bleedinblue Posted April 19, 2018 Report Posted April 19, 2018 The previous owners routed drains from the downspouts away from the house, so that's awesome, the problem is last week one of them popped open. The dirt around it either eroded away, or the dog dug it up (no signs of that, though), or it just naturally worked it's way up. For some reason they didn't extend the drain pipe all the way down and out of the yard, it is only about halfway. I'm going to extend it on down the hill and just outside of the fence when I re-bury the existing pipe. What I'm not clear on though is how to terminate it. My neighbor is a contractor and he says to just leave it exposed, but wouldn't that allow it to fill with dirt and debris? On the other hand, if the end is buried...same question, how does it continue to allow flow? Up until now the end of the pipe was buried in the center of my yard and I didn't even know it, I always assumed the pipes ran to the woodline. Any tips? Quote
Tpt life Posted April 19, 2018 Report Posted April 19, 2018 Look for pop ups. They lay flat with gravity when dry, but the stopper floats up to let water out. NDS 422G 4" Pop Up Drainage Emitter with Elbow, Green https://www.amazon.com/dp/B002CSQ0P2/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_api_.9f2AbRR0FCPK Quote
Woodenskye Posted April 19, 2018 Report Posted April 19, 2018 What I did was I had it sloped a little more at the end and I also dug a deep hole and filled with small rocks. The rock goes over the downspout that is buried and then put some top soil and the grass I cut. No issues. 1 Quote
Guest Posted April 19, 2018 Report Posted April 19, 2018 3 hours ago, C Shaffer said: Look for pop ups. They lay flat with gravity when dry, but the stopper floats up to let water out. NDS 422G 4" Pop Up Drainage Emitter with Elbow, Green https://www.amazon.com/dp/B002CSQ0P2/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_api_.9f2AbRR0FCPK 28 minutes ago, Woodenskye said: What I did was I had it sloped a little more at the end and I also dug a deep hole and filled with small rocks. The rock goes over the downspout that is buried and then put some top soil and the grass I cut. No issues. When redoing the drainage at my sister and brother in laws house, we used both of these options. Their house is on 30+ acres on the CT/RI border and they get a crap ton of weird weather. Tons of rain and trees and animals everywhere. We used the gravel on the long run on one side of the house that ran downhill and completely buried it to prevent critters from infiltrating. We used the pop up closer to the house, but still downhill some, as winter was setting in at the time and we wanted to get it done before the ground froze too much. Quote
RichardA Posted April 19, 2018 Report Posted April 19, 2018 Gravel is used in drainage fields for septic tanks, it should work fine for rain runoff. 1 Quote
Isaac Posted April 19, 2018 Report Posted April 19, 2018 Mine (installed by previous owners contractor) simply come to daylight with some rock at the end, to avoid washout. No issues. The rain seems to flush the pipe clean of any minor debris that settles in there easily. Quote
Chestnut Posted April 19, 2018 Report Posted April 19, 2018 Are you sure that's the end? The pipe might run to the property line and due to some circumstances the soil could have eroded around the pipe and gotten carried away. For this small flexible pipe it's possible for the joints to separate and cause a sink hole like this. There is a name for it but i can't remember it right now. It could also run to a french drain, I don't know what soil conditions are like in STL area. If you soil is really sandy and takes infiltration well it may not daylight to the surface at all and would just drain to a rock bed and into the ground. If that's the case the above still might be the case. If you get more details on what exactly is going on it might be easier to figure out a solution. My advice at this point is if you need to put some rock in make sure that the rock is angular. Round pea rock is BAD when it gets full of soil and water it turns into a liquid and will cause more problems than solve. Also you might need a bit of landscaping fabric to separate soil from rock or soil from the pipe in the ground. A good practice is to wrap the pipe joins in a filter fabric to stop what i mentioned above. You won't have to worry about an open end. A properly designed system will get enough velocity to clean the pipe. Looking at your pictures your problem will be erosion around the end from too much velocity not the other way around. You could do a pop up but those are more for aesthetics than anything. So unless you want to hide the end an open pipe is common practice. Let me know if you have any other questions stormwater is my wheelhouse. Quote
thatCharlieDude Posted April 19, 2018 Report Posted April 19, 2018 What I did with our downspouts Quote
AceHoleInOne Posted April 19, 2018 Report Posted April 19, 2018 I would put a T there with a removable cap so you can run a garden hose and use it as a snake should you need to clean the pipe out. Terminate the pipe past the fence with a removable cap and drill holes in it for drainage. -Ace- Quote
