Popular Post Ron Swanson Jr. Posted August 20 Popular Post Report Posted August 20 @Von I've read through this a few times and still not sure I'm tracking correctly. (This is a reader problem, not a writer problem. The reader is an idiot.) The issue is that the dogs behind the leg would be encumbered by the top stretcher? If so, that makes sense. Here's a few things to think about - 1. At 13" on center, I'm not sure how often you'll be using both dogs on one work piece. Maybe more often than I'm thinking if working with a panel or something, but that seems awfully far apart for some reason. 2. Are you also installing some kind of tail vise on the other end, to be used with dogs running parallel to the grain? If so, and this is just my experience, but the dogs in the shoulder vise become much less important. I have a leg vise on my bench and don't have any dogs in it at all. That job gets done by the tail vice + dogs. 3. You could also consider not using traditional dogs, and opting for something like the veritas planing stop that doesn't require dog holes to go all the way through the slab. Shifting the bench top seems like an awful lot of effort, just to have some dogs that, in all reality, probably won't see a lot of use (again, this assumes a tail vise with dogs on the other end) But if that's the way you're going, then full speed ahead! 4 Quote
Popular Post wtnhighlander Posted August 20 Popular Post Report Posted August 20 I'm with @Ron Swanson Jr. on this. A single dog in the tail vise is a much more useful option, IMO. I have never found a need for a dog in my face vise, let alone two. The only use I can think of would be for holding non-rectilinear objects, but even then, 3 dogs would be more effective than 4 (1 in the vise jaw, 2 on the bench, or the opposite). Also, I don't use dogs that stay in the bench and 'pop up', opting for 3/4" round holes with drop-in dowels instead. Holes do double-duty for hold fasts, and allow great flexibility for dog-based planing stops. 5 Quote
Von Posted August 20 Author Report Posted August 20 @Ron Swanson Jr. @wtnhighlander You've grasped things correctly. And yes, I will have a tail vise with a single dog as well. I really appreciate your perspective. I may have fallen in love with a concept here that just isn't worth it. Good food for thought. 2 Quote
Popular Post Von Posted August 22 Author Popular Post Report Posted August 22 With thanks again for the adjustment in my perspective I was back at it today having decided to leave my top as is and forego the shoulder vise dogs. Before I got too far on making cuts for the tail vise, I wanted to cut the jaw so I could cut table to its thickness. Back to rough cutting and milling. Thanks to this forum for the Huskey table and Jaw Stand suggestions, they make material management and rough cutting straight forward. And cooking show fast forward through milling and more cutting to jaws and apron pieces. At final thickness, but still a little oversized otherwise at this point so I have some extra wood if needed. And I cut the bench to length. I decided to start with the track saw and then finish with the pull saw (since the track saw runs out of depth). I did this because it seemed simpler than trying to flip the tops over and then either re-align them or cut them separately. The Huskey table served as great off-cut catcher. I raised it under the offcuts until I felt pressure and then backed off a little so it supported without putting pressure. This two-saw system worked fairly well. I've got some sanding to do to clean up as I expected. This was probably my messiest cut. I tried to keep the pull saw tight to the good side of the kerf, but clearly failed towards the end of this cut. I finished the day laying out the cut for the tail vise jaw. I decided it was a good time to break for the day before making that cut and think it through. 4 Quote
Ron Swanson Jr. Posted August 22 Report Posted August 22 If that's your roughest cut, I'd say you did great. A sharp block plane will make short work of any misalignment. I used a track saw for that cut and definitely had clean up to do afterwards. Which vise are installing on the tail? 1 Quote
Von Posted August 22 Author Report Posted August 22 33 minutes ago, Ron Swanson Jr. said: Which vise are installing on the tail? The Veritas Quick Release Sliding Tail vise. 2 Quote
