Marcus Hand Posted April 13, 2017 Report Posted April 13, 2017 Like most of us, I have limited shop space and one tool I've never felt justified the space it takes up is a miter saw. Currently, I break down lumber with a jig saw and do all cross cutting on table saw with an Incra miter gauge or my shop made sled. I have a project that I am wrapping up that requires cutting long crown molding. I've cut shorter crown molding in the past on my tablesaw, but even with the short length it felt awkward. I'm looking at getting a miter saw and am trying to think through whether I should get a less expensive miter saw that will get the crown molding job done or if I should spent more and get a miter saw that I could integrate with my workflow. The cheaper saw I'm looking at is the Dewalt 12" single-bevel saw. Lowes has it for $220 and it should get the crown molding job done and then I would probably try to find a place outside of my shop to store it. The more expensive option would probably be the Bosch gliding miter saw. They have 10" and 12" options and are around $600. If I go the Bosch route, I would setup a permanent place for it in my shop and would want to use it for most of my cross cutting. My questions: I'm assuming the Dewalt is likely not going to be accurate enough to use as a final cut cross cutting option. Maybe this is bad assumption? If I go Bosch, any reason to get the 10" instead of 12"? The cost is comparable here and wouldn't be a consideration. With the 10" there are probably more blade options and I could use same blades as table saw. For those that use a miter saw in your workflow, do you consider it a must have now? Do you see it as a big improvement to how you work? Is it safe to break down rough boards with a miter saw? Before jointing rough boards, I always break them down to rough size with a jigsaw. It works, but can be bit of a pain. Quote
Eric. Posted April 13, 2017 Report Posted April 13, 2017 All good questions. I like options. I think ultimately you'd be happy you went with the slider. If you're gonna go 10", you might as well go 12". Do not break down rough material with a miter saw. Quote
gee-dub Posted April 13, 2017 Report Posted April 13, 2017 Having bought a miter saw and having had to store it 99.999% of the time, I would have to cut a lot of molding before I would buy as opposed to rent. Especially if you are space challenged. My saw sets on its stand in the shed out back and comes out every other year or so to cut long, thin stock. If I could get a decent return on it (or if I ever need the space it is taking up) it would go in a heartbeat and I would beg, borrow, rent when I needed that function. P.s. As Eric mentions, I use a jigsaw to breakdown rough material. Cutting irregular material on any fixed-path machine is asking for kickback. 1 Quote
BonPacific Posted April 13, 2017 Report Posted April 13, 2017 Like many others, my miter saw lives in the shed, not the workshop. I've also never been called upon to do crown molding. But here's my advice: Go 12", because at some point you're probably going to want to cut a 4x4 fence post or other thick stock, and not having to do any crazy tricks is worth it. My second bit of advice is look for used options. A single-bevel saw is a relatively simple tool, and they can take a lot of abuse. My old Hitachi has been beat to hell, and still cuts square. At least locally, you can usually find a homeowner or DIY'er selling one off after one crown-molding job. Even a slider, as long as you check it for square, should be a relatively safe used purchase, plus you can probably sell it at the end for what you paid. 1 Quote
..Kev Posted April 13, 2017 Report Posted April 13, 2017 Just another thought to add to yours.. It sounds to me like this is a need for a job inside yours (or another) house? I know when I have larger jobs like this in my house, I try and set up my cutting station in the house. Several trips to the shop to get a cut just right gets old really quick! So, with that in mind, something with DC makes more sense. From there, having some sort of portable stand that you can set up when you want to use the saw in your shop would make perfect sense. The Bosch 12" is a very nice saw and would be my choice if I didn't have the Kapex. I love having the SCMS in my shop and don't want to imagine my shop without it. As far as the safety part goes, the way you're doing it is the safest way. With that said, if I have material that isn't really warped and twisted, I will break it down on the miter. For smaller stuff like crown, I nearly always just use the miter saw. 1 Quote