Tom King Posted April 19, 2018 Report Posted April 19, 2018 I dig out a spot maybe a foot and a half square, and 8" under the solid PVC pipe. With the pipe propped up that 8 inches above the bottom of the hole, sticking out into clear air with some to spare, I pour concrete around it, and finish the concrete flush with the top of the ground. Once the concrete is set up, I cut the PVC pipe flush with the surface of the concrete using a Sawzall. That way, you can drive a mower, or truck right over it, and it can't get hurt. I've never had to redo one, and have done many. I do the same thing for my complicated basement waterproofing system drains, and I've driven the 16,000 lb. tractor right over them many times, with no trouble. The basement French drain outlets have two or three 4" pipes in the same outlets. The plastic that's exposed to the sun gradually deteriorates, but the concrete remains. I've also never had to clean one out. Quote
bleedinblue Posted April 22, 2018 Author Report Posted April 22, 2018 On 4/19/2018 at 9:24 AM, Chestnut said: Are you sure that's the end? The pipe might run to the property line and due to some circumstances the soil could have eroded around the pipe and gotten carried away. For this small flexible pipe it's possible for the joints to separate and cause a sink hole like this. There is a name for it but i can't remember it right now. It could also run to a french drain, I don't know what soil conditions are like in STL area. If you soil is really sandy and takes infiltration well it may not daylight to the surface at all and would just drain to a rock bed and into the ground. If that's the case the above still might be the case. If you get more details on what exactly is going on it might be easier to figure out a solution. My advice at this point is if you need to put some rock in make sure that the rock is angular. Round pea rock is BAD when it gets full of soil and water it turns into a liquid and will cause more problems than solve. Also you might need a bit of landscaping fabric to separate soil from rock or soil from the pipe in the ground. A good practice is to wrap the pipe joins in a filter fabric to stop what i mentioned above. You won't have to worry about an open end. A properly designed system will get enough velocity to clean the pipe. Looking at your pictures your problem will be erosion around the end from too much velocity not the other way around. You could do a pop up but those are more for aesthetics than anything. So unless you want to hide the end an open pipe is common practice. Let me know if you have any other questions stormwater is my wheelhouse. It is entirely possible that that's not the end, but I poked around a couple of feet past it and couldn't find more pipe. My neighbor has lived here since this house was built, has known everyone who has lived here, and has a lot of knowledge of the work that has been done here. He says he is pretty confident they didn't carry the pipe to the fence, he said the owners that did that work were lazy. I'm not sure how a french drain works with downspouts and their drainage. I am pretty sure my basement has a french drain, and the sump pump drains into this particular pipe, but I'm sure that's not what you mean. If it means this drain could be the collection point for all of the downspouts from each corner of the house, that's entirely possible. I just don't know for sure. I think I am leaning toward the pop-up, mainly because it's easy for me to visualize and it "should" look good. I'm very much a visual learner, so wrapping my head around these descriptions aren't the easiest for me. I do have a lot of landscaping rock, we have a lot of landscaping that has rock and we are slowly transitioning to mulch. This rock is all half inch to an inch round. I think my neighbor rattled off one option of filling up a five gallon bucket with this rock and burying it at the end of the pipe to reduce the exit velocity and subsequent erosion. I see HD has this, too, so this could help to keep debris out of the pipe... Quote
Chestnut Posted April 22, 2018 Report Posted April 22, 2018 If that's the end of the line a pop up will probably be your best bet. Balances being nice looking, functional, and easy. You don't really want a grate on the outlet end of a pipe because it will either get blown off or trap debris inside the pipe (that enters from the inlet end) and get plugged. Quote
Tpt life Posted April 22, 2018 Report Posted April 22, 2018 The ONLY reason I suggest pop up is the better chance of maintaining a usable yard without a hole. Tom’s way is my preferred sans the concrete as that is how I was trained in non-trafficked areas. We cut the pipe a tad below flush and installed a walkable critter grate that would help contain some soil for planting. The downhill side can benefit from a sod transfer as water events can wash new seed away for weeks after planting. Quote
Tom King Posted April 22, 2018 Report Posted April 22, 2018 I'll try to take some pictures tomorrow of one. My "french drains" for basement waterproofing always have the drain pipe coming out to daylight somewhere downhill. Sometimes the gutter drain exits at the same place. Every one is different, for its own particular reasons. Quote
