Recommended Posts

Posted

Found an article on making you own spoke Shave looks like a fun little project but I will need a rasp or 2 to shape the handles.  My online research is not helping me figure out what rasp(s) I need. 

So how are rasps graded?  Grain, TPI, teeth per sq. cm?

How to I compare different brands?

What would you recommend for a project like this?  I think $100 per file is a little steep for me.

Beyond this one project - If you only had 2 or 3 rasps, what sizes, shape and coarseness would you choose ( assume no real heavy duty wood removal)?

Posted

I'd go coarse, medium, fine. So maybe a 6 grain, 9, grain, 13 grain. Though you don't necessarily need a rasp to do this, you can use any method of shaping. You can power carve, you can chip carve and sand, etc. I've read people having good success with the Narex rasps. Auriou, and Logier rasps are  $100+ each. The difference is they are hand stitched versus machine stitched. Hardness, steel quality, etc also plays into the quality of the rasp. For what you're doing a nicholson rasp or Narex rasp will be more than sufficient. 

Posted

Here is a really good video from Chris Schwarz on rasps.  Explains the differences and what you need to get started.

I have a bunch of cheap rasps and I was given an Auriou 9" 10 grain for Christmas.  The Auriou is on a different level completely.  Cuts like a hot knife through melted butter. 

Posted

I have looked at Narex and Nicholson rasps on line.  I understand that there is quite a difference between machine and hand stitched rasps that has to do with the alignment of the teeth and thus the smoothness of cut.  It looks like the Narex are machine (CNC) stitched and that the Nicholson are hand stitched.  The teeth in pics of Nicholson files appear to me more randomly spaced.   Are these observations correct and does it really make a difference?
 

Posted

Hand stitched rasps are less uniform in position and therefor do not try to track like machined or machine stitched teeth (too regular).  I have a Nicholson 49 but, had to go through three of them to get one I would accept; really poor initial product and QA currently.  I have been happy with a Grobert #6 that I have had for awhile.

They take some getting used to but, I have a couple of Japanese Milled Tooth files that I find myself reaching for more than I would have thought.  If I had to limit it to 2 I would probably go with a Shinto (no, really . . . very versatile) and a #6 half round toothed on both surfaces.

Posted

I agree with Eric.  I know it is always tempting to save money but Auriou rasps are just plain awesome and you only "need" a few of them.  Yes they are addictive but you can easily and enjoyable get by with two of them.  I have a 9" 10 grain (or vice versa, can't remember) cabiner maker's rasp and a 13 grain modelers rasp.  

It makes no sense to me cheap out on this and try to save $50 when you can get the absolute best quality rasp imagineable for $110 or so.  This is truly one of the few bargains in woodworking.  

 

Posted
53 minutes ago, Mike. said:

I agree with Eric.  I know it is always tempting to save money but Auriou rasps are just plain awesome

+1  If you go with these pay attention when ordering, they are left and right handed.

  • Like 1
Posted

I dug a little deeper into the Auriou and Liogier web sites.  I understand that both are excellent rasps.  Right now I and mulling it all over. Since I don't see a need for a very aggressive cuts right now, I am leaning towards Liogier and Mike's suggestion of a 10"- #9G cabinet makers and a 7" #13 modellers rasp.  Logier looks to be a little less expensive.  Chet, Thanks for the right - left handed reminder. AceHOleinOne - interesting.  I saw those at woodcraft and will now take a second look.

Thanks for all of your replies.

Posted
6 hours ago, mds2 said:

Here is a really good video from Chris Schwarz on rasps.  Explains the differences and what you need to get started.

I have a bunch of cheap rasps and I was given an Auriou 9" 10 grain for Christmas.  The Auriou is on a different level completely.  Cuts like a hot knife through melted butter. 

Neat video. Thanks for sharing. I always wondered how to pronounce Auriou. "RU"

Posted

One of my Auriou rasps is a 5 on one side, 9 on the other, so you get two for one.  I also have a 13 modeler rasp and a 10 half round.  Those three have served me very well. They are worth the money if you are going to work curves in the future. 

  • 3 weeks later...
Posted
On 4/27/2016 at 2:24 PM, AceHoleInOne said:

151297.jpg

 

I'm gonna cheap out. Flat ass removes wood and for $20.00. A "yeah buddy" in my book! 

 

-Ace-

18 minutes into the video, check it out...

Posted

I received mine today but it looks like they backordered the sustainer.

Rasp.jpg

Sweet Ken! Is that the 9 grain? And dont feel left out, none of mine came with systainers either. I paid extra for that

Sent from my SM-N910W8 using Tapatalk

Posted

Thanks! It's the 9", 10 grain. It arrived about noon via UPS and I've been stroking it ever since, blatantly ignoring the priced packing slip:huh:

Posted
7 hours ago, K Cooper said:

I received mine today but it looks like they backordered the sustainer.

After I bought the Auriou's, but after I did I couldn't afford their sustainers :wacko:

Posted

So after playing with it for 30 min. or so, I'd say it takes it to comparable to 80 grt. sandpaper or so? One fine ma-chine mann! Now, how do you clean it , with a tooth pick, fine bristle dry paint brush or brass wire brush and what preventative do you take against rust?

25 minutes ago, Chet K. said:

After I bought the Auriou's, but after I did I couldn't afford their sustainers :wacko:

So true!

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   3 Members, 0 Anonymous, 44 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32k
    Total Topics
    437.5k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,007
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    FurniCore
    Newest Member
    FurniCore
    Joined