bleedinblue Posted July 1, 2018 Report Posted July 1, 2018 I'm in the (very) preliminary stages of researching composite decking. My house currently has a cedar deck and as far as I know the framing is in good shape. I'd be looking to replace the floorboards, railings and stair treads with composite, and cover the existing 6x6 posts with conposite wraps/sleeves. I'm guessing a composite dealer can look at what I have and basically piece together a "kit" that I could do myself? Has anyone updated an existing deck with composite materials? What other things should I consider? Quote
Chestnut Posted July 1, 2018 Report Posted July 1, 2018 Neignbor just re did his with sme 1/2" stuff from a box center. For what some of those composite decks cost i'd go to the lumber yard and order 500 BF of Ipe or Jatoba. Ipe might be cheaper. Quote
..Kev Posted July 1, 2018 Report Posted July 1, 2018 I've done a few in Trex. Although I love the low maintenance of Trex, it does have a couple downsides.. 1. You really have to pay attention to the joists.. If they're too far apart, the material flexes too much - 16"oc minimum IMO. 2. It does get slick when wet - Admittedly, the ones I did were are a bit older now and I think they've made some improvements since I did them. Quote
pkinneb Posted July 1, 2018 Report Posted July 1, 2018 I have Trex on my decks and agree with Kev's assessment above. Quote
bleedinblue Posted July 1, 2018 Author Report Posted July 1, 2018 A big reason I want to go to composite is the refinishing every couple of years. It's a huge pain in the butt, mainly because it's hard to plan ahead and dedicate a couple of rain-free days to get it done. Ipe or jatoba wouldn't solve that problem I don't think, plus I'd have the existing 6x6 cedar posts. Trex has a few local dealers I need to talk to. Slickness is a concern, for the toddler and for the dog. I'll look into that, maybe other brands provide better traction. Quote
pkinneb Posted July 1, 2018 Report Posted July 1, 2018 8 minutes ago, bleedinblue said: A big reason I want to go to composite is the refinishing every couple of years. It's a huge pain in the butt, mainly because it's hard to plan ahead and dedicate a couple of rain-free days to get it done. Ipe or jatoba wouldn't solve that problem I don't think, plus I'd have the existing 6x6 cedar posts. Trex has a few local dealers I need to talk to. Slickness is a concern, for the toddler and for the dog. I'll look into that, maybe other brands provide better traction. To clarify it can be slick when wet but the dogs still slide around on the interior floor a heck of a lot more than the deck when its wet. A couple other things first they are not really maintenance free, I end up washing it every couple of years. Its due now Second make sure you buy the decking at the same time or you could end up with a racing strip that after 14 years is still very visible...I guess the good news is the decking doesn't fade. 1 Quote
Chet Posted July 1, 2018 Report Posted July 1, 2018 I have a front porch built with composite and really like it. The brand, which I can't remember right now but it wasn't Trex has a wood grain texture to it which almost eliminates the slippery when wet thing. The other thing that I have found is that it can be really hot when it is in the sun all day. The porch is mostly shaded but when I was doing the work, the pieces that were in the sun all day would get hot like asphalt. Quote
..Kev Posted July 1, 2018 Report Posted July 1, 2018 10 minutes ago, bleedinblue said: A big reason I want to go to composite is the refinishing every couple of years. It's a huge pain in the butt, mainly because it's hard to plan ahead and dedicate a couple of rain-free days to get it done. Ipe or jatoba wouldn't solve that problem I don't think, plus I'd have the existing 6x6 cedar posts. Trex has a few local dealers I need to talk to. Slickness is a concern, for the toddler and for the dog. I'll look into that, maybe other brands provide better traction. It's not so slick that you can't walk on it. Comes more into play where steps are involved really. And to agree with @pkinneb, we always given them a quick pressure wash each year to keep them looking fresh.. Quote
bleedinblue Posted July 1, 2018 Author Report Posted July 1, 2018 Pressure washing a couple times a year isn't a problem. Easy peasy. If I had to, I'm sure I could lay some of those adhesive textured non-slip strips on the steps. I'd thought about the heat but it's not a deal breaker. I'll look into brands that don't hold as much heat though. Quote
Chestnut Posted July 1, 2018 Report Posted July 1, 2018 1 hour ago, bleedinblue said: Ipe or jatoba wouldn't solve that problem I don't think, plus I'd have the existing 6x6 cedar posts. From my research people don't even finish Ipe or Jatoba decks. So matinence free and still wood but $$$ and lots of work. I wasn't really saying it to be helpful just trolling. I hate composite decking. I've seen trex an some others which is why what i say below means something. The house we bought has this on the deck. It's not slick at all when wet. The texture holds dirt so you have to clean it but it's one of the few that i don't mind. All of the composites look aweful to me. It's the edge details and the little things about it that bother me. And this stuff is good. Maybe it was the installer maybe it's the brand but i don't mind it. 1 Quote
drzaius Posted July 1, 2018 Report Posted July 1, 2018 When I rebuilt our deck 6 or 8 years ago I looked at the various options. The only composites that were acceptable to me were actually more expensive than ipe. So, ipe is what I went with. No refinishing, no pressure washing, not slippery when wet, & it doesn't get especially hot in the sun. I love the stuff. 2 Quote