drzaius Posted April 13, 2017 Report Posted April 13, 2017 I use my miter saw just enough to keep it, but certainly not to have a full on miter saw station. Mine is in a cubby in some shelves & is on heavy duty slides so I can pull it out to use, yet it doesn't take much space when stored. The cubby is enclosed on the sides & top & has an 8" duct connected to it, so dust collection is not a problem. I'd definitely go with a 12" if you're going to get one. You'll only use 1 kind of blade on it, so just get a good 12" blade & leave it on all the time. 1 Quote
SawDustB Posted April 13, 2017 Report Posted April 13, 2017 38 minutes ago, drzaius said: I use my miter saw just enough to keep it, but certainly not to have a full on miter saw station. Mine is in a cubby in some shelves & is on heavy duty slides so I can pull it out to use, yet it doesn't take much space when stored. The cubby is enclosed on the sides & top & has an 8" duct connected to it, so dust collection is not a problem. I'd definitely go with a 12" if you're going to get one. You'll only use 1 kind of blade on it, so just get a good 12" blade & leave it on all the time. Any chance you'd have a picture, Frank? I haven't found a great way to use mine, but that sounds like an interesting setup. Quote
TerryMcK Posted April 13, 2017 Report Posted April 13, 2017 I would definitely go the Bosch Glide route. Takes up much less room behind than a conventional slider. 2 Quote
Chet Posted April 13, 2017 Report Posted April 13, 2017 2 hours ago, Marcus Hand said: If I go Bosch, any reason to get the 10" instead of 12"? The cost is comparable here and wouldn't be a consideration. With the 10" there are probably more blade options and I could use same blades as table saw. I have the Bosch 12" glide and I am real happy with it. With just a minor adjustment out of the box it makes excellent final cross cuts. The price is close so just get the 12", sharing a blade with the table saw would get old real quick. You do want to take some time and make a better zero clearance plate and fence for it. 1 Quote
Woodenskye Posted April 13, 2017 Report Posted April 13, 2017 I have a Hitatchi 12" which will slide forward on the rails so it takes up a little less space. I swapped the blade and got it set up where it cuts perfectly. However I am looking to reorganize my shop and I may ditch and keep in my shed. It just takes up to big of a footprint. 1 Quote
drzaius Posted April 13, 2017 Report Posted April 13, 2017 2 hours ago, SawDustB said: Any chance you'd have a picture, Frank? I haven't found a great way to use mine, but that sounds like an interesting setup. I can do that this weekend. Gotta warn you though, it's nothing pretty. Quote
Tom King Posted April 13, 2017 Report Posted April 13, 2017 If you're not going to use one much, it's foolish to put a bunch of money in one. I have several, including one we call the "beater". It's probably considered one of the bottom of the barrel ones. We had a wooden shingle making job a while back, and it was put in service to chop 8' boards down to 2' lengths. I tied the trigger on with a piece of wire. One helper slid a board through until it hit a stop. After the board hit the stop, using my left hand, I chopped the board as fast as I could. I used my left hand so that I could take the cut piece off with my right hand, and stack it to be carried to the infeed side of the resaw bandsaw by my other helper. We made some number of thousands of cuts like this for runs of a couple of hours at the time. The motor started smelling hot once, so I unplugged it and poured some of the nearest lubricant I could find down into the bearings through the air slots. The lubricant was leftovers in a rear axle lubricant bottle-I think 90-140 synthetic. It never stopped running after that. It still today can be used to cut molding accurately, if I need it to, and it gets carried to jobsites where we don't want to bother to take the slider. It's a Ryobi 12" that came off of Craigslist for 50 bucks, and the blade is a 100 tooth 35 buck blade from Home Depot. It would do your crown molding job just fine. 2 Quote
drzaius Posted April 13, 2017 Report Posted April 13, 2017 9 minutes ago, Mike. said: I don't keep a miter saw in my shop. for my furniture work it would be a waste of space. If I were to buy one for a trim job it would be a 12" non slider. Sliders have more moving parts, which is more that can go wrong. sliders are also harder to transport. 12" will give you enough cutting capacity for nearly all trim jobs. See if CPO outlet has a refurb unit. Sliders also have much more flex than a non slider. If I had to get another, I'd go 12" non slider. Quote