Popular Post Von Posted August 23 Author Popular Post Report Posted August 23 Started in installing the tail vise today and I figured it would be a challenging day and it did not disappoint. I made my own bed here: the veritas tail vise is meant to be installed with an apron and I'm embedding it into my bench, so I undertook this knowing I was on my own with regards to the process (<foreboding music here>). I stated by marking out the area for the vise jaw and used the track saw to make initial cuts on the top. This is the fist time I've made stopped cuts with the track saw and it was fairly straight forward. Make the bulk of the cut and then its sneak up on the line. I used a stop on the track to protect against slippage or moments of idiocy. Easy. I then finished the cut with the pull saw. This was my second mistake (the first one wasn't apparent to me yet and I'll get back to it). As a right-handed person, this was an awkward cut to make as I could not find good body mechanics. I believe I should have used the track saw again to finish the long cut at least as the result of my hand saw work here was messy and not very straight. I ended up with a wandering saw towards the end of the cut. I don't think this will be a functional problem, but suspect I end up with an unsightly gap between the jaw and the bench. I don't want to remove more wood yet to square things up as I don't have much extra wood on my jaw. Tool acquisition disorder comes in useful. This little right angle connector for my combination square lets me attach a small ruler to it and measure offset to the front of the bench even though it's a considerable distance away. I use it to align the vise mounting plate. As luck would have it one of the mounting screws for the vise mounting plate lands right on a knot. I proceeded without that screw and planned on finishing my day with an epoxy filling party. And putting the vise into place, I ran into my first mistake, made back when I cut the notch out of the bench. Turns out I made too long a cut as I assumed the jaw was flush with the end of the bench. It actually needs to overhang by a couple of inches. Veritas was a little loose on their directions as they assumed you'd get the vise installed and then install the apron to the end of the vise. Even with my extra length, while I could make it work, there is no where near enough wood for the bolts on the end. However, I realized later, the blank I cut for my shoulder vise was longer and would be long enough. And the blank I made for the tail vise is long enough for the shoulder. I wish I could take credit for that bit of accidental contingency planning, but it was luck. This is nice because I'm starting to run low on lumber from this particular tree. I realized this after I started pouring epoxy so still need to actually try the fits to make sure, but I believe it will work. And I finished my day with a epoxy party. I went ahead and mixed up 4 oz of epoxy and filled all the knot holes to make sure I don't run into any problems with the shoulder vise installation or problems with knots down the road when clamping. 6 Quote
Popular Post Ron Swanson Jr. Posted August 23 Popular Post Report Posted August 23 A little miscalculation, a little good fortune, but the takeaway I'm getting here is that you're still on your feet and the install is moving in a forward direction. Nice!! 5 Quote
gee-dub Posted August 24 Report Posted August 24 I've got India ink dyed epoxy repairs in walnut that have been in service for 20 years without issue. I think you are going to be fine. 2 Quote
Popular Post Chestnut Posted August 24 Popular Post Report Posted August 24 This thread convinced me that i need to get around to finally installing my tail vise. So i just went and bought the hardware. Oddly the price doesn't seem too different from 7 years ago when i started my bench adventure. Regarding the tail vise and dogs for holding, i built my bench 7 years ago and have used plane stops and hold fasts and haven't had much motivation to ever install my tail vise. If you are planning on using the dogs for work holding for hand planing I'd recommend a plane stop instead, it may be overthinking it but clamping the board end to end or side to side may introduce a bend and cause flattening issues. If you don't have hold fasts consider them as they get the most use on my bench. I don't know if you have a sliding deadman in your plans as well but that's another feature that i used a LOT. These hold fasts are supposedly some of the best and they are incredibly affordable. 4 Quote
Popular Post Ron Swanson Jr. Posted August 24 Popular Post Report Posted August 24 On 8/24/2026 at 8:45 AM, Chestnut said: This thread convinced me that i need to get around to finally installing my tail vise. So i just went and bought the hardware. Oddly the price doesn't seem too different from 7 years ago when i started my bench adventure. Regarding the tail vise and dogs for holding, i built my bench 7 years ago and have used plane stops and hold fasts and haven't had much motivation to ever install my tail vise. If you are planning on using the dogs for work holding for hand planing I'd recommend a plane stop instead, it may be overthinking it but clamping the board end to end or side to side may introduce a bend and cause flattening issues. If you don't have hold fasts consider them as they get the most use on my bench. I don't know if you have a sliding deadman in your plans as well but that's another feature that i used a LOT. These hold fasts are supposedly some of the best and they are incredibly affordable. +1 for the Grammercy holdfasts. I use them constantly and they really work well. 4 Quote
