Recommended Posts

Posted

I'm in the market to buy my first table saw...my budget is $600-$700 CDN. My budget leaves me few choices...either a contractor saw or a low-end hybrid saw. I'm avoiding contractor saws for obvious reasons. I have it narrowed down to either a Ridgid or a used Craftsman.

 

As it stands now the best bang for my buck is the Ridgid R4512 (link below)...$600 new.

 

However someone is selling a used Craftsman saw for $600 (link below)...appears to be a older version of their $1000 offering now. Both are labeled by Craftsman as a Hybrid.

 

If the Craftsman saw a better saw than the Ridgid? Or is the Craftsman over priced?

 

Or should I keep looking for a better saw at my price point (I don't think one exists to be honest, but I may be wrong). Living in Canada (NF to be exact), my options are somewhat limited compared to other parts of Canada; much more limited to woodworkers south of the border (USA).

 

Any thoughts, advice or alternatives would be welcomed...thx.

 

Ridgid R4512: http://www.homedepot.ca/product/10-inch-cast-iron-table-saw/965803

 

Used Craftsman: http://www.kijiji.ca/v-power-tool/st-johns/craftsman-table-saw/589794613?enableSearchNavigationFlag=true

 

New Craftsman: http://www.craftsman.com/craftsman-professional-1-3-4-hp-premium-hybrid-10inch/p-00922116000P?prdNo=3&blockNo=3&blockType=G3

Posted

I have to agree with TIDOS. Ridgid and Craftsman aren't the kind of quality I would want. I started out on a Craftsman table saw and burned up the motor ripping some oak. Replaced it with a Craftsman contractors saw and didn't really get happy until I got a better saw than that.

The table saw is the center of any woodworking shop. If you stretch and get a good one now the power and accuracy will last for years to come.

Posted

I had a Ridgid 3650 that worked quite well. I sold it for 50 bucks less than what I bought it. I'm sure the 4512 would serve you well until you can budget for a cabinet saw.

Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

Posted

I'm with Nestor on this one.

I have the ridgid, and while it is not the best saw out there it has served my needs well. Also, I have two people that want to buy it from me when I upgrade it. I'll lose about $50 on the deal. I consider that a win.

Posted

I'm not sure I understand what "not wanting a contractor saw for the obvious reasons" means, nor am I sure what the "obvious reasons" are.  I have a contractor saw and am quite happy to have it.  Mind you it's not one of those small plastic bodied units that you can get for $100 US.  Basically, at least to me, it's a pretty well made top half of a cabinet saw on a mobile base.  I had two of the plastic bodied on a metal stand variety and now use the second one at the barn for rough fix it work. 

 

My contractor saw at home, on the other hand, was the best I could afford at the time and is a solid well made saw.  The trunions run true, the dust collection is fair, the cast iron top is flat and, while it could be better powered, proves to be adequate when used properly.  The one part I'm less than satisfied with and is still adequate when used with care is the rip fence.

 

So, I don't want to seem offended but I'd suggest you do a little research before you dismiss an entire class of tools because of your (mis)perceptions.  My saw cost, US, more than the wheelhouse of what your budget is CDN (taking exchange rate into consideration).  In a small or smaller shop, there's a lot to be said for a mobile piece of equipment.  Just ask all the guys with cabinet saws who added mobile bases to them.

  • Like 1
Posted

I've heard some stories about that Ridgid having alignment issues.  It was impossible to get it aligned because as you raised and lowered the blade the alignment would change.  I don't know if that's something that only affects a percentage of the saws or was something that affected it early in production and has been fixed.  Something to check out carefully if you get that one.  I have a contractor saw too (ridgid 3650) and don't have any serious issue with it.  Just doesn't have a riving knife and could be a little smoother, and the fence could be better.

 

I would say the main difference between the two is the fence.  The Craftsman looks to have a Beis style while the Ridgid has a ye olde front and rear locking fence.

Posted

I use an old Rigid 24241, and am quite happy with it. The blade squares nicely to the slots, the table is flat and the fence is spot on. I can achieve finish ready cuts as long as my blade is clean. Personally, I find the front and rear locking fence to be very sturdy, with no deflection. The aluminum extrusion is very straight. But the best thing about the machine is the Herculift base it came with. In a garage shop like mine, mobility is everything!

  • Like 1
Posted

I do.  And I consider all three of the saws he linked to be hybrids.  I use contractor and jobsite saws interchangeably...any saw that you can pick up with your hands and put in a truck is a contractor/jobsite saw in my world.  A hybrid is too big and heavy to do that with, and if that's what Byrdie was talking about, then I generally agree with him.

 

But I do believe that a hybrid is probably bare bones for any serious hobby shop.  I personally wouldn't wanna be without my cabinet saw, but I could probably live with a hybrid.  I would never be happy if I had to do my work on a contractor saw.  I know that from experience.

Posted

The only difference between a "contractor" saw and a "hybrid" saw is the contractor saw has the motor hanging out the back while the hybrid has it inside.  Just because a hybrid looks like a cabinet saw doesn't mean it acts like a cabinet saw.  If anything the Ridgid 3650 contractor saw was heavier than the current one because it had cast iron extension wings instead of stamped steel.  It also cost over $100 USD more. 

Posted

I've heard some stories about that Ridgid having alignment issues.  It was impossible to get it aligned because as you raised and lowered the blade the alignment would change.  I don't know if that's something that only affects a percentage of the saws or was something that affected it early in production and has been fixed.  Something to check out carefully if you get that one.  ...

