhead paid for itself in about 18 months based on my previous knife sharpening and replacement schedule. Buying something to fit your power availability may be a factor for folks who are renting. I would not make a purchase of this size only to replace it. I made do with some decent used gear until I was sure of shat I wanted. When I bought for keeps I bought for keeps. JMHO. Quote
mattbu Posted March 4, 2017 Author Report Posted March 4, 2017 Thanks for all of the replies. I think I've decided to go with a 6" for now. My shop is my 2 car garage that my wife still wants to park inside, so the bigger footprint of the 8" and the additional costs to install 220v outlets or a subpanel put it too far out of reach for now. If the situation changes it the future I'm thinking the resale value of a good jointer should be pretty solid in my area, based off of my experiences with Craigslist around here. I've narrowed it down between the Jet 6" with the helical head of the Powermatic 6" 54A with straight knives. One of most important factors for me is to buy something that I won't have to be messing with a lot to get it properly setup. I hate the back and forth of having to make small micro-adjustments to get machines finely tuned. I like to be able to set it up, and use it for the stuff that I enjoy. All of that kind of draws me towards the Powermatic, but it would be nice to have the helical heads for all of the benefits of having them. I guess another option is to just wait for the next Powermatic sale and buy the 6" with the helical head. Anyone have an idea when that will be? I was really hoping they'd have one this spring. 1 Quote
RichardA Posted March 4, 2017 Report Posted March 4, 2017 Before you commit... Take a look at Oliver jointer #4220 helical heads and 120v with 1 1/2 hp It's 6" but has an almost 6' bed you might be surprised. 1 Quote
sjeff70 Posted March 4, 2017 Report Posted March 4, 2017 Powermatic: 5 year warranty, Byrd head means no blade changes, and best resale value. 1 Quote
sjm1580 Posted March 4, 2017 Report Posted March 4, 2017 1 hour ago, RichardA said: Before you commit... Take a look at Oliver jointer #4220 helical heads and 120v with 1 1/2 hp It's 6" but has an almost 6' bed you might be surprised. I second the Oliver. I looked at all the same ones you are and due to limits on power and space I had to go with a 6 inch model. Bought from my dealer who also sells Powermatic and Jet. He highly recommended the Oliver of both. He was right, long bed, helical cutter. It was extremely easy to set up and get dialed in perfectly. Check em out! Quote
mattbu Posted March 4, 2017 Author Report Posted March 4, 2017 That looks pretty nice, but there aren't any local dealers near me. This place looks to be the only online dealer that I've come across so far. http://www.southern-tool.com/store/oliver-6inch-jointer.php Am I reading it correctly that the only main difference between the one for $1,700 and the $1,200 is that the more expensive one has a 1.5HP motor instead of just a 1 HP? Both have helical blades, correct? Quote
sjm1580 Posted March 4, 2017 Report Posted March 4, 2017 1 hour ago, mattbu said: That looks pretty nice, but there aren't any local dealers near me. This place looks to be the only online dealer that I've come across so far. http://www.southern-tool.com/store/oliver-6inch-jointer.php Am I reading it correctly that the only main difference between the one for $1,700 and the $1,200 is that the more expensive one has a 1.5HP motor instead of just a 1 HP? Both have helical blades, correct? I'm not sure, I have the 1.5 HP with helical head model. I'm not sure about going down to a 1 HP . The 1.5 HP model I have goes through my jointing chores very well. What part of the world do you live? Quote
bleedinblue Posted March 4, 2017 Report Posted March 4, 2017 I hate it when topics on jointers come up because it is a reminder of how nice a 8" bed would be, then I am reminded of how much they weigh. Getting a 600 pound machine from my driveway, through my sloped yard to my walkout would be a nightmare. Reason #312 why I'd rather work out of the garage. Quote
Matter of Fractions Posted March 21, 2017 Report Posted March 21, 2017 I just ordered a Shop Fox W1755S. https://smile.amazon.com/gp/product/B004IYJ9QU/ref=oh_aui_detailpage_o07_s00?ie=UTF8&psc=1 I was all set on getting a Grizzly 6" with spiral cutter, but most of their 6" and 8" are out of stock. I did a little more searching and came across the Shop Fox. It seems like a great value to me with long beds and a mobile base. If anyone has any input or experience with this model, let me know. I can probably cancel the order if I need to. Spec-wise, it's comparable to the powermatic with a shorter bed and a mobile base for 400 less. Needless to say, I'm excited to get it! It'll be my first large 'professional' woodworking tool! Quote
