Recommended Posts

Posted

I'm in the market for a new jointer. 90+ % of the things I will be jointing will be 50" and under making me perfectly ok with a 46-48" bed. My small garage shop will also not allow much more than that either.

Problem.. I'm revving up to build my forever bench and those top 7'x4.5" sticks are throwing me a curve ball. Another issue besides bed length is power. Most jointers in that class are running a 1 horse motor. For those with a jointer in this class, do you think it would be possible to accurately mill boards that big on a new machine with only the 1-1.5 hp available?

Posted

I'm in the market for a new jointer. 90+ % of the things I will be jointing will be 50" and under making me perfectly ok with a 46-48" bed. My small garage shop will also not allow much more than that either.

Problem.. I'm revving up to build my forever bench and those top 7'x4.5" sticks are throwing me a curve ball. Another issue besides bed length is power. Most jointers in that class are running a 1 horse motor. For those with a jointer in this class, do you think it would be possible to accurately mill boards that big on a new machine with only the 1-1.5 hp available?

My jointer is a delta x5 series 6". It's about 1.5 hp I believe, and I've never had an issue flattening face stock full 6" and 6 feet long.

My shop is small as well, but I will make room for an 8" jointer soon - it seems every board I buy is 6.5 to 7.5" wide. I would also like the longer tables.

Posted

Lunchbox planers can and regularly do plane 12-13" wide boards running no more than 1 or 1.5 hp. And from a cutting/motor perspective that's really no different than what a jointer does. I'd say a similar principle applies: if the motor starts to bog down just set it for a lighter cut. I keep my 8" jointer with a 1 or 1.5 hp motor set to take about 1/32" per pass and have never had any problems with it bogging down.

Posted

So now that the 1 or 1.5 hp won't be a problem,

What do you guys think about being able to fave and edge a few 7' boards on a 46" platform?

My thoughts are that hand too guys can do it with 22-24" so I should be able to get it with proper support.

Posted

A little extra HP on a 6" jointer can be a useful thing for longer boards.   When jointing boards longer than the tables, it's often helpful to take a much bigger bite during earlier passes.   This gets a straight reference edge on the outfeed faster, preventing you from making a narrower banana with a lot of shallow passes...  :D  

 

Shorter boards, where the ends never leave either table are less of an issue.  Of course, there are other ways to "prestraighten" a crook, but it's more work.

Posted

Yeah I agree that 1HP is probably enough on a 6" jointer most of the time.  You might have to slow down a bit when face jointing full-width exotics.  I take such a small bite on the jointer that I've probably never needed the 2HP that my jointer has.  The biggest drawback to smaller jointers is the smaller capacity, both length and width.  But if you're only building smaller projects it is a waste of space to have a bigger machine.  Problem is, you will occasionally do larger builds - it's inevitable - and you'll wish you had an 8" with longer beds when you do...but life ain't perfect.

 

If your lumberyard offers milling services, I'd probably have them joint all your boards for your benchtop slab.  A 6" jointer can handle the rest of the build.

Posted

I think Eric nailed it. I actually built my Roubo without owning a jointer, I picked my boards carefully, used a straight edge and router to get pretty close on the long edges, and used the skip technique Marc demonstrated in his guild build to flatten the faces. I glued the top sections into 12"x4.25" slabs, then ran them through my planner-with help, those slabs are heavy. Since then I was given a 6" jointer, and while I would like a 8" jointer, I get by.

Posted

Soo.. I took what you said mad thought about it more and was checking out on the grizzly 6" 46" model and decided I might as well check CL one last time to see what was around. 45 minutes later I was in an industrial park down the road at a picture framing company that was going out of business with a 4' straight edge in hand and came home with this aircraft carrier..

It's a Taiwan delta knockoff 8" rabbeting jointer with 2 hp induction motor and 72" bed. I was really unsure about where the heck it would go but it sits perfectly 1/2" under my table saw surface. It's a perfect fit.

Once it got into the shop, I knocked a bit of rust dust off of the tables, wd'40'd the adjusting mechanisms, rewired from 240 to 110, installed a dust right port over the chip chute and it's off to the races. This thing will plumb do work.

On the test run, I found it has a few decent Knicks in the blades where it leaves a ridge so I'm going to be looking for a new set of blades. Anybody have any recommendation?

Before I install the blades and go through the entire setup procedure, I'm going to give it a new coat of paint because the paint is pretty chipped and faded.

post-16319-0-77987800-1437017981_thumb.j

Posted

==>jointers are more speed than torque

More about mass at speed... Think flywheel... and favorable angle of attack --- it's why the higher-end jointers have 8" or 10" diameter heads...You need some torque get these bad boys up to speed... A decent monoblock head can weight 200lbs easy (I learned that the hard way when swapping bearings)... So it's not like the torque needed for a compressor, but it's not like a tablesaw either...

 

But for the OP --

If it's old-shool 1HP, it's fine for a 6" jointer... If you process Cherry, Maple, etc -- no problem.. If you process high-Janka sticks, then it's probably not the right tool for the job.

Posted

==>jointers are more speed than torque

More about mass at speed... Think flywheel... and favorable angle of attack --- it's why the higher-end jointers have 8" or 10" diameter heads...You need some torque get these bad boys up to speed... A decent monoblock head can weight 200lbs easy (I learned that the hard way when swapping bearings)... So it's not like the torque needed for a compressor, but it's not like a tablesaw either...

 

 

Something taking 1/32" passes doesn't need much torque when its spinning. Momentum will keep the mass spinning fast.  Look up start up current vs running current to see what I mean. 

Posted

Who takes 1/32” passes? Maybe with a toy... or maybe some sort of pretend jointer? Mine is rated for 19mm depth of cut over 340mm or so – and it takes torque to spin-up a 240lb cutterblock -- I've never taken a full depth full width cut -- don't think the DC would keep-up -- but I purchase rough stock, so I take plenty of 1/4" and 3/8 passes on face and 1/2+" on edge. The inrush is around 62a, give or take -- haven't measured it in a while.. Spun-up is around 20a. Real jointers are about mass in motion -- and keeping it that way.

 

Again, not a high-torque motor, but not a low-torque (read as tablesaw) either. It depends on the jointer -- if it's a small footprint 2 7/8" diameter head, then yea, you don't need much torque... But not all jointers are the same.

Posted

Who takes 1/32” passes? Maybe with a toy... or maybe some sort of pretend jointer? Mine is rated for 19mm depth of cut over 340mm or so – and it takes torque to spin-up a 240lb cutterblock -- I've never taken a full depth full width cut -- don't think the DC would keep-up -- but I purchase rough stock, so I take plenty of 1/4" and 3/8 passes on face and 1/2+" on edge. The inrush is around 62a, give or take -- haven't measured it in a while.. Spun-up is around 20a. Real jointers are about mass in motion -- and keeping it that way.

Wow! Those are some big bites! A 1/2" in a single pass - that's big!

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   2 Members, 0 Anonymous, 43 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,008
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Bob44
    Newest Member
    Bob44
    Joined