Mark J Posted October 23, 2015 Report Posted October 23, 2015 Doing a little searching in the forums I have seen a lot of discussions about random orbit sanders. I don't see any conversations about palm sanders, those square-ish units that mount a quarter sheet square of sand paper on a vibrating pad. Clearly random orbit sanders are popular and desirable, but what (if anything) is the roll of a palm sander. I have one that is multi-years old and wondering what to expect to use it for. Quote
Trip Posted October 23, 2015 Report Posted October 23, 2015 Not so popular anymore... Industry made a zillion of them, so I bet a fair percentage of WTO members have one in their toolbox... I've got a couple of Makitas -- used for DIY or the boatyard... Quote
treeslayer Posted October 23, 2015 Report Posted October 23, 2015 hey mark, I have both, a 5" RO and a porter cable 330 1/4 sheet. bought the PC in a weak moment, it's ok for sanding between coats of finish but that's about it, too soft of a pad, poor at removing planer marks or glue lines, I would like a 6" RO in the future, stick with the RO for fast stock removal and leave the 1/4 sheet for the light work, IMO 1 Quote
Coop Posted October 23, 2015 Report Posted October 23, 2015 I use the flexible sanding dealily that Marc showed us. Am thinking of using something electrical powered in the near future! Quote
Marty Backe Posted October 23, 2015 Report Posted October 23, 2015 I think they both have a place. I use my random orbit sanders most of the time, but I'll still use the PC when I need to sand narrow stock or finishes. The palm sander moves a lot less than a random orbit sander which will more easily get caught on the edges of narrow stock (such as face frames), and it's much less aggressive, which is good for sanding finishes.A palm sander also allows you to use a much wider variety of sandpaper since any sheet variety will work. For example, you can buy 2000+ grit wet/dry sandpaper at your local auto store and use it with your palm sander to sand finishes. Your choice in 5 or 6 inch disks is much more limited. 1 Quote
collinb Posted October 23, 2015 Report Posted October 23, 2015 And a palm sander, with its square edge, can let you do edges better than the RO.My wife does all our finish sanding and uses what's suited to the task.She is more concerned about the job than the tool. Quote
treeslayer Posted October 23, 2015 Report Posted October 23, 2015 marty is right, more choices for sandpaper with a palm and it does get into corners better, forgot to add i have a ryobi detail sander for the really tight spaces, all are PSA, but lets not open the can of worms called PSA vs hook and loop Quote
Mark J Posted October 23, 2015 Author Report Posted October 23, 2015 Thanks for the insights (and further comments that may yet come). If I get a random orbit sander I won’t toss this one out. I recently finished a small bench (think elongated step stool). I pulled out the palm sander that I’ve had these many years, but I was impressed at how much work it took to keep the thing flat on the boards and moving where I wanted it to go, and frankly it transmits a heck of a lot of vibration to my wrists. And did I mention loud.All in all it was so unpleasant that I got out a sanding block and went at the project by hand. Actually this was very relaxing. This was no dining room table, just a small bench, with no particular time line, but I found it quite pleasant to do after a day at the office (it’s more mindless than say using a power saw). So I don’t think I will give up hand sanding for small pieces. Although next time I think I might make up separate sanding blocks for each of the sand paper grits that I am going to use. That way I can quickly change grits while working on one board without changing paper, and be less inclined to throw out an half used sheet rather than reload it on the sanding block. Quote
Brendon_t Posted October 23, 2015 Report Posted October 23, 2015 I agree that most of us own them, they are just old tech with better options available. I have one that I use every once in a while. Most recently to clean up rust on a jointer bed.I liken the difference to something like the biscuit jointer. Guys still have them, many have upgraded to a dominatrix Quote
Chet Posted October 23, 2015 Report Posted October 23, 2015 I am weird, I still have three palm sanders set with different grits I use for final sanding. And I still use my biscuit joiner, although that is changing some as grow in to other methods, no dominos though... Yet. Quote