 

I've read a lot of stories about the R4512 having alignment issues....enough so that I'm no longer suggesting that people buy it.  It's not all of them, but it's been going on along time.  I've heard rumor of Ridgid getting a handle on the problem, only to read a slew of new threads about the issue.  It's been several years now....I doubt they're going to fix it.  Even the Griz G0715P that has a similar trunnion design has suffered some of the same alignment issue.  The new Delta 36-725 @ ~ $600 USD at Lowes appears to be the safer buy in a new full size hybrid style contractor saw.  Craftex should have the equivalent of the former Ridgid 3650 ....CT146 ($600 CDN). 

 

The used Craftsman you linked to appears to be an older 22114 made by Steel City.  It has cabinet mounted trunnions and was a good saw, but the fence on that model was marginal....$600 seems steep for a used saw with no riving knife, no warranty, and a modest fence.  

 

FWIW, most contractors use a portable jobsite saw, not a contractor saw, which makes the term sort of a misnomer.  A contractor saw is a full size cast iron belt drive saw....some of the newer ones have in inboard motor, while the older ones traditionally had an outboard motor hanging out the back.  Contractor saws have become largely relegated to stationary use in a home type shop.  

 

Contractor saws:

00921833000.jpgpm64a.jpg

 

 

Portable jobsite saw used by contractors :unsure: :

GTS1031C.jpg

Posted

Eric - no offense taken.  I was more offended by a former co-worker who corrected me shortly after I got the saw.  I would say "table saw" and he would butt in and say "contractor saw."

 

The point I was trying to make is that I paid $600 US for my saw and it's a pretty good, solid saw.  I sure as heck won't be trying to heft it into the back of any truck, at least not by myself.  Since the OP's budget was $600 CDN he's talking about less money than I paid for my saw if I understand the exchange rate correctly.  And I'm not trying to make this a battle of dollar value, just was trying to make the point that turning up one's nose at a particular type of saw because of the label it bears rather than the job it does may lead one away from a perfectly suitable choice.

 

If someone snuck into my shop in the middle of the night and left a used cabinet saw would I chuck it out?  Heck no!  But I probably won't be getting rid of the saw I have now anytime soon and on my budget it's light years better than the one I had. (Maybe will be upgrading the fence some time, however.)

 

I get your truck analogy and it's a good one.  But some trucks (and saws) aren't "make dos", they're appropriate (hate that word) to the job.

Posted

kiki/eric/lakisha, has the right way of thinking about it.   If you and one friend can pick it up and put it on a pick up, it's a lightweight and won't perform over many years!  And alighnment will be a growing problem!

  • 3 weeks later...
Posted

I'm glad this topic came up I was going to ask a close to question, I am looking for a good starter saw..to put in some kind of cabinet.. but until I can get to a place with a shop it will have to be able to stored somewhere out of the way.. thank you for the information and the links

Posted

Here's my limited opinion to add to the discussion, not necessarily help decide on the specific saws mentioned.

Our shop had a used craftsman. Worked ok, but certainly struggled, and had some design deficiencies. We were donated an older model Delta Unisaw, and it changed our shop. I love it.

So I agree that in a powertool shop, tablesaws generally take centerstage, and don't skimp if you don't have to. But I also understand having a next to nonexistant budget. So research, and as you research, look for deals.

  • Like 1
  • 2 weeks later...
Posted

The original poster hasn't even been online since May 8 ! It's amazing how a thread can take on a life of its own

 

I guess it's because table saw debates is such a hot/contested subject...Or perhaps I offended the contractor saw owners (not my intent).

 

 

Thanks to everyone that posted, I appreciate everyone taking the time to give me there opinions. Life took over and I didn't have time to respond promptly. 

 

I've decided to postpone my table saw purchase and continue to save until I can afford a "proper" saw...again, no offense to the contractor saw owners. When I were young and ventured into the world for my first time, I quickly realized you get what you pay for. So I adopted the personal policy of spending extra for quality rather than short changing myself. I would much rather wait and buy the saw I want, then settle and then lament my purchase for years. 

 

People often say you can't buy quality anymore; I respond, "you can still buy quality, you just can't get it at Wal-mart".

  • Like 2
Posted

...People often say you can't buy quality anymore; I respond, "you can still buy quality, you just can't get it at Wal-mart".

 

True, but Busy Bee might be able to  help you....the Craftex CT146 is on sale from $699 to $475, leaving some budget for a decent blade or two, plus a mobile base or aftermarket miter gauge.  The original TS3650 that the CT146 is very similar to, had a very large happy following...

 

Here's a nifty video of the saw

 

craftex-ct146-contractor-table-saw.jpg

Posted

As contractor saw owner (traditional with cast iron and belt drive motor hanging off the back)  I am totally offended! :)  Just kidding of course!  If you are able to take the time and and are able to get a higher end saw, I say go for it! 

Posted

 

I've decided to postpone my table saw purchase and continue to save until I can afford a "proper" saw...again, no offense to the contractor saw owners.

 

I hate to see a good fire go out so quickly so I feel I must stir the coals a little. What do you consider a "proper " saw? :D

Posted

i am a little late to the party. i have a rigid saw that i bought used from the home depot rental.  they replace them about once a year.  i replaced the blades and it works fine.  i don't really have much of a shop and it works for me cuz i can wheel it in and out of the garage. if i built a shop i would probably not get a new saw and just build a cabinet with extensions around this saw.

  • 2 weeks later...
Posted

I used a Rigid hybrid for about 7 years.  It was a difficult saw to tune up but as long as I was careful it cut safely.  My biggest complaint with the saw was the fence which always pulled to one direction when locked in place.  I could never get it just right and had to be careful about kick back.  Other than that it worked extremely well.  If I had to chose between the saws you indicated I would go with the Rigid.

You might want to check out the Grizzly saws.  Almost every review gives them the thumbs up for best bang for the buck.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.