Chet Posted April 13, 2017 Report Posted April 13, 2017 33 minutes ago, drzaius said: Sliders also have much more flex than a non slider. If I had to get another, I'd go 12" non slider This is what makes the Bosch glide so superior, it doesn't have that flex. Quote
drzaius Posted April 13, 2017 Report Posted April 13, 2017 7 minutes ago, Chet K said: This is what makes the Bosch glide so superior, it doesn't have that flex. It's got a lot less than most, but I had a look at one & it definitely flexes more than a good non-slider. Quote
Just Bob Posted April 14, 2017 Report Posted April 14, 2017 9 hours ago, Marcus Hand said: The more expensive option would probably be the Bosch gliding miter saw. They have 10" and 12" options and are around $600. If I go the Bosch route, I would setup a permanent place for it in my shop and would want to use it for most of my cross cutting. I am in the "would not be without one" camp. I have had the 12" Bosch for almost 5 yrs now, and use it in almost every project. It replaced a 10" nonslider that I had a for over 20yrs. I have a small shop and my saw is set permanently in my work flow. Correctly tuned it just as accurate as any of my other tools. The DC is like every other miter saw out there, but I made some minor changes that made a huge difference. Don't expect this saw to be portable. It's not. You might carry it once or twice, but climb a bunch of stairs with it and I would tempted to just leave it there. I understand the other side of this conversation, and agree that if this is just going to be a one time situation, rent one. 2 Quote
Marcus Hand Posted April 14, 2017 Author Report Posted April 14, 2017 Thanks for all the advice. I checked yesterday and I can rent a 12" Makita from HD for a day. I don't need to make that many cuts, so I think that may be the best way to go. Quote
Marmotjr Posted April 14, 2017 Report Posted April 14, 2017 Throwing another idea out there.... If you have a roller stand and the floor space to do this, you could make a special cross cut sled specifically for long cuts. IT could be a normal sized sled, but not as deep, and one side had an extra long wing on it to support the work piece, and that rest on the roller stand. And if you design it so the wing section bolts on, you could have this sled setup for intermediate length cuts too, but it would be thinner than a normal sled, so it would store easily. If you rarely, if ever, have the need for a miter saw, then this may be the way to go, save some cash. 1 Quote
Eric Anderson Posted April 14, 2017 Report Posted April 14, 2017 As several people have posted, the non-sliders have fewer moving parts and tend to hold there calibration better than a slider. So a non-slider will likely be more accurate and hold that accuracy over time better than a slider. I have an old Dealt 705 (long since discontinued) that is a 12" single bevel. I have used it for framing, general construction, cutting hardie plank siding, and yes, even fine woodworking. It is dead nuts straight after all of these years of abuse. I certainly use it much more for non-woodworking activities, but it is so accurate, I'm not afraid of using it to cut face frames and other furniture grade pieces. If you ever build a shed, a fence, garden pergola, etc, you will wonder how you live without one. If I never did anything other than fine woodworking, I might think differently, but after doing crown, baseboard, window and door moldings in my own home. I'll keep it. While I love and have several Festool tools, the Kapex, is probably a bridge too far, but never say never. Quote
bushwacked Posted April 18, 2017 Report Posted April 18, 2017 On 4/13/2017 at 8:07 PM, Just Bob said: The DC is like every other miter saw out there, but I made some minor changes that made a huge difference. any pics of this? Quote
Just Bob Posted April 19, 2017 Report Posted April 19, 2017 5 hours ago, bushwacked said: any pics of this? I just added a piece of rubber to the DC intake that catches and directs the sawdust up. This helped the most. The other thing I discovered was the if I reduce the amount of air by opening a blast gate further up the line greatly increases the amount of dust being captured. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.