TheFatBaron Posted August 14, 2013 Report Posted August 14, 2013 I'm thinking it's time to buy a new tool. Obviously, both tools are very different and serve a ton of different purposes. I'd have an immediately use for either. Both would make it much easier to do mortices reliably - particularly when they're in a funny place, and each has other benefits. A router would also allow me to do some pattern work, plus simple edge profiles. Plus, since its a portable tool, I can do the morticing wherever. On the downside, I've only used a router table a couple times and and not super confident with it. (I'd probably get the Bosch 1617EVSPK 2.25hp kit with the fixed and plunge bases, plus a couple bits, plus an edge guide.) On the plus side for a drill press - it's way less scary to me. It'll still to mortices perfectly well. And then I'd actually be able to drill everything at a right angle. Of course, it's a fixed tool, so there's a little less flexibility there if I have to work on a larger/awkwardly shaped piece. I could get (and very carefully use) spindle sanding bits. Long term I'll be getting both. Short term, however, I'm trying to figure out what's right for me. Any thoughts about flexibility or alternate uses I may be missing? Quote
dwacker Posted August 14, 2013 Report Posted August 14, 2013 It almost sounds like your afraid of routers. I think a router should come before a drill press. Id spend some more time with a router and become comfortable. Be safe of course but I would not fear the router. FWIW you shouldn't use a drill press as a spindle sander, the bearings are not designed for side loads. 1 Quote
..Kev Posted August 14, 2013 Report Posted August 14, 2013 I agree with PB. I use my router much more than my drill press.. Quote
mikem Posted August 14, 2013 Report Posted August 14, 2013 +1 On the router first. They can be a little scary as they are noisy and the bit is spinning at a very high RPM. The 1617 is a good choice, I have two of them. Use it in the plunge base for handheld operations, as that will give you more control. Start off with using smaller bits, especially edge profiling bits like a round over or chamfer bit. Being a little scared of a new tool is not a bad thing, but as anything like that, take your time with it and ease into it. Quote
ChetlovesMer Posted August 14, 2013 Report Posted August 14, 2013 I would agree that a router is more versatile. In truth, a router might be as versatile as any power tool out there. If you want to cut down on the intimidation factor, you might consider a palm router. Quote
jmaichel Posted August 14, 2013 Report Posted August 14, 2013 Another vote for the router. I did not have any router experience when I bought one and used it for the first time (I still don't have a lot of experience). It's a good thing to be a little scared of a tool, its when your overly confident or complacent when an accident occurs. Watch some videos and make some practice cuts. Routers have so much versatility that once you get comfortable with it you see all sorts applications where a router will work. I would say that a palm router is just as dangerous as a any other router out there and a lot less versatile. I would not want to make a dado with a palm router. I If you are going to make mortices with the router just make sure that the base is stable when creating a mortices in thin stock. Good luck and let us know what you decide. Quote
dwacker Posted August 14, 2013 Report Posted August 14, 2013 Get yourself a 690 with a D handle, use and abuse it. Quote
pghmyn Posted August 14, 2013 Report Posted August 14, 2013 Just another vote here for a router. In my hobby work, the router got used much more than the drill press. Quote
jHop Posted August 14, 2013 Report Posted August 14, 2013 I purchased the bench top drill press before purchasing a router. (to be fair, I already had been given a router by my father.) having used the drill press far more than the router, I can honestly say: Get the router. The drill press is not a one trick pony, but the tricks it knows are fewer than the router. (and get a router that either you swap an adjustable base on to, comes with an adjustable base, or you can upgrade simply into a plunge base. my fixed base is more limited than I'd like to admit.) Quote
Tom King Posted August 15, 2013 Report Posted August 15, 2013 Get yourself a 690 with a D handle, use and abuse it. exactly what I was going to say. I have a D-handle that has its third motor in it. Quote
Byrdie Posted August 15, 2013 Report Posted August 15, 2013 It's way easier to "work around" a drill press than it is the router. I'd go for the router first as well. I have both but that's the route I took as well. Quote
TheFatBaron Posted August 15, 2013 Author Report Posted August 15, 2013 Wow... ok. Thanks for the advice. I didn't quite expect it to be that universal. I'll check out the PC 690 too. Other than the router itself, an edge guide, and a couple bits (maybe a spiral upcut bit and a pattern bit... any accessories I might as well get at the beginning? Quote
Gary Posted August 15, 2013 Report Posted August 15, 2013 Assuming you already have a decent driver/drill, get a router with plunge and fixed bases. I'm not clear if you have or will be getting a router table, but mount the fixed base in the table and use the plunge base for everything else. Take your time, practice and stay focused when using the router and you will be ok. The main thing is to learn to recognize the situations that can cause the router to kick on you before you even power it on. (Climb cuts,etc. ) Quote
TheFatBaron Posted August 15, 2013 Author Report Posted August 15, 2013 Sling - I don't have a router table (I'm in my basement so space is at a severe premium), but I would consider a benchtop model in the future if I'm ever able to get my storage / work space issues straightened out. Quote
jmaichel Posted August 15, 2013 Report Posted August 15, 2013 Wow... ok. Thanks for the advice. I didn't quite expect it to be that universal. I'll check out the PC 690 too. Other than the router itself, an edge guide, and a couple bits (maybe a spiral upcut bit and a pattern bit... any accessories I might as well get at the beginning? I went with this bit set from whiteside http://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/B0012JI4UQ/ref=mp_s_a_1_6?qid=1376531710&sr=8-6&pi=SL75 a little expensive but worth it. Quote
wdwerker Posted August 15, 2013 Report Posted August 15, 2013 Get a 690 and get to know it, use it and abuse it! Then get a drill press before you get a second router! 2 drill presses and 20 routers later, experience speaks! 5 of my routers are 690's ! Quote
wtnhighlander Posted August 15, 2013 Report Posted August 15, 2013 No way, man! Go for the drill press! Just kidding. The router is by far the more versatile tool. 1 Quote
rodger. Posted August 15, 2013 Report Posted August 15, 2013 Get a 690 and get to know it, use it and abuse it! Then get a drill press before you get a second router! 2 drill presses and 20 routers later, experience speaks! 5 of my routers are 690's ! Another woodworker with the famous router addiction! I wonder who has the most routers... Quote
ChetlovesMer Posted August 15, 2013 Report Posted August 15, 2013 I have six of them, which probably doesn't even put me near the top of the list. But one of them is cordless, do I get points for that? (BTW - It is INTENTIONALLY cordless... not like the cordless circular saw I have.) 1 Quote
adambaum Posted August 15, 2013 Report Posted August 15, 2013 I'm going to go against the grain and go with drill press. I have both and use the drill press way more than I use my router. Yes, the router is more versatile, but it really depends on what you plan on doing. If you think you are going to make more holes than slots and profiles, go with the drill press. Adam Quote
mikem Posted August 15, 2013 Report Posted August 15, 2013 Routers are like clamps, you can never have too many! Quote
CT Proctor Posted August 15, 2013 Report Posted August 15, 2013 I can go long periods of time without using the drill press but it seems like a router is used on almost every project. I have 8 PC router motors and two of those are in tables, plus a shaper. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.