bleedinblue Posted April 22, 2018 Author Report Posted April 22, 2018 48 minutes ago, C Shaffer said: The ONLY reason I suggest pop up is the better chance of maintaining a usable yard without a hole. Tom’s way is my preferred sans the concrete as that is how I was trained in non-trafficked areas. We cut the pipe a tad below flush and installed a walkable critter grate that would help contain some soil for planting. The downhill side can benefit from a sod transfer as water events can wash new seed away for weeks after planting. Do you have a picture, or what search terms I could look for to find one? The part past the fence isn't trafficked really at all. A few random kids chasing a loose ball or dog, that's about it. Quote
Tpt life Posted April 22, 2018 Report Posted April 22, 2018 Don’t overthink it. Something sort of like this only with bigger holes and made of steel. I am fairly sure we were cutting up commercial entry grates (I did all this work for a college and my boss on the side.) the idea was that when we set these a half inch below grade and filled around the tile, the grass would root through that area and hold it in place by locking the soil in place. If it is untrafficked, Tom’s way is likely cheaper if you don’t slum around job sites like I do all summer. A bag of quick set even makes it a shorter process. NDS 1211G 12-Inch Square Grate, Black https://www.amazon.com/dp/B000BOC4ZO/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_api_Fpp3AbW2TQ73Q Quote
Tom King Posted April 22, 2018 Report Posted April 22, 2018 I have used something similar to that also, but always set the whole assembly in concrete. If it was in an area that never gets mowed, I might not use the concrete, but if it's going to ever be driven over by anything, I want to make sure it won't get hit with a mower blade, and that wheels can roll right over it with no worries, and not turn into something that can only be trimmed around with a string trimmer. Quote
Pondhockey Posted April 24, 2018 Report Posted April 24, 2018 Late to the party, but what worked for me in a similar situation was to run water from the house using a perforated pipe covered with a sock. I ran the pipe to a french drain (basically a trench filled with rocks; I've also use a deep hole filled with a perforated pipe covered by a sock. How, and how well these ideas work depends a lot on the soil and water table. I insisted on a foundation drain for my current house, watched it being installed, and then tried to test it. Like the builder told me, the soil is so porous that the water I poured down the drain never made it to the outlet. My garage drains just go out to a large buried hole filled with rocks. the garage/shop is heated and this is snow country, so lots of snow comes in with the vehicles and goes down the drain. Never (yet) a problem. Quote
AJ_Engineer Posted April 24, 2018 Report Posted April 24, 2018 I used a NDS pop-up in my previous house in Nebraska. Soil was too high in the clay content to do a french drain so I just dumped it out at the property line and it flowed into the road from there. Quote
Tom King Posted April 28, 2018 Report Posted April 28, 2018 I was by one of the old houses we look after this morning, checking to see when we need to cut the grass, and remembered to take this picture. This is from one of my basement waterproofing systems. It gets driven over by a 16,000 lb. tractor, and batwing mower. I think it was 2011 when we put this system in, so the 4" PVC hasn't been exposed to sunlight long enough to deteriorate yet, but in some more years, there will only be the concrete left, where it's exposed to sunlight. This has been trouble free. 1 Quote
sjeff70 Posted April 28, 2018 Report Posted April 28, 2018 If a pop-up is used without adequate drainage then it will arode the soil around the pop-up. I've only seen these pop-ups used on top of small dry-wells buried in the ground, so that the water can disperse in the ground away from the pop-up. If there is excessive water, beyond the capacity of the dry-well, then the pop-up allows excess water to escape. This is my understanding, I have no direct experience in the matter. Quote
Tpt life Posted April 28, 2018 Report Posted April 28, 2018 1 hour ago, sjeff70 said: If a pop-up is used without adequate drainage then it will arode the soil around the pop-up. I've only seen these pop-ups used on top of small dry-wells buried in the ground, so that the water can disperse in the ground away from the pop-up. If there is excessive water, beyond the capacity of the dry-well, then the pop-up allows excess water to escape. This is my understanding, I have no direct experience in the matter. See the pic. It’s a slope. Quote
sjeff70 Posted May 1, 2018 Report Posted May 1, 2018 On 4/28/2018 at 12:59 PM, C Shaffer said: See the pic. It’s a slope. If there is a lot of water that needs diverted, water will remain for a long time around the pop-up while it is coming out. Areas around my downspouts have taller and greener grass than the rest of the lawn. The earth is also more sunken at the downspout. No big deal, it all depends on what you want. Of course this all depends on soil conditions. Quote
bleedinblue Posted May 12, 2018 Author Report Posted May 12, 2018 I ultimately did a pop up. I *think* it went well. The slight grade of the yard continues past the fence and the location of the pop up, so the water flows out and away from the pop up pretty well. Aside from the labor of digging the trench, the components and the pop up couldn't have been simpler to piece together. 1 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.