Tom King Posted October 24, 2015 Report Posted October 24, 2015 this thread made me look at my 330 today. It's a Rockwell that did a lot of work until they came out with RO sanders. I haven't used it in so long that the pad on it is dry rotten. Quote
Coop Posted October 24, 2015 Report Posted October 24, 2015 this thread made me look at my 330 today. It's a Rockwell that did a lot of work until they came out with RO sanders. I haven't used it in so long that the pad on it is dry rotten. I get the feeling that if you could find a new pad, you would! Sounds like an old friend? Quote
rodger. Posted October 24, 2015 Report Posted October 24, 2015 I had two of these units, and sold them both. All they did was collect dust and get in the way. I use the ets 150/3 for all power sanding now, and I use a wood block with cork to finish sand between coats of finish. Quote
Pete Staehling Posted October 24, 2015 Report Posted October 24, 2015 I hadn't used the 1/4 sheet sander in a long time since the pad was shot a few years ago. After reading this thread I dug it out and refurbished it. I have a couple RO sanders that I use constantly and thought it might be nice to have the 1/4 sheet sander again to do final sanding and sometimes sanding between coats. I tried a some scraps switching between the three sanders with 100, 220, and 600 grit and was please with how quickly I hot a very nice smooth surface. The drawback was that the 1/4 sheet sander was really hard on my arthritic hands and wrists. Quote
Tom King Posted October 24, 2015 Report Posted October 24, 2015 I get the feeling that if you could find a new pad, you would! Sounds like an old friend?I'm sure I have replacement pad somewhere, as well as the soft, flexible one, but I must not have needed to use this sander, because I probably haven't even thought about it for 20 years. It's the same as the PC 330-just made the few years in the early '70s when Rockwell owned the Porter-Cable manufacturing. Quote
collinb Posted October 30, 2015 Report Posted October 30, 2015 Personally, I wouldn't worry about replacing the pad.Just watch CL & yard sale ads.Lots of time a good unit is out there for $10 or less.And you'll likely spend >$10 on a pad.Unless you really like that unit ... Quote
BuilderBill Posted October 31, 2015 Report Posted October 31, 2015 Doing a little searching in the forums I have seen a lot of discussions about random orbit sanders. I don't see any conversations about palm sanders, those square-ish units that mount a quarter sheet square of sand paper on a vibrating pad. Clearly random orbit sanders are popular and desirable, but what (if anything) is the roll of a palm sander. I have one that is multi-years old and wondering what to expect to use it for.The problem with the old orbital sanders is that they leave pigtails in the surface no matter how you run them. That's why everybody uses RO sanders, they're a better mousetrap. You could cut an 8-1/2x11 piece of plywood, put it on top of your sandpaper sheets and use the sander to weight it down and keep them flat. Or just realize it's an obsolete technology and pitch it in the trash.As far as sanding finish between coats, if you need a sander to do that you need to work on your finishing chops. Quote
ponderingturtle Posted November 3, 2015 Report Posted November 3, 2015 I think they both have a place. I use my random orbit sanders most of the time, but I'll still use the PC when I need to sand narrow stock or finishes. The palm sander moves a lot less than a random orbit sander which will more easily get caught on the edges of narrow stock (such as face frames), and it's much less aggressive, which is good for sanding finishes.A palm sander also allows you to use a much wider variety of sandpaper since any sheet variety will work. For example, you can buy 2000+ grit wet/dry sandpaper at your local auto store and use it with your palm sander to sand finishes. Your choice in 5 or 6 inch disks is much more limited.You can order 2000 grit discs. http://www.amazon.com/Sungold-Abrasives-024264-5-Inch-Premium/dp/B008JT789U/ref=sr_1_2?ie=UTF8&qid=1446569992&sr=8-2&keywords=5"+hook+and+loop+2000 Quote
treeslayer Posted November 3, 2015 Report Posted November 3, 2015 i'm with you ponderingturtle,i thought builderbill was a little harsh in his judgement of plan sanders, i used a makita palm sander until i got my RO, when i bought my PC330 i didn't like it for general sanding duties but i love it for sanding between coats of finish and as a finish sand before stain Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.