pkinneb Posted July 1, 2018 Report Posted July 1, 2018 35 minutes ago, Chestnut said: From my research people don't even finish Ipe or Jatoba decks. So matinence free and still wood but $$$ and lots of work. I wasn't really saying it to be helpful just trolling. I hate composite decking. I've seen trex an some others which is why what i say below means something. The house we bought has this on the deck. It's not slick at all when wet. The texture holds dirt so you have to clean it but it's one of the few that i don't mind. All of the composites look aweful to me. It's the edge details and the little things about it that bother me. And this stuff is good. Maybe it was the installer maybe it's the brand but i don't mind it. Nice! Quote
Woodenskye Posted July 1, 2018 Report Posted July 1, 2018 Frank, go to the pro desk at the big orange box store with the general dimensions of your deck and number of steps. They used to have a deck estimating software and could price out your options. Generally the new composite decking has 2 faces, one which would be the slick side and the other textured. Also you will need to decide on the fasteners which can get expensive. Ipe is a great choice, however if you are allergic you need to take precautions. I don't appear to be the few times I worked with it. A friend of mine is very allergic and only found out by working with it. Quote
Bankstick Posted July 3, 2018 Report Posted July 3, 2018 Wood magazine had an article on various types of decking material. The big negative of synthetic was that it got very hot in the sun. Quote
Tom King Posted July 3, 2018 Report Posted July 3, 2018 I might use it, if it's a location out of the Sun-like the steps on the dog porch, but I've not seen any that lasts as long as they claim it will out in the elements. Quote
Bankstick Posted July 3, 2018 Report Posted July 3, 2018 FWIW, I have been this house for almost 22 years and am just now replacing some of the boards- the greenish treated wood. The deck was built by the previous owner during some earlier prehistoric period. Quote
bleedinblue Posted July 3, 2018 Author Report Posted July 3, 2018 My neighbor is a general contractor and we had dinner with him last night. I brought the topic up, he said he installs composite decking over original wooden frames often. He offered to help and will help put together a parts list, then use his contacts to get the best price. He suggested some line of Trax. He did, however, suggest NOT wrapping the 6x6 posts, because the wraps or sleeves trap moisture. That seems odd to me, and it seems like it would be difficult to navigate those aesthetics. Quote
Chet Posted July 3, 2018 Report Posted July 3, 2018 I just ran across the paper work from when I purchased the materials from my front porch. The composite decking was called Evergrain made by Tamko. Quote
Chestnut Posted July 3, 2018 Report Posted July 3, 2018 54 minutes ago, bleedinblue said: He suggested some line of Trax. He did, however, suggest NOT wrapping the 6x6 posts, because the wraps or sleeves trap moisture. That seems odd to me, and it seems like it would be difficult to navigate those aesthetics. He's probably right and this is my problem with composite decks. They never seem cohesive. There is always some natural wood showing and it is very jarring visually. If your talking about posts below the deck you could try enclosing the area with lattice that is similar to the decking. Other decks I've seen do some sort of skirting that leaves gaps to allow air flow and also doensn't encase the posts. Quote
wdwerker Posted July 3, 2018 Report Posted July 3, 2018 Maybe add furring strips to the posts and only apply the composite to 3 sides of the posts max. That should prevent moisture being trapped. Maybe handrail posts could use furring strips and a gap bottom & top to use convection to remove or drain moisture with 4 sides wrapped. Quote
Tom King Posted July 3, 2018 Report Posted July 3, 2018 One thing that helps wooden deck longevity is to not put two fasteners in every joist. I built this dock in 1991. #1 5/4x6x16 decking boards. I alternated the screws from one side to the other on consecutive joists. It was left lying in place for a few days, and as it started to twist, that showed me where to put the one fastener on the end. At that stage, they had started to show how they wanted to move, but were still soft enough, wet from the treating process, to be easy to persuade down. We turned those boards over in 2009, or something like that, if I'm remembering correctly. Just a couple of weeks ago, 16 boards needed to be replaced. I did the same with them, leaving them lying unfastened in place until they revealed how they were going to move. Since these new replacements went in between some of the old ones, after they started to move, a wooden wedge was used to keep the gaps uniform as we screwed them down. The owners are coating it with one of those thick deck coatings, but I haven't been on it since they did that. The framework underneath still looks like I built that a few weeks ago. If I had put two fasteners into every joist, I have no doubt this would have been split all to pieces by now. Quote
drzaius Posted July 3, 2018 Report Posted July 3, 2018 My deck originally had plywood & a vinyl deck covering, so the framing underneath was not pressure treated. I put a layer of that sticky ice shield over the top of each joist before installing the ipe. That keeps the water from sitting on top of the joists & soaking in under the ipe planks. Lot easier than re-framing the whole deck. Quote
Bankstick Posted July 4, 2018 Report Posted July 4, 2018 bleedinblue, go for the help offered by the contractor. Seems like he is offering his expertise and a chance to save you some $$$. I would suggest a sizeable gift card to a nice restaurant a payment. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.