Woodworking_Hobby Posted November 8, 2023 Report Posted November 8, 2023 Just wondering....any thoughts on the Leigh FMT vs the Powermatic PM701 benchtop mortiser? In the past I have done my M&T joints with a plunge router and table saw and then rounded the ends of the tenon to fit into the joint. I was looking for something to speed up the process and not take as long when I am working on multiple projects. I have read multiple pros and cons to the bench top mortiser and the leigh FMT. I was just looking for something that was a little more accurate, would speed up the process, and would just not take just as long as my current method by the time you sharpen bits, adjust jigs, or setup the machine. All in it would cost about $350 more to get the Leigh by the time you add in the additional bits and plates. I only have one plunge router so I would also have to install and remove the plate on the router to use the Leigh or get a dedicated plunge router. I know I prob. will not go wrong but just wanted to see what others had experienced. Maybe I should just stay with my current method and go slower bust was trying to get a little more efficient with the limited time I have to get my projects done. Quote
pkinneb Posted November 8, 2023 Report Posted November 8, 2023 I have owned 2 benchtop mortiser's over the years and really was not happy with either I now have the PM719 with the moving table and it is a game changer. If you can find a used one with a moving table I would go that route if not honestly I personally would stick with your router setup. Quote
Woodworking_Hobby Posted November 8, 2023 Author Report Posted November 8, 2023 How hard is it to sharpen and maintain the chisels on the powermatic mortiser? Quote
treeslayer Posted November 8, 2023 Report Posted November 8, 2023 I have a bench top and it’s ok, underpowered I think, Rikon makes one with X/Y adjustment for $540.00 I don’t know anyone who has one, I will say the PM719 is a beast, a friend has one and I’ve used it several times and if I could find room to put it I would definitely have one, great machine 1 Quote
pkinneb Posted November 8, 2023 Report Posted November 8, 2023 On 11/8/2023 at 5:19 PM, Woodworking_Hobby said: How hard is it to sharpen and maintain the chisels on the powermatic mortiser? Pretty straight forward. Like any chisel you want to polish the four outside edges (once) just count stokes so that all four sides are the same length. Then use a diamond cone for the inside and you're good to go. 1 Quote
Popular Post Coop Posted November 9, 2023 Popular Post Report Posted November 9, 2023 @Woodworking_Hobby, I have the Wood River mortiser and it does a decent job but haven’t used it since I got the Domino. If by chance, you live within driving distance of Houston, I’ll make you a helluva deal on it, including the chisel bits. 24 pack of Miller Lite. 1 2 Quote
treeslayer Posted November 9, 2023 Report Posted November 9, 2023 Agree with @Coop the Domino pretty much eliminated the bench top mortice machine, and I don’t have one of those either 1 Quote
Coop Posted November 9, 2023 Report Posted November 9, 2023 The Domino has been a game changer for me. It’s pretty much, wham, bam, ……. Well, you get the idea. 1 Quote
curlyoak Posted November 9, 2023 Report Posted November 9, 2023 On 11/8/2023 at 10:44 PM, Coop said: The Domino has been a game changer for me. It’s pretty much, wham, bam, ……. Well, you get the idea. I had a delta mortice. Like you I needed a faster more accurate method. When Festool came out with the domino machine I bought one as soon as it was available. I had a 2 minute hesitation on the price and got over the hesitation and paid $500. That was a long time ago. Now they are a lot more. But If mine goes bad I will get another one. it gives me strong joints quick compared to M&T. I also have the jumbo size for doors etc. 1 Quote
Mark J Posted November 9, 2023 Report Posted November 9, 2023 What about the Pantorouter? I thought a couple of people here were big fans. Quote
BillyJack Posted November 9, 2023 Report Posted November 9, 2023 A Domino does not replace a M&T… It’s just a faster dowel.. Quote
Coop Posted November 9, 2023 Report Posted November 9, 2023 On 11/9/2023 at 7:10 AM, BillyJack said: A Domino does not replace a M&T… It’s just a faster dowel.. Do you agree that a tenon and a floating tenon are one in the same? Quote
BillyJack Posted November 9, 2023 Report Posted November 9, 2023 On 11/9/2023 at 7:38 AM, Coop said: Do you agree that a tenon and a floating tenon are one in the same? No… Quote
curlyoak Posted November 9, 2023 Report Posted November 9, 2023 On 11/9/2023 at 8:38 AM, Coop said: Do you agree that a tenon and a floating tenon are one in the same? YES, but not for a bridal joint. 1 1 Quote
Tom King Posted November 9, 2023 Report Posted November 9, 2023 If your mortise and tenon relies on glue, it doesn't matter much. I haven't used glue in a mortise and tenon joint in a few decades, so for the work that I do, a floating tenon is of no use. 1 Quote
BillyJack Posted November 9, 2023 Report Posted November 9, 2023 Two joints or one. It isn’t hard to figure out the strengths.. Quote
Woodworking_Hobby Posted November 9, 2023 Author Report Posted November 9, 2023 13 hours ago, Coop said: @Woodworking_Hobby, I have the Wood River mortiser and it does a decent job but haven’t used it since I got the Domino. If by chance, you live within driving distance of Houston, I’ll make you a helluva deal on it, including the chisel bits. 24 pack of Miller Lite. Oh man that sounds temping but alas it is too far to make the trip and it would prob get me in trouble at home to be gone that long ;-) I am assuming that no matter how I make the joint (domino / router & table saw / mortiser & table saw / other) as long is the joint does not structurally fail on my project it does not "matter" how I get there and is totally a function of my preference and ability to use the different tools? I have not progressed to doing through tenons or other styles yet and I understand that might change this thinking a little. My buddy had a Domino 500 that he let me use on a project a long time ago and for that one it worked well but I felt like it was a little awkward to get it lined up correctly and to hold my work so I could make the joints. Now that was a long time ago and I have a much better bench and working space than in the past, but that experience made me think I should skip over the domino and not consider as an option for M&T joints. 1 Quote
wtnhighlander Posted November 10, 2023 Report Posted November 10, 2023 11 hours ago, Tom King said: If your mortise and tenon relies on glue, it doesn't matter much. This is something that people tend to forget, modern wood glue being as good as it is. Joinery should be designed so the interlocking shape of the parts, not the adhesion of the glue, is what resists the primary force on the joint. Glue just keeps the joint from disassembling itself in the direction of the lesser forces on the joint. Quote
Popular Post gee-dub Posted November 10, 2023 Popular Post Report Posted November 10, 2023 Maybe someone has a used Mortise Pal for sale ( no longer made ). I used the original version for years. I have the new version and still use it despite having a domino and cutting my own M&T’s. I use the method that makes sense for what I’m doing. On 11/9/2023 at 6:17 PM, wtnhighlander said: Joinery should be designed so the interlocking shape of the parts, not the adhesion of the glue, is what resists the primary force on the joint. I recall a post where someone cut a rounded end mortise and then inserted a square (traditional) tenon into it with the rounded gaps at each end remaining empty. The theory put forward was that the rounded end grain didn't add enough strength to worry about. If someone has found something that works for them I don't usually pipe up even though I may disagree. I stayed silent in this case as well but it gave me pause and often comes to mind when I am working to fix a poor fitting tenon. IMHO your joinery should fit well and leave just enough room for an adequate glue layer. 4 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.