Recommended Posts

Posted

I'm not getting nice edges when making long dados on soft wood (pine) with hand tools only...

Been watching some videos about kerfing planes. I'm considering maybe making one of those, but I'm not sure.

Cool. Post pics. Sent from my SGH-I337M using Tapatalk
Posted

I always use a marking knife first, several passes. Then I push a chisel, bevel up, starting at about half inch from the line and until I meet that line. So for so good. After that, I start removing material with my chisels or router planes, but I always end up ruining the edge at some point...

Posted (edited)

I'm confused how a kerfing plane would help in this case. A kerfing plane normally cuts along the grain, like a rebate.  Anyways, it's true pine does bruise very easily. I have found that it's better if I saw the shoulders of a dado with a carcass saw. The other option, would be tho remove the waste in the middle, while keeping quite clear of the shoulders. Then you can work towards your knife line, very slowly with paring cuts to keep from bruising. 

Edited by lumberninja
Posted

For a groove I'd just use a combination or plow plane.  Then you're done in one operation, with a kerf plane you still have to chop out the waste.

The problem is that the groove was 4'' wide and stopped. Also 1'' deep. Even if I had had the right plane for the job it would've taken forever.

Posted

I think this may be one of the few situations for which a side rebate trimmer may have been introduced. After undersize roughing your groove, you could skew down a paring pass much more quickly than some other options. I'd love to know why 4" wide. I think another common practice in softwoods with a dado running deep in the middle is to trim the joining stock to have a shoulder that will hide some tearout. This may be too late in the process for that now. 

Posted

I think this may be one of the few situations for which a side rebate trimmer may have been introduced. After undersize roughing your groove, you could skew down a paring pass much more quickly than some other options. I'd love to know why 4" wide. I think another common practice in softwoods with a dado running deep in the middle is to trim the joining stock to have a shoulder that will hide some tearout. This may be too late in the process for that now. 

Lots of my projects involve wide grooves these days, including the last two I shared on these very forums. Look at the wood filler partying on this one for example:

2015-10-31_19.57.13.thumb.jpg.b1f3a49a09

The other project was the ninja saw case, I also had the same problem there but wood filler was not an option.

Posted

If you've got one,  Eric's router suggestion would be my choice.

If you're sticking with hand tools, I'd saw the walls using a batten and a rip filed back saw  (dovetail saw or tenon saw) and then with both side battens still in place chisel out the waste.  Final cleanup with a router plane.

Posted

Eh...I hate to be that guy...but that's a job the router was born for.  Spiral straight bit and edge guide and don't think twice.

yeah and get it done in five minutes. Then  what do I do the rest of the weekend? :(

 

Posted

yeah and get it done in five minutes. Then  what do I do the rest of the weekend? :(

 

Fill the grooves with things. Router with edge guide is honestly your best bet for consistency as well as sanity. If you're gonna start cobbling together solutions for something that's already got an answer, you're wasting time building jigs and tools that already do the job rather than working on your project itself. 

Posted

Fill the grooves with things. Router with edge guide is honestly your best bet for consistency as well as sanity. If you're gonna start cobbling together solutions for something that's already got an answer, you're wasting time building jigs and tools that already do the job rather than working on your project itself. 

My project? Can you be more specific? I just want to improve my hand tool techniques. If that means I have to make a tool, then I make it and enjoy the process. 

 

Posted

So in this case, I would saw multiple kerfs running parallel to your groove shoulders and then destroy the waste with a chisel. Clean up with a router plane and a shoulder plane. You mentioned it's a stopped groove. Might need to be gentle near the stopped portions. Treat that area like a mortise. 

I think power tools and stopped grooves were meant for each other. Even on narrow grooves, you have to resort to a chisel because the plows skate will ride up and over the stopped portion. 

  • Like 1
Posted

You may want to consider a kerfing saw riding against a batten to define the margins, repeated passes with the saw in the waste area to ease removal, chisel the waste and cleanup with a router plane... Look for a kerfing saw with a depth stop and fence...

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   3 Members, 0 Anonymous, 64 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,008
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Bob44
    Newest Member
    Bob44
    Joined