Popular Post pkinneb Posted August 24 Popular Post Report Posted August 24 On 8/24/2026 at 10:15 AM, Ron Swanson Jr. said: +1 for the Grammercy holdfasts. I use them constantly and they really work well. x2 3 Quote
Popular Post Ron Swanson Jr. Posted August 24 Popular Post Report Posted August 24 On 8/24/2026 at 1:44 PM, pkinneb said: x2 I glued crubber pads on, and they hold extremely well. Usually I don't need more than a light tap to set or dislodge them. 5 Quote
Popular Post Von Posted August 24 Author Popular Post Report Posted August 24 7 hours ago, Chestnut said: This thread convinced me that i need to get around to finally installing my tail vise. So i just went and bought the hardware. Oddly the price doesn't seem too different from 7 years ago when i started my bench adventure. Regarding the tail vise and dogs for holding, i built my bench 7 years ago and have used plane stops and hold fasts and haven't had much motivation to ever install my tail vise. If you are planning on using the dogs for work holding for hand planing I'd recommend a plane stop instead, it may be overthinking it but clamping the board end to end or side to side may introduce a bend and cause flattening issues. If you don't have hold fasts consider them as they get the most use on my bench. I don't know if you have a sliding deadman in your plans as well but that's another feature that i used a LOT. These hold fasts are supposedly some of the best and they are incredibly affordable. Agree completely. I've got one of the Gramercy hold fasts and wish I had bought two. I also picked up a used Veritas Hold Down and get a lot of use out of it. Plus I have various planing stops and a couple cheap, small hold downs I need to replace some day. I'm still going to do some of my pop-up dogs, but have scaled back. Given the good advice from this forum, I've realized how little I actually use my dogs for work holding and I can always add them later. Back to bench building... I realized today that my tail vise jaw was too short - I could have bolted it onto the vise, but just barely and with not enough wood for comfort. I thought I cut the jaws oversized but not enough. I need to mill up my last board to make a new jaw which needs to wait until I get the bench back together and make room in the shop. Question for the forum: what you see below is the inside corner I cut that will serve as the jaw for the tail vise on the bench top. Due to my poor handsaw technique it's sloppy and out of square top-to-bottom and front-to-back (right-to-left in the photo). Any ideas how to square it up? I'm not worried so much about top-to-bottom - it's upside down in this photo and having the tops touch first is fine - but front-to-back (right-to-left in the photo) which will be ugly if not problematic. The tool will have to come to the wood as the top is too big for me maneuver to the table or band saw. TIA for suggestions. In terms of accomplishments today, being stymied on the tail vise for the moment, I turned to the shoulder vise and got the hardware installed and the inside jaw made and attached to the top. I also did a bunch of uninteresting sanding of various rough surfaces. 4 Quote
Ron Swanson Jr. Posted August 24 Report Posted August 24 To square that up, you'd probably need a sharp shoulder plane, or maybe a rabbeting block plane, something where the blade goes all the way to the edge of the tool. That said, I don't know how critical it is that this be 100% flush/plumb/square. The tail vice's job is mainly to push a dog forward to engage a workpiece with an upstream dog in the bench. You CAN use it to secure a board vertically between the 'carrier' and the surface that you're showing, (see picture) but the shoulder vise is better suited for this task. Just my .02, obviously, but I would probably just leave it as is. I don't think it will harm anything. But maybe there's something with your vise that's not occurring to me. I can only say this based on the function of my somewhat similar, but different enough, tail vise. 2 Quote
Chestnut Posted August 24 Report Posted August 24 Square it up. If your having to mill a board to fit get the opening squared up. There are a lot of ways to get it square but I'm not sure the tools you have. Track saw and guide would work well then clean up with chisel. Overall square is more important than surface finish. 1 Quote
Ron Swanson Jr. Posted August 24 Report Posted August 24 On 8/24/2026 at 5:43 PM, Chestnut said: Square it up. If your having to mill a board to fit get the opening squared up. There are a lot of ways to get it square but I'm not sure the tools you have. Track saw and guide would work well then clean up with chisel. Overall square is more important than surface finish. Maybe I'm missing something here. Why is it critical that face be more square than it is right now? It doesn't really interface with anything in use(?) 1 Quote