Unknown craftsman Posted March 21, 2017 Report Posted March 21, 2017 Not much choice when it comes to new.It looks good to me I like the color.I also think the insert head is unnecessary in a jointer unless you plan to use very difficult woods. But that's just my opinion hope it works perfect for you. Aj Quote
prov163 Posted March 21, 2017 Report Posted March 21, 2017 I know this will sound crazy but... I'm not generally a Craigslist kind of guy but about 3 years ago when I was looking for a jointer I thought it would be worth a look see. I found an 8" Delta DJ-20 in excellent condition which I bought for a song as the guy needed it gone. It works great but I have nicked one of the blades so instead of going through the process of putting new straight blades in, now's my chance to move over to the Byrd Shelix which I hope to do in the next few weeks. I'll still have less than $1000 into it with the Byrd head. Not a lot of deals out there like that but it's worth some looking. 1 Quote
mattbu Posted March 23, 2017 Author Report Posted March 23, 2017 I've looked for over a year on Craigslist around here and haven't had much luck at all. Most of the things are old and very rusted, but expect to get absurd prices. I went with a Powermatic 54HH. I bought it online through ACME Tools so I avoided tax and shipping, also planned to use a price guarantee through Discover card if they end up running a sale soon. Today was the day of delivery, I had been pretty excited all day. Unfortunately, after I signed for the delivery with no reported damage I noticed a piece of the support base was damaged. I noticed that the box with the base had some scrapes on it so I opened it up to check it out, everything seemed well intact inside of the styrofoam. I checked over the box that had the base, but there was no signs of exterior damage that I could see. I opened up the top and everything looked fine. Once I opened up the bottom of the box to start unboxing and taking it out I noticed that one of the supports was badly bent. At first, I thought it was a piece that helps support the bed, but after further inspecting it it looks to be a support clip for bolting it to either the floor or a stand. Not really sure what to do, I sent an e-mail to ACME to report the damage. I tried calling their customer service and Powermatic's but both were closed because it was after 5PM CST. I'll call in the morning and see what they have to say. Quote
Llama Posted March 23, 2017 Report Posted March 23, 2017 On 3/4/2017 at 10:08 AM, mattbu said: for now Please rethink this... Your statement is already saying you will be upgrading to at least an 8" (which is still too small)... Hard to spend someone elses money, but just give it some thought. You can get a 220 put in for a few hundred. Don't let that stop you. Caveat: Unless you find a 6" machine on CL for $400 or something. Quote
mattbu Posted March 23, 2017 Author Report Posted March 23, 2017 For now meaning that I'll be good with it for several years. My shop is in a two car garage that my wife still likes to park inside when possible. So along with the increased cost in machine and for an electrician, along with the bigger footprint I think I'll be happy with a 6" for the time being. If I do get to the point where I want to upgrade in a few years, the resale value seems pretty strong from what I've seen. The occasionally few times that I've seen a good conditioned jointer on Craigslist it's been bought up pretty quick for a high asking price. Update on the broken base support clip: Contacted ACME and Powermatic this morning. Powermatic's customer support was great, they're sending out a new base assembly today and told me I can keep the damaged one. Don't know what I'll use it for, I guess I can keep it around for parts or something. 1 Quote
sjeff70 Posted March 23, 2017 Report Posted March 23, 2017 13 hours ago, mattbu said: I've looked for over a year on Craigslist around here and haven't had much luck at all. Most of the things are old and very rusted, but expect to get absurd prices. +1. Sad that our nation would rather buy very old instead of new. We are following the example of our nation's greediest rule makers by screwing each other in the underground market of old tools. Ape culture. Quote
CandorLush Posted March 23, 2017 Report Posted March 23, 2017 13 hours ago, Llama said: Please rethink this... Your statement is already saying you will be upgrading to at least an 8" (which is still too small)... Hard to spend someone elses money, but just give it some thought. You can get a 220 put in for a few hundred. Don't let that stop you. Caveat: Unless you find a 6" machine on CL for $400 or something. That's what I paid for my 8" on CL Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.