Von Posted August 24 Author Report Posted August 24 22 minutes ago, Ron Swanson Jr. said: Maybe I'm missing something here. Why is it critical that face be more square than it is right now? It doesn't really interface with anything in use(?) I think you've got it. As you described a couple comments ago, this is the "fixed jaw" for the tail vise. I've never had a tail vise before, but have no reason to doubt you when you say I probably won't use it much. Even so, the aesthetics are bugging me. I believe these flaws will show up as ugly gaps from above when the vise is closed as the two jaws won't meet cleanly. Yeah, not the end of the world, but I don't want to give up on this yet. 1 hour ago, Ron Swanson Jr. said: To square that up, you'd probably need a sharp shoulder plane, or maybe a rabbeting block plane, something where the blade goes all the way to the edge of the tool. I have a 78 shoulder plane but I have low confidence in my ability to use it effectively at an awkward vertical angle on end grain with so little surface area to guide me. I think I'd need to clamp some extra boards to keep me working square and even then I'm finding the body mechanics challenging to imagine as that face will be vertical - I don't see any way around that. Even if I could turn the top on its end, the face would be ~6 feet off the ground. 34 minutes ago, Chestnut said: Square it up. If your having to mill a board to fit get the opening squared up. There are a lot of ways to get it square but I'm not sure the tools you have. Track saw and guide would work well then clean up with chisel. Track saw.... yes, I think see a way. Which if it works, would have been how I should have cut it in the first place. It will take a little engineering to hold the track steady but seems doable. Stay tuned. 34 minutes ago, Chestnut said: Overall square is more important than surface finish. Agreed. I plan to cover it with cork as I would any jaw face. Thanks all. 2 Quote
Beechwood Chip Posted August 24 Report Posted August 24 On 8/24/2026 at 7:29 PM, Von said: these flaws will show up as ugly gaps from above when the vise is closed Do you need to square it up, or just make sure that the top meets cleanly and any gap is under the table? Maybe just sand or chisel away the high spots. 1 Quote
Popular Post Chestnut Posted August 25 Popular Post Report Posted August 25 13 hours ago, Ron Swanson Jr. said: Maybe I'm missing something here. Why is it critical that face be more square than it is right now? It doesn't really interface with anything in use(?) 12 hours ago, Von said: I've never had a tail vise before, but have no reason to doubt you when you say I probably won't use it much. Is this the spot we're talking about? If you work on long items that don't fit in a traditional leg vise or are cumbersome to lift into a face vise it'll slide into that and be able to be held vertically, chair leg long dowel, table leg etc. Think of it as another vise jaw. I guess it's not critical you could just never use it in that manner, but there may be a time in the future you wish you had it and won't The second reason is it'll be a lot easier to square up and then mill a board to meet the square opening than to not. If the jaws don't meet well they may not hold well. The 3rd reason is if you have the opportunity to "do it right" why not just "do it right"? you have to mill a new board, the size it gets milled to could be slightly larger? The hardware doesn't care what size the jaw is. 12 hours ago, Von said: Track saw.... yes, I think see a way. Which if it works, would have been how I should have cut it in the first place. It will take a little engineering to hold the track steady but seems doable. Stay tuned. Scribe a line all the way around and make as many cuts on as many sides as you can with the track saw. Then use a chisel to connect the lines under cutting slightly. The other options is once you have a line created with the track saw use a bearing strait bit (pattern flush trim etc) to then work away at the middle. You will always need to chisel the corner but a good square knife line makes that easy. Layout is king. 3 1 Quote
Popular Post Chestnut Posted August 25 Popular Post Report Posted August 25 Post broken into parts because i wanted to search for pictures and not loose my text. The veritas vise is different than this picture and honestly it's way WAY better. With the veritas vise you won't have to lift a large part into the opening you can just move it into place. There may be a time when you want to hold something vertical that is long and this is a good tool for that. The face vise may work but when you get longer items 48" - 72" pushing parallel to the vise jaws causes rotation and the hold isn't as good. It's better to push into the jaw rather than parallel to it. It's a REALLY odd use case and doesn't come up. I've had it come up a few times in the last 7 years and i just used a sliding deadman with a hold fast or 2 and that worked ok so there are other ways. This would have been better. Ron's picture above shows a small part, but think large and cumbersome. Think a 60" long stretcher for a trestle table that you need to clean up the through mortise and tenon on. Boy it'd be nice to get that large heavy 8/4 part vertical to do the chisel paring. 3 Quote
Von Posted August 25 Author Report Posted August 25 29 minutes ago, Chestnut said: Is this the spot we're talking about? Yes. Thank you. I've done a horrible job describing this and appreciate your much better picture. 30 minutes ago, Chestnut said: Scribe a line all the way around and make as many cuts on as many sides as you can with the track saw. Then use a chisel to connect the lines under cutting slightly. The other options is once you have a line created with the track saw use a bearing strait bit (pattern flush trim etc) to then work away at the middle. You will always need to chisel the corner but a good square knife line makes that easy. Layout is king. I did my initial cut with the track saw, but with the piece right side up, it was a stopped cut and I couldn't go very far. Then my cut with a hand saw wasn't very square, despite the guidance from the track saw kerf, and hence the situation I'm in. I'm finding the usual "clean up with hand tool" approach challenging because the workpiece is so large, it's hard for me to get my body positioned as I normally would. I could make a full cut with the track saw if I put the piece on its edge. I would need to find a way to fully support the track but I think that's doable with some roller stands and the like. I'd probably also clamp some extra wood to the piece for extra support. I'm also thinking roughly the same thing but with a router instead, which removes the need to support the long track and instead would just need some extra wood clamped on for support. Thanks. 2 Quote
Popular Post Chestnut Posted August 25 Popular Post Report Posted August 25 21 minutes ago, Von said: I could make a full cut with the track saw if I put the piece on its edge. I would need to find a way to fully support the track but I think that's doable with some roller stands and the like. I'd probably also clamp some extra wood to the piece for extra support. This is where layout and knife lines help. That edge is hard if you don't have a way to manage it just drop the chisel in the knife line and give a gentle tap and work slow. Lay out is critical though use squares etc to make sure your line is square. Highlight the line with pencil. The router technique with flush trim or pattern bits is probably your best bet. It has it's own potential for issues but is pretty safe. Again I'm going to hammer the knife line. It's the layout technique that just helps a ton. I use it on every project. 3 Quote
Mark J Posted August 25 Report Posted August 25 46 minutes ago, Von said: I'm finding the usual "clean up with hand tool" approach challenging because the workpiece is so large, it's hard for me to get my body positioned as I normally would. I could ... put the piece on its edge. This is my thought. After mark-up, lay the top on the floor edge down. Slip 4 - 6 parallel clamps underneath the edge to act as legs. Now instead of being 6' off the ground, the work will be 16" off the ground. Not ideal, but better. 2 Quote
Popular Post Von Posted August 26 Author Popular Post Report Posted August 26 I started today by finishing off the shoulder vise. I'll just touch on a couple of highlights. BTW, my one bit of advice for something like this is get used to the idea you will be assembling and dissembling the vise a lot to fit and tune things. I started by clamping the movable jaw to the fixed jaw and used the same forstner bits I used to drill the holes in the fixed jaw to transfer the hole locations. Somewhere along the line I learned the trick of shimming the bottom of the movable jaw, flipping it over and running it through the planer to put a slight taper on it so that the top contacts first, where you want the most pressure in practice. With the two jaws firmly in place, I made them the same size. Trimming the apron took a little engineering since it's already glued to the top. I took the vise off before I put the top back on since it's heavy and I'll moving the top around a fair amount to install the tail vise, but here's a photo of what the finished apron look like. The movable jaw will just span the leg. With that shoulder vise mostly done (I'll add some chamfers and other details on the movable vise later), I turned back to the tail vise. First thing I did was, as suggested, mark and cut lines for cleaning up the fixed jaw. I then clamped on a couple of offcuts for more support and used a clamp-on straight end and a router to clean things up. I was nervous about routing the board on edge, but with the cutoffs clamped on, it was very stable and I had no issues in practice. The eagle-eyed will notice I didn't quite route far enough to the left on the photo and was glad I had the knife line to finish the clean up with a chisel. Much better. Unfortunately in my efforts to sand this face with my ROS, I put a dimple along the inner face, visible under the fat part of the square in the photo below. I'm going to wait to see how things look when it's assembled before jumping on it. Thanks all for your advice. 4 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.